Skip to content

Require CM replay and complete KGM source reconciliation - #1884

Draft
realmarcin wants to merge 8 commits into
feat/stable-mim-source-candidate-20261110from
feat/cm-mim-consumer-gates-687-20261119
Draft

realmarcin wants to merge 8 commits into
feat/stable-mim-source-candidate-20261110from
feat/cm-mim-consumer-gates-687-20261119

Conversation

@realmarcin

@realmarcin realmarcin commented Nov 19, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

The accepted CultureMech v3 intake and the native MIM source-binding export are different contracts. This dependent PR adds fail-closed CM replay/integration checks to #1833 and now supplies the complete reviewed historical KGM source closure needed to select the actual prior inputs.

Base remains #1833 (15a03c1f48cfb3d3f5b29ca7809daaeee554a8d0) after #1750 → #1804 → #1833. The selected KGM generation is explicitly historical f10fb3909ed32898a54176ca77e509a950d16b84; no current-master freshness or new production release is claimed. Production pins and active MIM inputs are unchanged.

The new closure preserves the old 95-member receipt and verifies 212 members, all 35 generated graph/audit members, 91 consumed dependencies and 10 recursive fingerprint markers. Full-row reconciliation preserves all 5,740 occurrences, 507 identities and 549 provider cases, including the 42 shared MetaTraits/GTDB identities and every qualifier/hold. The committed 8c66be0b... pin record binds already-consumed MIM 0dac2784... independently of the future final MIM canary.

The reviewed selector is ~/agent-work/kg-microbe/source-reconciliation-1879-20261120/evidence/SOURCE-SELECTION-r1.json, SHA256 f7f935ced327088826e5a6614a5bfce3065679ed081d5a93c314ce4f97397721. Final source receipt SHA256 is 02b2d617172b879efc0b3df80831fc44d647eb3f0399146f162e4712fdaeeae2. See docs/KGM_SOURCE_RECONCILIATION_1879_20261120.md and the existing integration report for exact source/CM pins and complete limits.

Independent review findings #1880, #1881, #1883, #1885 and the new helper/artifact findings #1887, #1888, #1889 are addressed with refusal controls. #1882 remains an upstream replay prerequisite enforced by the consumer; parent #1879 remains open for final integration acceptance. Both real MIM scientific reports and native manifest inputs must select the same evidence. P3556, supported/withheld partitions, explicit companion selection and inventory-versus-medium-presence rules remain binding.

Validation for new candidate 90ebea295874200cdf49a5babcdbd2a768d5ec82:

  • 112 affected row/downstream controls and 40 collector controls passed. Required formatting/spelling preparation passed.
  • Actual historical row reconciliation and versioned closure capture completed exit 0. Independent complete row/graph/byte review and final v2 rehash passed with no unresolved artifact finding.
  • The exact-head final scripts/run_pr_gates.py --require-stable-mim run passed: lock/config and quality gates, then one full suite with 10,467 passed / 56 skipped. All 53 required native controls passed with all three explicit selectors; none skipped or xfailed. This uses the existing immutable native fixture and does not establish final CM v3/MIM release acceptance. The three exact-head CI builds remain in progress. Earlier b186a357 validation is preserved only for that previous candidate.
  • Failed preparatory attempts and closure-v1 remain retained. No historical receipt was restamped; old native-helper outcomes are explicitly labelled historical.

Draft intentionally. Real final native products/replay/canary, full R3, separately approved paired pin promotion, current-master stack reconciliation, dependency-derived producer rebuild, source admission and graph/archive/model/release checks remain prerequisites. No merge or public-release approval is requested or implied.

@realmarcin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Code validation is complete for head b186a3572567cb478611c857e889d12ec2d017f5, against exact base 15a03c1f48cfb3d3f5b29ca7809daaeee554a8d0. The PR remains draft/open with the same eight changed files.

The separate actual CM intake canary passed on an independent copy, preserving 623 supported / 4,384 withheld cases and the original inventories. It is not the final combined-artifact canary. Package cf7e1f1434ab2dfc61922a47ae785f474c06cf4f88fbfd76d09e6b55993f70c8 remains distinct from reviewed-intake 9fd1da62fad47c3b5b7290ea3f9fc2b687b23fc8c98e8dc926e1460572c3f1d8. Inventory/identity support cannot grant medium presence; P3556 and explicit companion selection remain binding.

Evidence is retained under ~/agent-work/kg-microbe/culturemech-mim-consumer-687-20261119/evidence/:

Record SHA256
FINAL-CODE-VALIDATION.json 7eb8e177ddcdf81bfc0efa6c1119385a91c5ddbfed8457c4fd86d5ec46bb96f6
integration-1885-independent-adversarial-review-r9.json 0dd0096875af277bb6084fec91346d6b86be1c92a64923122db4cc451bf6132f
evidence-closure-independent-review-r11.json 61b14e5c364009caf5d91b741d656c270375e5f448bd81c75953660dfcea788b
upstream-trackers-final.json 083d99e982621cc5781852f8b3933a82c4567f8f750d812c70c5dd4557ccf1f6

Status: CODE_GATES_COMPLETE_RELEASE_BLOCKED, production_authorized=false. The final read of MIM #1431 and CultureMech #687 still identifies native original-CM replay (#1882), a reviewed current KGM closure containing its committed release-pin snapshot, certified combined products and the real final-artifact canary as prerequisites. This is bounded to those tracker records and the selected producer, not a claim of global artifact absence.

After approved coherent pin promotion, reconcile the stack with current master, complete full R3 row/multiplicity comparison, derive/rebuild affected producers, admit finalized fingerprints, and run guarded canonical merge plus archive/model/path/release checks. No production pin promotion, graph rebuild, merge or publication was performed. Historical interrupted/cheap-failed attempts remain preserved and are not passes.

Bind the already-consumed release independently of future MIM canaries. Preserve historical evidence and all scientific holds. Repairs review findings #1887, #1888 and #1889.
Require typed arrays and exact provider multiplicity; retain ordered case-ID pair binding. Address actual-run and independent-review findings on #1889.
Preserve prior receipts while correcting the new version lineage and explicitly recording that native helpers and transforms were not rerun. Address artifact review on #1887.
@realmarcin realmarcin changed the title Require explicit CM replay and current KGM integration evidence Require CM replay and complete KGM source reconciliation Nov 20, 2026

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant