You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Align adjudication instructions with the registered canonical-persistence policy #219
The new evidence-adjudication prompt in PR #214 tells the adjudicator to save/read back a final canonical draft and then the remaining cases. The retained finalization contract validates final drafts with canonical_persistence_checked=False and counts only the two initial reviewers' 20 canonical pairs. The new instructions therefore require work that the prospective acceptance path does not account for.
Evidence: scripts/adhoc/scientific_invocation_20261117.py around line 645; scripts/adhoc/finalize_m5_calibration_20261116.py around lines 139–157 and its initial-pair accounting; retained round03 adjudicator instructions. Found during a separate read-only readiness review before a new scientific round.
Proposed repair: preserve the registered 20 initial canonical-pair denominator and explicitly require sealed, proof-validated final drafts/matrix under the original scientific manifest. Align the new phase prompt and plan to that draft-only final adjudication contract. The adjudicator's fresh environment must still pass its own canonical production save/readback canary. Do not claim final drafts are saved canonical pairs or modify historical outcomes. Add a focused regression for the generated phase instructions.
Acceptance: one consistent prospective persistence policy in generated instructions, documentation and finalizer; original 20-pair accounting unchanged; a negative instruction regression; focused tests and independent re-review. No scientific launch until remaining package/evidence readiness gates pass.
Activity