diff --git a/NEXT_TASKS.md b/NEXT_TASKS.md index fc9bb72..011a881 100644 --- a/NEXT_TASKS.md +++ b/NEXT_TASKS.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Edge-review next tasks -Last reconciled: **2026-11-15** (America/Los_Angeles), against `main` at `abf0002ab1dea4dc7702f28be1fe49983e42ab8f`, merged PRs #128/#120, open PRs #102/#37, issue #127 and retained review evidence. PR #128 is merged and #129 is closed. The current branch implements #127's abstract replay; its source inspection found a separate BactoTraits strain conflict filed as #130. Independent calibration ratings and correction verification remain pending. +Last reconciled: **2026-11-15** (America/Los_Angeles), against `main` at `a4c8ce937ffd791b7c7b4d05b85121dea1aa09d6`, merged PRs #131/#128/#120 and open PRs #135/#102/#37. PR #131 is merged and #127 is closed. #130's bounded source quarantine has been independently verified against regenerated producer bytes in [KG-Microbe PR #1867](https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/pull/1867); merge and graph-release verification remain pending. Independent scientific calibration has not passed. Scope: the stratified edge review and related edge-quality follow-ups. Update this file when work starts or ships, checking GitHub and current code before changing status. Record completion dates and PRs. Preserve historical manifests, packets, reports and scientific decisions; a merged engineering PR does not promote an edge's scientific status. Unrelated release/deployment work is outside this backlog. @@ -23,14 +23,15 @@ Evidence: [fresh-canary report](artifacts/edge-recanary-20261113/RECANARY-REPORT | Priority / status | Work | Next action and completion evidence | | --- | --- | --- | | 1 — **DONE preparation, PR #128** | Pin calibration cases and decision thresholds | Merged 2026-11-15. The [ten-case protocol](docs/plans/edge-calibration-20261115.md) fixes first-cohort 1/28/30/32/43 and fresh-cohort 4/5/14/32/47, exact occurrence bindings and operational error/coverage thresholds before new scoring. [Preparation receipts](artifacts/edge-calibration-20261115/PREPARATION.md) record 10/10 replayed source packets, 20/20 endpoint roles and two staged authorities after separate canaries. #129's cross-case packet binding fix passed a new canary before all ten were replayed again. These receipts pin the PR #128 runtime; replay under changed profile code requires a new round, not updated historical hashes. Calibration and independent agreement have not passed. | -| 1b — **IMPLEMENTED, awaiting PR review/merge, #127** | Replay primary abstract evidence | Metadata-bound Europe PMC abstract replay and the single retained fresh-05 canonical save/readback canary passed. [Validation](docs/validation/abstract-evidence-20261115.md): two quotations, 16 words, partial completion and six conservative assessments. This technical self-review is excluded from the independent calibration matrices; it cannot resolve #130's conflicting strain join. | +| 1b — **DONE, 2026-11-15, PR #131** | Replay primary abstract evidence | Metadata-bound Europe PMC abstract replay and the single retained fresh-05 canonical save/readback canary passed. [Validation](docs/validation/abstract-evidence-20261115.md): two quotations, 16 words, partial completion and six conservative assessments. All 687 tests, two adversarial reviews and post-merge CI passed. This technical self-review is excluded from the independent calibration matrices; it does not resolve #130's conflicting strain join. | +| 1c — **CANDIDATE VERIFIED; merge pending, #130** | Reconcile the mixed BactoTraits strain row | Four primary catalogs confirm the conflict. [Evidence and independent inspection](docs/validation/bactotraits-identity-20261115.md): actual baseline has 21 assertions including the reviewed nonmotility edge; candidate has zero and one mandatory original-row audit. [KG-Microbe PR #1867](https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/pull/1867) is unmerged. Preserve the original occurrence; producer correction before finalization is distinct from graph-release verification. | | 2 — **PENDING, actionable bounded audit** | Semantic identity, relation and node-category correctness | Prepare pinned authorities and audit the selected calibration cases, then the existing 100 after gates pass. Prioritize [#68](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/68)/[#106](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/106) identity joins and [#75](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/75)/[#86](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/86)/[#87](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/87) relation/type-strain/bin semantics. Review nonempty categories, not only missing fields. All 22 fresh-canary biological-literature exclusions still receive identity/modeling review. | | 3 — **PENDING, actionable retained-evidence work** | DOI identity, exact snippets and categorical claim judgments | Resolve publication identity [#69](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/69); replay retained evidence for the selected calibration cases first, then retrieve missing relevant text through appropriate channels. Verify literal quotes and independently judge entailment, conditions and organism/strain scope. Record support, refutation, conflicts, insufficient evidence and assessment blockers distinctly. | | Parallel — **IN PROGRESS** | General full-text credential protection: [#100](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/100), [PR #102](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/pull/102) | The draft has a clean independent review and green CI at `2364161819951b7899ba62cebcd461bf0394c4a7`. Reconcile with current main and validate before a separately authorized merge. Complete this before further authenticated general-helper retrieval; it need not block local modeling or retained-evidence review. | | 4 — **PENDING, gated execution** | Calibrate, then review the retained 100 | After cases, thresholds and evidence preparation are fixed, independently assess the ten cases with all six axes and report disagreements. Canary any newly introduced worker/launcher or evidence-adapter path end to end before using it in a batch. Cover the existing 100 only after calibration passes. Preserve historical bytes; re-review adds coverage depth, not new reviewed occurrences. | | 5 — **PENDING; upstream fixes/releases where needed** | Correct and verify affected assertions and nodes | File each finding, identify its maintained owner, retain before/after proposals, add regressions, regenerate a new candidate and independently re-assess affected occurrences. Include [#56](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/56), [#70](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/70), [#72](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/72) and proof of existing fixes [#71](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/71)/[#73](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/73). A merged source PR is distinct from a verified corrected graph release. | -**Recommended continuation:** finish #127's PR review, reconcile the BactoTraits strain conflict [#130](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/130), and assemble versioned predicate/node authority and DOI/snippet proofs before freezing a new evidence package for two separate reviewers. Reconcile ontology versions before assessing #75/#87; an old local snapshot cannot stand in for the frozen or maintained version. Prepare #102 in parallel for authenticated retrieval. Reuse the 100 retained occurrences as the first correction-focused cohort; do not expand to the remaining 9,900 until evidence, modeling, correction-verification and reviewer-calibration gates in the plan are met. At least one real finding's correction must be independently verified against regenerated candidate bytes; a dependency explanation cannot substitute for that proof ([#119](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/119)). Work within the retained 100 can continue while this expansion gate is unmet. +**Recommended continuation:** finish the reviewed #130 correction PRs through separately approved merges, then assemble versioned predicate/node authority and DOI/snippet proofs before freezing a new evidence package for two separate reviewers. Reconcile ontology versions before assessing #75/#87; an old local snapshot cannot stand in for the frozen or maintained version. Prepare #102 in parallel for authenticated retrieval. Reuse the 100 retained occurrences as the first correction-focused cohort; do not expand to the remaining 9,900 until evidence, modeling and reviewer-calibration gates in the plan are met. #130 now supplies the bounded independent candidate-byte correction demonstration required by [#119](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/119); this does not establish a graph release or satisfy the remaining gates. Work within the retained 100 can continue while expansion remains gated. ## Source, ontology and regression follow-ups @@ -39,7 +40,8 @@ All entries below remain open as of the reconciliation date. Local evidence audi | Issues | What remains | Closure evidence | | --- | --- | --- | | [#68](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/68), [#106](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/106) | Discordant MicrobeDecoder organism crosswalks, including frozen records 10743 and 20904 | Trace the exact joins, independently resolve identity or prove an existing quarantine, and prevent unrelated NCBI fields from entering the measurement/reference binding. Edge47 currently excludes the discordant fields. | -| [#130](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/130) | BactoTraits row 8521 lists DSM 19353/JCM 14586 while its BacDive 17851 link and nominal taxon identify DSM 18772 | Independently resolve collection accessions and the maintained BactoTraits identity join, verify any existing fix/quarantine, and test regenerated candidate bytes before claiming correction. Preserve the source conflict; the nominal-strain paper does not reconcile it. | +| [#130](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/130) | Exact-row quarantine and regenerated producer bytes independently verified; owner merge and graph-release verification remain pending | [Identity investigation](docs/validation/bactotraits-identity-20261115.md), [owner PR #1867](https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/pull/1867). No replacement subject or trait cells are inferred. The partial canonical identity review predates correction validation and remains unchanged. | +| [#132](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/132) | Neighboring BactoTraits row 8517 also has conflicting collection codes; wider source alignment remains unassessed | Independently resolve the additional accessions and trace complete row/column provenance before bounding or repairing other rows. Do not broaden the single-row quarantine automatically. | | [#69](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/69) | Inherited dataset DOIs identify unrelated publications | Verify exact titles/identifiers in the maintained assignment table; prove corrections with a bounded regression before any bulk repair. Database provenance is not biological claim evidence. | | [#70](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/70), [#72](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/72) | Maximum salinity tolerance mapped to halophily; generic sporulation mapped to endospore formation | Establish the correct trait semantics and a source-grounded mapping or explicit exclusion. Preserve range/optimum/tolerance and spore-type distinctions. | | [#75](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/75), [#86](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/86), [#87](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/87) | Obsolete observation predicate; taxon/type-strain conflation; opaque BactoTraits quantitative classes | Obtain maintained predicate/type-strain representations and auditable bin definitions with bounds, endpoint conventions, units and range-versus-optimum meaning. Preserve API-kit outcome context. Do not invent local ontology definitions. | @@ -52,7 +54,7 @@ Related edge-quality work, **PENDING source/release follow-up**: ## LBNL/library service usage and next access check -Usage below is scoped to the two canaries and the edge47 follow-up. The LBNL literature/review skills were used for the follow-up, but successful licensed-library full-text retrieval was not demonstrated in these runs. +Usage below is scoped to the two canaries, the edge47 follow-up and the BactoTraits identity investigation. The LBNL literature/review skills were used, but successful licensed-library full-text retrieval was not demonstrated in these runs. | Run / service | Observed use and result | | --- | --- | @@ -60,6 +62,7 @@ Usage below is scoped to the two canaries and the edge47 follow-up. The LBNL lit | Fresh 50 | 425 total paper-retrieval HTTP attempts. Five credential-backed Springer **open-access JATS** API attempts all returned 401. Seven Wiley TDM attempts returned four 403s and three 400s. These publisher attempts supplied no successful full text. Public discovery/retrieval also used Europe PMC, Crossref, OpenAlex and NCBI. | | Edge47 follow-up | The authenticated Wiley attempt for the 1993 paper returned 403. Local Zotero search found neither the priority 1983 nor 1993 paper. The 1983 access check skipped the LibKey/proxy route because it was unconfigured at that time. The complete 2024 paper actually inspected was retrieved anonymously through Europe PMC, with 149,817 XML bytes saved and verified. | | CBORG tools | No Valency, Tavily or Context7 execution is recorded in the examined fresh-canary/edge47 transport, packet and receipt metadata. This is a statement about retained traces, not proof that no conversation-level tool call ever occurred. Skill names alone do not establish service execution. | +| BactoTraits identity investigation, 2026-11-15 | Three successful CBORG Tavily calls (one search, two extracts) and four anonymous primary-catalog fetches. Request-ID provenance and raw catalog/text/hash receipts were retained privately. DSMZ/JCM/BacDive establish the accession conflict; no Valency, Context7, publisher TDM or full-paper retrieval was used. | Public provenance is in the reports linked above. Detailed private receipts remain outside Git: `edge-sample-review-20261112-data/phase2/literature/http-attempts.jsonl` (Springer entries 17, 44, 165, 223, 397; Wiley entries 93, 95, 103, 105, 124, 126, 345), and `retained-pr107-20261115/.temp/fulltext/salt-evidence-47-20261115/` (`local-search.json`, `kandler1983-access.json`, Wiley and primary2024 receipts). These are relative archive locators under the private EdgeMech agent-work directory, not repository files. Do not commit raw article bodies, private source packets or credentials. diff --git a/docs/validation/bactotraits-identity-20261115.md b/docs/validation/bactotraits-identity-20261115.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c433ded --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/validation/bactotraits-identity-20261115.md @@ -0,0 +1,180 @@ +# BactoTraits mixed-strain source investigation + +This investigation follows [#130](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/130) +for the exact fresh-05 occurrence +`urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136`: +`NCBITaxon:1123071 biolink:has_phenotype METPO:1000703`. + +The source row contains identifiers for two different organisms. A replacement +subject or culture-code edit would assume which parts of the row are trustworthy. +The bounded candidate correction therefore withholds that row's BactoTraits +contribution and preserves the reason and original identity in an audit. It does +not declare the biological nonmotility claim false or remove another source's +independent evidence for that claim. + +## Primary identity evidence + +| Source identity | Independently checked catalog identity | +| --- | --- | +| DSM 19353 / JCM 14586 | *Thioprofundum lithotrophicum*, strain 106; BacDive 17847 and NCBITaxon 571898 | +| DSM 18772 / MBIC 08254 / NBRC 103619 | *Rubritalea squalenifaciens*, HOact 23; BacDive 17851 | + +The first mapping is confirmed by [DSMZ DSM 19353](https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-19353) +and [JCM 14586](https://www.jcm.riken.jp/cgi-bin/jcm/jcm_number?JCM=14586). +JCM documents an original-publication typo, JCM 14596; the catalog-corrected +accession is 14586. That typo is not a reason to identify either strain with +*Rubritalea*. + +The second mapping is independently confirmed by [DSMZ DSM 18772](https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-18772) +and [BacDive 17851](https://bacdive.dsmz.de/strain/17851). The BacDive page identifies +NCBITaxon 1123071 with genome GCA_900141815 and NCBITaxon 407226 with 16S sequence +AB277853. These are distinct identifiers in the source, not interchangeable +replacement subjects. The retained primary description, DOI +[10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0](https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0), describes nonmotility +for HOact23/DSM 18772 in its abstract; no new full paper was inspected here. + +Four anonymous catalog responses, deterministic text derivatives and capture +receipts are retained privately under `.temp/identity130/authorities/`. Raw HTML +and full text derivatives are excluded from Git. The first DSM19353 fetch was +run and inspected before the other captures. The +[capture helper](../../scripts/adhoc/capture_strain_authorities_130_20261115.py) +records response and text hashes, access time, URL, extent and its own code hash. + +## Maintained owner and observed failure + +The owner is `Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe`, specifically +`download.yaml` and `kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py`. +Current remote master inspected was `ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc`. +Both files have the same Git blobs as the inspected local checkout at +`e3d1213a8bf7a4408204ebd48c19e42ec2e14b5e`; the remote branch check therefore did +not establish a later correction in either owner file. + +The June 2022 source CSV is SHA256 +`18316d7a0b6c2bef6fcb96a7659c2e3f3734c14786f383c2a93fefe2ae226a4b`; +its MD5 matches the maintained download pin `e6bca5b947c1aa692d45ac24aa9025f3`. +Its data row 8521 contains BacDive 17851 and the *Rubritalea squalenifaciens* +name, but culture codes DSM 19353 / JCM 14586. The complete retained row text +has SHA256 `345fd2d00ee93334d975085716692dd4d4c530d5529f04c5b07af0766d5a512a`. + +The current transform reads the BacDive ID and joins it through the consumed +BacDive lookup. It copies the collection-code field without checking its +agreement with that identity. The lookup itself distinguishes BacDive 17847 / +NCBITaxon 571898 from BacDive 17851 / NCBITaxon 1123071. The mixed row is already +present in the original CSV; EdgeMech's extraction did not create it. + +The [CSV-aware bounded query](../../scripts/adhoc/inspect_bactotraits_owner_130_20261115.sql) +inspected rows 8517–8525. Row 8517 contains another accession mismatch, recorded +separately in [#132](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/132). This +supports investigating a wider alignment problem; it does not establish its +extent or authorize an automatic repair of neighboring rows. Ordinals count data +records after the two preamble records and header, not raw physical line numbers. + +GitHub all-state searches for the exact terms `19353` and `17851` returned no +issues during the owner trace. The related BactoTraits lookup-freshness changes +do not resolve the source identity conflict. These are bounded search results, +not proof that no correction exists anywhere outside the examined surfaces. + +## Correction boundary + +The owner change in [KG-Microbe PR #1867](https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/pull/1867) +is a finite, reviewed-row quarantine with an input +policy and mandatory audit. It matches the complete original row before source +cell normalization, fails on changed/missing/duplicated reviewed identities, and +records actual consumed input hashes. It does not infer corrected accessions, +taxon IDs or phenotype cells, and does not introduce a general mismatch filter +over unreviewed rows. + +The real single-row transform replay reproduced 21 assertions and 22 nodes on +baseline `ef27b97a`, including the exact reviewed nonmotility assertion. Candidate +`9c1fb3633` emitted zero assertions and nodes, and one mandatory quarantine audit +containing the complete original row, original mapped identity, actual slice +ordinal 1, reviewed ordinal 8521 and policy/source hashes. This demonstrates a +bounded producer correction before source finalization. There were no unaffected +real rows in the slice; a separate synthetic-control regression tests their +retention. No replacement taxon or phenotype values were inferred. + +The same launcher and input bytes were used for both runs, including the actual +BacDive lookup, METPO templates and URI prefix registry. NCBITaxon labels came from existing read-only +database statements; the DB and OWL release agreed at `2026-07-12`. The launcher +pins the queried statements and database metadata, not a whole-database hash. +Neither run made provider calls. The first baseline attempt was stopped by the +stage-only guard on an import-time cache write; [KG-Microbe #1866](https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/issues/1866) +records the fix and fresh-process regression before the successful replays. +The original failed stage remains preserved. + +Separate launcher review found that the v2 receipts omitted the consumed prefix +registry, filed as [KG-Microbe #1868](https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/issues/1868). +The corrected launcher stages and pins that registry, binds input equality, +routes actual URI conversion through it before producer construction, and checks +original and staged inputs before and after execution. Five focused launcher +regressions passed, followed by fresh v3 baseline and candidate runs. Both +registry copies have SHA256 +`a11f11fc43db2d3d0ffd74aca08fbc1da08033074b355ef2e0a1d6d547c29762`. +The v2 receipts remain unchanged as superseded evidence; they are not relabeled +as complete input-equivalence proof. The obsolete owner's final gate was +interrupted after the finding and retained with exit 2, not counted as passing. + +Private stages in the owner worktree are +`data/validation-bactotraits-130/baseline-v3-20261116/` and +`candidate-v3-20261116/`. Their receipt SHA256 values are +`0000d1fd631d4bbfddf1d4d378824485911435c7a0fa162c939cbfb55ce2556d` and +`f33f8387be6518514ebcde34b56687947d64897484db8abc3c72f889745c6599`. +The launcher SHA256 is +`060d7e4dbb6189051f989a4a9efbf55336408e4224ecba5a4975e710538ea90e`. +See the [owner replay report](https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/blob/a86c63e778ebf8a646abb9d4d9e0718dfd49f5a0/docs/BACTOTRAITS_IDENTITY_QUARANTINE.md) +for the implementation boundary and retained evidence. + +A separate reviewer who authored neither the transform nor launcher inspected +the saved TSVs and audit directly, recomputed receipt/output/policy/original +source/lookup/registry hashes, compared input slices byte-for-byte with each other and the +original records, and independently confirmed data-row ordinal 8521. The v3 byte +inspection passed with no findings. Owner head +`a86c63e778ebf8a646abb9d4d9e0718dfd49f5a0` +has unchanged code from replay candidate `9c1fb3633` (the intervening change +adds the replay report). The reviewer also checked private-stage permissions and +left all evidence unchanged. This supplies the bounded candidate-byte correction +demonstration required by [#119](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/119). + +The source-owner PR is not merged and no graph release has been regenerated. +The frozen occurrence remains immutable. Biological claim/model judgments and +independent reviewer calibration remain separate from this source quarantine; +expansion beyond the existing 100 reviewed occurrences is still gated. + +## Saved review and validation + +The new [canonical identity review](../../reviews/structured/20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity/review.md) +replays seven evidence records and six bounded quotations. The retained paper +quotations total 16 words; each catalog contributes at most 25 quoted words. +It records claim and source fidelity as `NOT_ASSESSABLE`, literature support as +`PARTIAL`, and relation/subject/object modeling as `UNRESOLVED`. It is a partial +technical self-review, excluded from independent reviewer calibration, with no +admission recommendation. It links the original finding without rewriting the +prior review. This review records the identity investigation, before verification +of a candidate transform correction. + +The first save attempt exposed [#133](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/133): +the capture receipt's timezone-aware `+00:00` timestamp was incompatible with +the canonical contract's UTC `Z` form. The adapter now normalizes that field, +preserving the original receipt bytes and timestamp precision. The failed stage +and original helper snapshot remain private; a fresh v2 stage saved and checked +the canonical pair successfully without new provider calls. + +Validation completed on this evidence implementation: 698 tests passed, Ruff +passed for the CI scope (`src/edgemech tests scripts/adhoc`), all 16 pinned CLAW +contract files verified, and both source distribution +and wheel were built and inspected as nonempty artifacts. These checks establish +the evidence adapter's behavior, not a corrected graph release. +The broader `ruff check .` reports two pre-existing E741 warnings in the vendored +ID-label validator, filed separately as [#134](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/134) +and deferred to its maintained owner. + +## Services used + +CBORG Tavily supplied three successful keyed calls: one search and two extraction +calls covering four catalog pages. Their request identifiers are recorded in the +private service-provenance receipt, and one complete extraction response is +retained. Four separate anonymous catalog fetches supplied the raw bytes used for +replay. An initial sandbox DNS failure preceded the successful single-fetch +canary. No Valency, Context7, publisher TDM or licensed full-text retrieval was +used for this identity check. Catalog retrieval is distinct from library access +to a full scientific paper. diff --git a/reviews/structured/20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity/review.md b/reviews/structured/20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity/review.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a48daac --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/structured/20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity/review.md @@ -0,0 +1,950 @@ +# Fresh-05 source identity investigation confirms incompatible culture accessions + +- Review: 20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity +- Repository: CultureBotAI/EdgeMech +- Started UTC: 2026-11-16T07:40:49Z +- Finished UTC: 2026-11-16T07:40:49Z +- Reviewer: Codex agent (self_review) +- Completion: partial +- Verdict: needs_curation +- Scientific review: true + +## Summary + +Primary catalog snapshots confirm that DSM 19353/JCM 14586 and DSM 18772 belong to distinct taxa. No safe source-field replacement, independently verified correction or resolved graph claim follows. Six newly authored categorical assessments remain conservative; the review is partial and excluded from independent calibration. + +## Scope And Provenance + +One occurrence's source identity investigation after abstract replay. + +Selection: Fresh-05 retained original occurrence and source conflict #130. +Coverage: partial; 1 reviewed / 1 in the declared population. +Source: working_tree at Git base a4c8ce937ffd791b7c7b4d05b85121dea1aa09d6. +Working-tree hashes do not imply those bytes were committed. + +| Target | Path / selector | Kind | Label | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/packet.json # occurrence_id=urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | snapshot_row | Fresh-05 source strain identity investigation | + +## Validation + +| Check | Status | Required | Targets | Result | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Ignored private staging preflight | passed | True | urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | Git ignore check passed; no tracked destination files; fresh private directory and exclusive 0600 files enforce no overwrite. | +| Exact retained source and endpoint replay | passed | True | urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | Fixed input hashes and cohort identity checked; build_packet and validate_packet replayed the newly persisted occurrence/source bytes. | +| Primary abstract identity and quotes | passed | True | urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | The abstract adapter selected the exact MED/PMID primary result, verified DOI/title identity, extracted the complete abstract, and verify_quote matched both literal excerpts with hashes/offsets within one 25-word budget. No full text was inspected or claimed. | +| Pinned CLAW contract byte verification | passed | True | urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | check_contracts returned successfully before review construction. | +| Verified source-row correction | unavailable | True | urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | Catalog identities are disambiguated, but no safe field replacement or implemented source-row quarantine has been independently verified on regenerated candidate bytes. The original graph claim remains unresolved. | +| Predicate and both endpoint authorities | unavailable | True | urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | Scoped versioned NCBI/METPO/Biolink/RO proofs were not authored in this canary; all modeling axes remain unresolved and review completion partial. | +| Captured catalog identity provenance | passed | True | urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | All four raw HTML/text/receipt hashes and the capture helper hash matched; the deterministic text derivative and bounded quotes replayed. Culture identities were independently disambiguated before authoring this review. | +| Maintained download and transform snapshots | passed | True | urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 | Nonempty download.yaml and BactoTraits transform bytes were read from the Git object at ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc and retained as pinned inputs. This is owner tracing, not a source patch or regeneration check. | + +## Scientific And Domain Assessments + +### Source-identity investigation: claim + +grounding: unknown. Targets: urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136. + +The retained abstract reports nonmotility for the nominal DSM 18772 strain. The original identifier-bound graph assertion remains not assessable: the source row mixes identities and formal predicate/node checks remain incomplete. + +### Source-identity investigation: literature + +evidence: unknown. Targets: urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136. + +The same two DOI/PMID-bound abstract quotations partly address nonmotility for HOact23/DSM 18772. Catalog identity checks add no full-paper assay evidence and do not establish ownership of every trait in the mixed source row. + +### Source-identity investigation: relation + +representation: unknown. Targets: urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136. + +Culture accession disambiguation does not validate has_phenotype/RO:0002200. A scoped versioned predicate authority assessment remains outstanding. + +### Source-identity investigation: subject node + +identity: unknown. Targets: urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136. + +Current DSMZ/BacDive catalogs verify the nominal DSM 18772/HOact23 culture link. DSM 19353/JCM 14586 instead identify Thioprofundum strain 106. Formal NCBI/Biolink identity, rank and category assessment remains unresolved. + +### Source-identity investigation: object node + +representation: unknown. Targets: urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136. + +Nonmotility is reported for the nominal isolate, but this identity review does not adjudicate METPO:1000703 definition or graph category fitness. + +### Source-identity investigation: source fidelity + +provenance: unknown. Targets: urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136. + +The incompatible culture links are now independently confirmed. The row's BacDive ID/name and collection codes refer to different taxa; the maintained transform selects NCBI by BacDive ID. A safe field replacement and verified row correction have not been established. + +## Findings + +### source-accession-conflict: Source row carries conflicting strain accessions + +major / open / confirmed; issue key: bactotraits-row8521-conflicting-strain-accessions. + +BactoTraits row 8521 names Rubritalea squalenifaciens/BacDive 17851 but lists DSM 19353/JCM 14586. Captured DSMZ/JCM authorities place that collection pair in Thioprofundum lithotrophicum strain 106/BacDive 17847/NCBI 571898. DSMZ and current BacDive 17851 instead bind the nominal Rubritalea to DSM 18772/HOact23/MBIC08254/NBRC103619. The incompatible identity fields are confirmed; the intended ownership of all source traits and a safe replacement remain unresolved. + +## Recommended Actions And Acceptance Checks + +### quarantine-and-verify-source-identity + +Propose a complete-reviewed-row-hash-bound quarantine at the maintained BactoTraits transform; do not silently substitute accession or taxon fields. Establish the intended source identity with the table owner, preserve the before/after proposal and independently verify regenerated candidate occurrences before claiming correction. + +- Retain original row hash, occurrence and all conflicting fields. +- Quarantine acceptance is keyed by the complete reviewed row hash and exact row identity; retain whole-source-file hash as receipt provenance, not as a requirement to reject an otherwise unchanged reviewed row. +- Do not replace graph subject 1123071 with 571898 from accessions alone. +- Add a regression against mixed-strain joins without altering unrelated rows. +- Independently verify candidate regeneration and affected occurrences. + +## Category Boundaries + + +## Evidence + +| Evidence | Reference / locator | Support | Observation | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| packet-source | .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/packet.json; original_assertion; endpoints; source_records: BactoTraits CSV row 8521, BacDive 17851, LPSN 785725 | context_only | Exact retained source/endpoint context includes incompatible collection-code fields; this is not independent biological proof. | +| abstract-nonmotility | https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0; abstract; PMID 17625207; chars 162:265; text_sha256=28ae92fb2c8f9d7319bd5ea1effc5587e84e9fb4ea78d6aa6e7a0499eb896f89 | partial | Literal primary abstract excerpt inspected in full abstract context; nominal DSM 18772 strain match does not settle disputed source accessions or the entire identifier-bound graph assertion. | +| abstract-strain | https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0; abstract; PMID 17625207; chars 1157:1208; text_sha256=28ae92fb2c8f9d7319bd5ea1effc5587e84e9fb4ea78d6aa6e7a0499eb896f89 | partial | Literal primary abstract excerpt inspected in full abstract context; nominal DSM 18772 strain match does not settle disputed source accessions or the entire identifier-bound graph assertion. | +| catalog-dsm19353 | https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-19353; catalog identity; chars 3153:3297; text_sha256=8fa3d180a19442d947a7bbdd86cf1efd78f6ca891fe2acbc42f2c6a9d15c6d82 | context_only | DSM 19353 and JCM 14586 identify Thioprofundum lithotrophicum strain 106, not the nominal Rubritalea strain. | +| catalog-jcm14586 | https://www.jcm.riken.jp/cgi-bin/jcm/jcm_number?JCM=14586; catalog identity; chars 776:820; text_sha256=93d5aec6c739d6bd48c4c4aa66416c7dfe4220ff9ca5c572a1010ad02be0440f | context_only | JCM 14586's complete catalog page corroborates strain 106/DSM 19353 and binds it to BacDive 17847 and NCBI 571898. It documents the original-paper JCM 14596 typographical error; that typo is not a new equivalent accession. | +| catalog-dsm18772 | https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-18772; catalog identity; chars 3083:3242; text_sha256=99c07d7d2dfeb73ed1fbb69e8213c8034146e51140b2a80f160bd59faead79c8 | context_only | The nominal Rubritalea squalenifaciens type strain has DSM 18772, HOact 23, MBIC08254 and NBRC 103619 aliases. | +| catalog-bacdive17851 | https://bacdive.dsmz.de/strain/17851; catalog identity; chars 674:819; text_sha256=29f41098eb41eb4a6ca0d46abe5ecd746e8cc5dbb4edac5cb6b8233bd6cdd7bc | context_only | Current BacDive 17851 retains the Rubritalea culture aliases. Its inspected sequence sections distinguish strain/genome 1123071 from species/16S 407226; this catalog is not independent NCBI ontology adjudication. | + +## Limits And Additional Notes + +- Partial self-review; not an independent calibration rating, agreement result or gold label. +- Complete catalog pages and the retained abstract were inspected; no full scientific paper. +- Four catalog snapshots resolve competing aliases, not all original statement/model semantics. +- The confirmed source conflict does not establish biological refutation or a safe field repair. +- Neighbor investigation #132 is context only and contributes no new reviewed occurrence here. +- Investigation used 3 successful CBORG Tavily calls and 4 anonymous catalog GETs; no Valency, publisher TDM or licensed-library full text. This replay launcher makes zero requests. +- Original source bytes/reviews remain intact; no source patch, native capability or graph admission. +- Private catalog/source bodies remain ignored; canonical review contains bounded snippets and hashes. + +## Complete Structured Record + +The sibling review.yaml is authoritative. + +```yaml +schema_version: 1.0.0 +review_id: 20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity +kind: record +repository: CultureBotAI/EdgeMech +title: Fresh-05 source identity investigation confirms incompatible culture accessions +started_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' +finished_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' +reviewer: + identity: Codex agent + kind: agent + independence: self_review + independence_basis: New authored source-identity judgments using retained source/abstract + and current catalogs. Historical reviews and labels were visible; excluded from + independent calibration matrices. +skill: edgemech-occurrence-review/v1 +completion: partial +verdict: needs_curation +scientific_review: true +summary: Primary catalog snapshots confirm that DSM 19353/JCM 14586 and DSM 18772 + belong to distinct taxa. No safe source-field replacement, independently verified + correction or resolved graph claim follows. Six newly authored categorical assessments + remain conservative; the review is partial and excluded from independent calibration. +source: + git_revision: a4c8ce937ffd791b7c7b4d05b85121dea1aa09d6 + state: working_tree + inputs: + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/abstract.json + sha256: 82d96c9481a6d11eefc5976e65b2863e10bed3cedf8b02f9b09cdb92802cf807 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/bacdive17851.html + sha256: 1a6b1f17cea659277484d7461db6ad3f50e6e32a85c6bf5abdc472e8a489b592 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/bacdive17851.json + sha256: 6a0e0f46648056fa529748d5010db3df04600a40fb86ab1da2edeba85ac26ea9 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/bacdive17851.txt + sha256: 29f41098eb41eb4a6ca0d46abe5ecd746e8cc5dbb4edac5cb6b8233bd6cdd7bc + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/cborg-service-provenance.json + sha256: f9e7ce85c9c9a2738d14384f46251797ad5d213f1efb1d7b8a2ce95d76b289d0 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/cborg-tavily-dsm18772.json + sha256: 49096c6b7b7607d1071415bac9e70ab298326c9628d45f7b2aa36351e1611481 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm18772.html + sha256: e6ce0ea2affb04b490b537478a4b804371e187e3eb44f29cff2a99e0875b7079 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm18772.json + sha256: c4dff78887cf1fc393286867e2954d2d39198ff521dec8417984cdecb3359328 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm18772.txt + sha256: 99c07d7d2dfeb73ed1fbb69e8213c8034146e51140b2a80f160bd59faead79c8 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm19353.html + sha256: d416237bc389c88a12185f6981a97faf10cfb091c579b6fb10f721a24c9e1921 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm19353.json + sha256: 99b8f7dde10107d7e6510f2cfb2ded46ca4dfba3e8b6e6230ef7990dc49e8bbf + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm19353.txt + sha256: 8fa3d180a19442d947a7bbdd86cf1efd78f6ca891fe2acbc42f2c6a9d15c6d82 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/jcm14586.html + sha256: 6ee861e0a76f89b937aa79249450267985202f26a326ce629d0119d1b36effaf + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/jcm14586.json + sha256: 8906c5337592813bbcf2767bc45cfe08f5520a45922e00df0545f84e01071b9c + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/jcm14586.txt + sha256: 93d5aec6c739d6bd48c4c4aa66416c7dfe4220ff9ca5c572a1010ad02be0440f + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/kg-microbe-bactotraits.py + sha256: 0d75c432f89f70f90ace3135e7142909721140ba416a638b95e52ac8fcfd7523 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/kg-microbe-download.yaml + sha256: 209669d1de7e2dfea17712a755217fd201241d2e32f763366ff0570270610153 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/occurrence.json + sha256: 7b537e0809c90529f7663866359bace6b7d9bd5c7547c74cf4faf88268430426 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/packet.json + sha256: 8198616d22c932487940fe40a55926a9f8c2c35c9e473a3210a223a435c86703 + role: target + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/prepared-packet.json + sha256: 9a456958680990e4d6742b2bc012579d6e48d5d2adefdfcd24c6f0b6ab56b34b + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/proofs.json + sha256: 21cebf11f52cf65a37fccb25f62fc457050467ea0f19a83834ea41b4fb08914e + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/source.json + sha256: 9ff02c936f66ec58ad26b25f6176cf96d1f2f92bb556b6c4e7c971995a42f8e7 + role: context + - path: artifacts/edge-calibration-20261115/cohort.json + sha256: 1dc756b0ba628756baf544cacf36f0a1ab2e4c68eed6724ee281205f22d606ee + role: context + - path: artifacts/edge-calibration-20261115/protocol.json + sha256: d24b9e1e9833d70407bf06a04ae6c0ff92f5564149a3b51e6402e5416e866517 + role: context + - path: docs/record-review-profile.md + sha256: 45e4a564d4926ad491e6a8c2ec4426f8249dfc18318d8c7e2e4d4422dd8143f6 + role: context + - path: reviews/structured/20261116T052355Z-fresh05-abstract-adapter/review.yaml + sha256: b1ca23d2c1d2854f73c85564d2cad27572736465c06ef47345319266664b3427 + role: context + - path: schema/record_review.yaml + sha256: 229baf9b69118a1fe318e4c31085c0820e4e3d1365e7b04d6ace451b7c35f9bb + role: context + - path: scripts/adhoc/capture_strain_authorities_130_20261115.py + sha256: 56b1ef847187e15a80a00e7b197f28435fcb465bdb0c3954cc097ffbe07388f1 + role: context + - path: scripts/adhoc/review_bactotraits_identity_130_20261115.py + sha256: 798dd020dea338e37eccb952c6715b3b2d33e23ce5fbf51b6905d5eef99ac5b9 + role: context + - path: scripts/adhoc/run_abstract_canary_20261115.py + sha256: 467f3dbdc899bbcc23f3097a87f51cd4b1f712abbafefd13ed02591c28d03e68 + role: context + - path: src/edgemech/contract-pins.json + sha256: 788ecc876a432feebeb89627fbe5a40dba1c1001598683c19834e4626667842c + role: context + - path: src/edgemech/literature_cache.py + sha256: 12e3d920e2a9978c25b5d7626aae087ccd089609c367339a240eb8f37b7a3fef + role: context + - path: src/edgemech/occurrence_packet.py + sha256: 7526fcb6f4467a342abc644c8f607b9b8c6fb395eac159c61f4654594cc490d7 + role: context + - path: src/edgemech/occurrence_review.py + sha256: 8821065a01a03752f1952accd0ae7fb53c5d31e85a8f5be621c2d8a7f43d43e3 + role: context +targets: +- target_id: urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/packet.json + selector: occurrence_id=urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + kind: snapshot_row + record_class: ReleaseOccurrence + label: Fresh-05 source strain identity investigation + ownership_note: Source publisher controls the BactoTraits table; maintained KG-Microbe + download/join paths are identified at ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc. + owner_paths: + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: download.yaml + role: Maintained BactoTraits source download and checksum pin + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py + role: Maintained BacDive-ID to NCBI identity join and BactoTraits transform +scope: + description: One occurrence's source identity investigation after abstract replay. + selection: 'Fresh-05 retained original occurrence and source conflict #130.' + coverage: partial + population_size: 1 + reviewed_target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + exclusions: + - target: Independent ten-case calibration scoring + reason: Self-review with historical labels visible; no new rating. + - target: 'Neighbor-row finding #132' + reason: Contextual follow-up only; not an additional reviewed target. + - target: Other retained occurrences and remaining 9900 + reason: No review expansion or population inference. +checks: +- check_id: private-staging + name: Ignored private staging preflight + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + command: git check-ignore --no-index --quiet .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/abstract.json + exit_code: 0 + expected_exit_code: 0 + summary: Git ignore check passed; no tracked destination files; fresh private directory + and exclusive 0600 files enforce no overwrite. +- check_id: source-packet + name: Exact retained source and endpoint replay + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + summary: Fixed input hashes and cohort identity checked; build_packet and validate_packet + replayed the newly persisted occurrence/source bytes. +- check_id: abstract-identity-quotes + name: Primary abstract identity and quotes + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + summary: The abstract adapter selected the exact MED/PMID primary result, verified + DOI/title identity, extracted the complete abstract, and verify_quote matched + both literal excerpts with hashes/offsets within one 25-word budget. No full text + was inspected or claimed. +- check_id: pinned-contracts + name: Pinned CLAW contract byte verification + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + summary: check_contracts returned successfully before review construction. +- check_id: source-identity-resolution + name: Verified source-row correction + status: unavailable + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + summary: Catalog identities are disambiguated, but no safe field replacement or + implemented source-row quarantine has been independently verified on regenerated + candidate bytes. The original graph claim remains unresolved. +- check_id: versioned-modeling + name: Predicate and both endpoint authorities + status: unavailable + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + summary: Scoped versioned NCBI/METPO/Biolink/RO proofs were not authored in this + canary; all modeling axes remain unresolved and review completion partial. +- check_id: catalog-identity-replay + name: Captured catalog identity provenance + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + summary: All four raw HTML/text/receipt hashes and the capture helper hash matched; + the deterministic text derivative and bounded quotes replayed. Culture identities + were independently disambiguated before authoring this review. +- check_id: maintained-owner-snapshots + name: Maintained download and transform snapshots + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + summary: Nonempty download.yaml and BactoTraits transform bytes were read from the + Git object at ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc and retained as pinned + inputs. This is owner tracing, not a source patch or regeneration check. +evidence: +- evidence_id: packet-source + kind: record_content + reference: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/packet.json + locator: 'original_assertion; endpoints; source_records: BactoTraits CSV row 8521, + BacDive 17851, LPSN 785725' + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' + support: context_only + snapshot_sha256: 8198616d22c932487940fe40a55926a9f8c2c35c9e473a3210a223a435c86703 + summary: Exact retained source/endpoint context includes incompatible collection-code + fields; this is not independent biological proof. +- evidence_id: abstract-nonmotility + kind: primary_source + reference: https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0 + locator: abstract; PMID 17625207; chars 162:265; text_sha256=28ae92fb2c8f9d7319bd5ea1effc5587e84e9fb4ea78d6aa6e7a0499eb896f89 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' + support: partial + quote: The strain, designated HOact23(T), was a non-motile, rod-shaped (0.44-0.53x0.65-0.79 + microm) bacterium. + snapshot_sha256: 82d96c9481a6d11eefc5976e65b2863e10bed3cedf8b02f9b09cdb92802cf807 + summary: Literal primary abstract excerpt inspected in full abstract context; nominal + DSM 18772 strain match does not settle disputed source accessions or the entire + identifier-bound graph assertion. +- evidence_id: abstract-strain + kind: primary_source + reference: https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0 + locator: abstract; PMID 17625207; chars 1157:1208; text_sha256=28ae92fb2c8f9d7319bd5ea1effc5587e84e9fb4ea78d6aa6e7a0499eb896f89 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' + support: partial + quote: type strain HOact23(T) (=MBIC08254(T)=DSM 18772(T)) + snapshot_sha256: 82d96c9481a6d11eefc5976e65b2863e10bed3cedf8b02f9b09cdb92802cf807 + summary: Literal primary abstract excerpt inspected in full abstract context; nominal + DSM 18772 strain match does not settle disputed source accessions or the entire + identifier-bound graph assertion. +- evidence_id: catalog-dsm19353 + kind: authority + support: context_only + reference: https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-19353 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207Z' + quote: '19353, Type strain dsm-19353 dsm19353 dsm 19353 Thioprofundum lithotrophicum + + Strain designation: + + 106 + + Other collection no. + + or WDCM no.: + + JCM 14586' + snapshot_sha256: 8fa3d180a19442d947a7bbdd86cf1efd78f6ca891fe2acbc42f2c6a9d15c6d82 + locator: catalog identity; chars 3153:3297; text_sha256=8fa3d180a19442d947a7bbdd86cf1efd78f6ca891fe2acbc42f2c6a9d15c6d82 + summary: DSM 19353 and JCM 14586 identify Thioprofundum lithotrophicum strain 106, + not the nominal Rubritalea strain. +- evidence_id: catalog-jcm14586 + kind: authority + support: context_only + reference: https://www.jcm.riken.jp/cgi-bin/jcm/jcm_number?JCM=14586 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:32:41.164578Z' + quote: 'BacDive ID: 17847. + + NCBI Taxonomy ID: 571898.' + snapshot_sha256: 93d5aec6c739d6bd48c4c4aa66416c7dfe4220ff9ca5c572a1010ad02be0440f + locator: catalog identity; chars 776:820; text_sha256=93d5aec6c739d6bd48c4c4aa66416c7dfe4220ff9ca5c572a1010ad02be0440f + summary: JCM 14586's complete catalog page corroborates strain 106/DSM 19353 and + binds it to BacDive 17847 and NCBI 571898. It documents the original-paper JCM + 14596 typographical error; that typo is not a new equivalent accession. +- evidence_id: catalog-dsm18772 + kind: authority + support: context_only + reference: https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-18772 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:32:36.482044Z' + quote: '18772, Type strain dsm-18772 dsm18772 dsm 18772 Rubritalea squalenifaciens + + Strain designation: + + HOact 23 + + Other collection no. + + or WDCM no.: + + MBIC08254,NBRC 103619' + snapshot_sha256: 99c07d7d2dfeb73ed1fbb69e8213c8034146e51140b2a80f160bd59faead79c8 + locator: catalog identity; chars 3083:3242; text_sha256=99c07d7d2dfeb73ed1fbb69e8213c8034146e51140b2a80f160bd59faead79c8 + summary: The nominal Rubritalea squalenifaciens type strain has DSM 18772, HOact + 23, MBIC08254 and NBRC 103619 aliases. +- evidence_id: catalog-bacdive17851 + kind: authority + support: context_only + reference: https://bacdive.dsmz.de/strain/17851 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:33:14.199643Z' + quote: 'BacDive ID + + 17851 + + Type strain + + Strain Designation + + HOact 23 + + Culture col. no. + + DSM 18772 + + MBIC 08254 + + NBRC 103619 + + HOact 23 + + NCBI tax ID(s) + + 1123071 + + 407226' + snapshot_sha256: 29f41098eb41eb4a6ca0d46abe5ecd746e8cc5dbb4edac5cb6b8233bd6cdd7bc + locator: catalog identity; chars 674:819; text_sha256=29f41098eb41eb4a6ca0d46abe5ecd746e8cc5dbb4edac5cb6b8233bd6cdd7bc + summary: Current BacDive 17851 retains the Rubritalea culture aliases. Its inspected + sequence sections distinguish strain/genome 1123071 from species/16S 407226; this + catalog is not independent NCBI ontology adjudication. +assessments: +- assessment_id: claim + area: grounding + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: claim' + outcome: unknown + summary: 'The retained abstract reports nonmotility for the nominal DSM 18772 strain. + The original identifier-bound graph assertion remains not assessable: the source + row mixes identities and formal predicate/node checks remain incomplete.' + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: claim + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: category + value: NOT_ASSESSABLE + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: assertion_scope + value: NCBITaxon:1123071 biolink:has_phenotype METPO:1000703, with original DSM + 18772/non motile labels. The accession conflict is not a biological refutation + and is not repaired by replacing the subject. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: assertion_scope' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain +- assessment_id: literature + area: evidence + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: literature' + outcome: unknown + summary: The same two DOI/PMID-bound abstract quotations partly address nonmotility + for HOact23/DSM 18772. Catalog identity checks add no full-paper assay evidence + and do not establish ownership of every trait in the mixed source row. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: literature + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: category + value: PARTIAL + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: search_scope + value: Retained complete abstract only, DOI 10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0, PMID 17625207; + no new paper search or full-paper inspection. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: search_scope' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: literature_channel + value: europepmc_abstract_retained; separate catalog discovery used 3 CBORG Tavily + calls and 4 anonymous primary-catalog GETs; no TDM. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: literature_channel' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: inspected_extent + value: Complete retained abstract and its two unchanged short snippets. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: inspected_extent' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain +- assessment_id: relation + area: representation + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: relation' + outcome: unknown + summary: Culture accession disambiguation does not validate has_phenotype/RO:0002200. + A scoped versioned predicate authority assessment remains outstanding. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: relation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: category + value: UNRESOLVED + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: direction + value: Original organism-to-phenotype direction preserved. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: direction' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: domain_range + value: No new versioned domain/range proof authored. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: domain_range' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: specificity + value: Relation fitness for the original nonmotility statement unresolved. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: specificity' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: qualifiers + value: Abstract and catalogs do not supply complete assay conditions or warrant + a universal-condition reading. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: qualifiers' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source +- assessment_id: subject-node + area: identity + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: subject node' + outcome: unknown + summary: Current DSMZ/BacDive catalogs verify the nominal DSM 18772/HOact23 culture + link. DSM 19353/JCM 14586 instead identify Thioprofundum strain 106. Formal NCBI/Biolink + identity, rank and category assessment remains unresolved. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: subject_node + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: category + value: UNRESOLVED + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: identity + value: NCBITaxon:1123071 retained. BacDive 17851 distinguishes genome 1123071 + from species/16S 407226. The competing culture pair maps through JCM to BacDive + 17847/NCBI 571898, not an equivalent Rubritalea accession. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: identity' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: label + value: Original Rubritalea squalenifaciens DSM 18772 label preserved. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: label' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: category_fit + value: biolink:OrganismTaxon retained; catalog agreement is not formal Biolink + category validation. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category_fit' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: rank_or_type + value: Catalogs distinguish type-strain aliases and species/genome identifiers; + independent NCBI rank/status verification remains incomplete. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: rank_or_type' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: definition + value: No complete versioned node-definition proof authored. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: definition' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: authority_version + value: Four independently captured catalog snapshots are bound by capture timestamps, + raw/text hashes and receipts; the unresolved source join prevents treating them + as complete original-assertion validation. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: authority_version' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 +- assessment_id: object-node + area: representation + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: object node' + outcome: unknown + summary: Nonmotility is reported for the nominal isolate, but this identity review + does not adjudicate METPO:1000703 definition or graph category fitness. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: object_node + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: category + value: UNRESOLVED + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: identity + value: Original METPO:1000703 retained; no replacement proposed. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: identity' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: label + value: Original non motile label retained. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: label' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: category_fit + value: biolink:PhenotypicQuality requires a scoped authority check. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category_fit' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: rank_or_type + value: Nominal phenotype class; formal typing remains unresolved. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: rank_or_type' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: definition + value: No new versioned METPO definition proof authored. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: definition' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: authority_version + value: Preparation authorities are not substituted for new inspected and scoped + modeling evidence. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: authority_version' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source +- assessment_id: source-fidelity + area: provenance + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: source fidelity' + outcome: unknown + summary: The incompatible culture links are now independently confirmed. The row's + BacDive ID/name and collection codes refer to different taxa; the maintained transform + selects NCBI by BacDive ID. A safe field replacement and verified row correction + have not been established. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: source_fidelity + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: category + value: NOT_ASSESSABLE + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: source_binding + value: Original BactoTraits row 8521 and all retained source records remain unchanged. + Maintained owner snapshots at ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc identify + the download pin and BacDive-to-NCBI join. Quarantine is a proposed action, + not an implemented or independently verified graph fix. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: source_binding' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 +findings: +- finding_id: source-accession-conflict + issue_key: bactotraits-row8521-conflicting-strain-accessions + category: identity + severity: major + status: open + certainty: confirmed + title: Source row carries conflicting strain accessions + description: BactoTraits row 8521 names Rubritalea squalenifaciens/BacDive 17851 + but lists DSM 19353/JCM 14586. Captured DSMZ/JCM authorities place that collection + pair in Thioprofundum lithotrophicum strain 106/BacDive 17847/NCBI 571898. DSMZ + and current BacDive 17851 instead bind the nominal Rubritalea to DSM 18772/HOact23/MBIC08254/NBRC103619. + The incompatible identity fields are confirmed; the intended ownership of all + source traits and a safe replacement remain unresolved. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + field_paths: + - 'source_records[0].text: culture collection codes' + - 'source_records[0].text: Bacdive_ID' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + ownership_note: Source publisher owns table correction; KG-Microbe owns download/join + and any reviewed row-quarantine policy at the listed maintained paths. + external_issues: + - https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/130 + owner_paths: + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: download.yaml + role: Maintained BactoTraits source download and checksum pin + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py + role: Maintained BacDive-ID to NCBI identity join and BactoTraits transform + previous_occurrences: + - repository: CultureBotAI/EdgeMech + review_id: 20261116T052355Z-fresh05-abstract-adapter + finding_id: source-accession-conflict +actions: +- action_id: quarantine-and-verify-source-identity + finding_ids: + - source-accession-conflict + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + description: Propose a complete-reviewed-row-hash-bound quarantine at the maintained + BactoTraits transform; do not silently substitute accession or taxon fields. Establish + the intended source identity with the table owner, preserve the before/after proposal + and independently verify regenerated candidate occurrences before claiming correction. + ownership_note: The maintained owner paths are known; no correction or quarantine + is claimed merged by this investigation. + acceptance_checks: + - Retain original row hash, occurrence and all conflicting fields. + - Quarantine acceptance is keyed by the complete reviewed row hash and exact row + identity; retain whole-source-file hash as receipt provenance, not as a requirement + to reject an otherwise unchanged reviewed row. + - Do not replace graph subject 1123071 with 571898 from accessions alone. + - Add a regression against mixed-strain joins without altering unrelated rows. + - Independently verify candidate regeneration and affected occurrences. + owner_paths: + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: download.yaml + role: Maintained BactoTraits source download and checksum pin + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py + role: Maintained BacDive-ID to NCBI identity join and BactoTraits transform +limitations: +- Partial self-review; not an independent calibration rating, agreement result or + gold label. +- Complete catalog pages and the retained abstract were inspected; no full scientific + paper. +- Four catalog snapshots resolve competing aliases, not all original statement/model + semantics. +- The confirmed source conflict does not establish biological refutation or a safe + field repair. +- 'Neighbor investigation #132 is context only and contributes no new reviewed occurrence + here.' +- Investigation used 3 successful CBORG Tavily calls and 4 anonymous catalog GETs; + no Valency, publisher TDM or licensed-library full text. This replay launcher makes + zero requests. +- Original source bytes/reviews remain intact; no source patch, native capability + or graph admission. +- Private catalog/source bodies remain ignored; canonical review contains bounded + snippets and hashes. +links: +- https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/130 +- https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/132 +- https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0 +- https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/blob/ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc/download.yaml +- https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/blob/ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc/kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py +tags: +- source-identity-investigation +- partial-review +- excluded-from-calibration-scoring +``` diff --git a/reviews/structured/20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity/review.yaml b/reviews/structured/20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity/review.yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9643a6f --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/structured/20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity/review.yaml @@ -0,0 +1,819 @@ +schema_version: 1.0.0 +review_id: 20261116T074049Z-fresh05-source-identity +kind: record +repository: CultureBotAI/EdgeMech +title: Fresh-05 source identity investigation confirms incompatible culture accessions +started_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' +finished_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' +reviewer: + identity: Codex agent + kind: agent + independence: self_review + independence_basis: New authored source-identity judgments using retained source/abstract + and current catalogs. Historical reviews and labels were visible; excluded from + independent calibration matrices. +skill: edgemech-occurrence-review/v1 +completion: partial +verdict: needs_curation +scientific_review: true +summary: Primary catalog snapshots confirm that DSM 19353/JCM 14586 and DSM 18772 + belong to distinct taxa. No safe source-field replacement, independently verified + correction or resolved graph claim follows. Six newly authored categorical assessments + remain conservative; the review is partial and excluded from independent calibration. +source: + git_revision: a4c8ce937ffd791b7c7b4d05b85121dea1aa09d6 + state: working_tree + inputs: + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/abstract.json + sha256: 82d96c9481a6d11eefc5976e65b2863e10bed3cedf8b02f9b09cdb92802cf807 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/bacdive17851.html + sha256: 1a6b1f17cea659277484d7461db6ad3f50e6e32a85c6bf5abdc472e8a489b592 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/bacdive17851.json + sha256: 6a0e0f46648056fa529748d5010db3df04600a40fb86ab1da2edeba85ac26ea9 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/bacdive17851.txt + sha256: 29f41098eb41eb4a6ca0d46abe5ecd746e8cc5dbb4edac5cb6b8233bd6cdd7bc + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/cborg-service-provenance.json + sha256: f9e7ce85c9c9a2738d14384f46251797ad5d213f1efb1d7b8a2ce95d76b289d0 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/cborg-tavily-dsm18772.json + sha256: 49096c6b7b7607d1071415bac9e70ab298326c9628d45f7b2aa36351e1611481 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm18772.html + sha256: e6ce0ea2affb04b490b537478a4b804371e187e3eb44f29cff2a99e0875b7079 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm18772.json + sha256: c4dff78887cf1fc393286867e2954d2d39198ff521dec8417984cdecb3359328 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm18772.txt + sha256: 99c07d7d2dfeb73ed1fbb69e8213c8034146e51140b2a80f160bd59faead79c8 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm19353.html + sha256: d416237bc389c88a12185f6981a97faf10cfb091c579b6fb10f721a24c9e1921 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm19353.json + sha256: 99b8f7dde10107d7e6510f2cfb2ded46ca4dfba3e8b6e6230ef7990dc49e8bbf + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/dsm19353.txt + sha256: 8fa3d180a19442d947a7bbdd86cf1efd78f6ca891fe2acbc42f2c6a9d15c6d82 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/jcm14586.html + sha256: 6ee861e0a76f89b937aa79249450267985202f26a326ce629d0119d1b36effaf + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/jcm14586.json + sha256: 8906c5337592813bbcf2767bc45cfe08f5520a45922e00df0545f84e01071b9c + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/jcm14586.txt + sha256: 93d5aec6c739d6bd48c4c4aa66416c7dfe4220ff9ca5c572a1010ad02be0440f + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/kg-microbe-bactotraits.py + sha256: 0d75c432f89f70f90ace3135e7142909721140ba416a638b95e52ac8fcfd7523 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/kg-microbe-download.yaml + sha256: 209669d1de7e2dfea17712a755217fd201241d2e32f763366ff0570270610153 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/occurrence.json + sha256: 7b537e0809c90529f7663866359bace6b7d9bd5c7547c74cf4faf88268430426 + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/packet.json + sha256: 8198616d22c932487940fe40a55926a9f8c2c35c9e473a3210a223a435c86703 + role: target + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/prepared-packet.json + sha256: 9a456958680990e4d6742b2bc012579d6e48d5d2adefdfcd24c6f0b6ab56b34b + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/proofs.json + sha256: 21cebf11f52cf65a37fccb25f62fc457050467ea0f19a83834ea41b4fb08914e + role: context + - path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/source.json + sha256: 9ff02c936f66ec58ad26b25f6176cf96d1f2f92bb556b6c4e7c971995a42f8e7 + role: context + - path: artifacts/edge-calibration-20261115/cohort.json + sha256: 1dc756b0ba628756baf544cacf36f0a1ab2e4c68eed6724ee281205f22d606ee + role: context + - path: artifacts/edge-calibration-20261115/protocol.json + sha256: d24b9e1e9833d70407bf06a04ae6c0ff92f5564149a3b51e6402e5416e866517 + role: context + - path: docs/record-review-profile.md + sha256: 45e4a564d4926ad491e6a8c2ec4426f8249dfc18318d8c7e2e4d4422dd8143f6 + role: context + - path: reviews/structured/20261116T052355Z-fresh05-abstract-adapter/review.yaml + sha256: b1ca23d2c1d2854f73c85564d2cad27572736465c06ef47345319266664b3427 + role: context + - path: schema/record_review.yaml + sha256: 229baf9b69118a1fe318e4c31085c0820e4e3d1365e7b04d6ace451b7c35f9bb + role: context + - path: scripts/adhoc/capture_strain_authorities_130_20261115.py + sha256: 56b1ef847187e15a80a00e7b197f28435fcb465bdb0c3954cc097ffbe07388f1 + role: context + - path: scripts/adhoc/review_bactotraits_identity_130_20261115.py + sha256: 798dd020dea338e37eccb952c6715b3b2d33e23ce5fbf51b6905d5eef99ac5b9 + role: context + - path: scripts/adhoc/run_abstract_canary_20261115.py + sha256: 467f3dbdc899bbcc23f3097a87f51cd4b1f712abbafefd13ed02591c28d03e68 + role: context + - path: src/edgemech/contract-pins.json + sha256: 788ecc876a432feebeb89627fbe5a40dba1c1001598683c19834e4626667842c + role: context + - path: src/edgemech/literature_cache.py + sha256: 12e3d920e2a9978c25b5d7626aae087ccd089609c367339a240eb8f37b7a3fef + role: context + - path: src/edgemech/occurrence_packet.py + sha256: 7526fcb6f4467a342abc644c8f607b9b8c6fb395eac159c61f4654594cc490d7 + role: context + - path: src/edgemech/occurrence_review.py + sha256: 8821065a01a03752f1952accd0ae7fb53c5d31e85a8f5be621c2d8a7f43d43e3 + role: context +targets: +- target_id: urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + path: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/packet.json + selector: occurrence_id=urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + kind: snapshot_row + record_class: ReleaseOccurrence + label: Fresh-05 source strain identity investigation + ownership_note: Source publisher controls the BactoTraits table; maintained KG-Microbe + download/join paths are identified at ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc. + owner_paths: + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: download.yaml + role: Maintained BactoTraits source download and checksum pin + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py + role: Maintained BacDive-ID to NCBI identity join and BactoTraits transform +scope: + description: One occurrence's source identity investigation after abstract replay. + selection: 'Fresh-05 retained original occurrence and source conflict #130.' + coverage: partial + population_size: 1 + reviewed_target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + exclusions: + - target: Independent ten-case calibration scoring + reason: Self-review with historical labels visible; no new rating. + - target: 'Neighbor-row finding #132' + reason: Contextual follow-up only; not an additional reviewed target. + - target: Other retained occurrences and remaining 9900 + reason: No review expansion or population inference. +checks: +- check_id: private-staging + name: Ignored private staging preflight + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + command: git check-ignore --no-index --quiet .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/abstract.json + exit_code: 0 + expected_exit_code: 0 + summary: Git ignore check passed; no tracked destination files; fresh private directory + and exclusive 0600 files enforce no overwrite. +- check_id: source-packet + name: Exact retained source and endpoint replay + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + summary: Fixed input hashes and cohort identity checked; build_packet and validate_packet + replayed the newly persisted occurrence/source bytes. +- check_id: abstract-identity-quotes + name: Primary abstract identity and quotes + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + summary: The abstract adapter selected the exact MED/PMID primary result, verified + DOI/title identity, extracted the complete abstract, and verify_quote matched + both literal excerpts with hashes/offsets within one 25-word budget. No full text + was inspected or claimed. +- check_id: pinned-contracts + name: Pinned CLAW contract byte verification + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + summary: check_contracts returned successfully before review construction. +- check_id: source-identity-resolution + name: Verified source-row correction + status: unavailable + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + summary: Catalog identities are disambiguated, but no safe field replacement or + implemented source-row quarantine has been independently verified on regenerated + candidate bytes. The original graph claim remains unresolved. +- check_id: versioned-modeling + name: Predicate and both endpoint authorities + status: unavailable + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + summary: Scoped versioned NCBI/METPO/Biolink/RO proofs were not authored in this + canary; all modeling axes remain unresolved and review completion partial. +- check_id: catalog-identity-replay + name: Captured catalog identity provenance + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + summary: All four raw HTML/text/receipt hashes and the capture helper hash matched; + the deterministic text derivative and bounded quotes replayed. Culture identities + were independently disambiguated before authoring this review. +- check_id: maintained-owner-snapshots + name: Maintained download and transform snapshots + status: passed + required: true + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + summary: Nonempty download.yaml and BactoTraits transform bytes were read from the + Git object at ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc and retained as pinned + inputs. This is owner tracing, not a source patch or regeneration check. +evidence: +- evidence_id: packet-source + kind: record_content + reference: .temp/identity130-review-v2-20261115/packet.json + locator: 'original_assertion; endpoints; source_records: BactoTraits CSV row 8521, + BacDive 17851, LPSN 785725' + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' + support: context_only + snapshot_sha256: 8198616d22c932487940fe40a55926a9f8c2c35c9e473a3210a223a435c86703 + summary: Exact retained source/endpoint context includes incompatible collection-code + fields; this is not independent biological proof. +- evidence_id: abstract-nonmotility + kind: primary_source + reference: https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0 + locator: abstract; PMID 17625207; chars 162:265; text_sha256=28ae92fb2c8f9d7319bd5ea1effc5587e84e9fb4ea78d6aa6e7a0499eb896f89 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' + support: partial + quote: The strain, designated HOact23(T), was a non-motile, rod-shaped (0.44-0.53x0.65-0.79 + microm) bacterium. + snapshot_sha256: 82d96c9481a6d11eefc5976e65b2863e10bed3cedf8b02f9b09cdb92802cf807 + summary: Literal primary abstract excerpt inspected in full abstract context; nominal + DSM 18772 strain match does not settle disputed source accessions or the entire + identifier-bound graph assertion. +- evidence_id: abstract-strain + kind: primary_source + reference: https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0 + locator: abstract; PMID 17625207; chars 1157:1208; text_sha256=28ae92fb2c8f9d7319bd5ea1effc5587e84e9fb4ea78d6aa6e7a0499eb896f89 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:40:49Z' + support: partial + quote: type strain HOact23(T) (=MBIC08254(T)=DSM 18772(T)) + snapshot_sha256: 82d96c9481a6d11eefc5976e65b2863e10bed3cedf8b02f9b09cdb92802cf807 + summary: Literal primary abstract excerpt inspected in full abstract context; nominal + DSM 18772 strain match does not settle disputed source accessions or the entire + identifier-bound graph assertion. +- evidence_id: catalog-dsm19353 + kind: authority + support: context_only + reference: https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-19353 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207Z' + quote: '19353, Type strain dsm-19353 dsm19353 dsm 19353 Thioprofundum lithotrophicum + + Strain designation: + + 106 + + Other collection no. + + or WDCM no.: + + JCM 14586' + snapshot_sha256: 8fa3d180a19442d947a7bbdd86cf1efd78f6ca891fe2acbc42f2c6a9d15c6d82 + locator: catalog identity; chars 3153:3297; text_sha256=8fa3d180a19442d947a7bbdd86cf1efd78f6ca891fe2acbc42f2c6a9d15c6d82 + summary: DSM 19353 and JCM 14586 identify Thioprofundum lithotrophicum strain 106, + not the nominal Rubritalea strain. +- evidence_id: catalog-jcm14586 + kind: authority + support: context_only + reference: https://www.jcm.riken.jp/cgi-bin/jcm/jcm_number?JCM=14586 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:32:41.164578Z' + quote: 'BacDive ID: 17847. + + NCBI Taxonomy ID: 571898.' + snapshot_sha256: 93d5aec6c739d6bd48c4c4aa66416c7dfe4220ff9ca5c572a1010ad02be0440f + locator: catalog identity; chars 776:820; text_sha256=93d5aec6c739d6bd48c4c4aa66416c7dfe4220ff9ca5c572a1010ad02be0440f + summary: JCM 14586's complete catalog page corroborates strain 106/DSM 19353 and + binds it to BacDive 17847 and NCBI 571898. It documents the original-paper JCM + 14596 typographical error; that typo is not a new equivalent accession. +- evidence_id: catalog-dsm18772 + kind: authority + support: context_only + reference: https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-18772 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:32:36.482044Z' + quote: '18772, Type strain dsm-18772 dsm18772 dsm 18772 Rubritalea squalenifaciens + + Strain designation: + + HOact 23 + + Other collection no. + + or WDCM no.: + + MBIC08254,NBRC 103619' + snapshot_sha256: 99c07d7d2dfeb73ed1fbb69e8213c8034146e51140b2a80f160bd59faead79c8 + locator: catalog identity; chars 3083:3242; text_sha256=99c07d7d2dfeb73ed1fbb69e8213c8034146e51140b2a80f160bd59faead79c8 + summary: The nominal Rubritalea squalenifaciens type strain has DSM 18772, HOact + 23, MBIC08254 and NBRC 103619 aliases. +- evidence_id: catalog-bacdive17851 + kind: authority + support: context_only + reference: https://bacdive.dsmz.de/strain/17851 + accessed_at: '2026-11-16T07:33:14.199643Z' + quote: 'BacDive ID + + 17851 + + Type strain + + Strain Designation + + HOact 23 + + Culture col. no. + + DSM 18772 + + MBIC 08254 + + NBRC 103619 + + HOact 23 + + NCBI tax ID(s) + + 1123071 + + 407226' + snapshot_sha256: 29f41098eb41eb4a6ca0d46abe5ecd746e8cc5dbb4edac5cb6b8233bd6cdd7bc + locator: catalog identity; chars 674:819; text_sha256=29f41098eb41eb4a6ca0d46abe5ecd746e8cc5dbb4edac5cb6b8233bd6cdd7bc + summary: Current BacDive 17851 retains the Rubritalea culture aliases. Its inspected + sequence sections distinguish strain/genome 1123071 from species/16S 407226; this + catalog is not independent NCBI ontology adjudication. +assessments: +- assessment_id: claim + area: grounding + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: claim' + outcome: unknown + summary: 'The retained abstract reports nonmotility for the nominal DSM 18772 strain. + The original identifier-bound graph assertion remains not assessable: the source + row mixes identities and formal predicate/node checks remain incomplete.' + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: claim + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: category + value: NOT_ASSESSABLE + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: assertion_scope + value: NCBITaxon:1123071 biolink:has_phenotype METPO:1000703, with original DSM + 18772/non motile labels. The accession conflict is not a biological refutation + and is not repaired by replacing the subject. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: assertion_scope' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain +- assessment_id: literature + area: evidence + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: literature' + outcome: unknown + summary: The same two DOI/PMID-bound abstract quotations partly address nonmotility + for HOact23/DSM 18772. Catalog identity checks add no full-paper assay evidence + and do not establish ownership of every trait in the mixed source row. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: literature + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: category + value: PARTIAL + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: search_scope + value: Retained complete abstract only, DOI 10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0, PMID 17625207; + no new paper search or full-paper inspection. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: search_scope' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: literature_channel + value: europepmc_abstract_retained; separate catalog discovery used 3 CBORG Tavily + calls and 4 anonymous primary-catalog GETs; no TDM. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: literature_channel' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + - name: inspected_extent + value: Complete retained abstract and its two unchanged short snippets. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: inspected_extent' + evidence_ids: + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain +- assessment_id: relation + area: representation + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: relation' + outcome: unknown + summary: Culture accession disambiguation does not validate has_phenotype/RO:0002200. + A scoped versioned predicate authority assessment remains outstanding. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: relation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: category + value: UNRESOLVED + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: direction + value: Original organism-to-phenotype direction preserved. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: direction' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: domain_range + value: No new versioned domain/range proof authored. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: domain_range' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: specificity + value: Relation fitness for the original nonmotility statement unresolved. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: specificity' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: qualifiers + value: Abstract and catalogs do not supply complete assay conditions or warrant + a universal-condition reading. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: qualifiers' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source +- assessment_id: subject-node + area: identity + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: subject node' + outcome: unknown + summary: Current DSMZ/BacDive catalogs verify the nominal DSM 18772/HOact23 culture + link. DSM 19353/JCM 14586 instead identify Thioprofundum strain 106. Formal NCBI/Biolink + identity, rank and category assessment remains unresolved. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: subject_node + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: category + value: UNRESOLVED + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: identity + value: NCBITaxon:1123071 retained. BacDive 17851 distinguishes genome 1123071 + from species/16S 407226. The competing culture pair maps through JCM to BacDive + 17847/NCBI 571898, not an equivalent Rubritalea accession. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: identity' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: label + value: Original Rubritalea squalenifaciens DSM 18772 label preserved. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: label' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: category_fit + value: biolink:OrganismTaxon retained; catalog agreement is not formal Biolink + category validation. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category_fit' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: rank_or_type + value: Catalogs distinguish type-strain aliases and species/genome identifiers; + independent NCBI rank/status verification remains incomplete. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: rank_or_type' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: definition + value: No complete versioned node-definition proof authored. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: definition' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: authority_version + value: Four independently captured catalog snapshots are bound by capture timestamps, + raw/text hashes and receipts; the unresolved source join prevents treating them + as complete original-assertion validation. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: authority_version' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 +- assessment_id: object-node + area: representation + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: object node' + outcome: unknown + summary: Nonmotility is reported for the nominal isolate, but this identity review + does not adjudicate METPO:1000703 definition or graph category fitness. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: object_node + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: category + value: UNRESOLVED + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: identity + value: Original METPO:1000703 retained; no replacement proposed. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: identity' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: label + value: Original non motile label retained. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: label' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: category_fit + value: biolink:PhenotypicQuality requires a scoped authority check. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category_fit' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: rank_or_type + value: Nominal phenotype class; formal typing remains unresolved. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: rank_or_type' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: definition + value: No new versioned METPO definition proof authored. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: definition' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - name: authority_version + value: Preparation authorities are not substituted for new inspected and scoped + modeling evidence. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: authority_version' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source +- assessment_id: source-fidelity + area: provenance + topic: 'Source-identity investigation: source fidelity' + outcome: unknown + summary: The incompatible culture links are now independently confirmed. The row's + BacDive ID/name and collection codes refer to different taxa; the maintained transform + selects NCBI by BacDive ID. A safe field replacement and verified row correction + have not been established. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + dimensions: + - name: axis + value: source_fidelity + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: axis' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: category + value: NOT_ASSESSABLE + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: category' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: scope + value: Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: scope' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - name: source_binding + value: Original BactoTraits row 8521 and all retained source records remain unchanged. + Maintained owner snapshots at ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc identify + the download pin and BacDive-to-NCBI join. Quarantine is a proposed action, + not an implemented or independently verified graph fix. + definition: 'Authored bounded source-identity judgment: source_binding' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 +findings: +- finding_id: source-accession-conflict + issue_key: bactotraits-row8521-conflicting-strain-accessions + category: identity + severity: major + status: open + certainty: confirmed + title: Source row carries conflicting strain accessions + description: BactoTraits row 8521 names Rubritalea squalenifaciens/BacDive 17851 + but lists DSM 19353/JCM 14586. Captured DSMZ/JCM authorities place that collection + pair in Thioprofundum lithotrophicum strain 106/BacDive 17847/NCBI 571898. DSMZ + and current BacDive 17851 instead bind the nominal Rubritalea to DSM 18772/HOact23/MBIC08254/NBRC103619. + The incompatible identity fields are confirmed; the intended ownership of all + source traits and a safe replacement remain unresolved. + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + field_paths: + - 'source_records[0].text: culture collection codes' + - 'source_records[0].text: Bacdive_ID' + evidence_ids: + - packet-source + - catalog-dsm19353 + - catalog-jcm14586 + - catalog-dsm18772 + - catalog-bacdive17851 + - abstract-nonmotility + - abstract-strain + ownership_note: Source publisher owns table correction; KG-Microbe owns download/join + and any reviewed row-quarantine policy at the listed maintained paths. + external_issues: + - https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/130 + owner_paths: + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: download.yaml + role: Maintained BactoTraits source download and checksum pin + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py + role: Maintained BacDive-ID to NCBI identity join and BactoTraits transform + previous_occurrences: + - repository: CultureBotAI/EdgeMech + review_id: 20261116T052355Z-fresh05-abstract-adapter + finding_id: source-accession-conflict +actions: +- action_id: quarantine-and-verify-source-identity + finding_ids: + - source-accession-conflict + target_ids: + - urn:kg-microbe:occurrence:v1:1e9dec218a07f7e480add8ff273e3a9285f79d57746ca74041702839207a8136 + description: Propose a complete-reviewed-row-hash-bound quarantine at the maintained + BactoTraits transform; do not silently substitute accession or taxon fields. Establish + the intended source identity with the table owner, preserve the before/after proposal + and independently verify regenerated candidate occurrences before claiming correction. + ownership_note: The maintained owner paths are known; no correction or quarantine + is claimed merged by this investigation. + acceptance_checks: + - Retain original row hash, occurrence and all conflicting fields. + - Quarantine acceptance is keyed by the complete reviewed row hash and exact row + identity; retain whole-source-file hash as receipt provenance, not as a requirement + to reject an otherwise unchanged reviewed row. + - Do not replace graph subject 1123071 with 571898 from accessions alone. + - Add a regression against mixed-strain joins without altering unrelated rows. + - Independently verify candidate regeneration and affected occurrences. + owner_paths: + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: download.yaml + role: Maintained BactoTraits source download and checksum pin + - repository: Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe + path: kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py + role: Maintained BacDive-ID to NCBI identity join and BactoTraits transform +limitations: +- Partial self-review; not an independent calibration rating, agreement result or + gold label. +- Complete catalog pages and the retained abstract were inspected; no full scientific + paper. +- Four catalog snapshots resolve competing aliases, not all original statement/model + semantics. +- The confirmed source conflict does not establish biological refutation or a safe + field repair. +- 'Neighbor investigation #132 is context only and contributes no new reviewed occurrence + here.' +- Investigation used 3 successful CBORG Tavily calls and 4 anonymous catalog GETs; + no Valency, publisher TDM or licensed-library full text. This replay launcher makes + zero requests. +- Original source bytes/reviews remain intact; no source patch, native capability + or graph admission. +- Private catalog/source bodies remain ignored; canonical review contains bounded + snippets and hashes. +links: +- https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/130 +- https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/132 +- https://doi.org/10.1099/ijs.0.65010-0 +- https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/blob/ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc/download.yaml +- https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/blob/ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc/kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py +tags: +- source-identity-investigation +- partial-review +- excluded-from-calibration-scoring diff --git a/scripts/adhoc/capture_strain_authorities_130_20261115.py b/scripts/adhoc/capture_strain_authorities_130_20261115.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4241101 --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/adhoc/capture_strain_authorities_130_20261115.py @@ -0,0 +1,130 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""2026-11-15: capture one public strain authority for EdgeMech issue #130. + +Inputs: one allowlisted public catalog URL selected by name; no credentials. +Outputs: exclusive private raw HTML, derivative text and hash/provenance receipt. +Run one authority end to end and inspect its artifacts before further captures. +Raw catalog bodies must remain gitignored. This does not adjudicate graph claims. +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import hashlib +import json +import os +import stat +import subprocess +import urllib.request +from datetime import datetime, timezone +from html.parser import HTMLParser +from pathlib import Path + +ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[2] +URLS = { + "dsm19353": "https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-19353", + "jcm14586": "https://www.jcm.riken.jp/cgi-bin/jcm/jcm_number?JCM=14586", + "dsm18772": "https://www.dsmz.de/collection/catalogue/details/culture/DSM-18772", + "bacdive17851": "https://bacdive.dsmz.de/strain/17851", +} +LIMIT = 4 * 1024 * 1024 + + +class Text(HTMLParser): + """Deterministic catalog text derivative, retaining content order.""" + + def __init__(self): + super().