Add exact quality evidence and runtime import constraints

[Flow-Fly]

Adds a verifiable quality-evidence bundle for delivery slice #604 under capability #602. The public commands collect five separate V8 profiles, check their complete source/test inventories and recorded inputs, enforce runtime imports, and accept intact local or downloaded evidence against exact revisions. Complexity and duplication receive explicit review dispositions. Root coverage runs one file at a time to avoid overlap with CLI fixtures.

Linked task issues

• [Clean-code task] Collect and accept exact five-profile quality evidence #613
• [Clean-code task] Enforce runtime imports and report measured quality provenance #614
• [Clean-code task] Make the exact quality gate reproducible in CI and handoffs #615

Execution order: #613 → #614 → #615.

Delivered revisions

Starting integration baseline: e94f52e4f8c22f78db93688f5dab3ad95430a652. Immediate develop base: d6d4042bddba54a050442534c32e97da9d8a8c07. Candidate: a3260ad1b7eb6ed0a68e6bbfe1a4f6ab1a1e7881.

After PR #617 advanced develop, its exact commit was merged without conflicts. The quality implementation remained unchanged. CI then caught an integration issue in its public CLI fixture: the imported browser configuration now needs vite.config.ts, which the fixture had not copied. One line adds that real file to the fixture copy list; app configuration, assertions and product behavior are unchanged.

CI 34463059849 preserves the failing setup as red evidence; its incomplete bundle is rejected. The corrected head passes all eleven focused quality exercises, typecheck, lint, full quality collection and acceptance, build and whitespace checks. CI 34463948977 passes checks and server-container with the existing workspace gates retained.

The real Linux bundle was accepted read-only from the clean macOS review checkout: artifact 10146915988, archive digest sha256:d4a0abe6383bb3b81ef19952cbc938ad699deccc5ee125386c4856843425adca, expires 2026-09-24T10:08:49Z. Local evidence uses the preserved starting baseline; CI evidence uses the exact immediate event base. Each is checked against its recorded base and this head.

Root: 989 passing tests / 307 source files; Chromium: 129 passing tests and one explicit native-API skip / 308 source files; shared: 35 tests / 6 sources; server: 79 tests / 18 sources; Worker: 13 tests / 1 source. Maps stay separate and test counts overlap; they are not combined coverage. No required Fallow blocker remains. The twelve exact complexity advisories keep their documented Director dispositions.

The superseded local integration run had four additional failures, absent in its CI. All 989 root tests pass at the corrected head both locally and in CI; those earlier failures remain recorded without a claimed cause. No product deadline or assertion was changed. Fresh independent Standards and Spec reviews pass. The finalizer returned APPROVE on unchanged a326, with one optional naming suggestion resolved without edits; no confirmed blocker remains.

Historical verification and review

The previous candidate 9db4e1e0d093d2b5b69045a69391a148454fef5d passed its required local gates, CI 34418910297, actual downloaded-bundle acceptance and independent finalizer review. Those records identify that previous head only; see the Director acceptance ledger.

The first review repaired external manifest-symlink acceptance through the existing confinement guard, with a public red/green regression. Verified platform scope is macOS/Linux; Windows producer/consumer support remains outside this slice. Five maps stay separate; tooling is behaviorally exercised without measured coverage. One extra raw root test run at the previous candidate exceeded an unchanged product deadline; that failure and its unknown cause remain recorded separately from the successful required gates.

Authorization

The owner replied “continue” to the explicit merge request. The Director recovery record records this approval and the new exact-base handoff. The independently approved, green head was merged into develop at ea1352ab7387aed9c052d5a7e8e47ed102ee4068; its tree equals the reviewed candidate. Post-merge CI 34465718704 passes, and its distinct downloaded bundle is accepted against that exact revision. See the integration acceptance ledger for artifact identity, expiry, scopes and dispositions. #604/#613/#614/#615 are closed; parent #602 remains open for pilot #605.

[coderabbitai]

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

• Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true

---

Note

🎁 Summarized by CodeRabbit Free

Your organization is on the Free plan. CodeRabbit will generate a high-level summary and a walkthrough for each pull request. For a comprehensive line-by-line review, please upgrade your subscription to CodeRabbit Essentials by visiting https://app.coderabbit.ai/settings/billing.

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.}

[Flow-Fly]

Director acceptance: PR #616 is ready for human merge approval at 9db4e1e0d093d2b5b69045a69391a148454fef5d. This is a Director record, not an owner-authored merge approval. No merge has been performed.

This delivers #604 under #602, with canonical tasks #613 → #614 → #615. The integration baseline and immediate base remain e94f52e4f8c22f78db93688f5dab3ad95430a652. The delivery and detached review checkouts are clean; the owner’s separate dirty checkout was preserved.

Review result

Pass 1 returned FIXED: STD-1 was a confirmed manifest-confinement blocker, repaired with the existing guard and a public red/green regression. The Director independently verified that the valid actual CI bundle is accepted and an external-manifest symlink is refused at the repaired head. SPEC-1 was resolved by the explicit macOS/Linux scope interpretation; Windows is outside the validated toolchain.

Pass 2 returned APPROVE on the unchanged corrected head. Its initial Standards/Spec invocations were rejected before execution by agent capacity. The missing axes were recovered in fresh separate contexts, sequentially, and the same finalizer resumed aggregation and final identity checks. This was completion of pass 2, not a third review or reuse of pass-1 opinions. The initial incomplete record remains retained. Approachability: B. No confirmed blocker or required simplification remains.

Standards

Standards axis: no substantiated documented-standard violation in the complete 21-file, ten-commit diff. This is the recovered independent axis of finalizer pass 2; the existing finalizer owns the verdict. No producer reruns or checkout edits occurred.

Reviewer: /root/quality_standards_recovery (fresh read-only context).
Checkout: /Users/flow/.codex/worktrees/pixel-forge-quality-review-1; detached, clean before and after inspection.
Base: e94f52e4f8c22f78db93688f5dab3ad95430a652.
Head: 9db4e1e0d093d2b5b69045a69391a148454fef5d.
Range: base...head. All ten commits and changed paths are enumerated in the frozen handoff, SHA-256 31750390ccd8b3ac4cf47f1cfa57ccb0367c3e256cb5d255ba8eebb1ea94cbd3.

Standards sources: candidate AGENTS.md, .agentic-loop.yml, docs/operations/codex-agent-workflow.md, docs/agents/handoffs.md, docs/agents/quality-verification.md, owning configuration and existing tooling. Tool-enforced style rules were excluded.

Requirements: live #602, #604, #613, #614 and #615 bodies were fetched on 2026-09-10 at 08:16–08:17 UTC. Each exactly matches its digest, supplied-version status and updated timestamp in the frozen handoff. Live PR #616 remains draft with the specified base/head. Governing Director comment 5610410252 has body SHA-256 29bbea6bc72340cfa8905dc333ca2c8b3a930f55c289e0beee688d4a774115de; its macOS/Linux scope is documented.

Baseline hypotheses, both advisory judgment calls with status unverified as violations; Director disposition pending:

• STD-H1 — Duplicated Code. scripts/quality/bundle.mjs:153 and scripts/quality/fallow.mjs:213 repeat “!Number.isFinite(record.durationMs)” and start-time validation. A shared validator is possible, but the surrounding records have different result/environment policies. Recommend retaining this small, readable duplication under the supplied repository preference and AGENTS.md:99’s boring-abstraction rule.
• STD-H2 — Mysterious Name. scripts/quality/bundle.mjs:19: “export function same(actual, expected, label)”. assertSame would expose its throwing behavior more clearly. The one-line body and labeled validation call sites already establish that role. Recommend no required rename; affected rule: clear names, AGENTS.md:99.

Approachability: the entry command reads in execution order; configuration, coverage structure and Fallow reconciliation have separate owners. The longer validators remain explicit and locally understandable. Public CLI fixtures exercise distinct failure boundaries; no private-helper harness, speculative framework, product-data change or unrelated cleanup was introduced. Numeric complexity scores alone provide no basis for further changes.

Spec

Spec result: PASS. No supported Spec findings in the complete 21-file diff.

• Missing or partial requirements: none found against [Clean-code capability] Make delivery responsibility, evidence, and review exact #602 → [Clean-code delivery slice 2] Make quality evidence measured and reject mismatches #604 → [Clean-code task] Collect and accept exact five-profile quality evidence #613/[Clean-code task] Enforce runtime imports and report measured quality provenance #614/[Clean-code task] Make the exact quality gate reproducible in CI and handoffs #615 and the live Director interpretation.
• Unrequested behavior: none found. Changes remain within the approved paths; product source, dependencies, lockfile, agent models, and finalizer verdict rules are unchanged.
• Implemented requirements with incorrect behavior: none found. Expected-checkout inventories, revision/input checks, artifact confinement, separate coverage maps, Fallow reconciliation, and CI command mapping satisfy the frozen contract.

The public CLI exercises execute copied production scripts and installed commands in temporary Git repositories. They prove collection, relocation, source completeness, failed-producer invalidation, new-only classification, and runtime-import refusal. Coverage corruption tests update artifact hashes and assert validator diagnostics (tests/scripts/quality-evidence.test.ts:220), so checksums do not conceal the coverage checks. The native complexity exercise verifies an actual high-crap-score result before mutating it (:311). Both manifest reads use the confinement guard (scripts/quality/bundle.mjs:101, :190), with a public external-symlink regression (tests/scripts/quality-evidence.test.ts:183).

I independently ran quality:check against the actual Linux CI bundle from the clean macOS checkout: exit 0; manifest and certification digests unchanged. CI run 34418910297 remains successful at this head. Its distinct root/browser/shared/server/Worker counts are 968/128/35/79/13; root includes eleven quality exercises. All twelve estimated tooling advisories match exact-head Director dispositions. These are neither measured script coverage nor combined coverage.

The Director clarification defines the verified macOS/Linux boundary; the guide records Windows as unsupported. The additional raw root run's unchanged five-second duplication timeout remains retained and unexplained; it does not establish a regression. The approved quality gate supplies the frozen test/Fallow acceptance evidence.

Reviewer: /root/quality_spec_recovery, fresh missing-axis recovery for pass 2. Base: e94f52e4f8c22f78db93688f5dab3ad95430a652. Head: 9db4e1e0d093d2b5b69045a69391a148454fef5d. Checkout: /Users/flow/.codex/worktrees/pixel-forge-quality-review-1, detached and clean before/after. No source edits or producer reruns. Live requirement hashes, unsupplied versions, retrieval/update times, commit/path inventory, and acceptance evidence are recorded in the identity record.

Director dispositions

• STD-1: confirmed blocker — resolved by the bounded repair and public refusal proof.
• SPEC-1: judgment call — resolved within the verified destination stack.
• STD-H1: judgment call — resolved; retain the small timing-check duplication because neighboring result/environment policies differ.
• STD-H2: judgment call — resolved; assertSame is optional wording, while the existing one-line throwing helper and labeled call sites are clear enough.
• REV-2-1: confirmed review blocker — resolved by fresh missing-axis execution and same-pass aggregation.

Exact-head verification

CI run 34418910297 passes both checks and server-container. Local quality:verify, quality:check, typecheck, lint, build and diff checks also pass. Existing shared/server/Worker noncoverage checks remain executed in CI; unit coverage does not imply database/storage integrations, subprocess coverage, or real workerd execution.

Separate profile	Passing tests	Declared source files
Root happy-dom	968	300
Chromium	128	301
Shared	35	6
Server unit	79	18
Worker mocked bindings	13	1

Root includes eleven public quality/boundary exercises. Counts overlap and must not be summed into a coverage claim. V8 maps remain separate; Fallow function provenance remains mixed. Tooling scripts are behaviorally tested but outside those measured maps.

An additional npm run test:run -- --maxWorkers=1 returned 1: 967/968 tests passed and the unchanged project-duplication test exceeded its five-second deadline (5,049 ms). Its cause is not established. The Director records this as a confirmed non-blocker because the frozen #604/#615 quality acceptance equivalent and CI pass that same complete root selection at this exact head. The raw failure is retained; no claim that every local command passed, no relaxed product deadline, and no blind retry. Raw Fallow audit exit 1 corresponds to the twelve declared advisory complexity findings; the accepted required policy has zero blockers.

The final observed CI checks job took 354 s versus 251 s at the baseline (+103 s); container smoke stayed 69 s. These are individual runs, not a stable benchmark. The final serial root setting was calibrated using retained timing failures and a passing complete collection.

Retained evidence

Actual Linux CI bundle: artifact 10130283654, digest sha256:104217e2256944ca6fa6eed5ca2047ace9a8c0cdd97f4f643f416329ccb0dab2, expiry 2026-09-23T23:59:26Z.

• CI manifest: 09a0db9d722b58e6b4bd98eeb290c5583f906a1f2864f57449981224e5234e99.
• CI certification: 19813c2a6d60039dc3191fc3851f29af20f1b56679e8eb86ce2a6570ade9c552.
• Local manifest: ff7f2b015bff382ffbb098647f734f702d20c5d9f0bf915d60d04df666f23848.
• Local certification: 326a53957ab17a6264f03aaf654fadf27777971b2f8615bdbb6c84c0084e2b47.

The actual Linux bundle was independently accepted through the public command in the clean macOS detached checkout by the Director, finalizer and recovered Spec reviewer. Acceptance is read-only. After expiry, regenerate from the same source revision/configuration with the documented command; historical green status alone is insufficient.

npm run quality:check -- --base e94f52e4f8c22f78db93688f5dab3ad95430a652 --head 9db4e1e0d093d2b5b69045a69391a148454fef5d --bundle <downloaded-directory>

Local durable record root: /Users/flow/.codex/artifacts/pixel-forge-quality-adoption/. It retains worker-return.md, both finalizer reports, the initial incomplete pass-2 record, fresh axis reports/identities, all local command records/raw failures, downloaded bundles, and Director proof/disposition records. Reviewed disposition snapshots keep their original hashes; final completion records have separate names.

Advisory catalogue

All twelve exact IDs below have disposition confirmed non-blocker; no score, exclusion or suppression was changed to hide them. Raw review catalogue SHA-256: 8bd7f44061ac0fb3aaaae7bd20c4f20f190d36a23aeaea7dbfb26f0a01041ece.

Registry reconciliation

The function owns one conversion from native audit/SARIF/registry evidence to the required/advisory policy. Its branches validate introduced identity, location/severity joins and the explicit heuristic allowlist. Real resealed-report regressions exercise this boundary. The 82-line function warrants review but its numeric complexity alone is not a blocker; splitting solely to move counts would add navigation without changing the contract.

• complexity:scripts/quality/fallow.mjs:21:0

Bundle and constraint acceptance

These entry points perform sequential fail-fast checks against the executable expected inventory, with named comparisons and focused file/coverage/Fallow helpers. Missing, mismatched, changed-input, failed-producer and relocated-bundle cases run through the public CLI; the actual Linux CI bundle also passes independently on macOS. Retain the visible acceptance sequence rather than add a generic validator framework.

• complexity:scripts/quality/fallow.mjs:194:7
• complexity:scripts/quality/bundle.mjs:99:7

Coverage counters

The counter validator has one schema responsibility across statements, functions and branches. The extra branch case is tied to a verified installed V8 sentinel and tested both positively and negatively. Keep that exception local and explicit; do not hide it or broaden accepted locations to reduce branching.

• complexity:scripts/quality/coverage.mjs:60:0

Small boundary guards

These small functions and callbacks perform explicit path, revision, location and process-result checks. Their required alternatives account for the score. Public success/refusal tests and actual retained-bundle acceptance exercise them; scripts are outside the five measured coverage maps, so estimated CRAP is not an absence-of-tests finding. No dependency, suppression or threshold adjustment is justified.

• complexity:scripts/quality/coverage.mjs:25:7
• complexity:scripts/quality/bundle.mjs:31:7
• complexity:scripts/quality/fallow.mjs:11:0
• complexity:scripts/quality/coverage.mjs:16:6
• complexity:scripts/quality/coverage.mjs:49:0
• complexity:scripts/quality/bundle.mjs:83:7
• complexity:scripts/quality/coverage.mjs:85:12
• complexity:scripts/quality/bundle.mjs:23:0

The untouched inherited clone dup:af384e5f retains its prior grouped disposition. Diagnostic --max-crap 1 rows enumerate provenance; they are not thousands of separate required review requests.

Requirement identities

Versions are not supplied. Digests hash exact UTF-8 GitHub body bytes, with no added newline. Updated times and retrieval times are separate in the frozen handoff and recovered identity records; fresh live checks again matched before final approval.

Source	Body SHA-256
#602	f259f3120a32eafeee0048e9a4f7925f6c9b809a3d02e3b56719adec80abcd77
#604	0fc8b08dcce4d76148fe19f2b7b4ce03cd9b8653987f702c1a5f63305c589fa1
#613	7e16c7353c117c83db5a9a243c55299eeb9f40604566bf8db3a321f81571c337
#614	c9e53ef2a736c444caa3123aefc5aaef627d70e6d1c0c10d3c7d0c57cc99da01
#615	7f55d41e07c4b5c740fe631925cf10fbcb1708fca802188dd8cdf4094d178bb8

The governing Director comment body digest is 29bbea6bc72340cfa8905dc333ca2c8b3a930f55c289e0beee688d4a774115de. These are technical workflow records; the owner’s explicit merge gate remains in force. #604 and its tasks remain open until delivery is merged, and #605 stays blocked by #604.

[Flow-Fly]

Director integration recovery and owner approval record for PR #616.

The owner replied “continue” to the explicit request to merge this PR into develop. I record that as approval to complete this bounded integration after the required checks and review. This is a Director attribution to the conversation, not an owner-authored GitHub comment. It does not authorize promotion to main or a product change under #605.

Pre-merge reconciliation found that PR #617 advanced develop from e94f52e4f8c22f78db93688f5dab3ad95430a652 to d6d4042bddba54a050442534c32e97da9d8a8c07. Strict branch protection reports #616 as BEHIND. Its approved head remains 9db4e1e0d093d2b5b69045a69391a148454fef5d; requirements #602/#604/#613/#614/#615 have unchanged exact body digests and no new blockers or review threads.

Under docs/agents/handoffs.md recovery, implementation is paused until this new exact-base handoff is recorded. Preserve the original integration baseline e94f52e4f8c22f78db93688f5dab3ad95430a652. The immediate integration base is now d6d4042bddba54a050442534c32e97da9d8a8c07. Merge that exact develop commit into the isolated dev-clean-code-quality branch, without rewriting the accepted #617 product changes. If a conflict or check requires changing product behavior or widening #604, stop and report it.

Return the PR to draft while the changed candidate is verified. Previous approval/evidence remains historical for 9db4e1e and cannot approve the new head. Collect local evidence against the preserved starting baseline, retain CI evidence against its actual event base, and renew independent Standards/Spec review plus a fresh finalizer for the resulting head. The prior two-pass cycle ended in APPROVE; this is recovery for a subsequently advanced integration base, not a third attempt to approve an unresolved candidate. Apply the same two-pass limit to the refreshed candidate.

Linked task order remains #613, #614, #615; write boundaries, product non-goals, advisory policy and model configurations remain unchanged. Owner merge approval remains applicable if this routine integration recovery produces an unchanged, reviewed, green, mergeable head within that scope.

[Flow-Fly]

Director disposition INT-1: confirmed blocker, repair authorized within #604.

Fresh CI 34463059849 at 04b3a74b244bbd7d9e238dda2087cf9f857468c9 failed the root producer. The retained report shows 981 passing tests, zero failed assertions and eight skipped CLI assertions because their beforeAll setup failed: the fixture's copied vitest.browser.config.ts now imports ./vite.config following #617, but its copy inventory omits vite.config.ts.

The required evidence was correctly refused; no current certification exists. The public downloaded-bundle checker also rejects this partial run. The old certification cannot certify this changed head.

The worker may add the real vite.config.ts to the existing quality fixture copy list in tests/scripts/quality-evidence.test.ts. Preserve the real browser configuration, test assertions, product source, deadlines and dependency lockfile. This is a bounded fixture compatibility repair to #613's existing public CLI exercise, not a change to #617. Retain this CI failure as red evidence, then run the focused quality exercises and complete required gates at the committed repair head. Independent finalization has not started for this integration recovery.

[Flow-Fly]

Director acceptance record for refreshed PR #616 — approved unchanged head.

Candidate a3260ad1b7eb6ed0a68e6bbfe1a4f6ab1a1e7881, tree 27389b006ea7fbfd505abf80e26e8b0374c5d143. Immediate develop base d6d4042bddba54a050442534c32e97da9d8a8c07; preserved initial baseline e94f52e4f8c22f78db93688f5dab3ad95430a652. Linked task order is #613, #614, #615 under #604 / #602. Requirement bodies remain unchanged.

The owner’s “continue” reply approved merging #616 into develop. The exact-base recovery and approval attribution are in #616 (comment). Merge 04b preserved #617; a326 adds only the imported app config to the CLI fixture copy list. This repair is governed by #616 (comment).

Verification at this candidate:

• All 11 focused public quality exercises, typecheck, lint, full quality collection, bundle acceptance, build and whitespace checks pass locally. Raw command records and results are retained in integration-refresh/a3260ad1b7eb6ed0a68e6bbfe1a4f6ab1a1e7881/worker-result.json below the artifact root /Users/flow/.codex/artifacts/pixel-forge-quality-adoption/.
• CI 34463948977 passes both checks and server-container: https://github.com/Flow-Fly/pixel-forge/actions/runs/34463948977 . Its actual Linux bundle is accepted read-only from the exact clean macOS review checkout.
• Local bundle base is the original e94 baseline: manifest a0c0bffff680cbbc1c60c00cd67f2c2b964c43699ddcc3af0746668ec9befd96, certification fff0421ed013d87701e63520bca9906f5f6b665ae5c62b11994686b6b324646f. CI bundle base is d6: manifest 4266245a0270875b0fc0f14de62dfd1e4c700d502ca2b29af3da45645f662e0c, certification 60b43c4b18454c5ed2b5463d821e4987248e45bcf9ae84434967b6f439a70c2a. These are distinct attributable collections at the same candidate; their bases are not relabeled.
• CI artifact 10146915988, digest sha256:d4a0abe6383bb3b81ef19952cbc938ad699deccc5ee125386c4856843425adca, expires 2026-09-24T10:08:49Z. Reproduce collection/acceptance using docs/agents/quality-verification.md when retained evidence expires.
• Separate profiles: root989 passing tests and307 source files; Chromium129 passing/1native-API skip and308 sources; shared35tests/6sources; server79/18; Worker13/1. Counts overlap and maps are not merged. Tooling has behavioral tests but no measured map; Worker bindings are mocked; database/storage integrations remain separate.
• No required Fallow blockers. Both local andCI catalogues contain the same 12 exact advisory IDs. director-advisories-a326.json retains their rationale; director-integration-dispositions.json records both catalogue digests, repaired INT-1 and the historical local failures.

The superseded 04b CI failed on the missing fixture config and its partial bundle was correctly rejected. Four additional local failures at 04b are retained without a claimed cause; all 989 root tests pass at a326 locally and in CI with unchanged product assertions/deadlines. No product source, dependency lock, threshold, agent model setting or unrelated owner work is changed by this delivery diff.

Fresh finalizer /root/quality_integration_finalizer returned APPROVE for this unchanged head after the complete 21-file, twelve-commit review. Its independent Standards and Spec reviewers were /root/quality_integration_finalizer/standards and /root/quality_integration_finalizer/spec. Standards: no violation, one optional naming hypothesis STD-INT-1; Director disposition judgment call — resolved, retain the locally clear one-line same assertion helper. Spec: no findings. No required simplification or confirmed blocker remains; approachability B.

The finalizer independently accepted both entire retained bundles read-only and verified all bundle files retained the same digests. Its report is integration-refresh/finalizer/report.md, SHA-256 cc8c8697616f74e12b29bf7b44d61c51be76bbc198da44d29afb38a4d7680733. The twelve unchanged advisory IDs retain the grouped rationales from the previous Director ledger, rechecked against both current catalogues and unchanged implementations. Current dispositions are also retained in director-advisories-a326.json and director-review-dispositions-a326.json.

Final pre-merge reconciliation confirms exact head/base, unchanged requirement hashes, no unresolved threads, and green checks/container/CodeRabbit. The owner approval is applicable to this bounded, repaired, independently approved integration. Mark ready and merge with an exact head guard. Post-merge acceptance will identify the resulting develop commit and its own CI artifact; this approval and these artifacts continue to identify a326 only.

[Flow-Fly]

PR #616 is accepted in develop at ea1352ab7387aed9c052d5a7e8e47ed102ee4068.

The merge parents are d6d4042bddba54a050442534c32e97da9d8a8c07 and approved PR head a3260ad1b7eb6ed0a68e6bbfe1a4f6ab1a1e7881. The integrated tree 27389b006ea7fbfd505abf80e26e8b0374c5d143 exactly equals the independently approved tree. The owner-approved merge and fresh Standards/Spec conclusions are recorded in the acceptance ledger.

Develop CI 34465718704 passes both checks and server-container, including the required workspace duties. Its distinct quality bundle was downloaded and accepted read-only from the clean detached integration checkout with:

npm run quality:check -- --base d6d4042bddba54a050442534c32e97da9d8a8c07 --head ea1352ab7387aed9c052d5a7e8e47ed102ee4068 --bundle /Users/flow/.codex/artifacts/pixel-forge-quality-adoption/integration-refresh/ci-ea1352a

The command returned 0; every artifact digest remained unchanged. This certifies the actual merge revision and event base, rather than relabeling a326 evidence.

• Artifact: 10147579485 / quality-ea1352ab7387aed9c052d5a7e8e47ed102ee4068-34465718704-1.
• Archive digest: sha256:931ddbff5658b46510cf9d53ea114a5964d0bae748c2b11455a613ff3a55fde9; expires 2026-09-24T10:27:28Z.
• Manifest SHA-256: 04cd2446088535e2f99d2b09a8919df0d1595d2fee19ec8c51aaddf06975bfbf.
• Certification SHA-256: b5759e8d6ed964ed00f779a3ec75518acbb30a60a31b0ab4d86285adb21a840e.
• Separate passing tests/source files: root 989/307; Chromium 129/308 plus one native-API availability skip; shared 35/6; server 79/18; Worker 13/1. Counts overlap and coverage maps are not combined.
• Zero required Fallow blockers. The twelve advisory IDs and review.json digest remain identical to PR CI. Their exact grouped Director dispositions therefore remain applicable to the identical integrated tree; recorded in director-advisories-ea1352a.json.

Attributable command records, full artifact hashes, scopes, exclusions, provenance and integration identity are retained under /Users/flow/.codex/artifacts/pixel-forge-quality-adoption/integration-refresh/ in ci-ea1352a-acceptance.json and merge-result.json. Regeneration and downloaded acceptance follow docs/agents/quality-verification.md when remote artifacts expire. Platform and coverage limits, the earlier rejected fixture run and unexplained superseded local failures remain in the review record.

All acceptance criteria for #604 / #613 / #614 / #615 are satisfied with no unresolved confirmed blocker. These four issues can close. Capability #602 remains open for the real product-behavior pilot #605; its readiness is not granted by completing this integration.