From f72534fc87d75b7077fb248f4cab134c1cf8107d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Codex Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2026 20:47:40 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] Revalidate all published Mech browser features with independent evidence --- _fleet/README.md | 5 + _fleet/data/site_features.json | 666 +- .../reviews/site-features-20261119/.gitignore | 27 + .../reviews/site-features-20261119/README.md | 80 + .../site-features-20261119/arbitration.json | 48 + .../site-features-20261119/changes.json | 4628 ++++++++++++ .../cross-column-review.md | 44 + .../AntibioticMech/audit-1/coverage.json | 317 + .../AntibioticMech/audit-1/followup-1.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 35161 bytes .../AntibioticMech/audit-1/publication.json | 714 ++ .../AntibioticMech/audit-1/raw.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 202544 bytes .../CellStructureMech/audit-2/coverage.json | 83 + .../audit-2/followup-1.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 2325 bytes .../audit-2/publication.json | 593 ++ .../CellStructureMech/audit-2/raw.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 668519 bytes .../CommunityMech/audit-1/coverage.json | 40 + .../CommunityMech/audit-1/followup-1.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 156088 bytes .../CommunityMech/audit-1/publication.json | 719 ++ .../group-a/CommunityMech/audit-1/raw.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 2232091 bytes .../group-a/HabitatMech/audit-3/coverage.json | 623 ++ .../HabitatMech/audit-3/followup-1.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 15339 bytes .../HabitatMech/audit-3/followup-2.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 27570 bytes .../HabitatMech/audit-3/publication.json | 589 ++ .../group-a/HabitatMech/audit-3/raw.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 227817 bytes .../group-a/PathwayMech/audit-2/coverage.json | 66 + .../PathwayMech/audit-2/publication.json | 520 ++ .../group-a/PathwayMech/audit-2/raw.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 672637 bytes .../group-a/TaxonMech/audit-1/coverage.json | 55 + .../TaxonMech/audit-1/followup-1.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 1560 bytes .../TaxonMech/audit-1/publication.json | 597 ++ .../group-a/TaxonMech/audit-1/raw.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 481345 bytes .../group-a/proposals.json | 1322 ++++ .../group-a/root-skeptic.md | 84 + .../group-b/cmmmech.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 202964 bytes .../culturemech-review-followup.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 825 bytes ...lturemech-review-followup.publication.json | 8 + .../group-b/culturemech-supplement.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 5601 bytes .../group-b/culturemech.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 266405 bytes .../group-b/dufmech-review-followup.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 3066 bytes .../dufmech-review-followup.publication.json | 8 + .../group-b/dufmech.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 194243 bytes .../group-b/evidence.json | 1348 ++++ .../group-b/group-a-skeptic.md | 141 + .../mediaingredientmech-supplement.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 14320 bytes .../group-b/mediaingredientmech.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 151401 bytes .../naturalproductmech-supplement.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 126136 bytes .../group-b/naturalproductmech.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 152947 bytes .../group-b/proposals.json | 776 ++ .../proteintraitsmech-controls.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 4196 bytes .../proteintraitsmech-supplement.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 130236 bytes .../group-b/proteintraitsmech.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 218839 bytes .../group-b/raw-artifacts.json | 79 + .../group-b/receipts-summary.json | 6611 +++++++++++++++++ .../group-b/root-cofactor-assay-skeptic.md | 63 + .../review-complete.json | 23 + .../root/aimech-auditor-v2.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 4056060 bytes .../root/aimech-supplement.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 4419 bytes .../root/assay-auditor.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 19245 bytes .../root/assay-supplement.json | 189 + .../root/cofactor-canary.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 22495 bytes .../root/cofactor-supplement.json | 259 + .../root/group-b-skeptic.md | 68 + .../root/proposals.json | 882 +++ .../root/raw-artifacts.json | 114 + .../root/trait-auditor.json.gz | Bin 0 -> 2924791 bytes .../root/trait-supplement.json | 187 + .../reviews/site-features-20261119/scope.json | 121 + mechs.md | 66 +- .../revalidate_aimech_supplement_20261119.py | 73 + scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_a_20261119.py | 320 + .../revalidate_group_a_20261119_followup.py | 98 + .../adhoc/revalidate_group_a_20261119_pack.py | 59 + .../revalidate_group_a_20261119_proposals.py | 188 + .../revalidate_group_a_20261119_review.py | 105 + scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_b_20261119.py | 229 + .../revalidate_group_b_20261119_controls.py | 42 + .../revalidate_group_b_20261119_curate.py | 211 + .../revalidate_group_b_20261119_publish.py | 46 + ...lidate_group_b_20261119_review_followup.py | 121 + .../revalidate_group_b_20261119_summarize.py | 54 + .../revalidate_group_b_20261119_supplement.py | 129 + .../adhoc/revalidate_integrate_20261119.py | 64 + .../revalidate_publish_receipts_20261119.py | 47 + .../revalidate_root_proposals_20261119.py | 117 + .../adhoc/revalidate_root_sites_20261119.py | 258 + scripts/adhoc/revalidate_scope_20261119.py | 59 + .../adhoc/revalidate_small_sites_20261119.py | 75 + .../revalidate_trait_supplement_20261119.py | 63 + 88 files changed, 24753 insertions(+), 368 deletions(-) create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/.gitignore create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/README.md create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/arbitration.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/changes.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/cross-column-review.md create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/coverage.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/followup-1.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/publication.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/raw.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/CellStructureMech/audit-2/coverage.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/CellStructureMech/audit-2/followup-1.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/CellStructureMech/audit-2/publication.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/CellStructureMech/audit-2/raw.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/CommunityMech/audit-1/coverage.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/CommunityMech/audit-1/followup-1.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/CommunityMech/audit-1/publication.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/CommunityMech/audit-1/raw.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/HabitatMech/audit-3/coverage.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/HabitatMech/audit-3/followup-1.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/HabitatMech/audit-3/followup-2.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/HabitatMech/audit-3/publication.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/HabitatMech/audit-3/raw.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/PathwayMech/audit-2/coverage.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/PathwayMech/audit-2/publication.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/PathwayMech/audit-2/raw.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/TaxonMech/audit-1/coverage.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/TaxonMech/audit-1/followup-1.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/TaxonMech/audit-1/publication.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/TaxonMech/audit-1/raw.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/proposals.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/root-skeptic.md create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/cmmmech.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/culturemech-review-followup.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/culturemech-review-followup.publication.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/culturemech-supplement.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/culturemech.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/dufmech-review-followup.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/dufmech-review-followup.publication.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/dufmech.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/evidence.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/group-a-skeptic.md create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/mediaingredientmech-supplement.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/mediaingredientmech.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/naturalproductmech-supplement.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/naturalproductmech.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/proposals.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/proteintraitsmech-controls.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/proteintraitsmech-supplement.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/proteintraitsmech.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/raw-artifacts.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/receipts-summary.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-b/root-cofactor-assay-skeptic.md create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/review-complete.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/aimech-auditor-v2.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/aimech-supplement.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/assay-auditor.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/assay-supplement.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/cofactor-canary.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/cofactor-supplement.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/group-b-skeptic.md create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/proposals.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/raw-artifacts.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/trait-auditor.json.gz create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/root/trait-supplement.json create mode 100644 _fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/scope.json create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_aimech_supplement_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_a_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_a_20261119_followup.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_a_20261119_pack.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_a_20261119_proposals.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_a_20261119_review.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_b_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_b_20261119_controls.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_b_20261119_curate.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_b_20261119_publish.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_b_20261119_review_followup.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_b_20261119_summarize.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_group_b_20261119_supplement.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_integrate_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_publish_receipts_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_root_proposals_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_root_sites_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_scope_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_small_sites_20261119.py create mode 100644 scripts/adhoc/revalidate_trait_supplement_20261119.py diff --git a/_fleet/README.md b/_fleet/README.md index 456322d..88a89f8 100644 --- a/_fleet/README.md +++ b/_fleet/README.md @@ -48,6 +48,11 @@ feature spot-check cannot redate the entire row. An entry without a published site cannot carry a website recheck. Adding these optional fields is a provenance assertion, not an automatic browser test or approval of a feature. + The November 19, 2026 full feature-only revalidation covers all sixteen published + corpus sites and moves the common feature baseline to that date; its retained + [observations, independent reviews and arbitration](reviews/site-features-20261119/README.md) + are separate from the unchanged corpus census and pins. EdgeMech's proposed + sample browser is tracked in its own PR and is not counted as published here. - `audit_notes.json` — hand-checked explanations of each source and its counted entities. PathwayMech records, DUFMech seed families, CofactorMech cofactors and AssayMech assays use the same pinned census, statistics and site-audit diff --git a/_fleet/data/site_features.json b/_fleet/data/site_features.json index 9eb8b30..ea6c6cb 100644 --- a/_fleet/data/site_features.json +++ b/_fleet/data/site_features.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { - "checked_on": "2026-11-09", - "scope": "Live GitHub Pages sites checked on November 9, 2026 against all 24 existing catalogue criteria. Each site had an auditor and an independent skeptic; the root editor resolved rubric disagreements and compared each feature across the fleet. Checks exercised identifier and label searches, filters and reset, sorting and URL restoration, representative record pages, scientific links and downloads, theme persistence, 390-pixel layouts and failed data requests. Corpus-wide claims additionally used complete published indexes or pinned source inventories. Record-page rendering was sampled rather than exhaustive. Each recorded deployed revision had a successful deployment status and a served Last-Modified date no earlier than its deployment request (where a newer deployment request failed without replacing the served site, the prior verified deployed revision was preserved). These live-site checks are separate from the common corpus pins.", + "checked_on": "2026-11-19", + "scope": "All sixteen published corpus Mech sites were rechecked against the existing 24 criteria on November 19, 2026 (America/Los_Angeles; evidence timestamps are UTC). Every verdict had an auditor and an independent skeptic, followed by a cross-site comparison of each criterion. Live Chrome/Playwright checks exercised identifier and label search, filters/reset, sorting and URL restoration where offered, populated record views, scientific links and downloads, persisted themes, fresh and resized 390-pixel layouts, and failed data requests with recovery. Complete published indexes, manifests or deployed source inventories support catalogue coverage; record rendering was sampled except for all CofactorMech and AssayMech records. Successful deployment statuses and served Last-Modified dates were verified before and after each pass. Redeployment alone did not change a rating. These observations are separate from the retained corpus census and its pins. EdgeMech remains separately listed infrastructure; its proposed sample browser is not a published-site audit.", "groups": [ { "title": "Find records", @@ -173,126 +173,126 @@ "AntibioticMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/AntibioticMech", - "deployed_revision": "d00e4533e81a8a605397042a61f83ce085dc7f01", + "deployed_revision": "6ec4c26ca0b650f895b4e3d7d642e5d9eb22dda7", "features": { "search": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Browse finds CHEBI:2637 and amikacin with matching counts, but large result sets stop at the first 500 links without result pagination. Category indexes provide separate routes through the corpus.", + "note": "CHEBI:2637 and rifampicin each find one compound. The antibiotic query has 553 matches but shows only the first 500 without search pagination; class listings provide a separate navigation route.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 3,125-record corpus.", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The Browse sort control offers Compound name (A–Z); Compound name (Z–A); Antimicrobial class (A–Z); Structural class (A–Z); Curation status (REVIEWED first); Grounding status (EXACT first). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "note": "The query and exercised facet/sort state survive URL reload with the same controls and matching counts.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "The 3,125-record browse index and linked paginated class listings provide routes into the complete corpus; the interactive result panel itself is capped at 500.", + "note": "The complete browse index contains 3,125 distinct record slugs and the chemical-map download contains 3,125 distinct identifiers and detail paths. Linked class listings provide pagination; opening antibacterial page 2 succeeds with 300 records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled amikacin, avibactam and D-cycloserine pages have stable URLs, source assertions, molecular context, curation histories and links to their own source records.", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Avibactam’s own identity and activity terms resolve, but four broader ChEBI identifiers still display Label unavailable; the main classification section remains incompletely labeled.", + "note": "Avibactam links its ChEBI identity and broader-compound CURIEs, but all four entries in its Classification section display Label unavailable instead of readable names.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Avibactam links PMID:25406838 in its molecular-target, causal-edge and record evidence. D-cycloserine retains linked evidence for its qualified pathway correspondence.", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record headers show workflow status, including REVIEWED on avibactam; the landing distinguishes recorded workflow status from human review.", + "note": "Sampled record headers show the workflow status, separately from dated curation events.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Avibactam shows dated seeding, reseeding, review and protein/causal-graph curation events, with curator identifiers and LLM-assisted labels where recorded.", + "note": "Sampled record views display dated curator actions and change summaries.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled Provenance sections link their own data/antibiotics YAML. Large records also link a complete per-record JSON.gz export.", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "The chemical map displays all 3,125 compounds and the sequence map 132 proteins; the corpus text map renders separately. Sampled causal mechanisms are available as node/edge tables.", + "note": "The chemical map renders 3,125 structures; populated compound views display chemical properties and causal mechanisms. The sequence map renders a subset of 132 proteins across 71 compounds, and a separate text map is available.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/chemical-map.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "D-cycloserine links to PathwayMech WikiPathways:WP5060 with source revision and qualified target/process correspondence; the target returns HTTP 200.", + "note": "D-cycloserine links directly to the specific PathwayMech WikiPathways:WP5060 record, which returns HTTP 200. Generic Explore searches are distinct from these specific-record relationships; their broken MediaIngredientMech route is tracked separately.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antimycobacterial/d-cycloserine.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing reports 3,125 compounds and generated grounding, review and mechanism statistics; its notice states 2,794 SEEDED records.", + "note": "The landing reports 3,125 compounds, 2,782 ontology-grounded records, 281 merged ChEBI/ARO records and 174 with REVIEWED workflow status, plus mechanism coverage counts.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" }, "category_browse": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse and the landing link antimicrobial class listings, including Antibacterial with 1,196 directly filed records and 1,274 including its 78-record antimycobacterial subclass; Antifungal has 617.", + "note": "The landing links antimicrobial-class listings. The antibacterial listing opens and its page-2 link loads a further 300 compound rows.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The landing links a 3,125-entry browse index and chemical-map coordinates, while sampled record pages link complete individual JSON.gz records. No bulk complete-record corpus export is linked; the old corpus.json/corpus.csv claim is unsupported.", + "note": "Linked downloads include the 3,125-row browse index, the complete chemical-map data and lazy per-record JSON for sampled compounds, rather than a bulk full-record corpus export.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Navigation links the annotated LinkML schema YAML successfully; no rendered schema documentation was linked from the sampled pages.", + "note": "Sampled navigation links the annotated LinkML YAML source, rather than a rendered schema reference.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" }, "license": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with upstream terms retained, consistent with the pinned license files.", + "note": "Sampled pages distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data, BSD-3-Clause code and retained upstream terms, consistent with license files read at the deployed revision.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The footer displays corpus digest 04a931dcbfed and 3,125 records, but its only date is the upstream ChEBI/CARD input date 2026-08-30; it does not identify a dated build of its own corpus.", + "note": "Sampled pages show an undated corpus digest or upstream-source dates, without a build date, displayed commit or dated version of the project corpus.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "present", - "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "note": "Dark mode chosen on the landing persists across the sampled browser, record and visualization pages in the same browser context.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "present", - "note": "All sampled live routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; wide content stays within its own region.", + "note": "The eight valid main/browser/detail/map routes fit 390px on fresh and resized loads. The actual linked antibacterial category pagination also fits 390px; a guessed unlinked category URL returned a retained 404 and is excluded from feature judgments.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Chemical-map and browse-index failures are explicit. After sequence-map JSON fails, typing in search replaces the error with Showing 0 of 0 proteins, which misrepresents an unavailable dataset as empty.", + "note": "Browse and the chemical map retain explicit fetch-error messages. On the sequence map, typing after a blocked JSON load replaces the error with Showing 0 of 0 proteins. Removing faults and reloading restores loaded data totals.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/chemical-map.html" } } @@ -300,126 +300,126 @@ "CellStructureMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CellStructureMech", - "deployed_revision": "6e0cbc219a1a600680373f141efb92f221c02493", + "deployed_revision": "7a5ef9e01fe8e8bc44f649d94b61b4b2bab5ef2b", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse searches by identifier and label. GO:0097589: 1 of 1022 records shown; MitoStore: 1 of 1022 records shown; cellstructuremech:insoluble_protein_deposit: 1 of 1022 records shown.", + "note": "GO:0097589, the label MitoStore and the local insoluble-protein-deposit identifier each return one record. The complete listing contains all 1,022 structures.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 1,022-record corpus.", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The Browse sort control offers Label (A–Z); Label (Z–A); Identifier (A–Z); Category; Kind; Mapping status. Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "note": "The query and exercised facet/sort state survive URL reload with the same controls and matching counts.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse exposes all 1,022 structure records, matching the landing and linked complete-corpus JSON; category pages and the 873-record grounded subset provide additional routes.", + "note": "Browse exposes all 1,022 records. The complete corpus and index downloads each contain 1,022 unique identifiers; the index supplies 1,022 distinct stable detail routes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "The sampled structure records have stable pages with components, evidence, curation history and their own YAML source links. Browse and the complete export both cover 1,022 records.", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Attachment organelle membrane now shows labeled GO:0033111, GO:0033099 and GO:0005886 resolver links in its mechanism Subject/Object cells, alongside labeled parent, taxon and UniProt-location links.", + "note": "The attachment-organelle membrane view labels and links its GO identity, structural parents, UniProt location and taxonomy terms; the populated archaellum and S-layer pages provide corresponding resolver links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/attachment_organelle_membrane.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled components, distribution statements, mechanism edges and record-level evidence link GO, DOI and PubMed references.", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled record headers and Browse rows show Proposed, separately from their dated curation histories.", + "note": "Sampled record headers show the workflow status, separately from dated curation events.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Attachment organelle membrane shows dated creation, expansion and review actions with named curators and change summaries.", + "note": "Sampled record views display dated curator actions and change summaries.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Each sampled record links its own data/structures YAML on GitHub.", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "The working embedding-map.html renders 1,022 structure points; the sequence map renders 469 proteins across 140 structures. The old note’s pages/map.html returns 404, and sampled mechanism sections are tables rather than rendered SVG diagrams.", + "note": "The text map renders all 1,022 structures. The sequence map renders 469 proteins associated with 140 structures; its populated context links the associated structure record.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/embedding-map.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "S-layer links traitmech:000064 to TraitMech’s stable S-layer record; that target returns HTTP 200.", + "note": "The S-layer record links directly to the corresponding TraitMech S-layer trait page, which returns HTTP 200.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/envelope/s_layer.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing reports 1,022 structures, 13 categories and 873 GO-grounded records; its category table includes 226 membrane organelles.", + "note": "The landing reports 1,022 structures, 13 categories and 873 GO-grounded records, with counts for each category.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" }, "category_browse": { "status": "present", - "note": "Thirteen category links lead to subset pages. The opened Microcompartment page shows all six records; the separate GO-grounded page shows 873.", + "note": "Thirteen named category routes and a GO-grounded subset are linked from the landing. The microcompartment and grounded listings open with populated record links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" }, "downloads": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing links the complete corpus JSON with 1,022 records and the 1,022-entry catalogue index; both downloads return HTTP 200.", + "note": "The linked complete corpus JSON contains 1,022 full records, with a separate 1,022-record catalogue index; both download successfully and have retained byte hashes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Visible Schema and LinkML schema links open the annotated LinkML YAML source. Reviewed navigation does not expose a rendered schema reference or explanatory guide.", + "note": "The linked annotated LinkML YAML is verified at the deployed revision through the GitHub API after a web-UI rate limit; sampled navigation does not expose a rendered schema reference.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" }, "license": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with upstream terms retained, consistent with the pinned license files.", + "note": "Sampled pages distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data, BSD-3-Clause code and retained upstream terms, consistent with license files read at the deployed revision.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "present", - "note": "Shared footers state corpus as of 2026-11-03 05:55:11 UTC, digest d7c5fef867d9 and 1,022 records.", + "note": "Main pages display the corpus date 2026-11-03 05:55:11 UTC, digest d7c5fef867d9, record count and generation script.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "present", - "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "note": "Dark mode chosen on the landing persists across the sampled browser, record and visualization pages in the same browser context.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "present", - "note": "All sampled live routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; wide content stays within its own region.", + "note": "All sampled routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; retained states record document widths for every route.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/cytoskeleton/stentor_myoneme_system.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "present", - "note": "Blocking either embedding-map JSON request displays Could not load embedding artifacts: Failed to fetch. The sequence map embeds its data without a fetch.", + "note": "Blocking both text-map artifacts produces Could not load embedding artifacts: Failed to fetch. Removing the fault and reloading restores 1,022 structures; the main browser uses embedded data.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/embedding-map.html" } } @@ -427,126 +427,126 @@ "CommunityMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CommunityMech", - "deployed_revision": "7ce759feb72be28e1860ccf70b69bb9888fe4a45", + "deployed_revision": "6097f1ad3d47424b3cc092fc24cdb869aee5b539", "features": { "search": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Name and description searches work across 512 communities, but known record identifiers CommunityMech:000134 and CommunityMech:000139 return zero matches; the corresponding named records are present.", + "note": "The full ANME-SRB community name finds one of 512 communities. Known identifiers CommunityMech:000134 and CommunityMech:000139 return zero matches despite their records being present.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Category and ecological-state filters have Clear All. BIOTECHNOLOGY selects 99 of 512 communities; reset restores all 512.", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "The live count shows three matches for ANME, one for its full community name and zero for the tested canonical identifiers and unmatched query.", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The browser offers Name (A → Z), Name (Z → A), Members (Most → Fewest), Members (Fewest → Most), Category (A → Z). Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "The URL retains search, category and sort; the combined BIOTECHNOLOGY/name-search selection restores the same controls and zero-match state.", + "note": "The positive full-name query survives reload. The BIOTECHNOLOGY facet and category sort also restore the same controls and 99 matches.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "The complete browser and its machine-readable export cover 512 published records; sampled record links open successfully.", + "note": "The live browser exposes 512 distinct community record links and its complete published JSON index contains 512 distinct record slugs; sampled individual pages open successfully.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Published communities have individual communities/.html pages; four sampled records display taxonomy, interactions, environment and growth media.", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled taxonomy and environmental sections show readable names beside NCBITaxon, ChEBI and ENVO resolver links.", + "note": "Sampled taxonomy and environmental sections show readable organism, chemical and habitat labels alongside NCBITaxon, ChEBI and ENVO resolver links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Aalborg_East_Full_Scale_EBPR_Community.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled interaction evidence links PMID and DOI references with supporting text and evidence-type labels.", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Alseth_FourSpecies_Pathogen_Phage_Community.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "missing", - "note": "Record headers show ecological state and evidence labels, not an overall curation or review status.", + "note": "The four sampled community views show ecological state and claim evidence, but no overall record curation/review status.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "missing", - "note": "The sampled community pages do not display curation events, even though the repository retains provenance.", + "note": "The four sampled community views do not display dated curator events or change histories.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Aalborg_East_Full_Scale_EBPR_Community.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Each sampled record footer now links its own kb/communities YAML file on GitHub.", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "Community pages render interaction diagrams, and text, taxonomic and sequence embedding views open as linked domain views.", + "note": "Community records render interaction diagrams and linked maps render populated views. The text map contains 458 communities and the sequence map 27 proteins; these are subsets, not complete coverage of the 512-community browser.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/community_umap.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { - "status": "present", - "note": "Copper Biomining links Standard 9K Medium directly to CultureMech normalized recipe 003277.", + "status": "partial", + "note": "Copper Biomining links a working CultureMech normalized recipe, but sampled TaxonMech record handoffs and several sibling browser links return HTTP 404.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Copper_Biomining_Heap_Leach.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing and browser report 512 published communities across 16 categories. Repository isolate records are outside this published-community count.", + "note": "The landing and browser display 512 published communities across 16 categories; repository isolate records are outside this published-community total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" }, "category_browse": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Category and ecological-state subsets are filters in the browser rather than separate category pages.", + "note": "Category subsets are accessible as browser filters, rather than standalone category pages. Selecting BIOTECHNOLOGY shows 99 of 512 communities.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html#category-facet" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Linked communities.json and TSV cover all 512 communities as catalogue summaries; they omit the complete taxon and interaction evidence stored in individual records.", + "note": "Linked JSON and TSV downloads cover all 512 communities as catalogue summaries, omitting the full taxonomy and interaction evidence of individual records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities.json" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "present", - "note": "The linked schema.html page documents the CommunityMech classes, slots and ontology groundings.", + "note": "The linked schema.html page renders a CommunityMech schema reference with classes, slots and ontology groundings.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/schema.html" }, "license": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Reviewed landing and record footers say License: BSD-3-Clause without distinguishing the project data license from the code license.", + "note": "Landing and record footers state License: BSD-3-Clause without distinguishing project data from code, although the deployed repository retains a separate CC BY 4.0 data license.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "missing", - "note": "Reviewed pages identify the generator and source corpus but do not give a build date, deployed commit or dated corpus version.", + "note": "Sampled pages identify the generator and source corpus but do not display a build date, deployed commit or dated corpus version.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" }, "theme_toggle": { - "status": "present", - "note": "Dark mode chosen on the landing persists through the browser, maps, schema and four sampled records.", + "status": "partial", + "note": "Dark mode persists across the templated browser, records and taxonomic/network views. The linked text and sequence maps ignore the saved dark choice, have no toggle, and render a light background.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" }, "responsive": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The reviewed landing, browser, maps and sampled community records fit a 390px viewport, but schema.html widens the document to 1,321px on fresh and resized loads.", + "note": "The schema page widens the document to 1,321px at a 390px viewport on fresh and resized loads; the other ten sampled routes fit.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/schema.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "not_applicable", - "note": "Reviewed community pages and visualizations use embedded data; no fetch or XHR catalogue request was observed to abort.", + "note": "The eleven sampled landing, browser, record, schema and visualization routes use embedded data; no fetch/XHR data request was observed. Blocking fetch/XHR while exercising browser search intercepted no request.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" } } @@ -554,126 +554,126 @@ "CultureMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CultureMech", - "deployed_revision": "2c9ac2a14cc1fb0808529225b378b5ce8b24f2b8", + "deployed_revision": "13c710defa9eddf17dab531f40b915e449f68663", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "CultureMech:000252 returns one recipe and Halophilic medium returns four, with individual recipe links.", + "note": "CultureMech:000252 returns one linked recipe and Halophilic medium returns four from 15,915 normalized recipes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "The category facet selects 14,332 bacterial recipes; combining it with Halophilic medium leaves two. Clear All restores all 15,915.", + "note": "The bacterial category selects 14,332 recipes, combined Halophilic medium search leaves two, and Clear All restores 15,915.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "The live count distinguishes one identifier match, four label matches, two bacterial label matches and zero for an unmatched query.", + "note": "The count changes to one identifier match, four label matches, two category/label matches and zero for an unmatched query.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "missing", - "note": "The recipe browser has no reader-facing sort selector, sort button or sortable table. Its facet lists are internally ordered, which does not provide record sorting.", + "note": "The main browser has no reader-facing record sort selector, sort button or sortable table.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Search and property filters restore from the URL: Halophilic medium with category=bacterial reloads with the same two recipes.", + "note": "Cold navigation and reload restore the Halophilic medium search plus bacterial category with the same two recipes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The main browser covers 15,915 normalized recipes. The landing also counts 6,325 merged recipes, whose separate pages/index.html listing is outside the main browser navigation.", + "note": "The main browser and linked export cover 15,915 normalized recipes. The landing also counts 6,325 merged recipes, whose separate pages/index.html is not linked from its navigation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/index.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Normalized and merged recipes have stable individual URLs; sampled normalized pages display composition, organisms and provenance.", + "note": "Sampled normalized recipes have stable pages with composition, organisms and provenance; normalized and merged indexes expose individual record links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Ingredient and organism terms have labels and resolver links, but mediadive.medium:1399 on recipe 000252 is shown as source link unavailable.", + "note": "Ingredients and organisms have labeled resolver links, but recipe 000252 still displays mediadive.medium:1399 as source link unavailable.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Sampled records link formal DOI references, but source URLs embedded in Notes remain plain text.", + "note": "Sampled recipes link formal DOI references while source URLs embedded in Notes remain plain text.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "missing", - "note": "Sampled recipe pages do not state record curation or review status. The separate growth-evidence report does not provide a status for each recipe.", + "note": "Sampled recipe pages do not state an overall curation or review status; the separate growth-evidence report is not a per-record workflow status.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000038.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Recipe Provenance tables show timestamps, curators or scripts, actions and notes.", + "note": "Recipe Provenance tables display timestamps, curators or scripts, actions and notes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The source YAML path appears as plain text in sampled record footers rather than as a link to that file.", + "note": "Sampled record footers name their individual YAML path as plain text and link the repository rather than that file.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "Text and chemically derived media maps and an ingredient map render interactive corpus views.", + "note": "Loaded text, media and ingredient maps provide corpus views; retained coordinate coverage is distinguished from current recipe counts.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/umap.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Recipe 015438 links CommunityMech:000064 to the specific pinned Soybean_N_Fixation_sfSynCom.yaml record.", + "note": "Recipe 015438 links CommunityMech:000064 directly to the retained Soybean_N_Fixation_sfSynCom.yaml record.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/015438.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing shows 15,915 normalized recipes, 6,325 merged recipes and five populated categories.", + "note": "The landing displays 15,915 normalized records, 6,325 merged records and five populated categories.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" }, "category_browse": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Categories are browser facets and headed sections on long indexes; the landing does not link separate category pages.", + "note": "Categories are main-browser facets and headed index sections; the landing does not link separate category pages.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/index.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "note": "Visible suite-directory links appear in reviewed core navigation and record footers.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The landing links JSON and TSV indexes covering 15,915 normalized recipes, but these omit full compositions and record evidence; a complete bulk record export is not linked.", + "note": "Linked JSON/TSV indexes cover 15,915 normalized recipes but omit full composition and evidence; complete bulk records are not linked.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/recipes.json" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "present", - "note": "The linked app/schema.html guide documents 51 classes and 34 enumerations, including MediaRecipe and growth-evidence structures.", + "note": "The linked app/schema.html guide documents MediaRecipe, growth-evidence classes and enumerations.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/schema.html" }, "license": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The reviewed landing, schema and record footers identify BSD-3-Clause but do not consistently distinguish the project data license from the code license.", + "note": "Reviewed core footers state BSD-3-Clause without separately identifying project data and code licenses; the growth-review and maps omit that distinction.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "missing", - "note": "The reviewed landing, browser and recipe footers do not state a site build, deployment revision or dated corpus version; recipe curation dates describe individual events.", + "note": "Reviewed core pages identify generators and recipe provenance but do not state a site build date, deployment revision or dated project-corpus version.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Dark mode persists through the core browser, indexes, maps and records. The linked growth-evidence report has no toggle and does not adopt the saved choice.", + "note": "Dark persists through core browser, indexes, maps and records; the linked growth-evidence report has no toggle and ignores the saved choice.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/media_growth_review.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Core reviewed pages and the normalized index fit 390px. The linked growth-evidence report still widens the document to 520px.", + "note": "Core reviewed routes fit 390px, but pages/media_growth_review.html remains 520px wide on both fresh and resized loads.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/index.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "present", - "note": "Blocking data.js shows Recipes could not be loaded and a retry control rather than a zero-record catalogue.", + "note": "Blocking browser data.js shows Recipes could not be loaded with a retry control; unblocking and reloading restores 15,915 recipes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" } } @@ -681,126 +681,126 @@ "DUFMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/DUFMech", - "deployed_revision": "17755af9c3c73a8a9d1cb472743cdd6f329b7b92", + "deployed_revision": "a030cca0dae2771e961ae12474c24c47a32b1363", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "PF04149, IPR007278 and Domain of unknown function (DUF397) each return one linked family from the 8,296-family catalogue.", + "note": "PF04149, IPR007278 and Domain of unknown function (DUF397) each return one linked family from 8,296.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Seed status, characterization and curation status filters combine with search; Clear search and filters restores all 8,296 families.", + "note": "Seed, characterization and curation filters combine with search; the exercised selections give 1,796 then 127 families, and reset restores 8,296.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "The live count shows one of 8,296 for each tested identifier/label and zero for an unmatched query.", + "note": "Matching counts change between one, zero, filtered subsets and the separate 8,296-family total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The browser offers Proteins: high to low, Proteins: low to high, Pfam accession, Family name: A to Z, Structures: high to low. Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "note": "Protein count, accession, family name and structure-count sorts change the leading family rows.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Query, seed status, characterization, curation status, sort and page are retained in the URL; the exercised combined filter state restores after reload.", + "note": "A cold URL and reload preserve search, seed, characterization, curation and sort selections; reset clears them.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "The complete index and catalogue contain 8,296 families. The browser provides numbered pagination and links individual family pages.", + "note": "The complete catalogue and family index each contain 8,296 families; the listing exposes 166 numbered pages and individual family links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Family accessions have stable families/PFxxxxx.html pages; PF04149, PF02698 and PF18141 opened successfully.", + "note": "PF04149, PF02698 and PF18141 have stable, populated families/PFxxxxx.html pages.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF18141.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled family grounding shows readable names with linked Pfam and InterPro identifiers.", + "note": "Sampled family grounding displays readable Pfam and InterPro labels with resolver links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Family views link frozen source descriptions and citations. Curated mechanism evidence is distinguished from imported descriptions and unresolved source citations.", + "note": "Sampled family pages link source descriptions and references, distinguishing imported provenance from curated functional evidence.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF02698.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Family headers and browser rows display curation status alongside seed classification and characterization tier.", + "note": "Family headers and browser rows distinguish curation status, seed status and characterization.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF18141.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "The sampled family views show retained dated curation events and reviews with attribution and outcomes.", + "note": "PF04149 displays dated, attributed curation events and retained review outcomes; uncurated samples explicitly disclose missing events.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Family pages link their individual YAML at the retained source revision, plus build-local YAML and JSON copies.", + "note": "Sampled family pages link their individual YAML at a retained source revision and offer build-local YAML/JSON copies.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "Family pages display domain tracks and causal diagrams where available; linked text and protein sequence maps provide corpus views.", + "note": "Family domain tracks and causal content accompany loaded text and sequence maps; the maps show 8,296 families and 634 proteins respectively.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled family pages link specific retained ProteinTraitsMech records, including Pfam:PF18141; the previous claim that PF18141 was outside the scan no longer applies.", + "note": "Sampled family pages link specific retained ProteinTraitsMech records, including PF04149 and PF02698.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing reports 8,296 families, 8,238 with InterPro IDs, 1,906 with structures and 8,242 with AlphaFold models; seed subsets total 1,796 EX_DUF, 373 historical DUFs and 6,127 unknown candidates.", + "note": "Landing counts show 8,296 families, 8,238 with InterPro IDs, 1,906 with structures and 8,242 with AlphaFold models.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "category_browse": { "status": "present", - "note": "The linked category index opens distinct paginated seed-status subsets.", + "note": "The category index links distinct paginated seed-status subsets: 1,796 former DUFs, 373 historical DUFs and 6,127 unknown candidates.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/categories.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links appear on the reviewed landing, families, categories, schema, sources and maps.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "downloads": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sources & schema and the catalogue link the complete index.json export containing all 8,296 families and retained provenance.", + "note": "The linked index.json export contains all 8,296 families with retained metadata and provenance; individual family exports are also linked.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/sources.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "present", - "note": "The linked schema.html guide documents family records, curation, evidence, history and enums, and provides the schema source.", + "note": "Sources links the rendered family-schema guide describing records, evidence, curation and history.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/schema.html" }, "license": { "status": "present", - "note": "Reviewed footers distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data from BSD 3-Clause code and retain third-party terms.", + "note": "Reviewed footers distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD 3-Clause code, with third-party terms retained.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/sources.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "present", - "note": "Footers identify the site build, retained corpus source revision and dated frozen upstream inputs.", + "note": "Reviewed footers identify site build c8350f3d911e6c4b, corpus source ea54567e804a and dated frozen inputs.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "present", - "note": "The System/Light/Dark selector persists Dark across the reviewed landing, families, categories, schema, sources and maps.", + "note": "The System/Light/Dark selector carries Dark through reviewed family, category, schema, source and map routes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" }, "responsive": { "status": "present", - "note": "Reviewed landing, sampled families, category index, sources, schema and maps fit 390px; wide tables scroll within their containers.", + "note": "All nine reviewed routes fit 390px on resized and fresh loads; sampled screenshots confirm readable wrapped navigation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "present", - "note": "Blocking catalogue.json visibly reports that interactive search is unavailable while retaining static rows and pagination.", + "note": "Blocked catalogue data visibly falls back to a static paginated catalogue with an unavailable-search explanation; blocked map data shows an error, and reload recovers.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" } } @@ -808,126 +808,126 @@ "HabitatMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/HabitatMech", - "deployed_revision": "6c89a863ce26add77a5b642009635af3a9580c31", + "deployed_revision": "61edb3d0ae912e8f041378e669928051fbbd509e", "features": { "search": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Browse finds ENVO:03000033 and marine sediment, but large match sets stop at 200 results without result pagination. Separate category pages remain paginated.", + "note": "Identifier ENVO:03000033 finds one habitat and marine sediment finds three. The water query reports 310 matches but exposes only 200 search results; the category listings are separate routes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "note": "The grounding filter reduces the water query from 310 to 86 matches. Keyboard activation of Reset filters restores the initial unfiltered category listing.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 3,209-record corpus.", + "note": "Counts change with identifier, label, unmatched-query and grounding-filter inputs; displayed results are distinguished from matching records when capped.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/category/aquatic.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The Browse sort control offers Assertions / Records (high–low); Assertions / Records (low–high); Name (A–Z); Name (Z–A); Grounding status (A–Z). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "note": "All five sort choices were exercised with the water query; the leading habitat changed between assertions, ascending/descending name, and grounding orders.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "note": "The identifier query restores after reload. Combined water search, grounding=EXACT and grounding sort also restore the same controls and 86 matches.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "Eight linked category indexes contain 3,209 records in total; paginated category pages expose records beyond the 200-result global search cap.", + "note": "Eight linked category indexes contain 3,209 distinct habitat slugs. Category pages expose paginated listings beyond the separate 200-result global-search cap.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "The sampled marine-sediment and aquatic-macrophyte records have stable pages with source attestations, environmental context, curation events and their own YAML links.", + "note": "Marine sediment and aquatic macrophyte-associated environment open at stable habitat URLs with source attestations, environmental context and their own YAML links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Marine sediment’s own ENVO grounding and broader habitat resolve, but its Associated taxa section still shows readable names beside unlinked NCBITaxon CURIEs. Nearby TaxonMech search links are not ontology resolver links.", + "note": "Marine sediment links its ENVO identity, while the Associated taxa section displays names and NCBITaxon CURIEs without ontology-resolver anchors. TaxonMech exploration links do not replace those resolver links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Marine-sediment causal-edge PMID citations and curation DOI references remain plain text without PubMed or DOI anchors.", + "note": "Marine-sediment mechanistic-edge PMID references and curation DOI citations are displayed as plain text rather than PubMed/DOI links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record headers display SEEDED or REVIEWED workflow status. The current landing says 1,901 of 3,209 are SEEDED and explicitly distinguishes workflow decisions from human review.", + "note": "Record views show workflow status; the landing reports 1,301 REVIEWED records and explicitly distinguishes workflow status from human review.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Marine sediment displays dated, attributed ADD_CAUSAL_GRAPH, SOURCE_SYNONYM_SCOPED, SOURCE_PARENT_EXCLUDED and UPDATE_CAUSAL_GRAPH events with change summaries.", + "note": "Marine sediment displays dated, attributed causal-graph creation/update and source-synonym/parent decisions, including the change explanations.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "The marine-sediment Provenance section links its own data/habitats/aquatic/marine_sediment.yaml file.", + "note": "The sampled marine-sediment Provenance section links its own data/habitats/aquatic/marine_sediment.yaml source file.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "The semantic text map renders 3,209 descriptions and marine sediment renders a directed SVG causal graph. The old pages/map.html route returns 404; the working route is pages/text-map/.", + "note": "The semantic text map renders the 3,209-record projection, and the marine-sediment detail displays its directed causal graph.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/text-map/" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Associated taxa now have TaxonMech search links, but they point at /TaxonMech/browse.html rather than the working /TaxonMech/pages/browse.html route. They do not resolve to specific sibling records.", + "note": "Record exploration links to TaxonMech/browse.html and TraitMech/browse.html return HTTP 404; the correct browsers live under pages/. These handoffs do not resolve to specific sibling records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing reports 3,209 habitats and generated grounding, corroboration and workflow counts; its current notice states 1,901 SEEDED records.", + "note": "The landing displays 3,209 habitats, 2,143 ontology-grounded records, 175 corroborated by at least two sources and 1,301 with REVIEWED workflow status.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" }, "category_browse": { "status": "present", - "note": "Eight named categories link to paginated subset listings, including Aquatic with 468 records and Host-associated with 1,655.", + "note": "Eight named category links lead to subset listings, including Aquatic with 468 records and Host-associated with 1,655.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "note": "All Mech projects links on the sampled templated landing, browse and record pages lead to the central suite directory, which returns HTTP 200.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Downloads & Schema links all eight category JSON indexes (3,209 rows together), the complete point projection and its manifest; these are compact indexes/projections rather than complete habitat records.", + "note": "The landing links all eight category JSON indexes and the complete semantic projection with its manifest. These retain 3,209 compact rows/points, rather than full habitat records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The landing and footers now link the annotated LinkML schema YAML and imported schemas. This is source access, not rendered schema documentation.", + "note": "Visible schema links open the annotated LinkML YAML and imported schemas. The sampled navigation supplies schema source rather than a rendered schema reference.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" }, "license": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Main templates state CC BY 4.0 data, BSD-3-Clause code and upstream terms. The linked standalone text-map-source page omits the project license statement.", + "note": "Templated pages state CC BY 4.0 data, BSD-3-Clause code and retained upstream terms, matching deployed-revision license files. The linked standalone text-map-source page omits these project licenses.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/text-map-source/index.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Main footers date upstream kg-microbe extraction (2026-08-16); the linked map manifest dates that projection. They do not identify a common dated build of the project corpus.", + "note": "Main footers date the upstream kg-microbe extraction. The linked manifest dates the semantic projection, but sampled main pages do not identify a dated build or commit of the habitat corpus.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The main Auto/Light/Dark control saves the preference across templated pages, but the linked standalone semantic map has no toggle or theme attribute and keeps its light presentation.", + "note": "Dark mode selected on the landing persists across templated pages. The linked standalone semantic map retains its light presentation without a theme control or theme attribute.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The aquatic-macrophyte record is 404px wide at a 390px viewport on fresh and resized loads. The other sampled landing, Browse, category, marine-sediment and semantic-map pages fit.", + "note": "The aquatic-macrophyte record widens the document to 404px at a 390px viewport on fresh and resized loads. The other seven sampled routes fit.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/aquatic-macrophyte-associated-environment-habitatmech-bacdive-38260eea00.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Blocking the global Browse category-index requests and searching shows Showing 0 of 0 matching habitats without explaining that data could not load. Category fallback rows remain available.", + "note": "Blocking Browse category-index requests and searching reports Showing 0 of 0 matching habitats without an error. Removing the fault and reloading restores the one matching habitat.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/category/host-associated.html" } } @@ -935,126 +935,126 @@ "MediaIngredientMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/MediaIngredientMech", - "deployed_revision": "e1f6497c50507d667ca528cd372658e4152aa2c1", + "deployed_revision": "fa7e877c42b87a641990c304a2ead008fb93065e", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "UNMAPPED_0196 and table salt each return one linked ingredient; CHEBI:63895 returns two of the 2,956 records.", + "note": "UNMAPPED_0196 and table salt each return one linked ingredient; CHEBI:63895 returns two from 2,956.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Mapping status, ontology source and mapping quality filters combine with search. AMBIGUOUS gives one record; Clear search and filters restores all 2,956.", + "note": "Status, ontology source and mapping quality combine with search; AMBIGUOUS selects one record and reset restores all 2,956.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "Showing N of 2956 ingredients changes to one for UNMAPPED_0196, two for CHEBI:63895 and zero for an unmatched query.", + "note": "The matching count changes to one, two, zero and filtered subsets separately from the 2,956-ingredient total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The browser offers Default Order, Name (A → Z), Name (Z → A), Media Count (Most → Least), Occurrences (Most → Least), Synonyms (Most → Least). Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "note": "Name ascending/descending, media count, occurrence count and synonym count reorder the leading records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Search, status, source, quality and sort values are encoded in query parameters and restore with the same matching count after reload.", + "note": "Cold URL navigation and reload preserve the exercised query, mapping status, source, quality and sort selections.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "The complete browser and its machine-readable export cover 2,956 published records; sampled record links open successfully.", + "note": "The browser, record index and linked data/ingredients.json cover 2,956 ingredients with individual record links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Mapped, rejected and unmapped ingredients have stable record URLs; sampled NaCl, GYPS and glucose pages open with mapping, evidence and history sections.", + "note": "NaCl, GYPS and rejected glucose have stable, populated individual record pages with mapping, evidence and history.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled ingredient groundings display names with resolver links for ontology terms and component identities; local registry identities can remain plain text.", + "note": "Sampled grounding and component sections show readable labels beside ontology resolver links; local registry identities remain literal identifiers.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" }, "evidence": { - "status": "present", - "note": "NaCl and GYPS expose linked PMID, DOI and source-URL references in their evidence sections.", + "status": "partial", + "note": "PMID and DOI links work in sampled sections, but GYPS material-component evidence leaves Bergey doi:10.1002/9781118960608.gbm00618 as plain text (existing issue 888).", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/GYPS.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record headers state mapping status and quality. Runtime metadata reports 2,611 MAPPED, 262 UNMAPPED, 82 REJECTED and one AMBIGUOUS ingredient.", + "note": "Record headers expose mapping status and quality; runtime metadata distinguishes 2,611 MAPPED, 262 UNMAPPED, 82 REJECTED and one AMBIGUOUS record.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Glucose_2.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled ingredient pages show Curation history tables with timestamp, curator, action and change details.", + "note": "Sampled records show dated curation events with curator, action, resulting status and change details.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Sampled record footers name data/ingredients/...yaml as plain text; their anchors do not link that individual YAML source.", + "note": "Sampled record footers name individual data/ingredients YAML paths but do not link those files.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "Text and chemical embedding maps render, and sampled records display role/partonomy diagrams. Embedding coverage is separate from the 2,956-record catalogue total.", + "note": "The text and KG embedding views load 2,872 and 2,337 plotted ingredients; these are explicit subsets of the 2,956-record catalogue.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/ingredient_umap.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "GYPS links CultureMech:002799 to its individual normalized recipe from the related-recipe and comparison-evidence sections.", + "note": "GYPS links CultureMech:002799 directly to the corresponding normalized recipe.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/GYPS.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "Runtime landing tiles show 2,956 ingredients, 2,611 mapped and 88% coverage; the linked catalogue metadata distinguishes all four mapping statuses.", + "note": "Landing tiles show 2,956 ingredients, 2,611 mapped and 88% coverage, matching runtime catalogue metadata.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" }, "category_browse": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The record index has identifier-prefix sections, while the main browser offers property filters; these do not form standalone category pages.", + "note": "Identifier-prefix sections and browser facets expose subsets without standalone linked category pages.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links appear on reviewed landing, browser, records, maps and schema routes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The landing links catalogue JSON and CSV covering all 2,956 ingredients, but they contain mapping/search fields rather than complete records with components, evidence and history.", + "note": "Linked catalogue JSON/CSV covers all 2,956 ingredients but contains search/mapping fields, not complete evidence, component and history records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "present", - "note": "The visible schema reference links rendered class, slot, enum and type documentation, including schema/classes-IngredientRecord.html.", + "note": "The visible schema index links rendered class, slot, enum and type documentation, including IngredientRecord.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/schema/index.html" }, "license": { - "status": "present", - "note": "The landing and sampled record footers distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data from BSD-3-Clause code.", + "status": "partial", + "note": "Landing and sampled record pages distinguish CC BY 4.0 data and BSD-3-Clause code, but browser, maps and schema pages omit these statements; the record index states only CC BY 4.0.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "present", - "note": "Generated timestamps and a linked build receipt identify the current record build, including NaCl at 2026-11-08T23:01:00+00:00.", + "note": "The record index and individual records display generated timestamps on 2026-11-17 and link a SHA-256 build receipt.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "present", - "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries across the browser, record index, sampled ingredients, maps and schema documentation.", + "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries through the reviewed browser, record index, ingredients, maps and schema documentation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" }, "responsive": { "status": "present", - "note": "The reviewed landing, browser, record index, ingredient pages, maps and valid schema pages fit a 390px viewport.", + "note": "Reviewed landing, browser, record index, ingredient pages, maps and schema documentation fit 390px on fresh and resized loads.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "present", - "note": "Blocking the catalogue request displays unavailable counters, Ingredients could not be loaded and a retry control.", + "note": "Blocking catalogue or KG-map JSON displays an explicit error with retry; ordinary reload after unblocking restores data.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" } } @@ -1062,126 +1062,126 @@ "NaturalProductMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/NaturalProductMech", - "deployed_revision": "6226602895d4d2e598dc70e281d43027f1c89471", + "deployed_revision": "bb763332f46c3d041b4481ad2ec642a3ea4475a3", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse searches by identifier and label. CHEBI:338412: 1 of 3136 compounds match; marneral: 1 of 3136 compounds match.", + "note": "CHEBI:338412 and marneral each find one linked compound from the full 3,136-record catalogue.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "note": "Filing-pathway and claim filters combine with search; alkaloids selects 512, adding causal-producer coverage gives 141, and reset restores 3,136.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 3,136-record corpus.", + "note": "Matching counts update for identifiers, labels, zero-match input and property filters, separately from 3,136 total compounds.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The Browse sort control offers Compound name (A–Z); Compound name (Z–A); Causal producers (high–low); Gene clusters (high–low); Bioactivities (high–low); Identifier (A–Z). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "note": "All six options change leading linked records: name ascending/descending, causal producers, gene clusters, bioactivities and identifier.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "note": "Cold navigation and reload restore the exercised query, pathway, claim and sort controls with the same matching count.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse exposes the complete 3,136-compound catalogue across eight filing pathways, matching the landing and chemical-map record count.", + "note": "Browse contains 3,136 unique individual compound links, matching the displayed corpus total and complete chemical-map export.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled natural products have stable compound URLs with structure, producers, occurrence evidence, biosynthetic loci, provenance and cross-fleet exploration links.", + "note": "Four sampled compound URLs open populated structure, producer, occurrence, biosynthetic and provenance sections.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Anisomycin and rebeccamycin display chemical, taxon, MIBiG and GenBank identifiers, but the main producer and biosynthetic sections leave their resolver links absent.", + "note": "Sampled producer and biosynthetic sections display taxon, MIBiG and GenBank identifiers as plain text rather than labeled resolver links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/rebeccamycin.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Anisomycin’s producer PMID:28373542 and occurrence DOI references remain plain text without PubMed or DOI anchors.", + "note": "Anisomycin’s PMID:28373542 and occurrence DOI references remain plain text, with no PubMed or DOI anchors.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Compound headers display grounding and SEEDED workflow tags with a What these status tags mean explanation.", + "note": "Sampled compound headers display grounding and SEEDED workflow tags with an explanatory disclosure.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "missing", - "note": "The sampled compound record views do not show dated, attributed curation events. Source/history links and mechanism summaries do not constitute a displayed event history.", + "note": "Sampled compound pages expose source/provenance links but do not display dated, attributed curation events.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/staurosporine-2.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Each sampled Provenance section links its own data/natural_products YAML on GitHub.", + "note": "Each sampled Provenance section links its individual data/natural_products YAML source.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "The chemical structure map renders 3,136 compounds, the text map covers a retained 3,114-compound projection, and the sequence map renders 763 proteins across 303 records. Sampled records also show a mechanism/biosynthesis summary diagram.", + "note": "Loaded chemical, text and sequence maps show 3,136 compounds, 3,114 retained text points and 763 proteins respectively; coverage scopes are disclosed.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/chemical-map.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Anisomycin links CHEBI:338412 directly to AntibioticMech’s anisomycin record with a same-structure/same-InChIKey qualifier; that target returns HTTP 200.", + "note": "Anisomycin directly links the specific CHEBI:338412 AntibioticMech compound page with a same-structure qualifier.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing reports a 3,136-compound corpus with generated source, producer, occurrence and causal-graph counts.", + "note": "The landing displays 3,136 compounds and generated source, producer, occurrence and causal-graph counts.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" }, "category_browse": { "status": "present", - "note": "Eight filing-pathway cards open category indexes. The checked Terpenoids page shows all 213 compounds.", + "note": "Eight filing-pathway cards link subset indexes; the Terpenoids page opens its 213-compound listing.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links appear on reviewed landing, browse, category, compounds and map pages.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The landing links chemical-map coordinates for all 3,136 compounds, the complete chemical-search index and a 763-protein map export. These are indexes/projections rather than complete source-record exports.", + "note": "Linked exports cover all 3,136 chemical-map entries, chemical-search values and 763 sequence-map proteins, but omit complete source-record evidence.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Downloads & Schema now links the LinkML YAML source. Reviewed navigation does not link rendered schema documentation or an explanatory schema guide.", + "note": "Downloads & Schema links the raw LinkML YAML source; reviewed navigation does not link rendered documentation or a schema guide.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" }, "license": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with upstream terms retained, consistent with the pinned license files.", + "note": "Reviewed generated footers distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code with upstream terms retained, matching repository licenses.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The footer states 3,136 records and corpus SHA-256 2838a2004e52, but its date is source retrieval (2026-10-31), not a dated build of the project corpus.", + "note": "The footer gives 3,136 records and corpus digest 2838a2004e52, but its dated source retrieval is upstream provenance rather than a dated project build.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "present", - "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries across reviewed browse, category, compound and map routes.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "partial", - "note": "At 390px the sampled compound pages overflow: anisomycin 409px, rebeccamycin 407px, staurosporine 415px and the long dehydrohistidyltryptophanyldiketopiperazine page 464px, on fresh and resized loads. Browse, category and maps fit.", + "note": "At 390px, anisomycin, rebeccamycin, staurosporine and the long diketopiperazine page overflow to 409, 407, 415 and 464px respectively on fresh/resized loads; browse/category/maps fit.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/dehydrohistidyltryptophanyldiketopiperazine.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Chemical-map JSON failures display an explicit error. After sequence-map JSON fails, using search replaces its error with Showing 0 of 0 proteins and no unavailable-data explanation.", + "note": "Blocked map JSON initially shows an explicit error, but typing in the failed sequence-map search replaces it with Showing 0 of 0 proteins; reload after unblocking recovers.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/chemical-map.html" } } @@ -1189,126 +1189,126 @@ "PathwayMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/PathwayMech", - "deployed_revision": "3a407d22ff5d578869af286a42b13be7d9dcf67a", + "deployed_revision": "d2f73822d650851193ce541d68c8ebd8ffac4907", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse searches by identifier and label. MetaCyc:PWY-6543: 1 of 282 pathways match; trehalose: 3 of 282 pathways match.", + "note": "MetaCyc:PWY-6543 finds one pathway and trehalose finds three of the 283 published pathways; all matches have directly reachable record links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 282-record corpus.", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The Browse sort control offers Pathway name (A–Z); Pathway name (Z–A); Mechanistic edges (high–low); Mechanistic edges (low–high); Identifier (A–Z); Pathway class (A–Z). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "note": "The query and exercised facet/sort state survive URL reload with the same controls and matching counts.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html?q=glycolysis" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse exposes all 282 stable pathway links, matching the landing and the 282-record downloadable pathway index.", + "note": "Browse contains 283 distinct stable record links, matching the complete downloadable index with 283 distinct identifiers and detail URLs.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled MetaCyc, GO and WikiPathways records have stable pages with organism scope, participants, mechanistic edges, evidence, curation history and their own YAML links.", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Organism-scope taxa are labeled and linked, but the main component and mechanistic-edge tables still display chemical, protein and reaction CURIEs without resolver links.", + "note": "Organism-scope taxa are labeled and linked, but the main component and mechanistic-edge tables display chemical, protein and reaction identifiers without resolver anchors.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled mechanistic edges link Rhea and PubMed references and source locations, separating source assertions from quotations.", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "missing", - "note": "Sampled pathway pages show pathway type and editing history but no record-level curation or review status.", + "note": "The sampled MetaCyc, GO and actinorhodin pathway pages display pathway type and curation history, but no overall record curation/review status.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled pathway pages show dated curator actions, change summaries and retained curation-session links, including current November edits.", + "note": "Sampled record views display dated curator actions and change summaries.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/GO_0036040.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Read the source YAML links sampled records to their own data/pathways file in GitHub.", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "Pathway pages render directed SVG networks with node selection and zoom controls. The text map renders 270 pathways and the sequence map 216 pathway centroids; the current corpus has 282 records.", + "note": "Populated pathway pages render directed SVG networks. The text map renders 270 pathways and the sequence map 216 pathway centroids; both are subsets of the current 283-record corpus.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "missing", - "note": "The sampled MetaCyc, GO and WikiPathways pages offer suite navigation and external authority links, but no direct links to specific sibling-Mech or kg-microbe records.", + "note": "The sampled MetaCyc, GO and actinorhodin pages provide suite navigation and external source-authority links, but no direct links to specific sibling-Mech or kg-microbe records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing reports 282 pathway records, 105 taxa, 14,838 mechanistic edges and 5,922 distinct references.", + "note": "The landing reports 283 pathway records, 105 taxa, 14,841 mechanistic edges and 5,927 distinct references.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" }, "category_browse": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The current Browse exposes subset filters, but sampled navigation does not link the previously claimed 15 standalone category pages. Its Pathway type options include edge-count strings, which need separate site correction.", + "note": "Subset selection is provided by Browse filters; sampled navigation does not expose standalone class pages. The Pathway class selector currently labels classes using mechanistic-edge counts.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" }, "downloads": { "status": "present", - "note": "Landing links KGX node and edge TSV exports plus the complete 282-record pathway index. These and the version/checksum manifest return HTTP 200; the manifest reports 5,472 nodes and 14,838 edges.", + "note": "The landing links KGX node/edge TSV exports and a complete 283-record pathway index. All downloads succeed; the checksum manifest identifies 5,476 nodes and 14,841 edges.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The current landing links LinkML YAML sources. The formerly claimed pages/schema.html returns HTTP 404; no rendered schema reference was linked.", + "note": "Sampled navigation links the annotated LinkML YAML source, rather than a rendered schema reference.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" }, "license": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The landing states CC BY 4.0 data and upstream terms, but does not state a code license; sampled record and browse pages omit the data/code license statement.", + "note": "The landing states CC BY 4.0 data and retained upstream terms, but does not state the code license. Sampled browse and record views omit the data/code license statement.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Landing displays an undated graph-content hash. No site build date, displayed commit or dated project-corpus version is shown on sampled pages.", + "note": "Sampled pages show an undated corpus digest or upstream-source dates, without a build date, displayed commit or dated version of the project corpus.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" }, "theme_toggle": { - "status": "present", - "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "status": "partial", + "note": "The manual dark choice persists in storage and the theme attribute, but the body remains light under a light OS preference. Manual rules update different CSS variables from those used by body text/background, producing mixed light and dark regions across the sampled pages.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "present", - "note": "All sampled live routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; wide content stays within its own region.", + "note": "All sampled routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; retained states record document widths for every route.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "not_applicable", - "note": "The sampled landing, Browse, record, text-map and sequence-map pages embed their data and issue no data fetch/XHR requests, so the data-request failure criterion does not apply.", + "note": "The eight sampled landing, browse, record, text-map and sequence-map routes embed their data; no fetch/XHR data request was observed. Blocking those request types while searching intercepted nothing.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" } } @@ -1320,122 +1320,122 @@ "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "Searching cd05137 returns one linked record; homogentisate 1,2-dioxygenase returns 16 after the relevant shards finish loading.", + "note": "After record shards load, cd05137 returns one linked record and homogentisate 1,2-dioxygenase returns 16 from the 429,421-record corpus.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Axis, source, category and status facets combine with text search. Selecting active sites gives 1,004 records and adding racemase gives nine; controls provide a facet reset.", + "note": "Axis, source, category and status facets combine with search. Active-site category plus racemase gives nine; Clear all resets the facet controls.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "Matching results are shown separately from the 429,421-record total; the active-site category plus racemase gives nine and an unmatched query gives zero.", + "note": "Matching counts change for identifier/label queries, zero-match input and active-site filters, separately from the 429,421-record total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The browser offers Identifier (A–Z), Label (A–Z), Label (Z–A), Axis & category, Source. Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "note": "Identifier, label ascending/descending, axis/category and source options reorder populated search results.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "A cold #cat=STRUCT_ACTIVE_SITE&q=racemase URL and its reload restore the category and search with nine matching records.", + "note": "A cold cat=STRUCT_ACTIVE_SITE&q=racemase hash route and reload restore the category, search and nine matches.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#cat=STRUCT_ACTIVE_SITE&sta=REVIEWED" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "The facet manifest totals 429,421 records in 73 shards; selecting all five axes exposes the full count through paginated results.", + "note": "The manifest totals 429,421 records across 73 shards; selecting all five axes loads the complete total into paginated results.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Cold browse.html#record=CURIE routes open individual record details, including MCSA:1, METPO:1000639 and ECOD:F.3755.3.1.364.", + "note": "Cold record hash routes open populated MCSA:1, METPO:1000639 and ECOD:F.3755.3.1.364 details; explicit waits exclude loading shells.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" }, "term_links": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Labeled ontology and internal record links are available, but some primary identifiers such as ECOD:F.3755.3.1.364 explicitly lack a source-entry resolver.", + "note": "Record details show labeled ontology/internal links, but the ECOD record explicitly states that its source-entry resolver is unavailable.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=ECOD%3AF.3755.3.1.364" }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Reference-bearing record details link PMID and DOI evidence separately from database-source links.", + "note": "Populated MCSA, METPO and ECOD details link PMID evidence; MCSA notes and causal evidence are separately displayed from database sources.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record details and status facets expose SEEDED, PROPOSED and REVIEWED workflow states; the runtime manifest has 39,591 REVIEWED records.", + "note": "Details and status facets expose SEEDED, PROPOSED and REVIEWED states; the manifest reports 39,591 REVIEWED records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record details show dated curation actions, curators and change summaries, including the MCSA:1 curation event.", + "note": "Populated MCSA:1 details show the dated edison-causal-graphs event, action and change summary.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record detail views link the record’s individual YAML path on GitHub, separately from external database-entry links.", + "note": "Populated record details link their individual repository YAML source files.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record views provide sequences, annotations and causal diagrams where available. The corpus map covers 344,797 current records; protein and sequence maps show 68,657 and 12,705 proteins.", + "note": "Loaded corpus, protein and sequence maps accompany record annotations/causal content. The corpus map explicitly covers 344,797 of 429,421 current records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "missing", - "note": "Checked record views link external databases and other ProteinTraitsMech records; their main sections do not link specific sibling-Mech or kg-microbe records.", + "note": "Sampled populated details link external databases and internal traits rather than specific sibling-Mech records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=METPO%3A1000639" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "Runtime statistics show 429,421 records: 118,338 structure, 147,149 sequence, 392 sequence/structure, 163,527 function and 15 evolution, across 63 categories and 34 source labels.", + "note": "The landing/manifest report 429,421 records across five axes, 63 categories and 34 source labels.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" }, "category_browse": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Landing axis/category/source links select filters in the common browser rather than standalone category pages.", + "note": "Landing axis/category/source links lead to filters in the common browser rather than standalone category pages.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "note": "Visible suite-directory links appear on the reviewed landing, browser, populated records, schema and maps.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The browser links facet counts and listing shards for all 429,421 records; complete detail is fetched per record, and map CSVs contain plotted points rather than the full corpus records.", + "note": "Linked facet counts and listing shards cover the catalogue, while complete details load per record; map CSV exports contain plotted points rather than full corpus records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "present", - "note": "The linked schema guide explains ProteinTraitRecord, enums and causal graph fields and links its LinkML source.", + "note": "The linked schema guide explains ProteinTraitRecord, enumerations and causal graph fields and links LinkML source.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/schema.html" }, "license": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Core pages and maps distinguish CC BY 4.0 data from BSD-3-Clause code. The linked SLC10 pilot does not state both project licenses.", + "note": "Core pages and maps distinguish CC BY 4.0 data and BSD-3-Clause code; the linked SLC10 pilot omits the two project-license statements.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/slc10.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Core pages show upstream releases and retained map coverage but no site build date or deployed revision; the embedding date is explicitly unrecorded.", + "note": "Core pages expose upstream releases and retained map coverage but no site build date or deployment revision; the embedding date is explicitly unrecorded.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The injected Browse toggle works, but the landing’s existing empty theme button does not respond. The linked SLC10 pilot has no theme toggle.", + "note": "Browse toggles and carries Dark, but clicking the landing’s existing theme button does not change its saved Dark state; SLC10 ignores that choice.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/slc10.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Core sampled routes fit 390px, but expanding all 63 category values widens the document to 400px.", + "note": "Sampled core and populated record routes fit 390px; expanding all 63 category values widens the document to 400px.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "present", - "note": "Blocked catalogue requests produce an explicit index-load failure; map requests display unavailable/error states instead of presenting zero coverage.", + "note": "Blocked facet/map requests show explicit failures and retry controls; unblocking and reloading restores populated content.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" } } @@ -1443,126 +1443,126 @@ "TaxonMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/TaxonMech", - "deployed_revision": "6a86624b7ba126a5982b758431b9804cf0ffb395", + "deployed_revision": "112cd752949da0fbb18cdfdeb1663b5dc5514c8f", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse searches by identifier and label. NCBITaxon:2173: 32 of 626048 records match · page 1 of 1.; Methanobrevibacter smithii: 26 of 626048 records match · page 1 of 1.; NCBITaxon:562: 259 of 626048 records match · page 1 of 2..", + "note": "NCBITaxon:2173 returns 32 matches and Methanobrevibacter smithii returns 26. NCBITaxon:562 returns 259 matches across two pages; the browser provides result pagination.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 626,048-record corpus.", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The Browse sort control offers Default (corpus order); Taxon name (A–Z); Taxon name (Z–A); NCBI ID (numeric); Taxonomic rank; BacDive strains (high–low); GTDB mappings (high–low); Attesting sources (high–low). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Search and sort restore from the URL, but changing domain to Bacteria and rank to species does not encode those filters. Reload changes 553,073 matches back to all 626,048.", + "note": "Search and sort restore, but domain/rank/source selectors are not retained in the URL. Reload changes the exercised 553,073-match filter selection back to all 626,048 records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "The browser covers 626,048 records across 3,131 pages; Next was exercised to page 2. Domain and type-strain subsets provide additional entry points.", + "note": "The complete published index contains 626,048 unique identifiers and 626,048 unique taxon detail routes. Browse exposes 3,131 pages; clicking Next successfully opens page 2.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Stable taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:N routes open individual records, including Methanobrevibacter smithii and Escherichia coli, with paged strain details.", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" }, "term_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled taxonomy sections show named NCBI lineage terms and resolver links for NCBI identifiers, LPSN entries and GTDB names.", + "note": "The sampled Methanobrevibacter record displays labeled NCBI lineage and organism identifiers, LPSN links and GTDB mappings with resolver anchors.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Methanobrevibacter smithii links its LPSN DOI references and PMID:390357; strain details retain source links.", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled record headers and browse rows display SEEDED workflow status; the browser also exposes its Deprecated filter.", + "note": "Sampled record headers show the workflow status, separately from dated curation events.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:81464" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Methanobrevibacter smithii shows a dated seed_from_sources event with curator, action, source list and change summary.", + "note": "Sampled record views display dated curator actions and change summaries.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled taxon views link their own data/taxa YAML in the repository.", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:562" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record pages show labeled, linked taxonomy lineages. The separate corpus map renders 31,258 embedded taxa; it is a subset of the 626,048-record corpus.", + "note": "Sampled records show named taxonomic lineages. The text embedding map renders 31,258 embedded taxa, explicitly a subset of the 626,048-record corpus.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Sampled details retain kgmicrobe.strain identifiers as plain text. Suite and exploratory links do not provide direct links for those named cross-Mech records.", + "note": "Record exploration links include CommunityMech search, but the sampled CultureMech, HabitatMech, PathwayMech and NaturalProductMech browser handoffs use missing routes and return HTTP 404.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing shows 626,048 taxa, 100,745 distinct strains and 20,648 taxa with a type strain. The live Archaea subset now contains 14,013 records.", + "note": "The landing displays 626,048 taxa, 100,745 distinct strains and 20,648 taxa with a type strain. The opened Archaea listing contains 14,013 taxa.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" }, "category_browse": { "status": "present", - "note": "Landing links domain and type-strain listings. Archaea shows 14,013 records and the type-strain subset 20,648, with pagination.", + "note": "Linked domain and type-strain pages provide paginated subsets; the opened Archaea and type-strain listings contain 14,013 and 20,648 records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The linked index.json.gz contains 626,048 catalogue rows, and its manifest records format and checksum. It is a browse index rather than full taxon records; individual pages link YAML, but no bulk complete-record export was linked.", + "note": "The linked compressed index contains all 626,048 catalogue rows and detail routes, with a separate format/checksum manifest. It is an index, rather than a bulk export of complete taxon records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Visible Schema and LinkML schema links now open the annotated YAML source, while reviewed navigation lacks rendered schema documentation.", + "note": "Visible schema links identify annotated LinkML YAML, verified through the GitHub API at the deployed revision after the web UI rate-limited a request. Sampled navigation does not expose a rendered schema reference.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" }, "license": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with upstream terms retained, consistent with the pinned license files.", + "note": "Sampled pages distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data, BSD-3-Clause code and retained upstream terms, consistent with license files read at the deployed revision.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "partial", - "note": "The footer now identifies corpus digest 959c8dfd8771 and 626,048 records, but provides no own build date or commit. Sources dates describe upstream snapshots.", + "note": "Sampled pages show an undated corpus digest or upstream-source dates, without a build date, displayed commit or dated version of the project corpus.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "present", - "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "note": "Dark mode chosen on the landing persists across the sampled browser, record and visualization pages in the same browser context.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "present", - "note": "All sampled live routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; wide content stays within its own region.", + "note": "All sampled routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; retained states record document widths for every route.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "present", - "note": "Blocking the search index preserves static pagination and says Search is unavailable. Blocked detail shards and corpus-map data display explicit load errors.", + "note": "Blocked search indexes report Search is unavailable while preserving static pagination. Blocked taxon-detail shards and embedding-map data show explicit load errors; removing each fault and reloading restores populated content.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" } } @@ -1570,7 +1570,7 @@ "TraitMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/TraitMech", - "deployed_revision": "69d6c885a535d38c29cd8365cd8b5cb91ba491fb", + "deployed_revision": "1db07d7456e55572546e2215fed19b0b870f911b", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", @@ -1599,12 +1599,12 @@ }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse exposes 1,130 distinct record links, matching the landing total and all 1,130 record HTML paths at the pin.", + "note": "Browse exposes 1,130 distinct record links, matching the landing, bulk export and all 1,130 canonical records and record HTML paths in the untruncated deployed-revision inventory.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "All 1,130 traits have static pages under pages/traits//.html. Sampled pages show overview, grounding, curation and source sections; 769 source records carry causal graphs.", + "note": "All 1,130 traits have static pages under pages/traits//.html. Sampled animal pathogen, aerobic respiration and Wood–Ljungdahl pages show populated overview, grounding, curation and source sections.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/traits/ecology/animal_pathogen.html" }, "term_links": { @@ -1619,7 +1619,7 @@ }, "review_status": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record headers and Identifier cards show workflow status, including REVIEWED on animal pathogen; the complete corpus retains all four mapping statuses.", + "note": "Sampled record headers and Identifier cards show the record workflow status, including REVIEWED on animal pathogen. This is distinct from a claim that all records were manually reviewed.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/traits/ecology/animal_pathogen.html" }, "curation_history": { @@ -1634,7 +1634,7 @@ }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled record pages render causal SVG diagrams; 769 source records carry causal graphs. PaCMAP, text and graph-layout maps each render 1,130 traits, and the sequence map renders 156 associated proteins. These source counts do not imply that every graph was visually inspected.", + "note": "Sampled record pages render causal SVG diagrams. PaCMAP, text and graph-layout maps each render 1,130 traits, and the sequence map renders 156 associated proteins; these are separately labeled views.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/umap.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { @@ -1659,7 +1659,7 @@ }, "downloads": { "status": "present", - "note": "The site links Download traits.json, a complete 1,130-record bulk JSON export. Downloaded map exports contain 1,130 traits or 156 proteins as labeled.", + "note": "Download traits.json provides 1,130 full records, including definitions, evidence, causal graphs and curation history. Downloaded map exports contain 1,130 traits or 156 proteins as labeled.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/index.html" }, "schema_docs": { @@ -1668,8 +1668,8 @@ "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/index.html" }, "license": { - "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled page footers state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with third-party source terms retained; these match the pinned license files.", + "status": "partial", + "note": "Templated landing, Browse, record and map pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with third-party terms retained. The linked discussions index omits these licence notices and links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/index.html" }, "build_provenance": { @@ -1689,7 +1689,7 @@ }, "load_failure": { "status": "present", - "note": "Aborted JSON requests produce explicit map failure messages and Retry; retry after restoring requests recovers 1,130 traits or 156 proteins. Aborting discussion data produces Discussion counts unavailable and a retry prompt.", + "note": "Aborted JSON requests produce explicit map failure messages and Retry; retry after restoring requests recovers 1,130 traits or 156 proteins. Aborting discussion data shows Discussions could not be loaded; reload after restoring requests recovers 925 discussions.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/umap.html" } } @@ -1697,126 +1697,126 @@ "CMMMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CMMMech", - "deployed_revision": "4bdd13ae94fd62127aa6ed0d61a164f175fc4461", + "deployed_revision": "b4266e6202ce391f5e96ba7e11662ae3e53469c1", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "CHEBI:27638 and cmmmech:copper each return one linked material; Cobalt returns 23 of 708.", + "note": "CHEBI:27638 returns one linked cobalt record and Cobalt returns 24 of the current 713 materials.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Kind, mechanism process and criticality filters have Clear filters. Element selects 66 records; adding bioleaching selects 15; reset restores all 708.", + "note": "Kind, mechanism and criticality filters combine with search; elements give 66, adding bioleaching gives 15, and reset restores 713.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "The count updates to one for identifier searches, 23 for Cobalt, 15 for bioleaching elements and zero for an unmatched query.", + "note": "Matching counts update for identifier, label, unmatched query and property filters separately from 713 total materials.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The browser offers Material name (A–Z), Material name (Z–A), Mechanisms (high–low), Microbial agents (high–low), Material kind (A–Z), Criticality (critical first). Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "note": "Name, mechanism count, organism count, kind and criticality sorts reorder the visible material cards.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Cobalt with element, bioleaching, criticality and sort selections reloads from its URL with all controls restored and one matching record.", + "note": "Cold navigation and reload restore the combined Cobalt query, element/bioleaching/criticality facets and sort with one match.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "The complete browser and its machine-readable export cover 708 published records; sampled record links open successfully.", + "note": "Browse and linked index.json cover 713 materials; record cards link individual pages and kind listings expose subsets.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse and kind/process listings link stable materials/.html pages; cobalt and akaganeite opened successfully.", + "note": "Cobalt and akaganeite open stable, populated materials/.html pages with mechanisms, references and curation history.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" }, "term_links": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled material identifiers and mechanism terms show readable labels with ChEBI, taxon and protein/ontology resolver links.", + "note": "Sampled material identities and mechanism terms display readable labels with chemical, taxon and protein resolver links.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled references link DOI or source URLs, and mechanism evidence points to the corresponding references.", + "note": "Sampled reference sections link DOI/source URLs and mechanism evidence points to those reference records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" }, "review_status": { "status": "missing", - "note": "Record headers show material kind and criticality; these and individual evidence labels do not state overall review status.", + "note": "Record headings show material kind and criticality, but do not display an overall record-review status.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" }, "curation_history": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled records include Curation History tables with timestamp, curator, action and summary.", + "note": "Sampled material pages display Curation History tables with timestamps, curators, actions and summaries.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" }, "source_link": { "status": "present", - "note": "Record source lines link the individual data/records YAML on GitHub.", + "note": "Sampled source lines link each record’s individual data/records YAML on GitHub.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "The mechanism graph renders 654 nodes and 972 edges; the text map retains 602 material points, a subset of the 708-record catalogue.", + "note": "The linked mechanism network and retained material embedding map render with populated counts; records include causal content where supplied.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/graph.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { "status": "missing", - "note": "Record sections provide cross-Mech search links and site navigation, but the sampled pages do not link specific sibling records.", + "note": "Sampled records expose sibling-site navigation and searches but do not link specific sibling records in their main sections.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing reports 708 materials, 609 mechanisms, 500 materials with mechanisms and 90 designated critical materials across six kinds.", + "note": "The landing now reports 713 materials and 609 mechanisms, with generated material-kind and criticality counts.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" }, "category_browse": { "status": "present", - "note": "Landing cards link six material-kind and process listings. Kind totals are 66 elements, 457 minerals, 111 secondary resources, 36 commodities, 31 primary resources and seven mineral groups.", + "note": "Landing cards link material-kind and process subset pages; the Minerals listing opens populated records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/kinds/mineral.html" }, "suite_nav": { "status": "present", - "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links appear on reviewed landing, browse, kind, record and visualization pages.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Linked index.json covers all 708 catalogue entries but contains listing metadata and mechanism counts, not full mechanism evidence; map exports and individual YAML links are also available.", + "note": "Linked index.json contains all 713 listing summaries and mechanism counts; full mechanism evidence remains in per-record source files.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" }, "schema_docs": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Visible schema links open the LinkML YAML source. The previously recorded pages/schema.html documentation URL returns 404.", + "note": "Visible schema links open LinkML YAML source; pages/schema.html still returns 404 rather than rendered schema documentation.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" }, "license": { "status": "present", - "note": "Reviewed footers separately state CC BY 4.0 data and BSD-3-Clause code, consistent with the repository license policy.", + "note": "Reviewed generated footers separately state CC BY 4.0 data and BSD-3-Clause code, consistent with repository license files.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" }, "build_provenance": { "status": "present", - "note": "Footers state 708 materials, 609 mechanisms, latest curation 2026-11-10 and corpus digest e5bc8a7270d8.", + "note": "Generated footers identify 713 materials, 609 mechanisms, latest curation 2026-11-11 and corpus digest ca4e8e5f93ec.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" }, "theme_toggle": { "status": "present", - "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries to Browse, kind, record, text-map and graph pages.", + "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries to browse, kind, record, map and graph pages.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" }, "responsive": { "status": "partial", - "note": "At 390px, cobalt widens the document to 597px and akaganeite to 669px. The ten newly curated records reach 652–669px, including copper at 652px, on fresh and resized views.", + "note": "At 390px cobalt and akaganeite widen the document to 597px and 669px respectively on fresh and resized loads; main listing/maps fit.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" }, "load_failure": { "status": "not_applicable", - "note": "Reviewed listings, records and canvas visualizations embed their data; no fetch/XHR data request was observed to abort.", + "note": "Reviewed listings, records and visualizations embed their data; no fetch/XHR catalogue dependency was observed.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" } } @@ -1824,41 +1824,41 @@ "AIMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/AIMech", - "deployed_revision": "78dcdfa7ff0b44ceb19c929e657ee630aea423e0", + "deployed_revision": "2d9910fad1acb4a193122b9418d910a8a72f7b8a", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", - "note": "AIMech:KernelPCA returns one linked concept and Adam returns 131 matches across the 1,929-record catalogue.", + "note": "AIMech:KernelPCA returns one linked concept, Adam returns 131 matches and SoftDTW returns one across the 1,930-record catalogue. Literal-markup and unmatched queries return zero.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" }, "facets": { "status": "present", - "note": "Origin, concept kind and AIO branch filters have Reset. Curated selects 1,487 records and curated algorithms 1,047; Reset restores all 1,929.", + "note": "Origin, concept kind and AIO branch filters have Reset. Curated selects 1,488 records, algorithm selects 1,047 and Layer selects 168. Combining attention, Curated and architecture selects 48; Reset restores 1,930.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" }, "result_counts": { "status": "present", - "note": "The matching count changes to one for AIMech:KernelPCA, 131 for Adam and zero for an unmatched query, separately from the 1,929 total.", + "note": "The matching count changes to one for AIMech:KernelPCA, 131 for Adam and zero for an unmatched query, separately from the 1,930 total.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" }, "sorting": { "status": "present", - "note": "The browser offers Concept name (A–Z), Concept name (Z–A), Curated claims (high–low), Evidence sources (high–low), Origin (Curated first), Identifier (A–Z). Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "note": "The browser offers six sort choices. Exercised name ascending, name descending and identifier ascending choices update the selected ordering and result rows.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" }, "shareable_state": { "status": "present", - "note": "Search, origin, kind, branch and sort are encoded in the URL; reload restores the exercised values and matching count.", + "note": "Search, origin, kind, branch and sort controls encode their state in the URL. A cold load of the combined attention, Curated and architecture query restores the controls and 48 matches.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html?q=attention&origin=curated&kind=architecture" }, "full_catalogue": { "status": "present", - "note": "The complete browser and its machine-readable export cover 1,929 published records; sampled record links open successfully.", + "note": "The complete browser and downloaded index contain 1,930 records, matching 1,930 canonical YAML records and 1,930 static record pages in the untruncated deployed-revision inventory. Sampled links open populated records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" }, "record_pages": { "status": "present", - "note": "Browse links static curated/.html and aio/.html record pages; sampled Adam, KernelPCA and TrainingStrategy pages open.", + "note": "Browse links static curated/.html and aio/.html record pages. Sampled Adam, KernelPCA, SoftDTW and TrainingStrategy pages render populated records.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/curated/Adam.html" }, "term_links": { @@ -1868,7 +1868,7 @@ }, "evidence": { "status": "present", - "note": "Sampled curated claims link source rows and primary evidence URLs; the landing distinguishes 5,149 claims from 3,269 evidence citations.", + "note": "Sampled curated claims link source rows and primary evidence URLs; the landing distinguishes 5,151 claims from 3,271 evidence citations.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/curated/Adam.html" }, "review_status": { @@ -1888,7 +1888,7 @@ }, "domain_view": { "status": "present", - "note": "The graph renders 1,949 nodes and 4,256 edges; the text map retains 1,259 concepts, a subset of the 1,929-record catalogue.", + "note": "The graph renders 1,950 nodes and 4,258 edges; the text map contains 1,259 concepts, a subset of the 1,930-record catalogue. KernelPCA and unmatched queries exercise both maps, with reset restoring their respective totals.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/graph.html" }, "cross_mech_links": { @@ -1898,12 +1898,12 @@ }, "corpus_stats": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing reports 1,929 concepts (1,487 curated and 442 AIO), 5,149 curated claims and 3,269 evidence citations.", + "note": "The landing reports 1,930 concepts (1,488 curated and 442 AIO), 5,151 curated claims and 3,271 evidence citations.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" }, "category_browse": { "status": "present", - "note": "The landing links twelve curated-kind and eight AIO-branch subset pages, including 121 architectures and 61 biases.", + "note": "The landing links curated-kind and AIO-branch subsets with counts; the browser also provides working kind and branch filters.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" }, "suite_nav": { @@ -1913,7 +1913,7 @@ }, "downloads": { "status": "partial", - "note": "Linked index.json covers all 1,929 concepts as listing metadata with claim/source counts; it omits complete claims and evidence. Map data and per-record YAML sources are also linked.", + "note": "Linked index.json contains all 1,930 concepts as listing metadata with claim/source counts; it omits complete claims and evidence. The downloaded corpus_map.json contains 1,259 map points. Per-record YAML sources are also linked.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" }, "schema_docs": { @@ -1928,7 +1928,7 @@ }, "build_provenance": { "status": "present", - "note": "Page footers identify the project snapshot date 2026-11-04 and digest de5b593fee12, separately from upstream AIO import provenance.", + "note": "Page footers identify the project snapshot date 2026-11-16 and digest 62a5ad9f4862, separately from upstream AIO import provenance.", "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/aio/TrainingStrategy.html" }, "theme_toggle": { @@ -1951,9 +1951,7 @@ "CofactorMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CofactorMech/", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CofactorMech", - "deployed_revision": "89a8ca3b37b4cd3607fdbb0b74b7b73c5c539fee", - "checked_on": "2026-11-12", - "scope": "Site-only review on November 12, 2026 UTC, separate from the existing corpus census pins. Browser evidence covers the catalogue and all 14 record pages at 1280 and 390 pixels, identifier/name searches, category filtering, keyboard reset, reload and explicit query URLs, no-JavaScript access and blocked data requests. All 36 publicly packaged manifest assets matched their hashes; the pinned Pages uploader excludes two recorded internal build markers. Deployment 7729964604 remained successful at the same revision before and after the browser pass, with served Last-Modified later than deployment creation. Feature verdicts are reviewed against the existing 24-feature catalogue; missing features are recorded without inferring scientific deficiencies.", + "deployed_revision": "1af737829b74a619610a7ee81972357d7fe178fd", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", @@ -2080,9 +2078,7 @@ "AssayMech": { "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AssayMech/", "repository": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/AssayMech", - "deployed_revision": "f7d2d79aa00b6e47816f2f7dea8b418ec084b91e", - "checked_on": "2026-11-12", - "scope": "Site-only review on November 12, 2026 UTC, separate from the existing corpus census pins. Browser evidence covers the catalogue and all nine record pages at 1280 and 390 pixels, identifier/name searches, category and record-kind filtering, keyboard reset, reload and explicit query URLs, no-JavaScript access and blocked data requests. All 27 publicly packaged manifest assets matched their hashes; the pinned Pages uploader excludes two recorded internal build markers. Deployment 7730250313 remained successful at the same revision before and after the browser pass, with served Last-Modified later than deployment creation. Feature verdicts are reviewed against the existing 24-feature catalogue; missing features are recorded without inferring scientific deficiencies.", + "deployed_revision": "2c39f17bfcd940c15c6f10dfdc26b4ce2d6e734e", "features": { "search": { "status": "present", diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/.gitignore b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/.gitignore new file mode 100644 index 0000000..022b454 --- /dev/null +++ b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/.gitignore @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +# Local uncompressed browser captures and screenshots are preserved for inspection. +# Published gzip archives are byte-identical and indexed by SHA-256. +*.png +/root/cofactor-canary.json +/root/assay-auditor.json +/root/aimech-auditor.json +/root/aimech-auditor-v2.json +/root/aimech-supplement.json +/root/trait-auditor.json +/group-a/*/audit-*/raw.json +/group-a/*/audit-*/followup-*.json +/group-a/HabitatMech/audit-1/ +/group-a/HabitatMech/audit-2/ +/group-a/PathwayMech/audit-1/ +/group-a/CellStructureMech/audit-1/ +/group-b/culturemech.json +/group-b/culturemech-supplement.json +/group-b/mediaingredientmech.json +/group-b/mediaingredientmech-supplement.json +/group-b/proteintraitsmech.json +/group-b/proteintraitsmech-supplement.json +/group-b/proteintraitsmech-controls.json +/group-b/dufmech.json +/group-b/naturalproductmech.json +/group-b/naturalproductmech-supplement.json +/group-b/cmmmech.json +/group-b/*-review-followup.json diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/README.md b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fbb0518 --- /dev/null +++ b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ +# Live browser-feature revalidation — November 19, 2026 + +This is a feature-only revalidation of the sixteen published corpus Mech sites. +The audit date uses America/Los_Angeles; raw observation timestamps use UTC. +It does not refresh the corpus census, card figures, corpus pins, or membership. +`scope.json` records the current canonical public fleet and verifies that its +public membership agrees with the retained manifest. + +The existing 24 criteria were retained. A new deployment was a reason to inspect +the served site, not evidence that any rating changed. Each accepted capture +records a successful deployment before and after the browser pass and a served +Last-Modified date at least as recent as that deployment request. Browser checks +cover reader actions, populated details, themes, fresh and resized 390px layouts, +and failed-request recovery. Catalogue claims have separate complete-index, +manifest or deployed-source inventory evidence. Most individual record pages +were sampled; CofactorMech and AssayMech were checked exhaustively. + +## Evidence and reproduction + +- `root/proposals.json`: TraitMech, AIMech, CofactorMech and AssayMech auditor judgments. +- `group-a/proposals.json`: HabitatMech, CommunityMech, TaxonMech, PathwayMech, + CellStructureMech and AntibioticMech auditor judgments. +- `group-b/proposals.json` and `group-b/evidence.json`: CultureMech, + MediaIngredientMech, ProteinTraitsMech, DUFMech, NaturalProductMech and CMMMech. +- `changes.json`: previous and final feature values, with rating changes distinguished + from changes to notes and counts. +- `review-complete.json`: independent reviewer assignments and completion record. + +Large captures are committed as deterministic `.json.gz` files. Decompress a +file before following its JSON pointer or documented locator. Publication indexes +record the uncompressed and archive SHA-256 values. The uncompressed originals and +screenshots remain local and ignored; archives preserve the complete captured +observations. Group B's evidence index maps logical `.json` names to these archives. +Incomplete/superseded attempts are excluded: Habitat audit-1/audit-2, Pathway +audit-1, CellStructure audit-1 and root AIMech auditor v1. + +The `scripts/adhoc/revalidate_*20261119*.py` helpers retain the observation, +coverage, packaging and integration procedures. Browser helpers require Python +with Playwright and an installed Chromium/Chrome executable, plus authenticated +read access through `gh`. They write new receipt paths and do not edit source +corpora. Rerunning a live observation later may observe a different deployment; +it is not a deterministic reproduction of a historical website. + +The integration helper reads the immutable website baseline and the reviewed +proposals, then updates only `_fleet/data/site_features.json` and the change +ledger. `scripts/fleet/assemble_page.py` regenerates `mechs.md` from those sources. + +## Scope of the EdgeMech work + +[EdgeMech PR #225](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/EdgeMech/pull/225) implements a +separate sample-occurrence browser. It is not counted as a published browser in +this audit. It exposes the public 10,000-occurrence sample, not the full native +graph; its 100 historical canary reviews retain distinct source-fidelity and +scientific-support assessments. Deployment and a later live-site audit must +precede adding it to this published-site matrix. + +## Findings tracked separately + +- [MediaIngredientMech #1548](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/MediaIngredientMech/issues/1548): + inconsistent data/code licence notices across browser, maps and schema routes. +- [MediaIngredientMech #888](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/MediaIngredientMech/issues/888): + existing issue reproduced for a plain-text DOI in GYPS component evidence. +- [CommunityMech #2716](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CommunityMech/issues/2716): + existing issue reproduced for broken TaxonMech record handoffs. +- [CommunityMech #2959](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CommunityMech/issues/2959): + text and sequence maps ignore the saved dark preference. +- [TraitMech #2098](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/TraitMech/issues/2098): + discussion index omits the project data and code licence notices. +- [PathwayMech #809](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/PathwayMech/issues/809): + manual theme variables do not control the main page background and text. +- [AntibioticMech #1374](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/AntibioticMech/issues/1374): + generic MediaIngredientMech exploration links use a missing route. The working + specific-record relationship keeps that separate criterion present. +- [Hub #626](https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CultureBotAI.github.io/issues/626): + corrected TraitMech evidence pointers and an unproven CellStructureMech + point-activation claim before publication. + +These upstream site defects are reflected in the ratings. This revalidation does +not silently fix or close them. The new EdgeMech implementation has its own +independent review and issue record in its PR. diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/arbitration.json b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/arbitration.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8c2fbb2 --- /dev/null +++ b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/arbitration.json @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +{ + "date": "2026-11-19", + "arbiter": "root editor, after separate auditor and skeptic passes", + "overrides": [ + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "auditor_status": "present", + "final_status": "partial", + "final_note": "The manual dark choice persists in storage and the theme attribute, but the body remains light under a light OS preference. Manual rules update different CSS variables from those used by body text/background, producing mixed light and dark regions across the sampled pages.", + "reason": "Computed styles and the sequence-map screenshot contradict the initial attribute-only inference. A saved theme must also apply visually.", + "issue": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/PathwayMech/issues/809" + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "auditor_status": "partial", + "final_status": "present", + "final_note": "D-cycloserine links directly to the specific PathwayMech WikiPathways:WP5060 record, which returns HTTP 200. Generic Explore searches are distinct from these specific-record relationships; their broken MediaIngredientMech route is tracked separately.", + "reason": "Apply the specific-record criterion consistently with CultureMech, MediaIngredientMech and NaturalProductMech. A generic name search is not a specific-record relationship. The concrete exploration defect remains filed.", + "issue": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/AntibioticMech/issues/1374" + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "auditor_status": "present", + "final_status": "present", + "final_note": "The text map renders all 1,022 structures. The sequence map renders 469 proteins associated with 140 structures; its populated context links the associated structure record.", + "reason": "A canvas-centre click did not change the default selection, so it does not establish a successful point activation. Retain the observed visualization and linked-context claim only.", + "issue": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CultureBotAI.github.io/issues/626" + } + ], + "root_proposal_corrections": [ + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "feature": "license", + "final_status": "partial", + "reason": "The linked discussion index lacks project data/code licence notices; apply the same linked-page coverage rule as HabitatMech and MediaIngredientMech.", + "issue": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/TraitMech/issues/2098" + }, + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "features": ["term_links", "cross_mech_links", "build_provenance"], + "reason": "Point evidence at the actual aerobic-respiration and Wood-Ljungdahl source pages and the captured landing/Browse/map footers. The correct observations already existed; statuses do not change.", + "issue": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/CultureBotAI.github.io/issues/626" + } + ] +} diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/changes.json b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/changes.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f61edaa --- /dev/null +++ b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/changes.json @@ -0,0 +1,4628 @@ +{ + "baseline": "bc50236b513043e907481c4a71b40d5251fcf744", + "checked_on": "2026-11-19", + "verdicts": 384, + "rating_changes": 6, + "changes": [ + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "AIMech:KernelPCA returns one linked concept and Adam returns 131 matches across the 1,929-record catalogue.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "AIMech:KernelPCA returns one linked concept, Adam returns 131 matches and SoftDTW returns one across the 1,930-record catalogue. Literal-markup and unmatched queries return zero.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Origin, concept kind and AIO branch filters have Reset. Curated selects 1,487 records and curated algorithms 1,047; Reset restores all 1,929.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Origin, concept kind and AIO branch filters have Reset. Curated selects 1,488 records, algorithm selects 1,047 and Layer selects 168. Combining attention, Curated and architecture selects 48; Reset restores 1,930.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The matching count changes to one for AIMech:KernelPCA, 131 for Adam and zero for an unmatched query, separately from the 1,929 total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The matching count changes to one for AIMech:KernelPCA, 131 for Adam and zero for an unmatched query, separately from the 1,930 total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser offers Concept name (A–Z), Concept name (Z–A), Curated claims (high–low), Evidence sources (high–low), Origin (Curated first), Identifier (A–Z). Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser offers six sort choices. Exercised name ascending, name descending and identifier ascending choices update the selected ordering and result rows.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Search, origin, kind, branch and sort are encoded in the URL; reload restores the exercised values and matching count.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html?q=attention&origin=curated&kind=architecture" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Search, origin, kind, branch and sort controls encode their state in the URL. A cold load of the combined attention, Curated and architecture query restores the controls and 48 matches.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html?q=attention&origin=curated&kind=architecture" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete browser and its machine-readable export cover 1,929 published records; sampled record links open successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete browser and downloaded index contain 1,930 records, matching 1,930 canonical YAML records and 1,930 static record pages in the untruncated deployed-revision inventory. Sampled links open populated records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse links static curated/.html and aio/.html record pages; sampled Adam, KernelPCA and TrainingStrategy pages open.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/curated/Adam.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse links static curated/.html and aio/.html record pages. Sampled Adam, KernelPCA, SoftDTW and TrainingStrategy pages render populated records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/curated/Adam.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled curated claims link source rows and primary evidence URLs; the landing distinguishes 5,149 claims from 3,269 evidence citations.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/curated/Adam.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled curated claims link source rows and primary evidence URLs; the landing distinguishes 5,151 claims from 3,271 evidence citations.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/curated/Adam.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The graph renders 1,949 nodes and 4,256 edges; the text map retains 1,259 concepts, a subset of the 1,929-record catalogue.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/graph.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The graph renders 1,950 nodes and 4,258 edges; the text map contains 1,259 concepts, a subset of the 1,930-record catalogue. KernelPCA and unmatched queries exercise both maps, with reset restoring their respective totals.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/graph.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 1,929 concepts (1,487 curated and 442 AIO), 5,149 curated claims and 3,269 evidence citations.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 1,930 concepts (1,488 curated and 442 AIO), 5,151 curated claims and 3,271 evidence citations.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing links twelve curated-kind and eight AIO-branch subset pages, including 121 architectures and 61 biases.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing links curated-kind and AIO-branch subsets with counts; the browser also provides working kind and branch filters.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked index.json covers all 1,929 concepts as listing metadata with claim/source counts; it omits complete claims and evidence. Map data and per-record YAML sources are also linked.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked index.json contains all 1,930 concepts as listing metadata with claim/source counts; it omits complete claims and evidence. The downloaded corpus_map.json contains 1,259 map points. Per-record YAML sources are also linked.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AIMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Page footers identify the project snapshot date 2026-11-04 and digest de5b593fee12, separately from upstream AIO import provenance.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/aio/TrainingStrategy.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Page footers identify the project snapshot date 2026-11-16 and digest 62a5ad9f4862, separately from upstream AIO import provenance.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AIMech/pages/aio/TrainingStrategy.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse exposes 1,130 distinct record links, matching the landing total and all 1,130 record HTML paths at the pin.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse exposes 1,130 distinct record links, matching the landing, bulk export and all 1,130 canonical records and record HTML paths in the untruncated deployed-revision inventory.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All 1,130 traits have static pages under pages/traits//.html. Sampled pages show overview, grounding, curation and source sections; 769 source records carry causal graphs.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/traits/ecology/animal_pathogen.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All 1,130 traits have static pages under pages/traits//.html. Sampled animal pathogen, aerobic respiration and Wood–Ljungdahl pages show populated overview, grounding, curation and source sections.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/traits/ecology/animal_pathogen.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record headers and Identifier cards show workflow status, including REVIEWED on animal pathogen; the complete corpus retains all four mapping statuses.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/traits/ecology/animal_pathogen.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record headers and Identifier cards show the record workflow status, including REVIEWED on animal pathogen. This is distinct from a claim that all records were manually reviewed.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/traits/ecology/animal_pathogen.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record pages render causal SVG diagrams; 769 source records carry causal graphs. PaCMAP, text and graph-layout maps each render 1,130 traits, and the sequence map renders 156 associated proteins. These source counts do not imply that every graph was visually inspected.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/umap.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record pages render causal SVG diagrams. PaCMAP, text and graph-layout maps each render 1,130 traits, and the sequence map renders 156 associated proteins; these are separately labeled views.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/umap.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The site links Download traits.json, a complete 1,130-record bulk JSON export. Downloaded map exports contain 1,130 traits or 156 proteins as labeled.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Download traits.json provides 1,130 full records, including definitions, evidence, causal graphs and curation history. Downloaded map exports contain 1,130 traits or 156 proteins as labeled.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled page footers state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with third-party source terms retained; these match the pinned license files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Templated landing, Browse, record and map pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with third-party terms retained. The linked discussions index omits these licence notices and links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": true + }, + { + "mech": "TraitMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Aborted JSON requests produce explicit map failure messages and Retry; retry after restoring requests recovers 1,130 traits or 156 proteins. Aborting discussion data produces Discussion counts unavailable and a retry prompt.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/umap.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Aborted JSON requests produce explicit map failure messages and Retry; retry after restoring requests recovers 1,130 traits or 156 proteins. Aborting discussion data shows Discussions could not be loaded; reload after restoring requests recovers 925 discussions.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TraitMech/pages/umap.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Browse finds ENVO:03000033 and marine sediment, but large match sets stop at 200 results without result pagination. Separate category pages remain paginated.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Identifier ENVO:03000033 finds one habitat and marine sediment finds three. The water query reports 310 matches but exposes only 200 search results; the category listings are separate routes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The grounding filter reduces the water query from 310 to 86 matches. Keyboard activation of Reset filters restores the initial unfiltered category listing.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 3,209-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/category/aquatic.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Counts change with identifier, label, unmatched-query and grounding-filter inputs; displayed results are distinguished from matching records when capped.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/category/aquatic.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The Browse sort control offers Assertions / Records (high–low); Assertions / Records (low–high); Name (A–Z); Name (Z–A); Grounding status (A–Z). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All five sort choices were exercised with the water query; the leading habitat changed between assertions, ascending/descending name, and grounding orders.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The identifier query restores after reload. Combined water search, grounding=EXACT and grounding sort also restore the same controls and 86 matches.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Eight linked category indexes contain 3,209 records in total; paginated category pages expose records beyond the 200-result global search cap.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Eight linked category indexes contain 3,209 distinct habitat slugs. Category pages expose paginated listings beyond the separate 200-result global-search cap.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The sampled marine-sediment and aquatic-macrophyte records have stable pages with source attestations, environmental context, curation events and their own YAML links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Marine sediment and aquatic macrophyte-associated environment open at stable habitat URLs with source attestations, environmental context and their own YAML links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Marine sediment’s own ENVO grounding and broader habitat resolve, but its Associated taxa section still shows readable names beside unlinked NCBITaxon CURIEs. Nearby TaxonMech search links are not ontology resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Marine sediment links its ENVO identity, while the Associated taxa section displays names and NCBITaxon CURIEs without ontology-resolver anchors. TaxonMech exploration links do not replace those resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Marine-sediment causal-edge PMID citations and curation DOI references remain plain text without PubMed or DOI anchors.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Marine-sediment mechanistic-edge PMID references and curation DOI citations are displayed as plain text rather than PubMed/DOI links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record headers display SEEDED or REVIEWED workflow status. The current landing says 1,901 of 3,209 are SEEDED and explicitly distinguishes workflow decisions from human review.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record views show workflow status; the landing reports 1,301 REVIEWED records and explicitly distinguishes workflow status from human review.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Marine sediment displays dated, attributed ADD_CAUSAL_GRAPH, SOURCE_SYNONYM_SCOPED, SOURCE_PARENT_EXCLUDED and UPDATE_CAUSAL_GRAPH events with change summaries.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Marine sediment displays dated, attributed causal-graph creation/update and source-synonym/parent decisions, including the change explanations.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The marine-sediment Provenance section links its own data/habitats/aquatic/marine_sediment.yaml file.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The sampled marine-sediment Provenance section links its own data/habitats/aquatic/marine_sediment.yaml source file.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The semantic text map renders 3,209 descriptions and marine sediment renders a directed SVG causal graph. The old pages/map.html route returns 404; the working route is pages/text-map/.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/text-map/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The semantic text map renders the 3,209-record projection, and the marine-sediment detail displays its directed causal graph.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/text-map/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Associated taxa now have TaxonMech search links, but they point at /TaxonMech/browse.html rather than the working /TaxonMech/pages/browse.html route. They do not resolve to specific sibling records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Record exploration links to TaxonMech/browse.html and TraitMech/browse.html return HTTP 404; the correct browsers live under pages/. These handoffs do not resolve to specific sibling records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/marine-sediment-envo-03000033.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 3,209 habitats and generated grounding, corroboration and workflow counts; its current notice states 1,901 SEEDED records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing displays 3,209 habitats, 2,143 ontology-grounded records, 175 corroborated by at least two sources and 1,301 with REVIEWED workflow status.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Eight named categories link to paginated subset listings, including Aquatic with 468 records and Host-associated with 1,655.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Eight named category links lead to subset listings, including Aquatic with 468 records and Host-associated with 1,655.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All Mech projects links on the sampled templated landing, browse and record pages lead to the central suite directory, which returns HTTP 200.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Downloads & Schema links all eight category JSON indexes (3,209 rows together), the complete point projection and its manifest; these are compact indexes/projections rather than complete habitat records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The landing links all eight category JSON indexes and the complete semantic projection with its manifest. These retain 3,209 compact rows/points, rather than full habitat records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The landing and footers now link the annotated LinkML schema YAML and imported schemas. This is source access, not rendered schema documentation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Visible schema links open the annotated LinkML YAML and imported schemas. The sampled navigation supplies schema source rather than a rendered schema reference.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Main templates state CC BY 4.0 data, BSD-3-Clause code and upstream terms. The linked standalone text-map-source page omits the project license statement.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/text-map-source/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Templated pages state CC BY 4.0 data, BSD-3-Clause code and retained upstream terms, matching deployed-revision license files. The linked standalone text-map-source page omits these project licenses.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/text-map-source/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Main footers date upstream kg-microbe extraction (2026-08-16); the linked map manifest dates that projection. They do not identify a common dated build of the project corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Main footers date the upstream kg-microbe extraction. The linked manifest dates the semantic projection, but sampled main pages do not identify a dated build or commit of the habitat corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The main Auto/Light/Dark control saves the preference across templated pages, but the linked standalone semantic map has no toggle or theme attribute and keeps its light presentation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Dark mode selected on the landing persists across templated pages. The linked standalone semantic map retains its light presentation without a theme control or theme attribute.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The aquatic-macrophyte record is 404px wide at a 390px viewport on fresh and resized loads. The other sampled landing, Browse, category, marine-sediment and semantic-map pages fit.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/aquatic-macrophyte-associated-environment-habitatmech-bacdive-38260eea00.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The aquatic-macrophyte record widens the document to 404px at a 390px viewport on fresh and resized loads. The other seven sampled routes fit.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/habitats/aquatic-macrophyte-associated-environment-habitatmech-bacdive-38260eea00.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "HabitatMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Blocking the global Browse category-index requests and searching shows Showing 0 of 0 matching habitats without explaining that data could not load. Category fallback rows remain available.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/category/host-associated.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Blocking Browse category-index requests and searching reports Showing 0 of 0 matching habitats without an error. Removing the fault and reloading restores the one matching habitat.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/HabitatMech/pages/category/host-associated.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Name and description searches work across 512 communities, but known record identifiers CommunityMech:000134 and CommunityMech:000139 return zero matches; the corresponding named records are present.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The full ANME-SRB community name finds one of 512 communities. Known identifiers CommunityMech:000134 and CommunityMech:000139 return zero matches despite their records being present.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Category and ecological-state filters have Clear All. BIOTECHNOLOGY selects 99 of 512 communities; reset restores all 512.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The live count shows three matches for ANME, one for its full community name and zero for the tested canonical identifiers and unmatched query.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser offers Name (A → Z), Name (Z → A), Members (Most → Fewest), Members (Fewest → Most), Category (A → Z). Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The URL retains search, category and sort; the combined BIOTECHNOLOGY/name-search selection restores the same controls and zero-match state.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The positive full-name query survives reload. The BIOTECHNOLOGY facet and category sort also restore the same controls and 99 matches.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete browser and its machine-readable export cover 512 published records; sampled record links open successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The live browser exposes 512 distinct community record links and its complete published JSON index contains 512 distinct record slugs; sampled individual pages open successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Published communities have individual communities/.html pages; four sampled records display taxonomy, interactions, environment and growth media.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled taxonomy and environmental sections show readable names beside NCBITaxon, ChEBI and ENVO resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Aalborg_East_Full_Scale_EBPR_Community.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled taxonomy and environmental sections show readable organism, chemical and habitat labels alongside NCBITaxon, ChEBI and ENVO resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Aalborg_East_Full_Scale_EBPR_Community.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled interaction evidence links PMID and DOI references with supporting text and evidence-type labels.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Alseth_FourSpecies_Pathogen_Phage_Community.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Alseth_FourSpecies_Pathogen_Phage_Community.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Record headers show ecological state and evidence labels, not an overall curation or review status.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The four sampled community views show ecological state and claim evidence, but no overall record curation/review status.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The sampled community pages do not display curation events, even though the repository retains provenance.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Aalborg_East_Full_Scale_EBPR_Community.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The four sampled community views do not display dated curator events or change histories.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Aalborg_East_Full_Scale_EBPR_Community.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Each sampled record footer now links its own kb/communities YAML file on GitHub.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Community pages render interaction diagrams, and text, taxonomic and sequence embedding views open as linked domain views.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/community_umap.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Community records render interaction diagrams and linked maps render populated views. The text map contains 458 communities and the sequence map 27 proteins; these are subsets, not complete coverage of the 512-community browser.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/community_umap.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Copper Biomining links Standard 9K Medium directly to CultureMech normalized recipe 003277.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Copper_Biomining_Heap_Leach.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Copper Biomining links a working CultureMech normalized recipe, but sampled TaxonMech record handoffs and several sibling browser links return HTTP 404.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/Copper_Biomining_Heap_Leach.html" + }, + "rating_changed": true + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing and browser report 512 published communities across 16 categories. Repository isolate records are outside this published-community count.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing and browser display 512 published communities across 16 categories; repository isolate records are outside this published-community total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Category and ecological-state subsets are filters in the browser rather than separate category pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html#category-facet" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Category subsets are accessible as browser filters, rather than standalone category pages. Selecting BIOTECHNOLOGY shows 99 of 512 communities.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html#category-facet" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked communities.json and TSV cover all 512 communities as catalogue summaries; they omit the complete taxon and interaction evidence stored in individual records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities.json" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked JSON and TSV downloads cover all 512 communities as catalogue summaries, omitting the full taxonomy and interaction evidence of individual records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities.json" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked schema.html page documents the CommunityMech classes, slots and ontology groundings.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/schema.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked schema.html page renders a CommunityMech schema reference with classes, slots and ontology groundings.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/schema.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Reviewed landing and record footers say License: BSD-3-Clause without distinguishing the project data license from the code license.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Landing and record footers state License: BSD-3-Clause without distinguishing project data from code, although the deployed repository retains a separate CC BY 4.0 data license.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Reviewed pages identify the generator and source corpus but do not give a build date, deployed commit or dated corpus version.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Sampled pages identify the generator and source corpus but do not display a build date, deployed commit or dated corpus version.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/communities/ANME_SRB_Marine_Methane_Seep_Consortium.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark mode chosen on the landing persists through the browser, maps, schema and four sampled records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Dark mode persists across the templated browser, records and taxonomic/network views. The linked text and sequence maps ignore the saved dark choice, have no toggle, and render a light background.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": true + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The reviewed landing, browser, maps and sampled community records fit a 390px viewport, but schema.html widens the document to 1,321px on fresh and resized loads.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/schema.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The schema page widens the document to 1,321px at a 390px viewport on fresh and resized loads; the other ten sampled routes fit.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/schema.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CommunityMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "not_applicable", + "note": "Reviewed community pages and visualizations use embedded data; no fetch or XHR catalogue request was observed to abort.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "not_applicable", + "note": "The eleven sampled landing, browser, record, schema and visualization routes use embedded data; no fetch/XHR data request was observed. Blocking fetch/XHR while exercising browser search intercepted no request.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CommunityMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse searches by identifier and label. NCBITaxon:2173: 32 of 626048 records match · page 1 of 1.; Methanobrevibacter smithii: 26 of 626048 records match · page 1 of 1.; NCBITaxon:562: 259 of 626048 records match · page 1 of 2..", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "NCBITaxon:2173 returns 32 matches and Methanobrevibacter smithii returns 26. NCBITaxon:562 returns 259 matches across two pages; the browser provides result pagination.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 626,048-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The Browse sort control offers Default (corpus order); Taxon name (A–Z); Taxon name (Z–A); NCBI ID (numeric); Taxonomic rank; BacDive strains (high–low); GTDB mappings (high–low); Attesting sources (high–low). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Search and sort restore from the URL, but changing domain to Bacteria and rank to species does not encode those filters. Reload changes 553,073 matches back to all 626,048.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Search and sort restore, but domain/rank/source selectors are not retained in the URL. Reload changes the exercised 553,073-match filter selection back to all 626,048 records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser covers 626,048 records across 3,131 pages; Next was exercised to page 2. Domain and type-strain subsets provide additional entry points.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete published index contains 626,048 unique identifiers and 626,048 unique taxon detail routes. Browse exposes 3,131 pages; clicking Next successfully opens page 2.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Stable taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:N routes open individual records, including Methanobrevibacter smithii and Escherichia coli, with paged strain details.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled taxonomy sections show named NCBI lineage terms and resolver links for NCBI identifiers, LPSN entries and GTDB names.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The sampled Methanobrevibacter record displays labeled NCBI lineage and organism identifiers, LPSN links and GTDB mappings with resolver anchors.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Methanobrevibacter smithii links its LPSN DOI references and PMID:390357; strain details retain source links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record headers and browse rows display SEEDED workflow status; the browser also exposes its Deprecated filter.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:81464" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record headers show the workflow status, separately from dated curation events.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:81464" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Methanobrevibacter smithii shows a dated seed_from_sources event with curator, action, source list and change summary.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views display dated curator actions and change summaries.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled taxon views link their own data/taxa YAML in the repository.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:562" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:562" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record pages show labeled, linked taxonomy lineages. The separate corpus map renders 31,258 embedded taxa; it is a subset of the 626,048-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled records show named taxonomic lineages. The text embedding map renders 31,258 embedded taxa, explicitly a subset of the 626,048-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled details retain kgmicrobe.strain identifiers as plain text. Suite and exploratory links do not provide direct links for those named cross-Mech records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Record exploration links include CommunityMech search, but the sampled CultureMech, HabitatMech, PathwayMech and NaturalProductMech browser handoffs use missing routes and return HTTP 404.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/taxon.html?id=NCBITaxon:2173" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing shows 626,048 taxa, 100,745 distinct strains and 20,648 taxa with a type strain. The live Archaea subset now contains 14,013 records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing displays 626,048 taxa, 100,745 distinct strains and 20,648 taxa with a type strain. The opened Archaea listing contains 14,013 taxa.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Landing links domain and type-strain listings. Archaea shows 14,013 records and the type-strain subset 20,648, with pagination.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Linked domain and type-strain pages provide paginated subsets; the opened Archaea and type-strain listings contain 14,013 and 20,648 records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The linked index.json.gz contains 626,048 catalogue rows, and its manifest records format and checksum. It is a browse index rather than full taxon records; individual pages link YAML, but no bulk complete-record export was linked.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The linked compressed index contains all 626,048 catalogue rows and detail routes, with a separate format/checksum manifest. It is an index, rather than a bulk export of complete taxon records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Visible Schema and LinkML schema links now open the annotated YAML source, while reviewed navigation lacks rendered schema documentation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Visible schema links identify annotated LinkML YAML, verified through the GitHub API at the deployed revision after the web UI rate-limited a request. Sampled navigation does not expose a rendered schema reference.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with upstream terms retained, consistent with the pinned license files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled pages distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data, BSD-3-Clause code and retained upstream terms, consistent with license files read at the deployed revision.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The footer now identifies corpus digest 959c8dfd8771 and 626,048 records, but provides no own build date or commit. Sources dates describe upstream snapshots.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled pages show an undated corpus digest or upstream-source dates, without a build date, displayed commit or dated version of the project corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark mode chosen on the landing persists across the sampled browser, record and visualization pages in the same browser context.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All sampled live routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; wide content stays within its own region.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All sampled routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; retained states record document widths for every route.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/sources.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "TaxonMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocking the search index preserves static pagination and says Search is unavailable. Blocked detail shards and corpus-map data display explicit load errors.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocked search indexes report Search is unavailable while preserving static pagination. Blocked taxon-detail shards and embedding-map data show explicit load errors; removing each fault and reloading restores populated content.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/TaxonMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse searches by identifier and label. MetaCyc:PWY-6543: 1 of 282 pathways match; trehalose: 3 of 282 pathways match.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "MetaCyc:PWY-6543 finds one pathway and trehalose finds three of the 283 published pathways; all matches have directly reachable record links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 282-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The Browse sort control offers Pathway name (A–Z); Pathway name (Z–A); Mechanistic edges (high–low); Mechanistic edges (low–high); Identifier (A–Z); Pathway class (A–Z). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html?q=glycolysis" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The query and exercised facet/sort state survive URL reload with the same controls and matching counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html?q=glycolysis" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse exposes all 282 stable pathway links, matching the landing and the 282-record downloadable pathway index.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse contains 283 distinct stable record links, matching the complete downloadable index with 283 distinct identifiers and detail URLs.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled MetaCyc, GO and WikiPathways records have stable pages with organism scope, participants, mechanistic edges, evidence, curation history and their own YAML links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Organism-scope taxa are labeled and linked, but the main component and mechanistic-edge tables still display chemical, protein and reaction CURIEs without resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Organism-scope taxa are labeled and linked, but the main component and mechanistic-edge tables display chemical, protein and reaction identifiers without resolver anchors.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled mechanistic edges link Rhea and PubMed references and source locations, separating source assertions from quotations.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Sampled pathway pages show pathway type and editing history but no record-level curation or review status.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The sampled MetaCyc, GO and actinorhodin pathway pages display pathway type and curation history, but no overall record curation/review status.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled pathway pages show dated curator actions, change summaries and retained curation-session links, including current November edits.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/GO_0036040.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views display dated curator actions and change summaries.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/GO_0036040.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Read the source YAML links sampled records to their own data/pathways file in GitHub.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Pathway pages render directed SVG networks with node selection and zoom controls. The text map renders 270 pathways and the sequence map 216 pathway centroids; the current corpus has 282 records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Populated pathway pages render directed SVG networks. The text map renders 270 pathways and the sequence map 216 pathway centroids; both are subsets of the current 283-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The sampled MetaCyc, GO and WikiPathways pages offer suite navigation and external authority links, but no direct links to specific sibling-Mech or kg-microbe records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The sampled MetaCyc, GO and actinorhodin pages provide suite navigation and external source-authority links, but no direct links to specific sibling-Mech or kg-microbe records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/records/MetaCyc_PWY-6543.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 282 pathway records, 105 taxa, 14,838 mechanistic edges and 5,922 distinct references.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 283 pathway records, 105 taxa, 14,841 mechanistic edges and 5,927 distinct references.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The current Browse exposes subset filters, but sampled navigation does not link the previously claimed 15 standalone category pages. Its Pathway type options include edge-count strings, which need separate site correction.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Subset selection is provided by Browse filters; sampled navigation does not expose standalone class pages. The Pathway class selector currently labels classes using mechanistic-edge counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Landing links KGX node and edge TSV exports plus the complete 282-record pathway index. These and the version/checksum manifest return HTTP 200; the manifest reports 5,472 nodes and 14,838 edges.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing links KGX node/edge TSV exports and a complete 283-record pathway index. All downloads succeed; the checksum manifest identifies 5,476 nodes and 14,841 edges.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The current landing links LinkML YAML sources. The formerly claimed pages/schema.html returns HTTP 404; no rendered schema reference was linked.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled navigation links the annotated LinkML YAML source, rather than a rendered schema reference.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The landing states CC BY 4.0 data and upstream terms, but does not state a code license; sampled record and browse pages omit the data/code license statement.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The landing states CC BY 4.0 data and retained upstream terms, but does not state the code license. Sampled browse and record views omit the data/code license statement.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Landing displays an undated graph-content hash. No site build date, displayed commit or dated project-corpus version is shown on sampled pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled pages show an undated corpus digest or upstream-source dates, without a build date, displayed commit or dated version of the project corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The manual dark choice persists in storage and the theme attribute, but the body remains light under a light OS preference. Manual rules update different CSS variables from those used by body text/background, producing mixed light and dark regions across the sampled pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": true + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All sampled live routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; wide content stays within its own region.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All sampled routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; retained states record document widths for every route.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "PathwayMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "not_applicable", + "note": "The sampled landing, Browse, record, text-map and sequence-map pages embed their data and issue no data fetch/XHR requests, so the data-request failure criterion does not apply.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "not_applicable", + "note": "The eight sampled landing, browse, record, text-map and sequence-map routes embed their data; no fetch/XHR data request was observed. Blocking those request types while searching intercepted nothing.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/PathwayMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse searches by identifier and label. GO:0097589: 1 of 1022 records shown; MitoStore: 1 of 1022 records shown; cellstructuremech:insoluble_protein_deposit: 1 of 1022 records shown.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "GO:0097589, the label MitoStore and the local insoluble-protein-deposit identifier each return one record. The complete listing contains all 1,022 structures.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 1,022-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The Browse sort control offers Label (A–Z); Label (Z–A); Identifier (A–Z); Category; Kind; Mapping status. Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The query and exercised facet/sort state survive URL reload with the same controls and matching counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse exposes all 1,022 structure records, matching the landing and linked complete-corpus JSON; category pages and the 873-record grounded subset provide additional routes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse exposes all 1,022 records. The complete corpus and index downloads each contain 1,022 unique identifiers; the index supplies 1,022 distinct stable detail routes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The sampled structure records have stable pages with components, evidence, curation history and their own YAML source links. Browse and the complete export both cover 1,022 records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Attachment organelle membrane now shows labeled GO:0033111, GO:0033099 and GO:0005886 resolver links in its mechanism Subject/Object cells, alongside labeled parent, taxon and UniProt-location links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/attachment_organelle_membrane.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The attachment-organelle membrane view labels and links its GO identity, structural parents, UniProt location and taxonomy terms; the populated archaellum and S-layer pages provide corresponding resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/attachment_organelle_membrane.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled components, distribution statements, mechanism edges and record-level evidence link GO, DOI and PubMed references.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record headers and Browse rows show Proposed, separately from their dated curation histories.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record headers show the workflow status, separately from dated curation events.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Attachment organelle membrane shows dated creation, expansion and review actions with named curators and change summaries.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views display dated curator actions and change summaries.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Each sampled record links its own data/structures YAML on GitHub.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/appendage/archaeal_type_flagellum.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The working embedding-map.html renders 1,022 structure points; the sequence map renders 469 proteins across 140 structures. The old note’s pages/map.html returns 404, and sampled mechanism sections are tables rather than rendered SVG diagrams.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/embedding-map.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The text map renders all 1,022 structures. The sequence map renders 469 proteins associated with 140 structures; its populated context links the associated structure record.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/embedding-map.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "S-layer links traitmech:000064 to TraitMech’s stable S-layer record; that target returns HTTP 200.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/envelope/s_layer.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The S-layer record links directly to the corresponding TraitMech S-layer trait page, which returns HTTP 200.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/envelope/s_layer.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 1,022 structures, 13 categories and 873 GO-grounded records; its category table includes 226 membrane organelles.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 1,022 structures, 13 categories and 873 GO-grounded records, with counts for each category.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Thirteen category links lead to subset pages. The opened Microcompartment page shows all six records; the separate GO-grounded page shows 873.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Thirteen named category routes and a GO-grounded subset are linked from the landing. The microcompartment and grounded listings open with populated record links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing links the complete corpus JSON with 1,022 records and the 1,022-entry catalogue index; both downloads return HTTP 200.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked complete corpus JSON contains 1,022 full records, with a separate 1,022-record catalogue index; both download successfully and have retained byte hashes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Visible Schema and LinkML schema links open the annotated LinkML YAML source. Reviewed navigation does not expose a rendered schema reference or explanatory guide.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The linked annotated LinkML YAML is verified at the deployed revision through the GitHub API after a web-UI rate limit; sampled navigation does not expose a rendered schema reference.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with upstream terms retained, consistent with the pinned license files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled pages distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data, BSD-3-Clause code and retained upstream terms, consistent with license files read at the deployed revision.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Shared footers state corpus as of 2026-11-03 05:55:11 UTC, digest d7c5fef867d9 and 1,022 records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Main pages display the corpus date 2026-11-03 05:55:11 UTC, digest d7c5fef867d9, record count and generation script.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark mode chosen on the landing persists across the sampled browser, record and visualization pages in the same browser context.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All sampled live routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; wide content stays within its own region.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/cytoskeleton/stentor_myoneme_system.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All sampled routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; retained states record document widths for every route.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/structures/cytoskeleton/stentor_myoneme_system.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CellStructureMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocking either embedding-map JSON request displays Could not load embedding artifacts: Failed to fetch. The sequence map embeds its data without a fetch.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/embedding-map.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocking both text-map artifacts produces Could not load embedding artifacts: Failed to fetch. Removing the fault and reloading restores 1,022 structures; the main browser uses embedded data.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CellStructureMech/pages/embedding-map.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Browse finds CHEBI:2637 and amikacin with matching counts, but large result sets stop at the first 500 links without result pagination. Category indexes provide separate routes through the corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "CHEBI:2637 and rifampicin each find one compound. The antibiotic query has 553 matches but shows only the first 500 without search pagination; class listings provide a separate navigation route.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters change the matching result count, and activating the reset control with the keyboard restores the unfiltered listing.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 3,125-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The matching count changes with known identifier, known label, unmatched-query and property-filter inputs, separately from the corpus total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The Browse sort control offers Compound name (A–Z); Compound name (Z–A); Antimicrobial class (A–Z); Structural class (A–Z); Curation status (REVIEWED first); Grounding status (EXACT first). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The available sort choices were exercised in the live browser; ascending and descending orders change the leading records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The query and exercised facet/sort state survive URL reload with the same controls and matching counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The 3,125-record browse index and linked paginated class listings provide routes into the complete corpus; the interactive result panel itself is capped at 500.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete browse index contains 3,125 distinct record slugs and the chemical-map download contains 3,125 distinct identifiers and detail paths. Linked class listings provide pagination; opening antibacterial page 2 succeeds with 300 records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled amikacin, avibactam and D-cycloserine pages have stable URLs, source assertions, molecular context, curation histories and links to their own source records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled populated records open at stable individual URLs and display their scientific sections and their own source-file links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Avibactam’s own identity and activity terms resolve, but four broader ChEBI identifiers still display Label unavailable; the main classification section remains incompletely labeled.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Avibactam links its ChEBI identity and broader-compound CURIEs, but all four entries in its Classification section display Label unavailable instead of readable names.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Avibactam links PMID:25406838 in its molecular-target, causal-edge and record evidence. D-cycloserine retains linked evidence for its qualified pathway correspondence.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record sections render citation identifiers as PubMed/DOI or source-reference anchors with associated evidence text. This judges linked rendering, not the scientific validity or external-service access policy of every citation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record headers show workflow status, including REVIEWED on avibactam; the landing distinguishes recorded workflow status from human review.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record headers show the workflow status, separately from dated curation events.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Avibactam shows dated seeding, reseeding, review and protein/causal-graph curation events, with curator identifiers and LLM-assisted labels where recorded.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views display dated curator actions and change summaries.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled Provenance sections link their own data/antibiotics YAML. Large records also link a complete per-record JSON.gz export.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled record views link directly to their own YAML files in the repository.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The chemical map displays all 3,125 compounds and the sequence map 132 proteins; the corpus text map renders separately. Sampled causal mechanisms are available as node/edge tables.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/chemical-map.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The chemical map renders 3,125 structures; populated compound views display chemical properties and causal mechanisms. The sequence map renders a subset of 132 proteins across 71 compounds, and a separate text map is available.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/chemical-map.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "D-cycloserine links to PathwayMech WikiPathways:WP5060 with source revision and qualified target/process correspondence; the target returns HTTP 200.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antimycobacterial/d-cycloserine.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "D-cycloserine links directly to the specific PathwayMech WikiPathways:WP5060 record, which returns HTTP 200. Generic Explore searches are distinct from these specific-record relationships; their broken MediaIngredientMech route is tracked separately.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antimycobacterial/d-cycloserine.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 3,125 compounds and generated grounding, review and mechanism statistics; its notice states 2,794 SEEDED records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 3,125 compounds, 2,782 ontology-grounded records, 281 merged ChEBI/ARO records and 174 with REVIEWED workflow status, plus mechanism coverage counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse and the landing link antimicrobial class listings, including Antibacterial with 1,196 directly filed records and 1,274 including its 78-record antimycobacterial subclass; Antifungal has 617.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing links antimicrobial-class listings. The antibacterial listing opens and its page-2 link loads a further 300 compound rows.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects navigation on the sampled main pages links to the central X-Mech directory; its target responds successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The landing links a 3,125-entry browse index and chemical-map coordinates, while sampled record pages link complete individual JSON.gz records. No bulk complete-record corpus export is linked; the old corpus.json/corpus.csv claim is unsupported.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked downloads include the 3,125-row browse index, the complete chemical-map data and lazy per-record JSON for sampled compounds, rather than a bulk full-record corpus export.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Navigation links the annotated LinkML schema YAML successfully; no rendered schema documentation was linked from the sampled pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled navigation links the annotated LinkML YAML source, rather than a rendered schema reference.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with upstream terms retained, consistent with the pinned license files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled pages distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data, BSD-3-Clause code and retained upstream terms, consistent with license files read at the deployed revision.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The footer displays corpus digest 04a931dcbfed and 3,125 records, but its only date is the upstream ChEBI/CARD input date 2026-08-30; it does not identify a dated build of its own corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled pages show an undated corpus digest or upstream-source dates, without a build date, displayed commit or dated version of the project corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark mode chosen on the landing persists across the sampled browser, record and visualization pages in the same browser context.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All sampled live routes fit a 390px viewport on both fresh load and resizing from 1280px; wide content stays within its own region.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The eight valid main/browser/detail/map routes fit 390px on fresh and resized loads. The actual linked antibacterial category pagination also fits 390px; a guessed unlinked category URL returned a retained 404 and is excluded from feature judgments.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Chemical-map and browse-index failures are explicit. After sequence-map JSON fails, typing in search replaces the error with Showing 0 of 0 proteins, which misrepresents an unavailable dataset as empty.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/chemical-map.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Browse and the chemical map retain explicit fetch-error messages. On the sequence map, typing after a blocked JSON load replaces the error with Showing 0 of 0 proteins. Removing faults and reloading restores loaded data totals.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/chemical-map.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "PF04149, IPR007278 and Domain of unknown function (DUF397) each return one linked family from the 8,296-family catalogue.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "PF04149, IPR007278 and Domain of unknown function (DUF397) each return one linked family from 8,296.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Seed status, characterization and curation status filters combine with search; Clear search and filters restores all 8,296 families.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Seed, characterization and curation filters combine with search; the exercised selections give 1,796 then 127 families, and reset restores 8,296.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The live count shows one of 8,296 for each tested identifier/label and zero for an unmatched query.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts change between one, zero, filtered subsets and the separate 8,296-family total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser offers Proteins: high to low, Proteins: low to high, Pfam accession, Family name: A to Z, Structures: high to low. Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Protein count, accession, family name and structure-count sorts change the leading family rows.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Query, seed status, characterization, curation status, sort and page are retained in the URL; the exercised combined filter state restores after reload.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A cold URL and reload preserve search, seed, characterization, curation and sort selections; reset clears them.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete index and catalogue contain 8,296 families. The browser provides numbered pagination and links individual family pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete catalogue and family index each contain 8,296 families; the listing exposes 166 numbered pages and individual family links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Family accessions have stable families/PFxxxxx.html pages; PF04149, PF02698 and PF18141 opened successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF18141.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "PF04149, PF02698 and PF18141 have stable, populated families/PFxxxxx.html pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF18141.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled family grounding shows readable names with linked Pfam and InterPro identifiers.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled family grounding displays readable Pfam and InterPro labels with resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Family views link frozen source descriptions and citations. Curated mechanism evidence is distinguished from imported descriptions and unresolved source citations.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF02698.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled family pages link source descriptions and references, distinguishing imported provenance from curated functional evidence.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF02698.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Family headers and browser rows display curation status alongside seed classification and characterization tier.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF18141.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Family headers and browser rows distinguish curation status, seed status and characterization.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF18141.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The sampled family views show retained dated curation events and reviews with attribution and outcomes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "PF04149 displays dated, attributed curation events and retained review outcomes; uncurated samples explicitly disclose missing events.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Family pages link their individual YAML at the retained source revision, plus build-local YAML and JSON copies.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled family pages link their individual YAML at a retained source revision and offer build-local YAML/JSON copies.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Family pages display domain tracks and causal diagrams where available; linked text and protein sequence maps provide corpus views.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Family domain tracks and causal content accompany loaded text and sequence maps; the maps show 8,296 families and 634 proteins respectively.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled family pages link specific retained ProteinTraitsMech records, including Pfam:PF18141; the previous claim that PF18141 was outside the scan no longer applies.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled family pages link specific retained ProteinTraitsMech records, including PF04149 and PF02698.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 8,296 families, 8,238 with InterPro IDs, 1,906 with structures and 8,242 with AlphaFold models; seed subsets total 1,796 EX_DUF, 373 historical DUFs and 6,127 unknown candidates.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Landing counts show 8,296 families, 8,238 with InterPro IDs, 1,906 with structures and 8,242 with AlphaFold models.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked category index opens distinct paginated seed-status subsets.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/categories.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The category index links distinct paginated seed-status subsets: 1,796 former DUFs, 373 historical DUFs and 6,127 unknown candidates.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/categories.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links appear on the reviewed landing, families, categories, schema, sources and maps.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sources & schema and the catalogue link the complete index.json export containing all 8,296 families and retained provenance.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/sources.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked index.json export contains all 8,296 families with retained metadata and provenance; individual family exports are also linked.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/sources.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked schema.html guide documents family records, curation, evidence, history and enums, and provides the schema source.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/schema.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sources links the rendered family-schema guide describing records, evidence, curation and history.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/schema.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reviewed footers distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data from BSD 3-Clause code and retain third-party terms.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/sources.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reviewed footers distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD 3-Clause code, with third-party terms retained.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/sources.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Footers identify the site build, retained corpus source revision and dated frozen upstream inputs.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reviewed footers identify site build c8350f3d911e6c4b, corpus source ea54567e804a and dated frozen inputs.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The System/Light/Dark selector persists Dark across the reviewed landing, families, categories, schema, sources and maps.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The System/Light/Dark selector carries Dark through reviewed family, category, schema, source and map routes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reviewed landing, sampled families, category index, sources, schema and maps fit 390px; wide tables scroll within their containers.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All nine reviewed routes fit 390px on resized and fresh loads; sampled screenshots confirm readable wrapped navigation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/families/PF04149.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "DUFMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocking catalogue.json visibly reports that interactive search is unavailable while retaining static rows and pagination.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocked catalogue data visibly falls back to a static paginated catalogue with an unavailable-search explanation; blocked map data shows an error, and reload recovers.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/DUFMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "CultureMech:000252 returns one recipe and Halophilic medium returns four, with individual recipe links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "CultureMech:000252 returns one linked recipe and Halophilic medium returns four from 15,915 normalized recipes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The category facet selects 14,332 bacterial recipes; combining it with Halophilic medium leaves two. Clear All restores all 15,915.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The bacterial category selects 14,332 recipes, combined Halophilic medium search leaves two, and Clear All restores 15,915.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The live count distinguishes one identifier match, four label matches, two bacterial label matches and zero for an unmatched query.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The count changes to one identifier match, four label matches, two category/label matches and zero for an unmatched query.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The recipe browser has no reader-facing sort selector, sort button or sortable table. Its facet lists are internally ordered, which does not provide record sorting.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The main browser has no reader-facing record sort selector, sort button or sortable table.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Search and property filters restore from the URL: Halophilic medium with category=bacterial reloads with the same two recipes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Cold navigation and reload restore the Halophilic medium search plus bacterial category with the same two recipes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The main browser covers 15,915 normalized recipes. The landing also counts 6,325 merged recipes, whose separate pages/index.html listing is outside the main browser navigation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The main browser and linked export cover 15,915 normalized recipes. The landing also counts 6,325 merged recipes, whose separate pages/index.html is not linked from its navigation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Normalized and merged recipes have stable individual URLs; sampled normalized pages display composition, organisms and provenance.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled normalized recipes have stable pages with composition, organisms and provenance; normalized and merged indexes expose individual record links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Ingredient and organism terms have labels and resolver links, but mediadive.medium:1399 on recipe 000252 is shown as source link unavailable.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Ingredients and organisms have labeled resolver links, but recipe 000252 still displays mediadive.medium:1399 as source link unavailable.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled records link formal DOI references, but source URLs embedded in Notes remain plain text.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled recipes link formal DOI references while source URLs embedded in Notes remain plain text.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Sampled recipe pages do not state record curation or review status. The separate growth-evidence report does not provide a status for each recipe.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000038.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Sampled recipe pages do not state an overall curation or review status; the separate growth-evidence report is not a per-record workflow status.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000038.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Recipe Provenance tables show timestamps, curators or scripts, actions and notes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Recipe Provenance tables display timestamps, curators or scripts, actions and notes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The source YAML path appears as plain text in sampled record footers rather than as a link to that file.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled record footers name their individual YAML path as plain text and link the repository rather than that file.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Text and chemically derived media maps and an ingredient map render interactive corpus views.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/umap.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Loaded text, media and ingredient maps provide corpus views; retained coordinate coverage is distinguished from current recipe counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/umap.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Recipe 015438 links CommunityMech:000064 to the specific pinned Soybean_N_Fixation_sfSynCom.yaml record.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/015438.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Recipe 015438 links CommunityMech:000064 directly to the retained Soybean_N_Fixation_sfSynCom.yaml record.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/015438.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing shows 15,915 normalized recipes, 6,325 merged recipes and five populated categories.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing displays 15,915 normalized records, 6,325 merged records and five populated categories.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Categories are browser facets and headed sections on long indexes; the landing does not link separate category pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Categories are main-browser facets and headed index sections; the landing does not link separate category pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible suite-directory links appear in reviewed core navigation and record footers.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The landing links JSON and TSV indexes covering 15,915 normalized recipes, but these omit full compositions and record evidence; a complete bulk record export is not linked.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/recipes.json" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked JSON/TSV indexes cover 15,915 normalized recipes but omit full composition and evidence; complete bulk records are not linked.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/recipes.json" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked app/schema.html guide documents 51 classes and 34 enumerations, including MediaRecipe and growth-evidence structures.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/schema.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked app/schema.html guide documents MediaRecipe, growth-evidence classes and enumerations.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/schema.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The reviewed landing, schema and record footers identify BSD-3-Clause but do not consistently distinguish the project data license from the code license.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Reviewed core footers state BSD-3-Clause without separately identifying project data and code licenses; the growth-review and maps omit that distinction.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The reviewed landing, browser and recipe footers do not state a site build, deployment revision or dated corpus version; recipe curation dates describe individual events.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Reviewed core pages identify generators and recipe provenance but do not state a site build date, deployment revision or dated project-corpus version.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/000252.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Dark mode persists through the core browser, indexes, maps and records. The linked growth-evidence report has no toggle and does not adopt the saved choice.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/media_growth_review.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Dark persists through core browser, indexes, maps and records; the linked growth-evidence report has no toggle and ignores the saved choice.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/media_growth_review.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Core reviewed pages and the normalized index fit 390px. The linked growth-evidence report still widens the document to 520px.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Core reviewed routes fit 390px, but pages/media_growth_review.html remains 520px wide on both fresh and resized loads.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/pages/normalized/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CultureMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocking data.js shows Recipes could not be loaded and a retry control rather than a zero-record catalogue.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocking browser data.js shows Recipes could not be loaded with a retry control; unblocking and reloading restores 15,915 recipes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CultureMech/app/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "UNMAPPED_0196 and table salt each return one linked ingredient; CHEBI:63895 returns two of the 2,956 records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "UNMAPPED_0196 and table salt each return one linked ingredient; CHEBI:63895 returns two from 2,956.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Mapping status, ontology source and mapping quality filters combine with search. AMBIGUOUS gives one record; Clear search and filters restores all 2,956.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Status, ontology source and mapping quality combine with search; AMBIGUOUS selects one record and reset restores all 2,956.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Showing N of 2956 ingredients changes to one for UNMAPPED_0196, two for CHEBI:63895 and zero for an unmatched query.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The matching count changes to one, two, zero and filtered subsets separately from the 2,956-ingredient total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser offers Default Order, Name (A → Z), Name (Z → A), Media Count (Most → Least), Occurrences (Most → Least), Synonyms (Most → Least). Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Name ascending/descending, media count, occurrence count and synonym count reorder the leading records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Search, status, source, quality and sort values are encoded in query parameters and restore with the same matching count after reload.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Cold URL navigation and reload preserve the exercised query, mapping status, source, quality and sort selections.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete browser and its machine-readable export cover 2,956 published records; sampled record links open successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser, record index and linked data/ingredients.json cover 2,956 ingredients with individual record links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Mapped, rejected and unmapped ingredients have stable record URLs; sampled NaCl, GYPS and glucose pages open with mapping, evidence and history sections.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "NaCl, GYPS and rejected glucose have stable, populated individual record pages with mapping, evidence and history.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled ingredient groundings display names with resolver links for ontology terms and component identities; local registry identities can remain plain text.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled grounding and component sections show readable labels beside ontology resolver links; local registry identities remain literal identifiers.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "NaCl and GYPS expose linked PMID, DOI and source-URL references in their evidence sections.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/GYPS.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "PMID and DOI links work in sampled sections, but GYPS material-component evidence leaves Bergey doi:10.1002/9781118960608.gbm00618 as plain text (existing issue 888).", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/GYPS.html" + }, + "rating_changed": true + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record headers state mapping status and quality. Runtime metadata reports 2,611 MAPPED, 262 UNMAPPED, 82 REJECTED and one AMBIGUOUS ingredient.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Glucose_2.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record headers expose mapping status and quality; runtime metadata distinguishes 2,611 MAPPED, 262 UNMAPPED, 82 REJECTED and one AMBIGUOUS record.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Glucose_2.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled ingredient pages show Curation history tables with timestamp, curator, action and change details.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled records show dated curation events with curator, action, resulting status and change details.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled record footers name data/ingredients/...yaml as plain text; their anchors do not link that individual YAML source.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled record footers name individual data/ingredients YAML paths but do not link those files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/Nacl.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Text and chemical embedding maps render, and sampled records display role/partonomy diagrams. Embedding coverage is separate from the 2,956-record catalogue total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/ingredient_umap.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The text and KG embedding views load 2,872 and 2,337 plotted ingredients; these are explicit subsets of the 2,956-record catalogue.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/ingredient_umap.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "GYPS links CultureMech:002799 to its individual normalized recipe from the related-recipe and comparison-evidence sections.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/GYPS.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "GYPS links CultureMech:002799 directly to the corresponding normalized recipe.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/ingredient/mapped/GYPS.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Runtime landing tiles show 2,956 ingredients, 2,611 mapped and 88% coverage; the linked catalogue metadata distinguishes all four mapping statuses.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Landing tiles show 2,956 ingredients, 2,611 mapped and 88% coverage, matching runtime catalogue metadata.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The record index has identifier-prefix sections, while the main browser offers property filters; these do not form standalone category pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Identifier-prefix sections and browser facets expose subsets without standalone linked category pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links appear on reviewed landing, browser, records, maps and schema routes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The landing links catalogue JSON and CSV covering all 2,956 ingredients, but they contain mapping/search fields rather than complete records with components, evidence and history.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked catalogue JSON/CSV covers all 2,956 ingredients but contains search/mapping fields, not complete evidence, component and history records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The visible schema reference links rendered class, slot, enum and type documentation, including schema/classes-IngredientRecord.html.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/schema/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The visible schema index links rendered class, slot, enum and type documentation, including IngredientRecord.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/schema/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing and sampled record footers distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data from BSD-3-Clause code.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Landing and sampled record pages distinguish CC BY 4.0 data and BSD-3-Clause code, but browser, maps and schema pages omit these statements; the record index states only CC BY 4.0.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": true + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Generated timestamps and a linked build receipt identify the current record build, including NaCl at 2026-11-08T23:01:00+00:00.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The record index and individual records display generated timestamps on 2026-11-17 and link a SHA-256 build receipt.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/records/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries across the browser, record index, sampled ingredients, maps and schema documentation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries through the reviewed browser, record index, ingredients, maps and schema documentation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The reviewed landing, browser, record index, ingredient pages, maps and valid schema pages fit a 390px viewport.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reviewed landing, browser, record index, ingredient pages, maps and schema documentation fit 390px on fresh and resized loads.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "MediaIngredientMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocking the catalogue request displays unavailable counters, Ingredients could not be loaded and a retry control.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocking catalogue or KG-map JSON displays an explicit error with retry; ordinary reload after unblocking restores data.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/MediaIngredientMech/browser.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "CHEBI:27638 and cmmmech:copper each return one linked material; Cobalt returns 23 of 708.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "CHEBI:27638 returns one linked cobalt record and Cobalt returns 24 of the current 713 materials.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Kind, mechanism process and criticality filters have Clear filters. Element selects 66 records; adding bioleaching selects 15; reset restores all 708.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Kind, mechanism and criticality filters combine with search; elements give 66, adding bioleaching gives 15, and reset restores 713.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The count updates to one for identifier searches, 23 for Cobalt, 15 for bioleaching elements and zero for an unmatched query.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts update for identifier, label, unmatched query and property filters separately from 713 total materials.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser offers Material name (A–Z), Material name (Z–A), Mechanisms (high–low), Microbial agents (high–low), Material kind (A–Z), Criticality (critical first). Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Name, mechanism count, organism count, kind and criticality sorts reorder the visible material cards.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Cobalt with element, bioleaching, criticality and sort selections reloads from its URL with all controls restored and one matching record.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Cold navigation and reload restore the combined Cobalt query, element/bioleaching/criticality facets and sort with one match.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The complete browser and its machine-readable export cover 708 published records; sampled record links open successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse and linked index.json cover 713 materials; record cards link individual pages and kind listings expose subsets.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse and kind/process listings link stable materials/.html pages; cobalt and akaganeite opened successfully.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Cobalt and akaganeite open stable, populated materials/.html pages with mechanisms, references and curation history.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled material identifiers and mechanism terms show readable labels with ChEBI, taxon and protein/ontology resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled material identities and mechanism terms display readable labels with chemical, taxon and protein resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled references link DOI or source URLs, and mechanism evidence points to the corresponding references.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled reference sections link DOI/source URLs and mechanism evidence points to those reference records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Record headers show material kind and criticality; these and individual evidence labels do not state overall review status.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Record headings show material kind and criticality, but do not display an overall record-review status.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled records include Curation History tables with timestamp, curator, action and summary.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled material pages display Curation History tables with timestamps, curators, actions and summaries.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record source lines link the individual data/records YAML on GitHub.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled source lines link each record’s individual data/records YAML on GitHub.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The mechanism graph renders 654 nodes and 972 edges; the text map retains 602 material points, a subset of the 708-record catalogue.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/graph.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked mechanism network and retained material embedding map render with populated counts; records include causal content where supplied.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/graph.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Record sections provide cross-Mech search links and site navigation, but the sampled pages do not link specific sibling records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Sampled records expose sibling-site navigation and searches but do not link specific sibling records in their main sections.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/akaganeite.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports 708 materials, 609 mechanisms, 500 materials with mechanisms and 90 designated critical materials across six kinds.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing now reports 713 materials and 609 mechanisms, with generated material-kind and criticality counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Landing cards link six material-kind and process listings. Kind totals are 66 elements, 457 minerals, 111 secondary resources, 36 commodities, 31 primary resources and seven mineral groups.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/kinds/mineral.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Landing cards link material-kind and process subset pages; the Minerals listing opens populated records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/kinds/mineral.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links appear on reviewed landing, browse, kind, record and visualization pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked index.json covers all 708 catalogue entries but contains listing metadata and mechanism counts, not full mechanism evidence; map exports and individual YAML links are also available.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked index.json contains all 713 listing summaries and mechanism counts; full mechanism evidence remains in per-record source files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Visible schema links open the LinkML YAML source. The previously recorded pages/schema.html documentation URL returns 404.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Visible schema links open LinkML YAML source; pages/schema.html still returns 404 rather than rendered schema documentation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reviewed footers separately state CC BY 4.0 data and BSD-3-Clause code, consistent with the repository license policy.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reviewed generated footers separately state CC BY 4.0 data and BSD-3-Clause code, consistent with repository license files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Footers state 708 materials, 609 mechanisms, latest curation 2026-11-10 and corpus digest e5bc8a7270d8.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Generated footers identify 713 materials, 609 mechanisms, latest curation 2026-11-11 and corpus digest ca4e8e5f93ec.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries to Browse, kind, record, text-map and graph pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries to browse, kind, record, map and graph pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "At 390px, cobalt widens the document to 597px and akaganeite to 669px. The ten newly curated records reach 652–669px, including copper at 652px, on fresh and resized views.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "At 390px cobalt and akaganeite widen the document to 597px and 669px respectively on fresh and resized loads; main listing/maps fit.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/materials/cobalt.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "CMMMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "not_applicable", + "note": "Reviewed listings, records and canvas visualizations embed their data; no fetch/XHR data request was observed to abort.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "not_applicable", + "note": "Reviewed listings, records and visualizations embed their data; no fetch/XHR catalogue dependency was observed.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/CMMMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Searching cd05137 returns one linked record; homogentisate 1,2-dioxygenase returns 16 after the relevant shards finish loading.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "After record shards load, cd05137 returns one linked record and homogentisate 1,2-dioxygenase returns 16 from the 429,421-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Axis, source, category and status facets combine with text search. Selecting active sites gives 1,004 records and adding racemase gives nine; controls provide a facet reset.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Axis, source, category and status facets combine with search. Active-site category plus racemase gives nine; Clear all resets the facet controls.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching results are shown separately from the 429,421-record total; the active-site category plus racemase gives nine and an unmatched query gives zero.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts change for identifier/label queries, zero-match input and active-site filters, separately from the 429,421-record total.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The browser offers Identifier (A–Z), Label (A–Z), Label (Z–A), Axis & category, Source. Changing each option reorders the displayed results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Identifier, label ascending/descending, axis/category and source options reorder populated search results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A cold #cat=STRUCT_ACTIVE_SITE&q=racemase URL and its reload restore the category and search with nine matching records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#cat=STRUCT_ACTIVE_SITE&sta=REVIEWED" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A cold cat=STRUCT_ACTIVE_SITE&q=racemase hash route and reload restore the category, search and nine matches.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#cat=STRUCT_ACTIVE_SITE&sta=REVIEWED" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The facet manifest totals 429,421 records in 73 shards; selecting all five axes exposes the full count through paginated results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The manifest totals 429,421 records across 73 shards; selecting all five axes loads the complete total into paginated results.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Cold browse.html#record=CURIE routes open individual record details, including MCSA:1, METPO:1000639 and ECOD:F.3755.3.1.364.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Cold record hash routes open populated MCSA:1, METPO:1000639 and ECOD:F.3755.3.1.364 details; explicit waits exclude loading shells.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Labeled ontology and internal record links are available, but some primary identifiers such as ECOD:F.3755.3.1.364 explicitly lack a source-entry resolver.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=ECOD%3AF.3755.3.1.364" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Record details show labeled ontology/internal links, but the ECOD record explicitly states that its source-entry resolver is unavailable.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=ECOD%3AF.3755.3.1.364" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reference-bearing record details link PMID and DOI evidence separately from database-source links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Populated MCSA, METPO and ECOD details link PMID evidence; MCSA notes and causal evidence are separately displayed from database sources.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record details and status facets expose SEEDED, PROPOSED and REVIEWED workflow states; the runtime manifest has 39,591 REVIEWED records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Details and status facets expose SEEDED, PROPOSED and REVIEWED states; the manifest reports 39,591 REVIEWED records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record details show dated curation actions, curators and change summaries, including the MCSA:1 curation event.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Populated MCSA:1 details show the dated edison-causal-graphs event, action and change summary.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record detail views link the record’s individual YAML path on GitHub, separately from external database-entry links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Populated record details link their individual repository YAML source files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Record views provide sequences, annotations and causal diagrams where available. The corpus map covers 344,797 current records; protein and sequence maps show 68,657 and 12,705 proteins.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Loaded corpus, protein and sequence maps accompany record annotations/causal content. The corpus map explicitly covers 344,797 of 429,421 current records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=MCSA%3A1" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Checked record views link external databases and other ProteinTraitsMech records; their main sections do not link specific sibling-Mech or kg-microbe records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=METPO%3A1000639" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Sampled populated details link external databases and internal traits rather than specific sibling-Mech records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html#record=METPO%3A1000639" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Runtime statistics show 429,421 records: 118,338 structure, 147,149 sequence, 392 sequence/structure, 163,527 function and 15 evolution, across 63 categories and 34 source labels.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing/manifest report 429,421 records across five axes, 63 categories and 34 source labels.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Landing axis/category/source links select filters in the common browser rather than standalone category pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Landing axis/category/source links lead to filters in the common browser rather than standalone category pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links connect the reviewed landing, browser, records and visualizations to the central suite directory.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible suite-directory links appear on the reviewed landing, browser, populated records, schema and maps.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The browser links facet counts and listing shards for all 429,421 records; complete detail is fetched per record, and map CSVs contain plotted points rather than the full corpus records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked facet counts and listing shards cover the catalogue, while complete details load per record; map CSV exports contain plotted points rather than full corpus records.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked schema guide explains ProteinTraitRecord, enums and causal graph fields and links its LinkML source.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/schema.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The linked schema guide explains ProteinTraitRecord, enumerations and causal graph fields and links LinkML source.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/schema.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Core pages and maps distinguish CC BY 4.0 data from BSD-3-Clause code. The linked SLC10 pilot does not state both project licenses.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/slc10.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Core pages and maps distinguish CC BY 4.0 data and BSD-3-Clause code; the linked SLC10 pilot omits the two project-license statements.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/slc10.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Core pages show upstream releases and retained map coverage but no site build date or deployed revision; the embedding date is explicitly unrecorded.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Core pages expose upstream releases and retained map coverage but no site build date or deployment revision; the embedding date is explicitly unrecorded.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The injected Browse toggle works, but the landing’s existing empty theme button does not respond. The linked SLC10 pilot has no theme toggle.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/slc10.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Browse toggles and carries Dark, but clicking the landing’s existing theme button does not change its saved Dark state; SLC10 ignores that choice.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/slc10.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Core sampled routes fit 390px, but expanding all 63 category values widens the document to 400px.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled core and populated record routes fit 390px; expanding all 63 category values widens the document to 400px.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "ProteinTraitsMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocked catalogue requests produce an explicit index-load failure; map requests display unavailable/error states instead of presenting zero coverage.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Blocked facet/map requests show explicit failures and retry controls; unblocking and reloading restores populated content.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/proteintraitsmech/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "search", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse searches by identifier and label. CHEBI:338412: 1 of 3136 compounds match; marneral: 1 of 3136 compounds match.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "CHEBI:338412 and marneral each find one linked compound from the full 3,136-record catalogue.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "facets", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Property filters and a reset are available in Browse. Exercised filters changed the matching counts; activating reset by keyboard restored the unfiltered view.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Filing-pathway and claim filters combine with search; alkaloids selects 512, adding causal-producer coverage gives 141, and reset restores 3,136.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "result_counts", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts respond to identifier, label, unmatched-query and property-filter changes, separately from the 3,136-record corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Matching counts update for identifiers, labels, zero-match input and property filters, separately from 3,136 total compounds.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "sorting", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The Browse sort control offers Compound name (A–Z); Compound name (Z–A); Causal producers (high–low); Gene clusters (high–low); Bioactivities (high–low); Identifier (A–Z). Changing order was exercised in the browser.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "All six options change leading linked records: name ascending/descending, causal producers, gene clusters, bioactivities and identifier.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "shareable_state", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Identifier search and the exercised property-filter/sort state survive URL reload, with matching counts and controls restored.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Cold navigation and reload restore the exercised query, pathway, claim and sort controls with the same matching count.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "full_catalogue", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse exposes the complete 3,136-compound catalogue across eight filing pathways, matching the landing and chemical-map record count.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Browse contains 3,136 unique individual compound links, matching the displayed corpus total and complete chemical-map export.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/browse.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "record_pages", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled natural products have stable compound URLs with structure, producers, occurrence evidence, biosynthetic loci, provenance and cross-fleet exploration links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Four sampled compound URLs open populated structure, producer, occurrence, biosynthetic and provenance sections.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "term_links", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Anisomycin and rebeccamycin display chemical, taxon, MIBiG and GenBank identifiers, but the main producer and biosynthetic sections leave their resolver links absent.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/rebeccamycin.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Sampled producer and biosynthetic sections display taxon, MIBiG and GenBank identifiers as plain text rather than labeled resolver links.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/rebeccamycin.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "evidence", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Anisomycin’s producer PMID:28373542 and occurrence DOI references remain plain text without PubMed or DOI anchors.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Anisomycin’s PMID:28373542 and occurrence DOI references remain plain text, with no PubMed or DOI anchors.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "review_status", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Compound headers display grounding and SEEDED workflow tags with a What these status tags mean explanation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled compound headers display grounding and SEEDED workflow tags with an explanatory disclosure.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "curation_history", + "previous": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "The sampled compound record views do not show dated, attributed curation events. Source/history links and mechanism summaries do not constitute a displayed event history.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/staurosporine-2.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "missing", + "note": "Sampled compound pages expose source/provenance links but do not display dated, attributed curation events.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/staurosporine-2.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "source_link", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Each sampled Provenance section links its own data/natural_products YAML on GitHub.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Each sampled Provenance section links its individual data/natural_products YAML source.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "domain_view", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The chemical structure map renders 3,136 compounds, the text map covers a retained 3,114-compound projection, and the sequence map renders 763 proteins across 303 records. Sampled records also show a mechanism/biosynthesis summary diagram.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/chemical-map.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Loaded chemical, text and sequence maps show 3,136 compounds, 3,114 retained text points and 763 proteins respectively; coverage scopes are disclosed.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/chemical-map.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "cross_mech_links", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Anisomycin links CHEBI:338412 directly to AntibioticMech’s anisomycin record with a same-structure/same-InChIKey qualifier; that target returns HTTP 200.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Anisomycin directly links the specific CHEBI:338412 AntibioticMech compound page with a same-structure qualifier.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/anisomycin.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "corpus_stats", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing reports a 3,136-compound corpus with generated source, producer, occurrence and causal-graph counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "The landing displays 3,136 compounds and generated source, producer, occurrence and causal-graph counts.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "category_browse", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Eight filing-pathway cards open category indexes. The checked Terpenoids page shows all 213 compounds.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Eight filing-pathway cards link subset indexes; the Terpenoids page opens its 213-compound listing.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "suite_nav", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "A visible suite-directory link appears on the sampled main site pages; the evidence lists each checked route and its target.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Visible All Mech projects links appear on reviewed landing, browse, category, compounds and map pages.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "downloads", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The landing links chemical-map coordinates for all 3,136 compounds, the complete chemical-search index and a 763-protein map export. These are indexes/projections rather than complete source-record exports.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Linked exports cover all 3,136 chemical-map entries, chemical-search values and 763 sequence-map proteins, but omit complete source-record evidence.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "schema_docs", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Downloads & Schema now links the LinkML YAML source. Reviewed navigation does not link rendered schema documentation or an explanatory schema guide.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Downloads & Schema links the raw LinkML YAML source; reviewed navigation does not link rendered documentation or a schema guide.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "license", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Sampled pages state CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code, with upstream terms retained, consistent with the pinned license files.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Reviewed generated footers distinguish CC BY 4.0 project data and BSD-3-Clause code with upstream terms retained, matching repository licenses.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "build_provenance", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The footer states 3,136 records and corpus SHA-256 2838a2004e52, but its date is source retrieval (2026-10-31), not a dated build of the project corpus.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "The footer gives 3,136 records and corpus digest 2838a2004e52, but its dated source retrieval is upstream provenance rather than a dated project build.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "theme_toggle", + "previous": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Selecting the theme on the landing persists across the sampled linked pages in the same browser context.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "present", + "note": "Dark selected on the landing carries across reviewed browse, category, compound and map routes.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/index.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "responsive", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "At 390px the sampled compound pages overflow: anisomycin 409px, rebeccamycin 407px, staurosporine 415px and the long dehydrohistidyltryptophanyldiketopiperazine page 464px, on fresh and resized loads. Browse, category and maps fit.