__init__(convert_charrefs=True) + self.parts = [] + self.skip = 0 + + def handle_starttag(self, tag, attrs): + if tag in {"script", "style"}: + self.skip += 1 + if tag in {"p", "div", "br", "tr", "td", "li", "h1", "h2", "h3"}: + self.parts.append("\n") + + def handle_endtag(self, tag): + if tag in {"script", "style"}: + self.skip = max(0, self.skip - 1) + if tag in {"p", "div", "tr", "td", "li", "h1", "h2", "h3"}: + self.parts.append("\n") + + def handle_data(self, data): + if not self.skip: + self.parts.append(data) + + +def sha(raw): + return hashlib.sha256(raw).hexdigest() + + +def write_new(path, raw): + descriptor = os.open(path, os.O_WRONLY | os.O_CREAT | os.O_EXCL | os.O_NOFOLLOW, 0o600) + with os.fdopen(descriptor, "wb") as stream: + stream.write(raw) + stream.flush() + os.fsync(stream.fileno()) + if path.read_bytes() != raw: + raise ValueError("Persisted artifact differs") + + +def main(): + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__) + parser.add_argument("name", choices=URLS) + parser.add_argument("--plan", action="store_true") + args = parser.parse_args() + destination = ROOT / ".temp" / "identity130" / "authorities" + for parent in (ROOT / ".temp", destination.parent, destination): + if parent.is_symlink() or not parent.is_dir(): + raise ValueError("Prepare real private staging directories first") + if stat.S_IMODE(parent.stat().st_mode) != 0o700: + raise ValueError("Staging directories must be mode 0700") + relative = destination.relative_to(ROOT) / (args.name + ".html") + subprocess.run(["git", "check-ignore", "--no-index", "--quiet", str(relative)], + cwd=ROOT, check=True) + paths = {kind: destination / (args.name + suffix) for kind, suffix in + (("raw", ".html"), ("text", ".txt"), ("receipt", ".json"))} + if any(path.exists() or path.is_symlink() for path in paths.values()): + raise ValueError("Authority artifacts already exist; preserve prior capture") + if args.plan: + print(json.dumps({"url": URLS[args.name], "writes": 0, "provider_calls": 0, + "destination": str(destination.relative_to(ROOT))})) + return 0 + fetched_at = datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat() + request = urllib.request.Request(URLS[args.name], headers={"User-Agent": "EdgeMech/0.1"}) + with urllib.request.urlopen(request, timeout=60) as response: + raw = response.read(LIMIT + 1) + content_type = response.headers.get("Content-Type", "") + charset = response.headers.get_content_charset() or "utf-8" + status, final_url = response.status, response.url + if status != 200 or not raw or len(raw) > LIMIT or "html" not in content_type.lower(): + raise ValueError("Expected one nonempty bounded HTML authority response") + extractor = Text() + extractor.feed(raw.decode(charset, errors="strict")) + text = "\n".join(" ".join(line.split()) for line in "".join(extractor.parts).splitlines() + if line.strip()) + "\n" + text_raw = text.encode("utf-8") + if not text.strip(): + raise ValueError("Authority response has no readable text") + receipt = {"name": args.name, "requested_url": URLS[args.name], "final_url": final_url, + "fetched_at": fetched_at, "status": status, "content_type": content_type, + "charset": charset, "raw_bytes": len(raw), "raw_sha256": sha(raw), + "text_bytes": len(text_raw), "text_sha256": sha(text_raw), + "extractor": "catalog-html-text/v1", "authenticated": False, + "channel": "anonymous_primary_catalog", "http_calls": 1, + "scope": "One public catalog page; identity still requires authored assessment", + "raw_path": str(paths["raw"].relative_to(ROOT)), + "text_path": str(paths["text"].relative_to(ROOT)), + "script_sha256": sha(Path(__file__).read_bytes())} + write_new(paths["raw"], raw) + write_new(paths["text"], text_raw) + write_new(paths["receipt"], (json.dumps(receipt, indent=2) + "\n").encode()) + if json.loads(paths["receipt"].read_text()) != receipt: + raise ValueError("Persisted receipt differs") + print(json.dumps(receipt, sort_keys=True)) + return 0 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + raise SystemExit(main()) diff --git a/scripts/adhoc/inspect_bactotraits_owner_130_20261115.sql b/scripts/adhoc/inspect_bactotraits_owner_130_20261115.sql new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1f4d98a --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/adhoc/inspect_bactotraits_owner_130_20261115.sql @@ -0,0 +1,24 @@ +-- 2026-11-15: read-only BactoTraits identity-owner trace for EdgeMech issue #130. +-- Input: unchanged KG-Microbe Jun-2022 raw CSV, converted losslessly from +-- ISO-8859-1 to UTF-8 because the installed DuckDB CLI has no encoding option. +-- Conversion command from EdgeMech worktree: +-- iconv -f ISO-8859-1 -t UTF-8 /Users/marcin/Documents/VIMSS/ontology/KG-Hub/KG-Microbe/kg-microbe/data/raw/BactoTraits_databaseV2_Jun2022.csv > .temp/identity130/owner-trace/BactoTraits_databaseV2_Jun2022.utf8.csv +-- Expected raw SHA256: 18316d7a0b6c2bef6fcb96a7659c2e3f3734c14786f383c2a93fefe2ae226a4b. +-- Output: bounded identity fields for source data row 8521, its four neighbors +-- on either side, and either implicated BacDive identifier. No graph mutation. +-- Run from the EdgeMech worktree with duckdb -json -init /dev/null < this file; +-- retain stdout only under ignored .temp/identity130/owner-trace/. + +WITH source_rows AS ( + SELECT row_number() OVER () AS source_data_row, * + FROM read_csv( + '.temp/identity130/owner-trace/BactoTraits_databaseV2_Jun2022.utf8.csv', + delim = ';', skip = 2, header = true, all_varchar = true + ) +) +SELECT source_data_row, "Bacdive_ID", "culture collection codes", + "Genus", "Species", "Full_name", "non-motile", "motile" +FROM source_rows +WHERE source_data_row BETWEEN 8517 AND 8525 + OR "Bacdive_ID" IN ('17847', '17851') +ORDER BY source_data_row; diff --git a/scripts/adhoc/review_bactotraits_identity_130_20261115.py b/scripts/adhoc/review_bactotraits_identity_130_20261115.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a74e0a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/adhoc/review_bactotraits_identity_130_20261115.py @@ -0,0 +1,436 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""2026-11-15: author one source-identity investigation review for EdgeMech #130. + +Inputs: unchanged fresh-05 source/occurrence/abstract, four captured catalogs, +their receipts and extractor, and two maintained KG-Microbe owner-file snapshots. +Outputs: fresh private proof stage and a new canonical partial structured review. +This is a self-review, excluded from independent calibration. No network calls, +source corrections, graph admissions, or changes to historical reviews occur. +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import json +import re +import subprocess +from datetime import datetime, timezone +from pathlib import Path + +import capture_strain_authorities_130_20261115 as capture +import run_abstract_canary_20261115 as base + +ROOT = base.ROOT +AUTHORITY_DIRECTORY = ROOT / ".temp/identity130/authorities" +CAPTURE_SCRIPT = "scripts/adhoc/capture_strain_authorities_130_20261115.py" +CAPTURE_SHA = "56b1ef847187e15a80a00e7b197f28435fcb465bdb0c3954cc097ffbe07388f1" +THIS_SCRIPT = "scripts/adhoc/review_bactotraits_identity_130_20261115.py" +PREVIOUS_ID = "20261116T052355Z-fresh05-abstract-adapter" +PREVIOUS_PATH = "reviews/structured/" + PREVIOUS_ID + "/review.yaml" +PREVIOUS_SHA = "b1ca23d2c1d2854f73c85564d2cad27572736465c06ef47345319266664b3427" +KGM = Path("/Users/marcin/Documents/VIMSS/ontology/KG-Hub/KG-Microbe/kg-microbe") +KGM_COMMIT = "ef27b97a0b450767da54235c6105b5250c178adc" +OWNER_PATHS = [ + {"repository": "Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe", "path": "download.yaml", + "role": "Maintained BactoTraits source download and checksum pin"}, + {"repository": "Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe", + "path": "kg_microbe/transform_utils/bactotraits/bactotraits.py", + "role": "Maintained BacDive-ID to NCBI identity join and BactoTraits transform"}, +] +AUTHORITY_PINS = { + "dsm19353": { + "raw": "d416237bc389c88a12185f6981a97faf10cfb091c579b6fb10f721a24c9e1921", + "text": "8fa3d180a19442d947a7bbdd86cf1efd78f6ca891fe2acbc42f2c6a9d15c6d82", + "receipt": "99b8f7dde10107d7e6510f2cfb2ded46ca4dfba3e8b6e6230ef7990dc49e8bbf", + "quote": "19353, Type strain dsm-19353 dsm19353 dsm 19353 Thioprofundum lithotrophicum\n" + "Strain designation:\n106\nOther collection no.\nor WDCM no.:\nJCM 14586", + "summary": "DSM 19353 and JCM 14586 identify Thioprofundum lithotrophicum strain 106, " + "not the nominal Rubritalea strain."}, + "jcm14586": { + "raw": "6ee861e0a76f89b937aa79249450267985202f26a326ce629d0119d1b36effaf", + "text": "93d5aec6c739d6bd48c4c4aa66416c7dfe4220ff9ca5c572a1010ad02be0440f", + "receipt": "8906c5337592813bbcf2767bc45cfe08f5520a45922e00df0545f84e01071b9c", + "quote": "BacDive ID: 17847.\nNCBI Taxonomy ID: 571898.", + "summary": "JCM 14586's complete catalog page corroborates strain 106/DSM 19353 and " + "binds it to BacDive 17847 and NCBI 571898. It documents the original-paper " + "JCM 14596 typographical error; that typo is not a new equivalent accession."}, + "dsm18772": { + "raw": "e6ce0ea2affb04b490b537478a4b804371e187e3eb44f29cff2a99e0875b7079", + "text": "99c07d7d2dfeb73ed1fbb69e8213c8034146e51140b2a80f160bd59faead79c8", + "receipt": "c4dff78887cf1fc393286867e2954d2d39198ff521dec8417984cdecb3359328", + "quote": "18772, Type strain dsm-18772 dsm18772 dsm 18772 Rubritalea squalenifaciens\n" + "Strain designation:\nHOact 23\nOther collection no.\nor WDCM no.:\n" + "MBIC08254,NBRC 103619", + "summary": "The nominal Rubritalea squalenifaciens type strain has DSM 18772, " + "HOact 23, MBIC08254 and NBRC 103619 aliases."}, + "bacdive17851": { + "raw": "1a6b1f17cea659277484d7461db6ad3f50e6e32a85c6bf5abdc472e8a489b592", + "text": "29f41098eb41eb4a6ca0d46abe5ecd746e8cc5dbb4edac5cb6b8233bd6cdd7bc", + "receipt": "6a0e0f46648056fa529748d5010db3df04600a40fb86ab1da2edeba85ac26ea9", + "quote": "BacDive ID\n17851\nType strain\nStrain Designation\nHOact 23\nCulture col. no.\n" + "DSM 18772\nMBIC 08254\nNBRC 103619\nHOact 23\nNCBI tax ID(s)\n1123071\n407226", + "summary": "Current BacDive 17851 retains the Rubritalea culture aliases. Its inspected " + "sequence sections distinguish strain/genome 1123071 from species/16S 407226; " + "this catalog is not independent NCBI ontology adjudication."}, +} +SERVICE_PINS = { + "cborg-service-provenance.json": + "f9e7ce85c9c9a2738d14384f46251797ad5d213f1efb1d7b8a2ce95d76b289d0", + "cborg-tavily-dsm18772.json": + "49096c6b7b7607d1071415bac9e70ab298326c9628d45f7b2aa36351e1611481", +} +AUTHORITY_IDS = ["catalog-" + name for name in AUTHORITY_PINS] +SOURCE_IDS = ["packet-source", *AUTHORITY_IDS] + + +def canonical_utc_timestamp(value): + """Convert an aware capture instant to CLAW's UTC-Z form without changing it (#133).""" + if not isinstance(value, str) or re.search(r"[.,]\d{7,}", value): + raise ValueError("Capture timestamp must be an ISO instant with at most microsecond precision") + instant = datetime.fromisoformat(value) + if instant.tzinfo is None or instant.utcoffset() is None: + raise ValueError("Capture timestamp requires an explicit timezone offset") + utc = instant.astimezone(timezone.utc) + precision = "microseconds" if utc.microsecond else "seconds" + return utc.isoformat(timespec=precision).removesuffix("+00:00") + "Z" + + +def load_authorities(): + base.checked_input(ROOT / CAPTURE_SCRIPT, CAPTURE_SHA) + base.checked_input(ROOT / PREVIOUS_PATH, PREVIOUS_SHA) + records = {} + for name, expected in AUTHORITY_PINS.items(): + raws = {kind: base.checked_input(AUTHORITY_DIRECTORY / (name + suffix), expected[kind]) + for kind, suffix in (("raw", ".html"), ("text", ".txt"), ("receipt", ".json"))} + receipt = json.loads(raws["receipt"]) + base.require(receipt["name"] == name and receipt["requested_url"] == capture.URLS[name] + == receipt["final_url"] and receipt["status"] == 200, + "Authority receipt identity or response status differs") + base.require(receipt["script_sha256"] == CAPTURE_SHA + and receipt["extractor"] == "catalog-html-text/v1" + and receipt["authenticated"] is False + and receipt["channel"] == "anonymous_primary_catalog" + and receipt["http_calls"] == 1, "Authority capture provenance differs") + for kind in ("raw", "text"): + suffix = ".html" if kind == "raw" else ".txt" + base.require(receipt[kind + "_sha256"] == expected[kind] + and receipt[kind + "_bytes"] == len(raws[kind]) + and receipt[kind + "_path"] == str( + (AUTHORITY_DIRECTORY / (name + suffix)).relative_to(ROOT)), + "Authority receipt content binding differs") + extractor = capture.Text() + extractor.feed(raws["raw"].decode(receipt["charset"], errors="strict")) + text = "\n".join(" ".join(line.split()) for line in "".join(extractor.parts).splitlines() + if line.strip()) + "\n" + base.require(text.encode() == raws["text"], "Authority text derivative does not replay") + document = base.LiteratureCache._document({"response_sha256": expected["text"]}, + "authority_text", text) + span = base.verify_quote(document, expected["quote"]) + base.require(len(expected["quote"].split()) <= 25, "Authority quote exceeds source budget") + records[name] = {"raws": raws, "receipt": receipt, "span": span} + service_raws = {name: base.checked_input(AUTHORITY_DIRECTORY / name, sha) + for name, sha in SERVICE_PINS.items()} + service = json.loads(service_raws["cborg-service-provenance.json"]) + base.require(len(service["tool_calls"]) == 3 + and all(call["auth_mode"] == "keyed" for call in service["tool_calls"]) + and service["publisher_tdm_calls"] == service["valency_calls"] == 0, + "Recorded service usage differs") + owners = {} + for owner in OWNER_PATHS: + owners[owner["path"]] = subprocess.check_output( + ["git", "-C", str(KGM), "show", KGM_COMMIT + ":" + owner["path"]]) + base.require(all(owners.values()), "Maintained owner snapshot is empty") + return records, service_raws, owners + + +def assessment(axis, area, summary, details): + ids = (base.PAPER_IDS if axis in {"claim", "literature"} + else SOURCE_IDS if axis in {"subject_node", "source_fidelity"} + else ["packet-source"]) + dimensions = {"axis": axis, "category": base.AXES[axis], + "scope": "Original fresh-05 occurrence; bounded source-identity investigation", + **details} + return {"assessment_id": axis.replace("_", "-"), "area": area, + "topic": "Source-identity investigation: " + axis.replace("_", " "), + "outcome": base.CATEGORIES[axis][base.AXES[axis]], "summary": summary, + "target_ids": [base.OCCURRENCE], "evidence_ids": ids, + "dimensions": [{"name": name, "value": value, + "definition": "Authored bounded source-identity judgment: " + name, + "evidence_ids": ids} for name, value in dimensions.items()]} + + +def authored_assessments(): + return [ + assessment("claim", "grounding", + "The retained abstract reports nonmotility for the nominal DSM 18772 strain. " + "The original identifier-bound graph assertion remains not assessable: " + "the source row mixes identities and formal predicate/node checks remain incomplete.", + {"assertion_scope": "NCBITaxon:1123071 biolink:has_phenotype METPO:1000703, " + "with original DSM 18772/non motile labels. The accession conflict is not " + "a biological refutation and is not repaired by replacing the subject."}), + assessment("literature", "evidence", + "The same two DOI/PMID-bound abstract quotations partly address nonmotility " + "for HOact23/DSM 18772. Catalog identity checks add no full-paper assay evidence " + "and do not establish ownership of every trait in the mixed source row.", + {"search_scope": "Retained complete abstract only, DOI " + base.DOI + + ", PMID " + base.PMID + "; no new paper search or full-paper inspection.", + "literature_channel": "europepmc_abstract_retained; separate catalog discovery " + "used 3 CBORG Tavily calls and 4 anonymous primary-catalog GETs; no TDM.", + "inspected_extent": "Complete retained abstract and its two unchanged short snippets."}), + assessment("relation", "representation", + "Culture accession disambiguation does not validate has_phenotype/RO:0002200. " + "A scoped versioned predicate authority assessment remains outstanding.", + {"direction": "Original organism-to-phenotype direction preserved.", + "domain_range": "No new versioned domain/range proof authored.", + "specificity": "Relation fitness for the original nonmotility statement unresolved.", + "qualifiers": "Abstract and catalogs do not supply complete assay conditions " + "or warrant a universal-condition reading."}), + assessment("subject_node", "identity", + "Current DSMZ/BacDive catalogs verify the nominal DSM 18772/HOact23 culture " + "link. DSM 19353/JCM 14586 instead identify Thioprofundum strain 106. Formal " + "NCBI/Biolink identity, rank and category assessment remains unresolved.", + {"identity": "NCBITaxon:1123071 retained. BacDive 17851 distinguishes genome " + "1123071 from species/16S 407226. The competing culture pair maps through " + "JCM to BacDive 17847/NCBI 571898, not an equivalent Rubritalea accession.", + "label": "Original Rubritalea squalenifaciens DSM 18772 label preserved.", + "category_fit": "biolink:OrganismTaxon retained; catalog agreement is not " + "formal Biolink category validation.", + "rank_or_type": "Catalogs distinguish type-strain aliases and species/genome " + "identifiers; independent NCBI rank/status verification remains incomplete.", + "definition": "No complete versioned node-definition proof authored.", + "authority_version": "Four independently captured catalog snapshots are bound " + "by capture timestamps, raw/text hashes and receipts; the unresolved source " + "join prevents treating them as complete original-assertion validation."}), + assessment("object_node", "representation", + "Nonmotility is reported for the nominal isolate, but this identity review " + "does not adjudicate METPO:1000703 definition or graph category fitness.", + {"identity": "Original METPO:1000703 retained; no replacement proposed.", + "label": "Original non motile label retained.", + "category_fit": "biolink:PhenotypicQuality requires a scoped authority check.", + "rank_or_type": "Nominal phenotype class; formal typing remains unresolved.", + "definition": "No new versioned METPO definition proof authored.", + "authority_version": "Preparation authorities are not substituted for new " + "inspected and scoped modeling evidence."