You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Apply the specific-record cross-Mech rubric consistently to TaxonMech and HabitatMech #628
Independent read-only review of PR #627 at f72534fc87d75b7077fb248f4cab134c1cf8107d found two remaining cross-Mech rubric inconsistencies:
P2: TaxonMech should be missing, not partial. The three sampled populated taxon records offer generic sibling searches and home links, but identify no specific related sibling records. Awarding partial for generic searches conflicts with the same criterion used for AIMech and CMMMech.
P3: HabitatMech needs the actual partial-rating evidence. The current note cites generic Explore links that return 404. Its associated-taxa table instead provides the valid basis: specific taxon names and NCBITaxon IDs next to TaxonMech search links, without direct navigation to individual records. Point the note and evidence to that table. Those anchors are in the retained desktop links collection; the helper's all_links intentionally excludes table anchors.
Acceptance:
Change TaxonMech cross_mech_links to missing, with sampled-source limitations stated.
Keep HabitatMech partial, but describe the named associated taxa and search-only handoffs rather than unrelated generic navigation failures.
Preserve original auditor proposals; record the final arbitration and regenerate the page and change ledger.
Update rating-change totals and validate the final published table against the recorded decisions.
This is a correction to the audit, not an assertion that a scientific cross-record relation exists or an instruction to create one. Existing generic navigation defects remain tracked separately.
Activity