Skip to content

Assemble and verify a new scientific package after evidence readiness #220

Open

Description

@realmarcin

The November19 readiness audit of PR #214 identifies the remaining integration boundary before another scientific calibration. The new typed adjudication contract does not itself create a runnable science package. Historical round03 has no new scientific-invocation envelopes; the November17 prerequisite package explicitly has engineering_prerequisites purpose and null scientific invocations. Neither can be retrospectively promoted into a positive #209 replay.

Required work, after evidence sufficiency review:

  • Register a new science package and round ID, instantiate neutral JSON instruction templates and per-phase plans, and pin complete runtime/proof helpers. The prerequisite builder currently hardcodes the engineering purpose; old prompts contain historical literal paths and cannot be reused unchanged.
  • Register reviewer IDs reviewer-a and reviewer-b, distinct fresh roots and distinct repository-relative artifact namespaces explicitly, as required by pair/finalizer accounting and unchanged-path collection into the adjudicator. Old round03 reused .temp/round03-reviewer/ in both clones; distinct absolute roots alone do not prevent collection collisions. Build authoring, citation and finalizer configurations against the original scientific manifest, retaining the separate adjudication launch manifest.
  • Independently check source views, definition omissions, counterevidence and all remaining semantic dependencies against the unchanged gates. No labels may be predicted or manufactured to justify a launch.
  • Pass actual same-clone production save/readback in the new reviewer environments before scientific use. Collect post-exit observed identities, native logs, complete readiness lineage and original relative file layouts before freezing the later phase.
  • Replay both new bound original sessions with Reject scientific adjudication invocations without bound initial matrices and seals #209 before adjudication. Preserve the 20 initial canonical pairs plus separately sealed/proof-validated final drafts, under the policy repaired in Align adjudication instructions with the registered canonical-persistence policy #219.

Evidence boundaries remain separate: first01 result convention; first30 original GTDB identity; fresh04 bin weights and cell lineage; fresh05 mixed-row cell lineage; fresh32 exact process-generation version; fresh47 original LPSN authority. The bounded first43/first28/fresh14 source replays do not automatically resolve these or their own remaining historical/semantic limits. New fresh05 public body-text extraction is not yet admitted by the existing abstract/JATS proof adapter; retain it as inspected access evidence, not canonical paper proof. Retrieve supported original bytes or separately review and canary a new extractor before using that extraction in scientific scoring.

Acceptance: a separately identified, exposure-reviewed and fully bound science package with concrete templates/configs and successful fresh-environment canaries, followed by complete #209 real-artifact replay. Historical failures remain unchanged. Remaining90 and expansion stay gated. This is a pending integration/evidence task, not permission to bypass evidence gates or launch now.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions