Skip to content

Revalidate all 16 Mech browsers against the 24-feature matrix - #627

Open
realmarcin wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
update/site-feature-audit-20261119
Open

realmarcin wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
update/site-feature-audit-20261119

Conversation

@realmarcin

@realmarcin realmarcin commented Nov 20, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

The browser-feature matrix was last broadly reviewed on November 9, with two November 12 exceptions. Revalidate all sixteen published sites against the existing 24 criteria and record the actual served revisions, rather than treating redeployment as a rating change.

The November 19 audit changes seven of 384 ratings. Six change from present to partial:

  • CommunityMech: specific cross-Mech record links and persisted themes.
  • MediaIngredientMech: evidence links and licence notices.
  • TraitMech: licence notices on the linked discussion index.
  • PathwayMech: manual theme application.

TaxonMech's generic sibling searches change from partial to missing under the specific-record-link criterion. HabitatMech retains partial based on named associated taxa with search-only handoffs.

The other 377 ratings remain unchanged after review. Notes now reflect current served counts and sampled behavior. Corpus pins, census assets, card figures and public membership remain unchanged. EdgeMech's sample browser is a separate proposal in CultureBotAI/EdgeMech#225 and is not counted as published here.

Evidence includes all 384 auditor judgments, independent skeptical reviews, cross-column arbitration, complete-index coverage receipts and lossless compressed browser observations. Corrected unsupported point-activation wording and misdirected evidence pointers are tracked in #626. Upstream defects are linked in the audit README; generic exploration links are distinguished from specific-record relationships.

The separate final PR review found the Taxon/Habitat rubric inconsistency recorded in #628. Targeted re-review cleared both corrections at 4dbfa4e, with no remaining review findings.

Validation:

  • Live Chrome/Playwright actions across all sixteen sites, with deployment-before/after and served-date checks; all CofactorMech and AssayMech records, representative records elsewhere.
  • Complete exports/manifests or source inventories for catalogue claims; fault injection and recovery, URL restoration, themes and fresh/resized 390px layouts.
  • Generated page check, archive integrity and 38 JavaScript tests passed.
  • All 392 local Python tests passed; 22 focused feature tests cover the final review corrections. Final CI passed on 4dbfa4e, including the pinned-contract checks, knowledge-gap data check, JavaScript tests and Jekyll build.

Fixes #626.
Fixes #628.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

2 participants