}), + assessment("source_fidelity", "provenance", + "The incompatible culture links are now independently confirmed. The row's " + "BacDive ID/name and collection codes refer to different taxa; the maintained " + "transform selects NCBI by BacDive ID. A safe field replacement and verified " + "row correction have not been established.", + {"source_binding": "Original BactoTraits row 8521 and all retained source " + "records remain unchanged. Maintained owner snapshots at " + KGM_COMMIT + + " identify the download pin and BacDive-to-NCBI join. Quarantine is a " + "proposed action, not an implemented or independently verified graph fix."}), + ] + + +def make_review(packet_pin, proofs_pin, copied_pins, paper_spans, records, + started, finished, ignored_check): + review = base.review_document(packet_pin, proofs_pin, copied_pins, paper_spans, + started, finished, ignored_check) + review.update( + review_id=finished.replace("-", "").replace(":", "") + "-fresh05-source-identity", + title="Fresh-05 source identity investigation confirms incompatible culture accessions", + summary="Primary catalog snapshots confirm that DSM 19353/JCM 14586 and DSM 18772 " + "belong to distinct taxa. No safe source-field replacement, independently verified " + "correction or resolved graph claim follows. Six newly authored categorical assessments " + "remain conservative; the review is partial and excluded from independent calibration.", + assessments=authored_assessments(), + scope={"description": "One occurrence's source identity investigation after abstract replay.", + "selection": "Fresh-05 retained original occurrence and source conflict #130.", + "coverage": "partial", "population_size": 1, + "reviewed_target_ids": [base.OCCURRENCE], + "exclusions": [{"target": "Independent ten-case calibration scoring", + "reason": "Self-review with historical labels visible; no new rating."}, + {"target": "Neighbor-row finding #132", + "reason": "Contextual follow-up only; not an additional reviewed target."}, + {"target": "Other retained occurrences and remaining 9900", + "reason": "No review expansion or population inference."}]}, + tags=["source-identity-investigation", "partial-review", "excluded-from-calibration-scoring"]) + review["reviewer"]["independence_basis"] = ( + "New authored source-identity judgments using retained source/abstract and current catalogs. " + "Historical reviews and labels were visible; excluded from independent calibration matrices.") + target = review["targets"][0] + target.update(label="Fresh-05 source strain identity investigation", owner_paths=OWNER_PATHS, + ownership_note="Source publisher controls the BactoTraits table; maintained " + "KG-Microbe download/join paths are identified at " + KGM_COMMIT + ".") + inputs = [item["path"] for item in review["source"]["inputs"]] + review["source"] = base.inspect_source( + ROOT, [target], [*inputs, CAPTURE_SCRIPT, THIS_SCRIPT, PREVIOUS_PATH])["source"] + for name, record in records.items(): + expected, span = AUTHORITY_PINS[name], record["span"] + text_pin = next(pin for pin in copied_pins if pin["path"].endswith("/" + name + ".txt")) + review["evidence"].append({ + "evidence_id": "catalog-" + name, "kind": "authority", "support": "context_only", + "reference": capture.URLS[name], + "accessed_at": canonical_utc_timestamp(record["receipt"]["fetched_at"]), + "quote": expected["quote"], "snapshot_sha256": text_pin["sha256"], + "locator": f"catalog identity; chars {span['start']}:{span['end']}; " + f"text_sha256={span['text_sha256']}", "summary": expected["summary"]}) + review["checks"].append({ + "check_id": "catalog-identity-replay", "name": "Captured catalog identity provenance", + "status": "passed", "required": True, "target_ids": [base.OCCURRENCE], + "evidence_ids": AUTHORITY_IDS, + "summary": "All four raw HTML/text/receipt hashes and the capture helper hash matched; " + "the deterministic text derivative and bounded quotes replayed. Culture identities " + "were independently disambiguated before authoring this review."}) + review["checks"].append({ + "check_id": "maintained-owner-snapshots", "name": "Maintained download and transform snapshots", + "status": "passed", "required": True, "target_ids": [base.OCCURRENCE], + "summary": "Nonempty download.yaml and BactoTraits transform bytes were read from the " + "Git object at " + KGM_COMMIT + " and retained as pinned inputs. This is owner tracing, " + "not a source patch or regeneration check."}) + check = next(check for check in review["checks"] if check["check_id"] == "source-identity-resolution") + check.update(name="Verified source-row correction", evidence_ids=SOURCE_IDS, + summary="Catalog identities are disambiguated, but no safe field replacement " + "or implemented source-row quarantine has been independently verified on " + "regenerated candidate bytes. The original graph claim remains unresolved.") + finding = review["findings"][0] + finding.update( + description="BactoTraits row 8521 names Rubritalea squalenifaciens/BacDive 17851 but " + "lists DSM 19353/JCM 14586. Captured DSMZ/JCM authorities place that collection pair " + "in Thioprofundum lithotrophicum strain 106/BacDive 17847/NCBI 571898. DSMZ and current " + "BacDive 17851 instead bind the nominal Rubritalea to DSM 18772/HOact23/MBIC08254/" + "NBRC103619. The incompatible identity fields are confirmed; the intended ownership " + "of all source traits and a safe replacement remain unresolved.", + evidence_ids=[*SOURCE_IDS, *base.PAPER_IDS], owner_paths=OWNER_PATHS, + ownership_note="Source publisher owns table correction; KG-Microbe owns download/join " + "and any reviewed row-quarantine policy at the listed maintained paths.", + previous_occurrences=[{"repository": "CultureBotAI/EdgeMech", "review_id": PREVIOUS_ID, + "finding_id": "source-accession-conflict"}]) + action = review["actions"][0] + action.update( + action_id="quarantine-and-verify-source-identity", + description="Propose a complete-reviewed-row-hash-bound quarantine at the maintained " + "BactoTraits transform; do not silently substitute accession or taxon fields. Establish " + "the intended source identity with the table owner, preserve the before/after proposal " + "and independently verify regenerated candidate occurrences before claiming correction.", + owner_paths=OWNER_PATHS, + ownership_note="The maintained owner paths are known; no correction or quarantine is " + "claimed merged by this investigation.", + acceptance_checks=["Retain original row hash, occurrence and all conflicting fields.", + "Quarantine acceptance is keyed by the complete reviewed row hash and " + "exact row identity; retain whole-source-file hash as receipt provenance, " + "not as a requirement to reject an otherwise unchanged reviewed row.", + "Do not replace graph subject 1123071 with 571898 from accessions alone.", + "Add a regression against mixed-strain joins without altering unrelated rows.", + "Independently verify candidate regeneration and affected occurrences."]) + review["limitations"] = [ + "Partial self-review; not an independent calibration rating, agreement result or gold label.", + "Complete catalog pages and the retained abstract were inspected; no full scientific paper.", + "Four catalog snapshots resolve competing aliases, not all original statement/model semantics.", + "The confirmed source conflict does not establish biological refutation or a safe field repair.", + "Neighbor investigation #132 is context only and contributes no new reviewed occurrence here.", + "Investigation used 3 successful CBORG Tavily calls and 4 anonymous catalog GETs; no " + "Valency, publisher TDM or licensed-library full text. This replay launcher makes zero requests.", + "Original source bytes/reviews remain intact; no source patch, native capability or graph admission.", + "Private catalog/source bodies remain ignored; canonical review contains bounded snippets and hashes."] + review["links"] = [base.SOURCE_CONFLICT_ISSUE, + "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/issues/132", + "https://doi.org/" + base.DOI, + *["https://github.com/Knowledge-Graph-Hub/kg-microbe/blob/" + KGM_COMMIT + + "/" + owner["path"] for owner in OWNER_PATHS]] + return review + + +def run(staging): + started = base.utc_now() + raws, occurrence, source, paper_raw, paper_spans = base.load_inputs(base.RETAINED, base.PAPER) + records, service_raws, owners = load_authorities() + base.check_contracts() + relative, stage, command, exit_code = base.destination(staging) + stage.mkdir(mode=0o700) + for name in ("occurrence.json", "source.json"): + base.write_new(stage / name, raws[name]) + base.write_new(stage / "prepared-packet.json", raws["packet.json"]) + base.write_new(stage / "abstract.json", paper_raw) + copied_pins = [base.pin(stage / name) for name in + ("occurrence.json", "source.json", "prepared-packet.json", "abstract.json")] + for name, record in records.items(): + for kind, suffix in (("raw", ".html"), ("text", ".txt"), ("receipt", ".json")): + base.write_new(stage / (name + suffix), record["raws"][kind]) + copied_pins.append(base.pin(stage / (name + suffix))) + for name, raw in service_raws.items(): + base.write_new(stage / name, raw) + copied_pins.append(base.pin(stage / name)) + for owner_path, raw in owners.items(): + name = "kg-microbe-" + Path(owner_path).name + base.write_new(stage / name, raw) + copied_pins.append(base.pin(stage / name)) + packet = base.build_packet(occurrence, source, occurrence_input=copied_pins[0], + source_input=copied_pins[1], root=ROOT) + base.write_json(stage / "packet.json", packet) + base.validate_packet(json.loads(base.read_bytes(stage, "packet.json")), root=ROOT) + packet_pin, paper_pin = base.pin(stage / "packet.json"), base.pin(stage / "abstract.json") + proofs = [{"evidence_id": "packet-source", "kind": "packet", "input": packet_pin, + "reference": packet_pin["path"], "support": "context_only", "scope": "exact", + "scope_rationale": "Original occurrence and complete source context unchanged; " + "the source identity conflict is not an independent biological proof.", + "inspected_extent": "Original occurrence/endpoints and all four retained source records.", + "axes": ["source_fidelity", "relation", "subject_node", "object_node"]}] + for eid, span in paper_spans.items(): + proofs.append({**base.paper_identity(), "evidence_id": eid, "input": paper_pin, + "support": "partial", "scope": "partial", + "scope_rationale": "Nominal DSM 18772 nonmotility evidence does not settle " + "the mixed source identity or complete graph model.", + "axes": ["claim", "literature"], + **{key: span[key] for key in ("text_sha256", "start", "end", "extractor")}}) + for name, record in records.items(): + receipt, span = record["receipt"], record["span"] + proofs.append({"evidence_id": "catalog-" + name, "kind": "authority", + "input": base.pin(stage / (name + ".txt")), "reference": capture.URLS[name], + "version": receipt["fetched_at"] + "; raw_sha256=" + receipt["raw_sha256"], + "support": "context_only", "scope": "context", + "scope_rationale": "Verified independent culture-accession identity context; " + "not a full resolution of the original source join or node model.", + "inspected_extent": "Complete captured catalog identity and sequence sections; " + "raw HTML, receipt and deterministic text derivative verified.", + "axes": ["subject_node", "source_fidelity"], + **{key: span[key] for key in ("text_sha256", "start", "end", "extractor")}}) + base.write_json(stage / "proofs.json", {"profile": base.PROFILE, + "occurrence_id": base.OCCURRENCE, "proofs": proofs}) + proofs_pin = base.pin(stage / "proofs.json") + finished = base.utc_now() + review = make_review(packet_pin, proofs_pin, copied_pins, paper_spans, records, + started, finished, (command, exit_code)) + base.write_json(stage / "authored-review.json", review) + base.validate_occurrence_review(ROOT, review, packet_pin["path"], proofs_pin["path"]) + result = base.save_occurrence_review(ROOT, review, packet_pin["path"], proofs_pin["path"]) + receipt = {**result, "staging": str(relative), "provider_calls": 0, + "historical_investigation_channels": {"cborg_tavily": 3, "anonymous_catalog_gets": 4, + "publisher_tdm": 0}, + "calibration_rating": False, "calibration_pass": False, "review_completion": "partial", + "previous_review": PREVIOUS_ID, "maintained_owner_commit": KGM_COMMIT, + "packet": packet_pin, "proofs": proofs_pin, + "paper_quotation_words": sum(len(q.split()) for q in base.QUOTES.values()), + "authority_quotation_words": {name: len(item["quote"].split()) + for name, item in AUTHORITY_PINS.items()}} + base.write_json(stage / "receipt.json", receipt) + base.require(json.loads(base.read_bytes(stage, "receipt.json")) == receipt, + "Persisted review receipt differs") + return receipt + + +def main(): + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__) + modes = parser.add_mutually_exclusive_group(required=True) + modes.add_argument("--plan", action="store_true") + modes.add_argument("--run", action="store_true") + parser.add_argument("--staging", default=".temp/identity130-review-20261115") + args = parser.parse_args() + if args.plan: + base.load_inputs(base.RETAINED, base.PAPER) + load_authorities() + base.check_contracts() + base.destination(args.staging) + result = {"action": "plan", "writes": 0, "provider_calls": 0, + "staging": args.staging, "occurrence_id": base.OCCURRENCE, + "assessments": base.AXES, "completion": "partial", "calibration_rating": False, + "authority_count": len(AUTHORITY_PINS), "maintained_owner_commit": KGM_COMMIT} + else: + result = run(args.staging) + print(json.dumps(result, sort_keys=True)) + return 0 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + raise SystemExit(main()) diff --git a/tests/test_bactotraits_identity_review.py b/tests/test_bactotraits_identity_review.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9152e75 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/test_bactotraits_identity_review.py @@ -0,0 +1,59 @@ +"""Capture instants must cross the pinned review timestamp boundary unchanged (#133).""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import importlib.util +from datetime import datetime +from pathlib import Path + +import pytest +import yaml +from kg_microbe_reviews import ReviewError, validate_review + +ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] +HELPER = ROOT / "scripts/adhoc/review_bactotraits_identity_130_20261115.py" + + +@pytest.fixture +def helper(monkeypatch): + monkeypatch.syspath_prepend(str(HELPER.parent)) + spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location("identity_review_130", HELPER) + module = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec) + spec.loader.exec_module(module) + return module + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize(("captured", "expected"), [ + ("2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207+00:00", "2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207Z"), + ("2026-11-15T23:31:54.779207-08:00", "2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207Z"), + ("2026-11-16T13:01:54.1+05:30", "2026-11-16T07:31:54.100000Z"), + ("2026-11-16T07:31:54+00:00", "2026-11-16T07:31:54Z"), + ("2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207Z", "2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207Z"), +]) +def test_133_normalization_preserves_instant_and_microseconds(helper, captured, expected): + normalized = helper.canonical_utc_timestamp(captured) + assert normalized == expected + assert datetime.fromisoformat(normalized) == datetime.fromisoformat(captured) + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize("captured", [ + "2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207", "2026-11-16", "not-a-timestamp", None, + "2026-11-16T07:31:54.7792071+00:00", +]) +def test_133_naive_invalid_or_unrepresentable_instants_are_rejected(helper, captured): + with pytest.raises(ValueError): + helper.canonical_utc_timestamp(captured) + + +def test_133_actual_capture_timestamp_is_accepted_by_pinned_review_contract_after_normalization(helper): + path = ROOT / "reviews/structured/20261116T052355Z-fresh05-abstract-adapter/review.yaml" + review = yaml.safe_load(path.read_text()) + review.update(started_at="2026-11-16T07:00:00Z", finished_at="2026-11-16T08:00:00Z", + review_id="20261116T080000Z-timestamp-contract-regression") + captured = "2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207+00:00" + review["evidence"][0]["accessed_at"] = captured + with pytest.raises(ReviewError, match=r"evidence\.0\.accessed_at"): + validate_review(review) + review["evidence"][0]["accessed_at"] = helper.canonical_utc_timestamp(captured) + validate_review(review) + assert review["evidence"][0]["accessed_at"] == "2026-11-16T07:31:54.779207Z"