Repository navigation
Description
The November 16 exact-row quarantine is merged in KG-Microbe PR #1867 at 2d94ed094167d94402f21400a9ad7dc4f7f20438. The strict BactoTraits-only merged candidate has now passed actual execution and independent persisted-artifact review. Full-snapshot verification and publication remain separate unmet dependencies.
Review PRs: EdgeMech #151 and KG-Microbe #1871.
The ordinary public merge CLI ran with -s bactotraits -p 1, after fresh, complete canonical ontologies → BacDive → BactoTraits producers, with strict finalization and recursive freshness enabled. It completed at 2026-11-16T22:01:06Z:
- Persisted archive: 9,757 nodes / 87,788 edges, all edges carrying
infores:bactotraits; the quarantined target SPO occurs zero times. - Archive: 447,980 bytes; SHA256
d217563f5d29ca2bc7ac729253acf5f83d23519d02a22ed91a5cc974ccf49976. - Receipt SHA256:
111a1d66ae90ae0136212c06f379f15fee447ebdc9db3f70e4fd4e1d806b03be. - Independent review r16 SHA256:
bf397abd283fc5103731be4642662a8c729916cf484a66d8067e2c8fd4c9b14b. It checked all 13 output artifacts, all three source trees, 457 input pins, protected original statistics, the interpreter and all 346 pinned distributions. - Exactly one complete 105-field quarantine audit retains original row8521/BacDive17851. The fresh BacDive lookup and Bacto mapping each retain the single identity join; the pruned Bacto cache retains no target row. No neighboring row was quarantined.
This verifies the correction through the finalized BactoTraits graph and persisted strict merged archive. It does not establish trait falsity, replacement identity or graph-wide scientific validation. Historical independent Madin provenance for the equivalent SPO is retained separately; a full graph may legitimately contain an independently sourced equivalent assertion.
The final GitHub metadata check at 2026-11-16T22:01:40Z still reports latest release 2025-03-07, published 2025-03-07T23:03:41Z. Its listed assets were last updated in March 2025. The earlier complete 14-release inventory at 21:20:12Z found its newest asset update in August 2026. No corrected published artifact has been verified. The preserved M5 canonical archive SHA256 remains 3d529dd0024843f9278ecfbfc8703413061ef9c4c7474805ecec03aa8cfdfd4c; its historical manifest records bcfa6bf5b-dirty and generation 2026-10-18T11:56:34+00:00. Neither historical artifact was overwritten.
The canonical configuration at producer commit b631cacf5bca2f5f993e85bacb96578919cc7d92 requires 24 source keys supplied by 15 producers (configuration SHA256 926c238e577931db06f6674ec96bdf0d85d185a7bcc5028ed6f5bde293d5d1d2). The completed three-producer chain leaves 12 additional whole-source producer completions required:
gold, gtdb, lpsn, lpsn_api, madin_etal, mediadive, metatraits, metatraits_gtdb, microbedecoder, ontologies_stubs, prego, rhea_mappings.
PREGO means the canonical habitat-only output. Exact-path inspection at 2026-11-16T21:19:50.929302Z found all twelve completion records absent, including ignored paths. This records unmet dependencies; absence alone is not proof that rebuilding is infeasible.
Upstream #887 remains open in the 22:01:40Z refresh, last updated 2026-08-26T06:22:48Z. The earlier default-branch workflow inspection still found the retired kg-hub artifact base URL (Git blob 7d27994282ae2a54d89eda17e96875f0e64ea9a8). This is status/configuration evidence, not a fresh HTTP404 observation or proof automated publication works.
Remaining completion criteria:
- Rebuild/finalize the additional twelve producers from individually validated retained raw inputs, satisfying their dependency closures, current code/schema fingerprints and consumed-input hashes.
- Run and independently inspect the canonical all-24-source merge, binding corrected code, exact sources/authorities/configuration, finalization implementation and output hashes. Trace the quarantined lineage; do not require unconditional graph-wide absence of the SPO.
- Resolve the artifact-source dependency in #887 or approve an alternative, obtain separate human publication approval, publish new assets, and independently verify downloaded hashes and corrected embedded provenance.
Retained evidence is under .temp/m5-worker-run-20261116/merged-candidate-r1/, publication-final-r1/ and publication-final-r2/. The previous issue body/draft and this update's receipts are preserved under issue143-final-handoff-r1/. This issue update does not authorize PR merges, unrelated downloads, a full multi-source batch or publication.
Activity