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/dehydrohistidyltryptophanyldiketopiperazine.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "At 390px, anisomycin, rebeccamycin, staurosporine and the long diketopiperazine page overflow to 409, 407, 415 and 464px respectively on fresh/resized loads; browse/category/maps fit.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/alkaloids/dehydrohistidyltryptophanyldiketopiperazine.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + }, + { + "mech": "NaturalProductMech", + "feature": "load_failure", + "previous": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Chemical-map JSON failures display an explicit error. After sequence-map JSON fails, using search replaces its error with Showing 0 of 0 proteins and no unavailable-data explanation.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/chemical-map.html" + }, + "current": { + "status": "partial", + "note": "Blocked map JSON initially shows an explicit error, but typing in the failed sequence-map search replaces it with Showing 0 of 0 proteins; reload after unblocking recovers.", + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/NaturalProductMech/pages/chemical-map.html" + }, + "rating_changed": false + } + ] +} diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/cross-column-review.md b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/cross-column-review.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..32f04d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/cross-column-review.md @@ -0,0 +1,44 @@ +# Cross-site criterion review and arbitration + +Root compared all sixteen proposed rows against the unchanged 24-criterion +catalogue after the independent passes. The decisions below apply to the final +table. `arbitration.json` preserves the differences from original auditor +proposals; the source observations remain immutable. + +| Criterion | Consistent interpretation across sites | +| --- | --- | +| search | Known labels and identifiers must work; Habitat/Antibiotic caps and Community identifier misses remain partial even when other navigation reaches the records. | +| facets | Property filters must change the result set and offer recovery/reset, not just appear as controls. | +| result_counts | Matching counts and corpus totals are distinct; map subset totals do not replace browser totals. | +| sorting | Observed ordering changes support present. Culture, Cofactor and Assay expose no sort UI. | +| shareable_state | Cold/reloaded controls and counts support present; Taxon property loss and Cofactor/Assay query-only links remain partial. | +| full_catalogue | Complete indexes/manifests or source inventories establish coverage. A capped search does not imply a capped catalogue when category pagination works. Culture's unlinked merged corpus remains partial. | +| record_pages | Stable, populated detail routes qualify, including hash routes after deferred content has loaded. | +| term_links | Readable labels and resolver links are assessed separately from raw CURIEs or unavailable source resolvers. | +| evidence | A displayed citation must have the corresponding source link. MIM's component DOI remains partial despite other working DOI links. | +| review_status | Record workflow states qualify; relationship badges, record kinds and ecological states do not substitute for whole-record status. | +| curation_history | Dated, attributed events qualify; a single created/updated metadata block does not establish an event history. | +| source_link | Individual source-file links qualify; repository home links and plain source paths are partial. | +| domain_view | Scientific diagrams/maps qualify even when their explicitly labeled scope is a subset. CellStructure's unsupported point-activation wording was removed without changing this rating. | +| cross_mech_links | Specific record relationships qualify. Broken specific Taxon record handoffs make Community partial. Generic Explore searches are assessed separately and do not invalidate Antibiotic's working WP5060 relationship; their broken route is filed. | +| corpus_stats | Current live-site counts are described without altering the separate corpus census or suggesting full scientific review. | +| category_browse | Linked category/subset routes qualify; facet-only subsets remain partial where the criterion requires browsing structure. | +| suite_nav | Visible links to the central suite directory qualify; sibling links alone do not. | +| downloads | Linked full-record bulk exports qualify; complete listing indexes or projection files alone are partial. DUF metadata contains all 8,296 full record objects. | +| schema_docs | Rendered guides/class references qualify; raw annotated YAML alone remains partial. | +| license | Both project data and code terms must be stated consistently across linked pages. Trait discussions, Habitat standalone map, MIM maps/schema and other omissions are treated alike. | +| build_provenance | Own build dates, commits or dated corpus versions qualify. Undated digests and upstream-only dates remain partial. | +| theme_toggle | The persisted choice must apply to the rendered page, not only a storage key/attribute. Community maps and Pathway's mixed CSS cascade are partial. | +| responsive | Fresh and resized 390px document widths reveal overflow; contained, keyboard-accessible table scrolling is not document overflow. | +| load_failure | Exercise the failing dependency's user action before judging silence: Culture's optional point-navigation error appears on activation. False zero results remain partial; embedded-only sites are not applicable. | + +The final rating changes are six present-to-partial corrections: Community +cross-Mech links and theme; MediaIngredient evidence and licence; Trait licence; +Pathway theme. The other 378 ratings retain their previous values after +revalidation, with notes updated to current observations. These are corrections +to the recorded assessment, not proof that each defect first appeared after the +previous audit. No rating is changed merely because a deployment is newer. + +Review limitations remain explicit: representative record rendering and scientific +links, rather than every record and external citation; current browser observations, +rather than a full corpus refresh; no rating for the unpublished EdgeMech proposal. diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/coverage.json b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/coverage.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f694b58 --- /dev/null +++ b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/coverage.json @@ -0,0 +1,317 @@ +{ + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "receipt": "_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/raw.json", + "receipt_sha256": "b0d5a60193a7b5440e3af075f7f165370c51760d531c7b88bb51d84fa1fd416c", + "deployed_revision": "6ec4c26ca0b650f895b4e3d7d642e5d9eb22dda7", + "downloads": { + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse-index.json": { + "body_sha256": "066ca0225600b0ed63f4a49379ac6104ab7d95cc86a0f71cdcef74430aec7cdc", + "arrays": { + "$": { + "rows": 3125, + "row_lengths": [ + 10 + ], + "columns": { + "0": { + "nonempty": 3125, + "unique": 3124, + "sha256": "552de1b205a781d8f50ea3c05bc7453304f708af0dc5e78dc6670e07e46aa4b1", + "samples": [ + "(+)-(11R,2'S)-erythro-mefloquine", + "(+)-N-(methoxycarbonyl)-N-norboldine", + "\u03b3-hexachlorocyclohexane", + "\u03b5-rhodomycinone" + ] + }, + "1": { + "nonempty": 3125, + "unique": 3125, + "sha256": "3cbb7f52beb5a1bd5bfeffb154763f64099a4786ada8b38f602d70788bda013e", + "samples": [ + "11r-2-s-erythro-mefloquine", + "n-methoxycarbonyl-n-norboldine", + "\u03b3-hexachlorocyclohexane", + "\u03b5-rhodomycinone" + ] + }, + "2": { + "nonempty": 3125, + "unique": 7, + "sha256": "627c5778db1823beebeee762fb3ba38cab2f7846de98afaa1db7f2fd068bdb2d", + "samples": [ + "antiprotozoal", + "unspecified", + "antibacterial", + "unspecified" + ] + }, + "3": { + "nonempty": 3125, + "unique": 7, + "sha256": "5b80c666820381eeb56f76a30d3c570642fb7aa8da3d8156d1a5f2fc0f7e11b8", + "samples": [ + "ANTIPROTOZOAL", + "ANTIMICROBIAL_UNSPECIFIED", + "ANTIBACTERIAL", + "ANTIMICROBIAL_UNSPECIFIED" + ] + }, + "4": { + "nonempty": 3125, + "unique": 72, + "sha256": "0e7a689fbf0526fa9fd34b4bf62c45e106c30a0b8b70b5158a1c0ed8fc748ac8", + "samples": [ + "\u2014", + "\u2014", + "\u2014", + "\u2014" + ] + } + } + } + } + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/data/chemical-structure-map.json": { + "body_sha256": "556a0e4278e0c013118ff54f3b4068ca8ca9a05fd6ff5cec635359d0a23ffcd9", + "arrays": { + "$.configuration.radii": { + "rows": 2 + }, + "$.configuration.weights": { + "rows": 2 + }, + "$.quality.duplicate_inchi_key_groups": { + "rows": 16, + "row_lengths": [ + 2 + ], + "columns": { + "0": { + "nonempty": 16, + "unique": 16, + "sha256": "d36768857c55d625ae3749dac0de773d3448d9cfc1124a2b383fbcfe60743f0b", + "samples": [ + "CHEBI:132987", + "CHEBI:134191", + "antibioticmech:aro-0734abf918", + "antibioticmech:aro-0aefa62f74" + ] + }, + "1": { + "nonempty": 16, + "unique": 16, + "sha256": "443c66d135e9b83231051165202fe9e4d7e0e9d64a34526cf6daecc83e86b8f8", + "samples": [ + "CHEBI:2596", + "CHEBI:77009", + "antibioticmech:aro-bf39ac682c", + "antibioticmech:aro-2ea67cad76" + ] + } + } + }, + "$.records": { + "rows": 3125, + "fields": { + "identifier": { + "nonempty": 3125, + "unique": 3125, + "sha256": "2e6ef4d494af4df61d36a27d05cfd7cf54fde092710cc37d2e7eb233120c2be0", + "samples": [ + "CHEBI:10003", + "CHEBI:100147", + "antibioticmech:curator-fe92479d4c", + "antibioticmech:curator-ff4802fa87" + ] + }, + "label": { + "nonempty": 3125, + "unique": 3124, + "sha256": "552de1b205a781d8f50ea3c05bc7453304f708af0dc5e78dc6670e07e46aa4b1", + "samples": [ + "ribostamycin sulfate", + "nalidixic acid", + "PBT2", + "IP-antibiotic 12" + ] + }, + "path": { + "nonempty": 3125, + "unique": 3125, + "sha256": "f8061fdcf3d4bb3518b3e88bec777e4c7c4ddde2b338f7ed74394a48c515fe80", + "samples": [ + "antibacterial/ribostamycin-sulfate.html", + "antibacterial/nalidixic-acid.html", + "antibacterial/pbt2.html", + "antibacterial/ip-antibiotic-12.html" + ] + } + } + } + } + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin/record-95343524bd8b9a46c2cf15ba842d7b163a0657af0b8b83af023fe432efc70823.json.gz": { + "body_sha256": "95343524bd8b9a46c2cf15ba842d7b163a0657af0b8b83af023fe432efc70823", + "arrays": { + "$.synonyms": { + "rows": 17, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.parent_compounds": { + "rows": 5 + }, + "$.activity_roles": { + "rows": 2 + }, + "$.activity_spectrum": { + "rows": 294, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.activity_membership_collections": { + "rows": 1, + "fields": { + "path": { + "nonempty": 1, + "unique": 1, + "sha256": "9d0c9e14a44051d6a4f569d6db382865fed5b243475a09ef28097eeb2833010c", + "samples": [ + "membership-a37c45fb1a20e600de75799e474f2e0bd69cd13bd42d517882d768c88ca75adc.json.gz", + "membership-a37c45fb1a20e600de75799e474f2e0bd69cd13bd42d517882d768c88ca75adc.json.gz" + ] + } + } + }, + "$.xrefs": { + "rows": 9 + }, + "$.drug_xrefs": { + "rows": 3 + }, + "$.document_xrefs": { + "rows": 3 + }, + "$.source_concepts": { + "rows": 2, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.resistance_mechanisms": { + "rows": 102, + "fields": { + "label": { + "nonempty": 102, + "unique": 102, + "sha256": "082907642de1b23a1609bd68b4e9af07166b18f2c6214e3f4968d9f1d97f7d27", + "samples": [ + "acrD", + "armA", + "aac(6')-Ib-cr11", + "Mycobacterium tuberculosis eis with mutation conferring resistance to amikacin" + ] + } + } + }, + "$.molecular_targets": { + "rows": 1, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.curation_history": { + "rows": 19, + "fields": {} + } + } + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antimycobacterial/d-cycloserine/record-c489fb792a4858d72e998281186020388df8950340ce0a4b24f725bf3a7c85bc.json.gz": { + "body_sha256": "c489fb792a4858d72e998281186020388df8950340ce0a4b24f725bf3a7c85bc", + "arrays": { + "$.synonyms": { + "rows": 20, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.parent_compounds": { + "rows": 4 + }, + "$.activity_roles": { + "rows": 2 + }, + "$.xrefs": { + "rows": 9 + }, + "$.drug_xrefs": { + "rows": 3 + }, + "$.document_xrefs": { + "rows": 3 + }, + "$.source_concepts": { + "rows": 2, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.evidence": { + "rows": 1, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.resistance_mechanisms": { + "rows": 3, + "fields": { + "label": { + "nonempty": 3, + "unique": 3, + "sha256": "e722f22b836638b4bca92c9db5e5132d0fe2394355524e54f9eca30aeb174d15", + "samples": [ + "Mycobacterium tuberculosis ddlA mutations confer resistance to cycloserine", + "Mycobacterium tuberculosis ald mutations confer resistance to cycloserine", + "Mycobacterium tuberculosis ald mutations confer resistance to cycloserine", + "Mycobacterium tuberculosis alr with mutation conferring resistance to cycloserine" + ] + } + } + }, + "$.molecular_targets": { + "rows": 3, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.activity_spectrum": { + "rows": 7, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.activity_membership_collections": { + "rows": 1, + "fields": { + "path": { + "nonempty": 1, + "unique": 1, + "sha256": "d293923e59a96c33a7ed568e9ffaab49fcc2059cd865199a10aa4ece98d9f20d", + "samples": [ + "membership-22631023b6dca71a93fd60519c5fa3c79d2ed7f467966a445b206ca860ebea69.json.gz", + "membership-22631023b6dca71a93fd60519c5fa3c79d2ed7f467966a445b206ca860ebea69.json.gz" + ] + } + } + }, + "$.clinical_status_assertions": { + "rows": 1, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.curation_history": { + "rows": 11, + "fields": {} + }, + "$.related_records": { + "rows": 1, + "fields": { + "identifier": { + "nonempty": 1, + "unique": 1, + "sha256": "3e5f0987575ad0b64ce9370be6d120bbca6469a9de428e6f16ead861cb98286f", + "samples": [ + "WikiPathways:WP5060", + "WikiPathways:WP5060" + ] + } + } + } + } + } + } +} diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/followup-1.json.gz b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/followup-1.json.gz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f637816258319f902c952493da85482c00177717 GIT binary patch literal 35161 zcmZs>Wl$we*rwUIL*ovOI~?5I-QC@xad&rU+}+*X-QBHm4(>EQyx;7^&PHtgI#F>d zDl03Wtjz1a2&15X{C9wUUHDi!;d1_Ydj3F%w(pvEtdhb&(&fz+k!oSJ)z*{DDb&V? zt%D_<2ZdX987m+^?(KzHl1)$rA2YcgadnOks{p<8_)Uf)Zu)u75ADHheDyFLcR1Zn zc#oXQ=*C}3@ph(*wg@oW0gF+MyfS=V13G72?QI)=jryL94({~N?~UJTKKCLb`SI{f z-HnktuM3aqjDTfd8`5G$?S@=LG+xhlhL28RGviPYMd6V(EdsN;GlQ96@Lp?X4)A4p z2)MJ|h(3I8v`IhEM1FtW_GdFaGlB;DeQ5I+*-aJK687cZ^c6E^j{W`w92=rx&hE)h z8TUsj35#JkQjhs8@LoKO|EZX3|D#aGv&ey1K)BoOgqlAA_``Svg-RfwI1iE<1p$2; zEPAaYSa^zGU4SohkWLvASH$kOjrjcehzh4VoFGWqD<17#0)j2K9^EP64(Yemu#0-! zDf3m2>HYeivL&=UMcKYAD>xJKO9}%<=mpp5;B==J{cWfBIUgc6g2p^R#yd{nV0RMEmPcator6mu@VW$E;(VXk9h+%?GR>XmRo0Q8 z@7FbF(^2qEc%8XAX+kI%GDuhp*)7__;!mj=A+q4vCrQ%r@$%4|X-Xup;oZ$8f!w~r7wzZ~6IIS2=4EAQnGj~(58oE*Ha{o2|;pN{s= zCZQa?+~S%g$JHh9{U8MQOo+gzU~O)-* $fg}V9Ilaix3hM2b^XeZKIjKW z>*IH6H0|lXTwPw=k`JElluo+3KV6x-WSEN%F#aHvrUuctyE;{)Y;7g<^Y0n%uzGVD zn_TOt>s+6-*6zG#^>BuqS?0fh2wo!?d)`<--)srVaG8%aFtgd&mPiYdH0E{5N5 zPc<0d$?{%FREHls@b&yYE3BZ;NWMG>cXzhEad!lL`rqVFT3eqT6z`uM^y1=WR^bk} z-fCMB5&Yj}gb4ROeRvA(C?TFTHeMbDy5knrA{sqo@~@u8ZwhO~$%LkgX9YJM^kGX+ zwkX276-V3U{G7Al%!yIdA@Ac~nLyW{Z)pbAQbO<)e1FYtYQsBMQXnaYi7m9zgc>0MmE#^Yp+63*xW=Q(3c<=Xx@@G-y&!;|0= zf6J~pxILBv?p#zBc9xJfZs>Ns@Qie)xP}SJ~!gSWAD3YJDuN`m94S;;VhHj8x zmy5{hXV!%tUgC5;?rBO)f<5JEC~wJ^&F0mwpyeW50$xX)MQ*vh$~mb9V9A40 zhFe(bNx*0T;6h&%ETwQJv9nu?-`-a|_KBdtet@%+1&=tF3WZjTmMN}eB?Ym;3h`OX zu?ArWMLb~y7V$lDoNkz(wFr&^=xP)0TtDsv79#Rs#*C-SS12DZUyFNmX&*I6nUXAf z1L>PvT)T98m7a)fcRjAXvzbnG6p|nAms7cukI$zcSI;+J-9J1&5MS;y@KH)??Mf?g zDDpqSUk^L5$(;y~JCE~IO0(yGQX`XtrJ47+GtV$;P>B1$BF9va&L+ufCz8I?-Qt=D z&-k*d;x3uzMT;s=9Oxi%mm*@7flP7oHDNF7QbAZ+97*|BpDc_E0yl(DlC#j!@KQrb za0DXE0MBLoOH->{kX)9?Cq|&zAW16BBSu<3XZorvrxMX85j;flhue0SaJjOpd>V9E z_6-c0F$%8#<(U(w1OwDEL71$`s`nda)J{%6>vq5L7kIh}sZsf`8NWnjuSfY0nfV<` zRoY@=mOuJm_ANm9WY&dNCw$*Y z&jLw5QE+?KCd!)@ zKxIey%>y~72!GDJofTtQ8V?=0G5e-uH&c~bo>rt*8ak8DWv7Lu@evXQxnKFLumd5qbJpZ6i1;v7EJRefI3YH!#g>0*hCT3f6y$T}Wv4%ZR=CXuPyWJyYLuC)Ypq#;R}N?dZP%EyXMMfKph0IQnKD>8RFRK_Z290b)!0=`f!l zcw4dz2}id4k0%}3c8aCts{;j*4{=yasiEr!u>W4oLuGxY7neHW-#F^*#9 zUhnIRfRbz1nU0sFUJ-Cra(|m#l6sFR3-Cc-1f1Rr7rW=q*0)guVb^RwmqsX{(9b2c zSt^X&;;Uf(i5Dr}Mf6%dXKCBaPk*%sLtnR$;1H^xi%4GxiQ=^iBvQ;YL_j8)$#Lc% z3N1`;tRV^3=saOv+dO3@6mCdlT336ckIn@Tx+j+r~%Qh>Wv6Kk5u+X{B1(PpUEWVWI{yyOO{hE30=*~8Ne!+ zuMC-A!E?%MESQUvJdPZ#q;YET0TzUKOa?rs14M1tkx*2>FB-L$CL$HvL|eagdeHMr zsgEvjIAWh zSeS?35KITFCOJ4oq5iINxWZ|lf2SudsAe7O5S4MFj4mBkG;=`HC-G;1HFNWbQ%CnP zCos9Lu^Tas9^Ipe{C9KFK{YLC#bBShF|v*)i+CzsW z<}A8H;wbzSxE$r{UP3)m$ZQMY_QXx$wJqGdT5;SpgF}83krC~pU9zFME(0tn-eFjY z%5iR_+9l+3UFcmlBX5!^)xqq)R;JLMI-*G+gY%xOu1riaUCHj3!jKIC-7bu4wQ$5Hv&Fx_O!R!nz^j4f zhWEKyI~+Lyw5uMN=?u%he_NB+>0iMsJo!j$)cfLF8RSwJd3{x$etBb%EA?8kRctvS z>Gs-4v3jwa_>&ZLFW)^li0ZHE+QWrk)QDb;oAuSW=pctEAE(B?_ZKDUYW~(?aE@T> z!+Y(z8O`9wf$zcgMt{Zd6H4FS?|&|=Cws&4<}=HfrPVH>tL(XwwSqI#wzZ44H1F}T zqc+tmxK@Kk4Hxm|npT3m01A(Dwj+g51M;cOw{-~IAaW1AEfCENCj4FkR6uIrV=dCl z#-TpqE^3{|J7ql4Deb@q)lHnK1Xt;brq>fE_md{Oz~!bnuid2Qk#nqp3j4$QGp)>! z*2g(-+?`J;GJ+z4@%mNmA1IuD)npMZh;`Q48%;zu{G%7ZzjmXd3 zTAKH6ax&s5h~@6|@^b;x(EsMP zZeIa$$QMdU%^G~7eIctifw?uu|AvuSV3zxX`PSnLj-vM_A1|AooY&ZX^==`0eJn06 zw)DGPMw@bE!leqL&!_NqoNsA-9S$wVj~`#QoIgVLt@i6`8}=Y_n;W#Xlqc7+%U#>N z6tI{+pl9eq=4%049zJV5A=r)cGmCKjqQna(@5;uVjHRDws@#^4lh5|I+%k#2xcAQ2 zgV>oCIvvi*;(gf9YlUE3iBKNptY|nycVi! zZGy!Z?GrWNm!s@9IJ-J7yY=$(_TMc|V0M%2U$-Ed(n?6d7WD(*cE;0d=iA*f&~?U2 z&6&4feNJ&S`}i`e(=RI*FQ-W{iwWC5&_X|WThPy;_;=}+t}#suOzwQH$dpVXel}@RLrP3}`&pQe;)w z<`euGGkVd^x;&c)yWAbvtWg0sOt&hqtm>xk$&$tbEHsT2<+h+VJ!_D4Cs`o&k265;>Yn4U+D&yr1}sxX zI8!E-EuD{T$t2;_DqDn~u8%!>jd+$Ki06EZORanfc~@(i{~)gElCsFs-~45H72Cj= zMGMQBJU8DBuKFivvu=rBBC^JB1FKRD9}=~MTods`I`@9F-%ib@dO8KnX%Uo^ia4It zCm06HVcu%e^;Nu&*+VJTg~`o#9$z_S)zk4kkhd4v7?jHhKssmD(50f`4^o zhqW=?v1MqCWtvU5Oto@A#iMp&Fx`kEij+KGX89RKjy*Z62EPX}iewxG!fGl}@tC$i z=&g#&gG)r874H%@0{S!Dv>2vG@0sg#MRcPx1NYA}`e)jR<*?*)lS6{+7}XPXu`(s1 zGj(YO+52%>v%}Q0RP2%G@YAR@cwRMJYid;&xCSC9QV{5kf9pYV%yA~hqiPZR@pc6Q z(#Tc{_DyA#;W#!yvv0D&LrS~v6_yobY)j!4_PLr)WR;}TR6|MT-Lp2)u@-ptE8a4) zNGy7VMWz#i)=~=iagKW(k6LcI>IvS8>ZvPTz1coQKcWbm!BsJpaHn5bJUD+>L*9mm z7*s4wY_yg8Qd?@DGig0>?lvUxe1Vs|a>}5Z&Q&wKWP$pXz4g8_h~J0@4Nf9gE#+t& zbk8OjEY$d&V2^vOULDI)8P2haUT?i^d-b|qKQB{kw<^Erx@_<45hWNGbfMwJcT!FA zy^$jaS-Mu>!9nNmUY*Ci`$-q135Z9B-}U76_I~}aMLk3M8U>vH{7C2|fE~QgjB@)? z-E*``K#wS&y+gF_WQs+KTopnAAB_J5)T}*dFJ!!blB`|io%lfL;{Anr*U3Qo2>s0a zB=hv?>Gg3`y&=SfmmM#^<@f#`A+kX>2=bEgYVg|vG>8VAiy#IVXTm`mRS1#oVGD4#ctK(u+~|9wg3%*+=CsH~^t|0&2xMF>smrslNZ!8= zEWi0roFrl7vwI6M@N8k+BR&j+kYn<|P$WhK3fkDGy@XMM!+%6BTlMlfl(gtbiSdw& zl(SGVr{tEC4!a2H4Q|Ub*biW330Uq^jU~UBarlH9n)s1nA4Qs=P?v*1kL-vq@spxa zf5xkVn9RkJA&voH@~a$xT>Z(CS0hGgudj1>8EH~cNvdF-mm7dp^sk?gwE4c0gopx zieJ>eRIQBg9Z+fO6A%-ApL#!Kx|^rKF007!FCX3HRY+e=KOBDCLuE?sG1A@oRM0!p zCB*424|j|{W}!`}j{hmHDxJ?UPlFmCQ4y(CP88 zM>K-}F8o_FDP$%Fszog8%H^rQ}v! zliOP`;an;pL{q*kU(u%b>X(hIx40xUZ9iSo4{sj==#j~H>Uu2B6#?Bf-2_-yKO-5J z<`PZgJGEYmS9s4qJd01Y3{$;2JhBOFG}HPg6xF@Hu0L2kEE-K&)6r{NgLJtrHD&Xt zWSOHT^m|*LhD^JS*Z;m8bdJ!7i)mCRYHw5mtK{nOA%@@Np)vvZS@)6YT3ao+s=!9Ic;JG)lP9~%#B7B7P`2HPN42M zN;e#n+5?3~!2i9dUd|(!c>6X> zn35hsXGFYR7tHynUkO!CPq=+kj)BD>PS%2sA&HiP4!*-m1inmiWzm?OYNU>-$Ezo< z-+N^3p2brQuIdADDosbBVU4koXK=k8G~v{J7V`gBT) zdV3nbtGOpdiM9MWV26@S8#DDtC$ja@jJTu$veF8-n9(Awla4=}?6@D5qSZeSQay<_ zCV%+lP=0-iB1fOwwdA6?fe97N)|& zxF6E~S<}LnR$uL;QHrqC0!7W;lsGbEg=7Vl%k~%DtH|k_|EDfU%dw)vSC~+huTe+a zEnBEaOCdA)aMW<8!QTZ+9KQ%YgX$layf zh-1^bh8}cKfEW{KQvF^1xq_gq=4ThK^o1$2^u-Cjh7kjDrW4s-2>jmJ=8@AD0?>Q-TsV4omg^E)^V%l zgIJ9=Fh@aRoe--%c+*57HDLC2!{xLaWMg!=-zM>sTFcqTrJCvxnEH_Sw}iq(NPW_>cJ7h zG|EV6^!?1o+XN+uE<+}BGmaLO3u(dAn+a@`;VSMNsstkttl_{gwGmbh4s58!yJm1) z5gH}*Wh#XawB@#+Q4UD+77U=+%(~bv$T4?PB3@S^3|ig`5J^OvNBtD_^d%hKs~RK0 zvIY7D=!fVq=n(fqntu(9ORlMDDYTX?UK@%SvJ0n%_@-Bw%-46b2QT^^uU@(p6!YzL z(rHMd3zEOqGy^PVe5wJ(;SiSoZjqGb9K}lg>R*5Va4M^>rP3qyN9u>;Svu83)tkAE zZfgqc2x;nt^lTei>KSIHlrmy4XbGOBsY)1sc1FWQs}a)h$tob<$=#>or{!Wu&jD+u zPVsV|RL$v{Zof)4SZYSUeCpHZGYU~Tx5qd`{r31D!+H*C*c|oL1zo`El|a}Y zdzs={v;_4rK(f*1(!7m1tXWGl=P+ ztEzz$>Bt8UTUFU0b|V{XRjgW?O=ag_K(*tTd2mvY15B!@w>Zrh6F_@JbIQY}20NN@ zl6Z#~rysOGesjKu>(qZIsoV`eh(x4voW!T?7H1~yF@o!cmYplhD%vT{t}%SyqL{qE0nBARE0>a-;5a5|M zyA2F<*t$bg=KktBU!t?@IxjC3^^6`v#3kt~sO*3`GbE{<67bOeimO7DdzioBhL zFDuA!es-b8GT=H)Jy~s0HA$c;msaZFa&%wFlzOF6*}5>U0H1!gzQ;DmrizlM&s-54 z<1&yX%1(N=tOC2LF;bT%Ix7QnsII{(Bds(>4z{<0xpw}Mt1QdhC-0R8{m!4)g*2Pc zu&wQtNW(E0>W^Gb%{NHPy;=qlg_uk8utRWpyv(4TqS+6*f)t^-ath%7V93LAibm}Z zVp&=K5n}{n^xi+=Q1WSpCgTOT{^lP5yyHLvJzTDtq;2A|36>V*&ou> zgT34^uZORVjNfHtso_RQpPr*8VAld-1VpC~cut~A4p9|Q>kBX*YjhY)_?n*IUX41N z{eyVjsHIi{!Zp#CB&-XVW+=`3l!y)2HJN*0@=Unlb9FG3sE0T1Jve-w8heH*eJ*T5 z#T?)4`qI_BaBkxx)FkU*P)u}rs}HL?#cmpign<=tNyLY)U8!8XY9-*H^$W<9=Y z1ULOw7Q61{$i7mYkQNv`1f7;`sN0_5?@@!;&!C! z6Xtw6ad44@MeiQIFKL~O_BAdxu72tSS^6kbYbK~O7wL_cR_PWFn%xxqn5CgJRuN)g zYnJts^<|!%{UB^`Po35erN;UK{cXRL`Q$7rsF+gc`gRJ$X+%XCzSf=(waWK;;`edd z)7##E3`VpNO-!nTih_%Pd5d#QmdNHfFQ1Pu!+`tMSsIHbCD4<|AkPx6^#{O|d@#P? zHJ9oKe7bJgujIU3YpPQ3r9htA~M+&SJtbud^q#P7NJ=TVb_v)O8l@UWr4pO z{b2j*;U!PdCJl?ZU8&>cK!DD2ts_0HPIujx4%Zhs-sWBxU;Y)lM%&MBvpv1MPotgY zel`=I6F|IvBbe&U8<`%W+HZmr|C}>I6&%xilOrCU8yc$&49((um_H7e+;yk__j~;^ z2hZrTK{oA=Tny)<-0P@C@=()vC#(E&yN?j710E6fr6JCFzK|x{O;DMDwB*i7q7TOJ z{>OB{x&uY+w0>YQb$)}LfE4Hy#laxh$i?+&V>fovPTcw}gz;&PC)a`cR^-u7IgTgx zefK8RSaDnjo*kIcgBXsS%ix1_s?mgu_|tIu(26aBUX=bMZPH@Lk^pm;JCyG!N}xtrd_c$l(}FI__U(GxdYhhsPazCMc}ThK=ikGSK|qaWO) zcBmX=CvQJL=3!E>X-ABI+D)AP2aKq+y2hb{Gnu4}$ZuDeh*9lv1piF{onK2W62hPOjB zEzni}@S*B=o656gm+X@ZzTfbsj*ndwUJ2u1 z-Mph)kkd&~SPL$4Tp5P_)Y$~E06Y6OoCa8u)#L5bk~{gB)kRfVD_80iz2Y74 zeKR282}PI&HLGvQudSr{r12jZQQ>ZP2e846-1NFsTU2h0ts4grSjs5|GxDbY2AXF% z7C6uI5kheO6vo51`~Gi+WznCE!me}|6GZLvHqObn$^vInt30!{6>vgzTMkc?*=X*ImK=a zXik*|`x(5ssRxUe`B^e#Acq#>?W6}7;Kh+ae)c*4r3U|qNpT38oHz12THEz~;0Cdq z>HBHHA5R9*A0mt(zAA;V8gU)eJw^lyQ^wg(k{_9U%(k!p-cG(|@D*OUu^p~&BhOx$ z@x-|b-;bq{$#916iNStVn`AmTDIN@*aR!;z@X&q#JaMqZ;d2Jwas|RRrwzWd zGzJ<>*s|>>iqIj?!eE8+g&pB-lxu(-E0lsan(?fW9n7;~A-RpOZ9^VR>N1&a8oVQC zA1`HWqI0p^O<$JkwmclLX}vDeV@JtiIZZ()w7bKpO~mk?Woa6v&1NuvhPwwQN41)W z^3=qt-6A?U{VM&zWJaCaKZhDlvxL&0gFC*DY_MVia-3u^5)F1S0dI5eSkv{xs&ynB ztR0+@aGcM@@|4Jne^RjO>C~IykXgj8+}&917Hzdy8lpc-`!iwXf52JvDBw#b$_h_8 z2W0iCaXiAQ`{x9blRTTSD&jTf{>}Qu5?iX^DD{PFhy7RD0G3~uG}xgWzJ@C>{*`{T zSSVsd->zsG%RgYQ$qysiaG_pOFrwKQ+V>73Q(y3_ZZP-xRc20Uff6geSR@ zPNN63l2>9Kzb~1ZP0d!!2s$^oQ*_m%&S@0(!xLYW2Rw)5jx!? zSC<`MT)PzLx?qDjxq;*6JVxK2rBVty(CZ3W`rQ=Fh@w$cXHPj;;~AyDGmsGejLg_` zKNB^`cav7(rfn?m2%@w=_M)fPr+@Np9DO&$A#P@5Vvl`iI+;2YfNEA*s?GaHP~?rm|5pFThbx~@|%Apc#69bfeM`z7(wj)up&1huYe4?8;2!u3%9 zyQ}$ktdV(>4d-&J;Frf;8ve*w9~YxtIB~;|MS4x-HmWp zPft%rZ)@~~ef7=c->suUH)v%@1SgBc*wT3J9d*XAuU^;b&ne-vbFkpIf5|t+j^=n4 z9y~v9kYb8@xeh9+qjSg=P8;ZT2s#2qAI+Ei3LeF8lcuqFZc&M(G#?^7kfim2VMsL( z#$~;ptgEkjL*PN>TsmX==c&(<&uy)9$hl<_Xs4MaS9jT7w`eFX9i^s{#LETyhA*AL zqZfjYOrq`Du2@w0yJojP(mISz5*TSO#(u*l!}|=9{0|=dF2x7Q=Q^(oyd17>;f9k5 zfCTZr0~Qz~=fz^9-l&tf@$qG%Ua6Oe5Ts<+=_N>e{H_mCxp>=ky?Mj)>gG9v{j$1P zSRv{ijD*jp2r(vg3PF5r{yPHoOg;?!>(5hnmJrLnw98uX6h=G)hFDh3iq`|lgK~$4f|NjC*qB*ZI zconEe4;GTZ8BOTNx&Q1Y8KE#qa0Egl961fV%R!Pj-m%-D*B!;zx1o>$rCR`uB_QU` z8!s=h>8R~GR3=-!EY1;e41Y-ip66IoIUXBJ1hW#Avi zhcyp1i1>c=q}l&X4jEr^R`Y34`D2~C5tT#AmyCAmarz~P@viNs zvgIx=KE($|f~gH9%>J*}FqD6#DmLDvvA)E}uKiOO0C(Twl$dd2pV$ z7aJQ7ZcnQ=uX7YuuIoM>zHFRV&O4j@T%BE4u(PuWT*OPo#id_(MVv8;Jg-uf1O=cd z-9Hvk4qMdHwKLHl71$p!UWSC0k3JPpz*v3kX1TDw_j+=_E$di8nXT{uXe{+w%mF=X z1PJV?XKDBCrhpBBQEEODhJOzpUa91TGEE3HyoRjbP|DEEJry__5ItLqQ63$PC&=vZ zrHj^)JlSYf;GQ}Y1t*Vm{7va)gi>t-Dg;k2k|&n)##Iyx-Oht@vaGBzWOOvK4mZ#H z4ERb%d}VtKYk|Z!RBc#Le}MT7j4la_;--u2D}j%Xw`BaO(FI$L#=rQ>xr-`clIg=c$*IlU3I% zL3h&s)l90{v*n2%yOASSVXB3(^$Ajwt_Ychs&=>SG*w)Q5u)w`C;yCRY&*P>E!FYq7YsvSN8~xu2;-T9(4WAoFQXjK)wj0~rmp{=qBf zK_K!GU-qN^CElWTvD4$c&Y!#VEt}vye%47)JZBNe?T)F;)eRVSPBF+x$@6+yNpCPe zR<43G)lC6QbK2zpe5s}`ex1YrUiSWP!wPZeTd-<~r?rF*|G)LBAW2#u7}By)oipd> zxaa%^BXqJ5PVqN#Mp$?C`hZ__5pN{gOWrDQj5t5!sOOEi86Z_*|dh z4w7zXk>y$nRCFdCK4K6_KA%W*Jd5hBBR>09|2-4PTjbj9HR2c;G;0)-W5zO=%RIN&r?2Vp{?+Ps;*}suXsTtXgd2uL z3A^9l_337*-%e2He(q^*2!v>K>)fm8t8XutmF)bb_A`63cALVRr%$!!$|tTBQjLRS z-C6kaP%rWOgF?XZ9D1+YPe?8`ct4o3PYFV+PV}sT=}HdM4Y*_$^PXsB2@IhSI0WvYHf>%Zi*>nDy|)AKg25$F-zLC39gebS$hE zDEA6J`96f!jvWW$=Z~+Xh?*Je_`;)T(m4?*#9CZy(h)OvB%77#K-Ms*3{nBVE| z!H;9DRCBUGvk;slfV6j*W-n+#3HayG!Ak={v1xeI8MEnv%3Ccek_-xxEQ)>_X%CC! z`wrX_;b#2h}(fDG?t{+=z$ck4zuIX zxJ<|ei=z_Bf<{t1z1ElIEE zb~JJ&9i{NkpEwm|k|pao)01HLf0`yRtb4Ue)(tj1*`~mR?}oGTV4Vs|#2RH%z@X4d zYPkb7Ytpoqx}x*Xd@5zE{EBt^10vPVb`|&ziPj1JY8?F@~) z-i%ba}%o8xf zEfZEUAVrtn)2f&J(mMB_bZCgpPAJ8gvQPYH#5`rhxesukqLGAs5t{Ba9|JbNG$jYK znM&&|kjgWK_a7n2m7HHedM%KIEm*DLB`# zs-g6=G|hSKq0T-z83xb}zb62BtCzjxXsA2lnb-bg?WG***htREXWPP@*-6f&P9LIO ziE2GnrrJYy<~1U?Ql~nlDPc@T;1u{Cw5YRg=P_pgmPKM$VVeW&>9p@!E$t|GC*;p8 zwd+YA^}d|*Dm>b4}CB?J+2x84b41jVD5;U+pE};GR5pww{X-1>Dqg~4qDCQ zX-$UNt7+njH#7!@=CoQX_%xTwDpi?Gk(BmW?JO&tUu%N6-IVXEURPhIiZeX(>;-VG zQ@!-8V?ypFFkn^f&(0(Wr9xWe)wj@h9R^$ZUs-{VxI${Vp`QQwkP3avnnf!r=rMhjv zEOCLbHH9zO*CgnU5h8yDFaB}_a9z#IG3;|oEEeZ(zB;DfR6^(~roR~@`TmdkwCwAn zP%sU15S5j%6A<28`z#9v7bVNavkDcPcskpgN|j9|>vcJfa~TWz*EfyXc+e9U3I+2% zELe?fvP)hS&~Z0@Yf5ymh7i6TIxlXW=5IC zyqWPtt%gxq&`O||y>=Un45jhhlr66~=Z!5Ld|9PXAq&|bOHrZTn)l|B;$WuRKECrg z4r|&++jX?Dz7@KJwtg+{YCci0iTsc|PLi3!Atk$gY ztb>bc0~3Cj2RkqST;uHMF-=s|_}4}X4_wEhyGwOBL|e@@1vV?Xq4FdO+9(b>MEBN7 zLdPoD*KfBReMqb8#&spR*R#!3CM;Lfv>6cSKjKWe^t0N`{t&tP6^2Gx+pe~RF*^7I zEmO?|`hL7EO|eHE6KJ98u7l;Co8^iR_uh>Tda(Y2h-{*X`8u*)D(i^q zRcRic&mocG)T9r;2A9oL_YKZb7+UCW9nVpA?In$vg2*54-c~C&Y9(CS)ha?KQ}mdm zhxR43*}TZ|DeYRTG1N${c;9c16EdtRpDm+w$HgYBb%MwZ2o65US3{UVf@C3dY^eWs zcl$d~!gYQdTNR5fkrlRe`fIcXdR7Z>(}}eAg1hCohJ5WE1!m3$@27nx4Bm#mnvu$~ zTXzT$o8J1#FQT%SMvOmxn{~ELnxPzzdNR!0SK=qjNX+jbcx$AVvmz6+Mvn=|dY(0+ z_ir3RWa>PHY!Sej%en?`fEsE^a^nXLLzzUC>V%9f^0o@jGg%~s569pMX<)T#gHJ{T z6UfGe;3CvmHS~Lqhsus~JZ4IxDKi(Ajm>kh`b%=bQr&BnK={0?6KrAO`oB79FKk|) z5Z3U`CTD7`TW}YrFa1$zA=oLlgrEd%=CP86(UQ@9tF4~Z^C<@Vkf~kCH0h7#+KWLo ztKw?{Ory@dT&ZkXmA$ zsF0IL;BVXC^Mn+`p^j$aB}%BzpbRdG$^(Chn%jOSq*f>I9c`SS=$<@ZLj@?oqC&__gmeAWCo(D zm2tY;WoNb0HN>E$-_R`tfTvy$wQz2-SRy8ka#1<(Hf zs4Ai-lhXLXhOF^shm2rSA?8f9Qi^-mRf2w1PZ6Qw=gV0Qr$b%ysJIxlM=1*17`DzJ zt=WwKHuOzV{*SAIz5So7QfdbjI#G>pdi~E;5xZTv`~UG&rd~cKJP$TNEIR0`YmXiV zPGcNd>$_k#2cSN&&w#TE@_wP7ugpt}x%oMtVZokS51EnZzgvRqZ!h$oXCjB|L5&FT zIiF#o#ORwMOBJ5kqr_@{I9RxWg<^95ve%>hdoYp{e8(d&D zPxoXVDNLPc-4BtO3{>4~!H&@gHDIK+>dBe^XG$3>_8l%gg&f+IaZ#l)9t@DM;Y@?} zXKfaw+VaFkNwDeA(DyJ#U;vJdDcu-iMH#-SF3r7etT-(gz(mbcM%*X`46D@?7>=L0 zJ{Fk%X@i=OmSR6e^Gp#ZMhgWnZ#gX{h%*W(Qn$zWxJpiZ&vwAKopNbouDKe~VQ?K; z-b_0`nrUl@Y46#^UcDXB;lGGJH!-dubQ^K8npV9KXpBT~u2>6TL&xxJiXIIRV+gA& z>n3v$n6p@^w{aDy43PM3X$8&gYWf3BClY700ptFZ#vR@X+}O@^4wJ=^ESRzLy;6w9 zj?(DVfAeAF7UDreY>3L~BkopkfD! z&W@CDEnEhy#G-V&S?U<5xN#bg|6S7)^L-8ABqikENMQ;{8uMhK%Yot~@<;2XdkW+aSd-E zG&`OFtyz)z``oX6Y!_VS|C$s$hEM<9e@}rP+TT?%B`qp>Lft^T^R6J2)`)8PZp~wd z{hbUP-DLBUFinC~rC$#Ho9bt4U=@_;6W;1r`mr)qSL=Di(Zb#xXc^w=Jo`=QL*#j! zK!Zl;!T?_wr6%ls=IjmT>_g@!8;zZP<|pfoZ{J7M?AyWl-`BAELGHzNIG|TM;oY7O-v;`RHp$4lR2f%)(RbRbbCN{weTKM28b%W zvG1#N9M2&#&LB=C!YEZ*V_Jy{x-qKn+S`FD?Pm5Z&TfQ+3S}ccBmJBWhcre5_MJfO zphms7*i{KmUuZgxAMHSO7v5lKE*Ej}z@VxyL^#5rm5qkXA5}c#9Hq;PzTjWb5JbvX zdx+PdGvx!=jff{6!Ad;LWqp9wz&4tq4&Ff5gVrB)W@1GOhyW}uVG1xNvkZtAF_N@# z_G9#<{I2;nRRG&wYb9K;>XfWK(#pS8(*I}M;7UPOp3e>O4?{Y*t9eraXVOQHfD^F( zFQM>YKpDLn?H0|FGlTI2YlSO3h!x#_LTWC)&^};EU<#X$EYRqUom!#F`>qVDudG!1 zJH2U?3O8kOM2Cm-C8!z9L+MY;%&OPef9)tY(zr<+3-y5*$kL@0OJv=2qRe z9Kn_Clx`@G=V(gKHV8Kc3LuSpTFM&nE<%sSVvFN+qk3#VKpHQ2(oUIPX{Cm+TrRZ% zGl=2Yq6V9P;OnrpTR;ECRUFJeones@U$Z1(VRU01DfK$%I!5Qg8A+DC4UDDb*t zIP|W93qACMeesAg@Y=sq&sR0(9hCeZ0JG4`M1_r4(xiNLH%lBdZU zlPp{~=2|z{X5@Efvk2e>!%#VjHhsD<4fd|+Dxk34NK!Bh&4eVhE#Kx$bB3K?l-we->7B{FlI$kyH`8wxbLb zjCM=#?AoM%+YmAy1EaidV~jR(_$qqnC`rb4a4LdR+RYQc>)=93oI-^H2?AfR-5Ot6 z;~5tj?@2^_|4S}kdDL~!1_>z9e|63i*C7p5{KU90n<&R7X8mv8@W)xI0SB0|DGS3s zzgHqQAP;7{OH~Wo9WtnfL1Z`FJO=}R4p~H>18^I*&bKJG?MmNV#htTb5e%DmpkzbK z!Yh7_z~>r2beg*SR1VGRnOkB{*!eXC+t=c6jOS~caH8)vbkA;_L-G{9zV=^6t>wl$ z4jrR`XfOl+0V{|wm`3>Y?`Xx?jTR+W++u!G>W8rz(3#4IPtLvoPF;?SV3sQ@v46cD zV=I~G&kNrTCq0lW7=dXRtx1hE)&>suUCjSl*{rcj-Vf#2+59cOe7 z*w=yi79#x9z3|U%1?io{zu7GM>fQzEt!L~tfh>e;^>BiYTA^Fh-ETC0y4X2rWVTy3 zNr6^zD)}B_7_dH7A;*r@fd;b(tF9(h>~Tvo*hhTBJdZVlShMyvXp8~JyDW)z z6XV8s4w9*n?6u`d%Rf?=$6}Wu=xJtSm%VhYox7%TffQgkfk;An=95~ol@c7VdVTtt=mbK7_*P{;%DDYxj@N3LL z%}&z%U&anrTJf6sUendkzlT^A|IP4suHU*(_A>}e{pVDBh>R}V0m*md{CyVz&OvNR zk?s)Vo=!vkM4Ohy=}`-{sA71c)jMn@V+urvZ#~B3(QO zi--60!@ZPr3B3ki;8(&LPR$f5{t{M^E*}E4CQ`pca{p!D@ZbFn^{!*=o3;NEJYIzB z6iId5u0ix25MRlugBZ8Y4iCIg7Qx^DC=IT|s=eQrz)aK!F`5D7%s>DypZ^zW_Z(f< zzb|^fv2EM7oyN9pHf)?GX>41KZL={Ot5IXyzO%o*&mH?b=g}DVuOw@XjHYu$IerTnB`DJA;@asDH;X; zDR8D2j>2(%TL-~yQR`%(%Y8nLv)FbV|3}vL}x!VDc6(c(BOR6 zeyNjUJLAov91m8BcC#>XDSQdv`!qBm8g8wM0W9A6jJ||TjU2@gkg)nGdvzpZ70T5C z&DMcvrcJ)8O+VjdXL0R4;@26Mt%Fd$i#Pi|rsP_Yv9R)j6pTr}G%b8+htZ)!-{l)4 zc18|nY&x=ZWiwhW{1t2<3m0;sD0^vM^S}Yiw!jo_N}@5&4MM+J-<8}i)ZQeVhr@<} zMqWDT$hCUIp8Z}&@CPCylU}9eu5;}x(xgqYyTi*`kJ|w5Q62%9 za%=qrBa;5lAJ1&ZLNm_=9%B~pIgjDUMfA@DouNfFxBXCiFbIc>6%C8I^8!>{DO;lN zI))vJ?ZaKc#?RuPe+X}~yG35CMV7>s&IvHcqL#s;BaLrT@LM32bJ2{g*PBYgbgBIG z{j{o$U=|ydFaM7z%WuVRJxvbsm3ol=9Uwu-7h0ll5qH|g3ZD?>f$!xZhxl?^xpcKQ zljiwSxO7AqA4jukIkO7pOw#irsuKHU({#%0qNZiZa3kSm_wtLYs31t$RIb#n=-@2a zHAhm9$RH1UcnRzOC{O4F?#Xc047dd>{|lA3<7RLIW+zA|Gl!f?`_x?i$Oj2eAf3Mf zB>}4sKHO8bI7{^Z3o0Ko=3I!yFgq=zEp6x57mUE*P~+}*5Dz4?HCLYdg+ZemV(l=2 zdm*IJ5oz0%<7>sM|%h_>7H2zPiR)+h%4naAs|L zODZCoVK@)}B4snUd}i;BefvTKYJ*rbD0X{l$;v!8&xbpmE?%s_!&i~tdt-|9n}v7D zF{x1cV;R3b9rsY>S<#i*T-dG@(3}wxoFGL1AE5HL8QlLwW&W)NIu~1)9Kz!emy5eZ zSksa2k9=}Sn~b%bGxphScpjhPpNr5FRz_ih;PUVq^`Cs}1aKWF=UEP1#*G>SV$^*` z3@(pu?)C7*)2;9{y!vd+5(4@sE*a-y!Ekbc2muF%C(vU1y@T3yGkHHYgL3pVR{rRinm zkYozdW_H&hszpXo{x?%DYXMBTyiNVTOj$y`uo)~Bcf`=f+0j$QW%lTO0S6UB|5<9Hp2XiD1m`?7pG*iI$NO z!F^@~gBbD5q4&}R3OxEHr#+3l^?oMABe?_7)JLJc*SYq8zm>Nas0yr%O+ zO{geLa+E8^ovWi~sz!+`ccu8)B)~RL9GK0v)8`?D%2OtuNR|V5qqvO3s+Y z2Z%4^31%z56clt!OTU;-kfFep^1`9GFsPD*(i=UynvIES;5Vy*AH6;i;YOpD{-GA& z!5szH;8Jyq1H~vq{2AfH;`<#{)IZI}gP4g59v1o7%ftWf==?e)%fGDyHw$U&VBv|% z*@dUGyREhBL1<0S|HawqZV#-ji?8R!J(EzfFi28e(TjgDZ*P`N>0>pOeSB}Qt42|! z=3kPVYxkd$oA>>$za)2D|F7ic{=)trk~=2)FUbv610*-G<*($H%>Cagc!@2>-Z$=G|cyWvj}DMT!J+nY3$CX_pH(1DXj$Qa;HibpLOJ&GZ!S~^MO zHq+KLpx7uPjAn(MMiLcFh|dZr_Yi3Qfx#Rc_EUnivF0wt>6457KHH4}2i<($ckOMy ziDwLC4vI@E!l~3dY6h`F^<0|7;@|$+9!3csRtb-Nd|yWQ=KUn6E;V*F%fo?Lp)*SpOy2;8FXozb2dH z2ewQupeQEjf9~#G(zV}Mo^i`{_28uRN=b&PDrwcC6YZrfZI#2Ii9x=rv67H}i$S$F z=G+J=#Hm5_<7Z*-xoIkdDy`YGyqz~EiP#+fF_{3PoQrj+5JFWF~l< zob+o$vqXkPt`7NzpN)5RX;2}%kvt-0`-oHQiF>^u!AB=CMk#c~m>f)|rCyt~iN6i4 zHNWKjNPgx@Lh_V4FZa)Oir-JGx5RWYPPqwhlXcy`#=%Vxa=GD=?CwRKXiWh_L@V(W z`erxViU&U1fYaj1*>qG=(Op+gG80+%76++iY|Dj=oR8Too&ktX4VZ=$*Qhj-vaFck~q;SHbBo#c*fh=!4lVQ;mDtD*~SVnqXVTEljwFD z#osi2uTU_6m1&GQj)Ei_DU%@Dt#osa5n z!(kJq+SqF8{rLj9fs^@Ev6#^RDaUpP{{Q3H-(OK3|E00`!_HkPWBxd58K@wfHqA>Q z`)m)xzvuSI`6lG1I7AEzIa3!xoaYX!B6Ry{ODS^0#C;W3Geqj+Ca-1mJ?R&QRG#P^ z#8mD^e@N(8CD3@s!PYp*suo2i>t;;6ZTjlH+4}CQ$O~92v5pAr{RhXkv(C&MFQrwh z?eds+32_mlTZf^`_@UwDJfU{S4wD8*OcyuCQ9=n-*Yi1Fw67+Z)(TdbSD2G}&o3b* z99Ct2yVuT?M0CXya`xG~PcA1gUD4Yy;(fBla^O8cX++%_SNPu^J53nY^#AO!O3J%? zlrN8>!3E=PKaa};or^^JCWjqx*k)t$)mnIZy<$pik{8+W7F7{-RG&`>{F)QNMA8Xl z*xPFyDq>dEOme=~GN6Ldp~kgMk52}nEq6^DjeQ>P3h?TSbVK7LuEy=SBy@278gp*S9zTT|~&&?G$M;M8L^HP(2_E{Em`t#lwhXrs|_Q~{we*R;|61uaeKS}RXpfC|L+M-wycvq80T2I^=dX}+Q6yUvb^ zXu5|{uA5aBM+&nfYtPE=Ln-zQ)v>N_HnCAG@l zP0knI9V?&W%`!k%I(FAT(mMF)UekAa?JP7EV^a6!as74JdU%|T?+H*BkowXPUk{$l z^X>&ZNPWJdEzeG`RN+K?n|%PrmYg=*zF5%*32>2A_7Ljo3_I(aXFySfST{HW>gtN} zXVE#UCx&2cz|s10BLse7r0wAfT4RF0>qT^s3PF=a|eSXtON zseZ?_J%KdOs|i8ThG|`(WLn;>cSI>J50}MZ95cGA!=^0=a=7>DIP&O$>9{=j@GnH;%sFGP$W={}SS)ZlYGOE|y;g`c z_^+93<)t1Eo4aA%+hP8ECW3a76T@d=ZNFpEdK@Gt6f?ui+D#1Cr%n)OmgJUp{H^=B{Mnth zr^1%Gt6z+CSeyrzoA|40im#_Usf5_q^6oP%(H{9O$d43p7LZk1(lLm@ckp+`+*$wU zq<5inRUHAnFE`Z${`}DUiYh{9l2mUy+v`bXnFWauLT?-w1U34bE<#e+)V zcaHBj5A9g#9)wo0G)Gp3dj;M1+)AMksx+PR1+On^`nx)$L>=XkZm}mkG)WZ+6tdci zV5TdjuV(0m)v!0ouxpZ`(@!{<+Px$*-OWxvdRG;eSqJd^5GdJ<$da0&Lz)AZ;i__!%vHEH(6($Gu)~mk#>d~MXGBlJxM|R~WR*d%ttG7MFtWqo-kfR1yLVeo{fl}` z3qEdJ*qaf}z>k`(BE-I0Tq(BeG?1b`HXO{N(#x-lc|sa5;{648HVWFeE9-~h2$4(9 zvZW4@obBIMe_{KaHM55A49?8(@{8?7IkZt|->9~@=HJkgYWbdK9Ksd+F?r%WQBa@^ zL_u0S_Y(UvsbglKuD5^UYu@E_2F0$Qy13-*Wqd2qmZ4=3Y|nD_9%XxLsaGJhgZqZF zbU4*2@gcU2`*!r{LlNrHpSSm84&?oV2I}#QUe$5P<5uNKqchH0yOws1vjAlrnO@@a zYG;xQC3{)IyF3q!7F*lZaLv$S{oZ2*$(J@ZSPu zm3OojO$dDrCaU0{10|}zGh3wktA`CSK-F5Lgf@s+9!^-`0+x7H22DB&+8>xZ zaOThRji&+G69ZUJ%q9zlxb?Toyr%8PHD;khv1^6FF+l~p!mOM2&kdu%_V=wxITB8RD`b#_9t1Q#A=w5M#AtjDE_0?iV93 z9$2lNjlW^`wEkpk;VCEN8lnJc_Df9?YG9{iP`AFE5B~H1;e0PW_DN}Y7$feZx9Xa+_a<(=m1hh6h%nOjkfHm4|ohx9_|Wr%JF>O8!lt0 z7?hG6q0ffk)?K9AJ~U~VGHOwRC78pCuTBAs5DH0Rw`foIQf3E@3{@7;;XRhPtI|Da zjkR6))bz%5|y+r z7wA6&@x%m@7PsxSw$6!*0G_2mDopEm!T}uHt}2jEN`<=QTfH&euymNT^52`^N=O^5 zpYSZ0Mi%YqF+GV(*|p@hSl zHQ3zE*5p*v4a)|HbELPcs{Y&n84bWelL$Yx9Q>*f2>l3B_sy+z6SEwV6_&>X@^%#0C2<5$3P&( zEDz0uhvXWFH?6?gfNU_3HHizi1$Kz?)!i+iHlpq5>?iI=26?@tFED>*XYMfU5RS>&QZ;mwSbxk-cXW!?mkf>O>+)vVz`#66|emRsp=MHeT#v-&uKX7 z@NLS$Y|0^Q>X(Q3gegvF)>Emxt`T-imE>TUpfZu;fCfNE(dued)I;Q&!q^RPCTi-M zpxA71Zr{}h7&S$;ZdB15>k6k)d~7{H3C{j)O)IB&!9lh2QrPCJe_3ncRbNS>I)_B2Y6f9q@Y*EsVavbvYgmvBF~D zyaB5e^g9{Y6c#p8TRHv}3Irozcb`MdZf-;ku#82hH5uxHKdH0Ja64K#z7HjL2(eKup!)bNqK z>(*G=z>apP3oAF@Vqgcb=5iBCaF{}0lFbmaSj7UBi~fo za;E3)qf69&Jr~VK1ovLYMv$IJg3BAuKVRFx{4#HQ9sqUY+)te_a^2!|L^Pghhv<;? zai7Rp_Xb3oA#(yXz~x6gHtzb8m#I2Q)QTrNtXY^14Y1D0T_t$a2I3Ct@7VD-e%TpMxM zo8NiwiKn2+d*lFL+gzB!ly;!ipuWCxN-Lqd>XsAM8o$wV;I{Vm`Y?H zwHSyn7P0CcKH;5|2ri2~RsX)L`#KlkY$=L+m45qol7PG?1=@ar{_R*{rn8qxe(Y+S z47iwsDX(Z(tNIAn{@xG_V;w%Qlz^JWz8s*;ny_tLFo?i93MFT}JQqA|mzQt9>`f-m z$aq`II9ljj9o8~d4QJZkEGEyWTpePE*0#es*x{+macM;8*`q-j_} z7{}}0pDf`&M*n%=5rfBu?N}0^Gx&b(T}Vhkh#8yXF(4TzK<~)`Ool&T@}s%j5WaRz zB<(2jBT^h#laE~&kg!rtdwB%LM|X@zzC7MvUyHtdJWaY4`E5k)+Ohlps!D!&6zqN- ze!4steD`vByL;By!}jao>FMY$I~e1XKHtG{ThPRSD@~7sJru<8>%`aV@>Ex!nFEK_ zOj+5>r_)mNmw2Pn@kdu&iTa5qgz_Wlb8gy0?QOE(V;+A#$hw!?;&WpA!R`?2-x}8T zpBk1~?%y@6!xd1&sx@6{YsX0~0E9M|(XkwMBOW`5x zyPT(Bl9$9`G3@~<;nl5Vaq4;rTLRdrmw8z{K@-C za9$H{kq|#b^^WR@M*rOR9r1{XB!&^hIf|f%M*V_LvcR<7V2=^QD9iwJ#059;`*N}Q z;-9*;qcw6t9${U1D2s_=I0OzWA{i*D$|`R$4|T7Y@8zRJoI@2Q8g`#BYi?twMx@2jgq%Jaw{d~e-0Xp&r zcFYpWEbY6}Vw%s?$#il!kz~6;Xc?;-EtBK&)Wpv1SgtUc^N5BoM^b|}=*>{)^Ce?p zX9{e)=tOHxuH*ui8-^})aN7;1BiWtkl~)#bo~77-&CxqvXhRl1K$>OL^fP**tg3PC zeEqoZu5NR}AHDbWgXn+QYTwSN7ay(P^Q<@5Z0e{uglaE+)tIyV$-qZ-&Xp+*zpz&B;J^;EzBrMNGBLO49QOUSi1Hx@i-S$y;3KTHho>&1?W0H3 z8&fxSz5dOIt+U&=m9vJCkcqr9ajaPqDR*mqp-KFJeiO|{6Rx@*OL?i=BG^0Z^<5)AOs*&cXgsr+cWNvh0YbUzmFx zK~3B67--1@nGQd&VwE`v@HLIpe)!JETDdt@ev{gy!5aSgd!%g88KkuJ3r=HWJe{zd ziT%$@8zk_eVZwF_PdRa`xx*3t(D-f&eIw5{qLh1g`p_5Sqsp#|!17H>66|k`sL)jR z`R3UKI4R~o{du#UKLV6Ns7TVcwybJzL-uJ*93w+BUeiOYOgT$USy2{82KNqv6@}CC z&{yFOKw?^Zc}hR9>qpUF+8nc+D>*mJEB)DME-$xFb|%-)SgopBV}ht^V$k0MA z84ly?!No^`goLtDXzt>>FUo!-|Ex1$jJqlzeh z*25kQYeL>ZmW$Ho`i+16LUs^Q+6F)_T5RTi`$+)468rr+?}g0C)8J%vYdy7QS!|l< zNl5alf9I{HU-FR2VgzV?MKBZv}@ z1NE%2YWT?giBu<@WfFDr19oRfxQ?V~SwuY9ZkAY+SavLHMv>upw9U6NSGzEx2{Gfe zs3gw5d0305ql__^)Jf*d89Vg;MN`Nwl!+~-*F_(iu50y07-!eft(u!OD3oW2r*T97 zA`j+lK5HiSu4!@$l31lIVk$_##+6dV?KlfD&t#9#R`N0GUT*00Nisn&^(#Mz&vZtx zD5<*P$kL396JT1l4Mu}xK2_5}_!{9@T6c8Bt>m?qm{Y0I)Fl0~9fGQq@?9U@mql`0 z`Epxy>3vJA!9ru`@8qhFCGxP|nRm5IYc1T51ssWkB;AU3`+p9a8ujQG(T5fBx|)i7 z;7_^?h?@s*qzXDeHByX*)a7#5w%T*%6QKS+8eRg5Sk|Fbrj!MN6VB8@2h^WZ5&*xh z)>_NSDGspN&5u*(dp7AU#KqC5%UY~SDqxE(Z+s&n*umu;&w(VG*Z$g1t;VqLtgN(A=j3U*@tWDbms$a{vzF^6mrLwqNhhdpou*9?{00RNsk>=@# zf&h;i8)PXsu56&u8rk`mmGp6gy;ZjUUMJcGlPl?HI}WX81B#R0B%eg85vQ{+=5#a) z_)2Nr*wD^RCO@Wc_(Q56l4-Y|#=Ib)XmJ;M3VljVcX?De)3L0hX?%-VZgy=1RV{%a zwp&!}N|Ul@|B`DtQ2N2S*Jvw=2udkh7Afdk2ki}KO-QKUj}yEOT-Yw@RU~T*y7ntL zP*U-qDPgEcL-nV05iq!4XN^2LfMpaOgOgp&TFWDW-PG#k`+Ztue-PwYk3dl7l)RdU z)kN-wAA=KbopTn(&c*?f$S9nkMn>tOr!qywf@tKG_Hs<#+PmxxdBzo-17@C*(8Q9LjKQ9(~&;!ejOz!n`C(M7QHc<_k#iw_Hh~jSpfY(MNXhMpXFQ|H|5#O|%I5 z{#$jw`mF8?;gx89gqVIP6PE~@Fl+TqIs;?4St>1!0JWT&ktQ^sfJsLmD{-gk6abhmw zRtXcwH`H^8PKNaE1AJks7{LNqla4{Uk-NHL|Io$dcY%T50NhWX&oG(?M^B z6D>T$56nnb)o>bLF&g0>xd-hF2i6!8@5)(r4<|tuUHAv}b>?iem^|B>3wu`f4!oR+ zsT;%)0?v0rL3i9}S!%r7=ulH-$n%`@Q!}ZkYQ4#RCVASvLLNiZa55~rHo;64lzK)v z8``BhjrE72eaHylFCr-$7+8!xrRELKt^Fjvqhq?oHPmA*FkS=*HhqB{yx;rMt>uj* zdW=>60y_mD*dbua@eXCcg0pQGLl!t@5l{^1q5bsg-^QB{EBy6hGzPx15dWU zwZ2xNVno2LH?9PeJ35HF2<51_K7UnB6(r0@v}fh^S%=a-Jz6`VHFEoD6GuE3sEVmeP$)=* zv+fmQEX9-lbdFJJ${fISC^0!*$>VRdPd9-PkpCMKeAuAOHIXGz2g2tH>G7Tt2!xp z+?G7P>s=4NmQ<_xOVLzq2hlJ_R&{9RN#~e#095JW$}6 z$Ftn1KCvY0mtE$twP#rA3jEj??R$aDEWChexZX zni6Y*=RQGy=S#A|1&lKiN$8l=Nw~_E?fl&~aFQ+i+DaB~UVmErph;P^QK}ZyV4iN; zwgS0iXc=QOWtO=5p{lY^EBxP%?hnd8la9aHL6(owaG7-3QP9jvRi9*&mh7|} zD_LmSrNt-9g`Vs}ta86#K7nMmCV4)Sa}q`JJmY@4=66TI5#*Q&sf6k6Bt@?)@o!Vt4%7k!8HOKHr6~WBs`ZSL6{E2narV#XWb+b-d zT5I*@wjVWS!Yk2fiXA97a}EP*rxFuWz_;V>CgnWL8nHKClo1Hy9N25gSupa!DTR_& zv^i8rR@ABzS5vMhZQLW}s8=D4|w%N|2$_I6_U020#5zY-6#4h zeqrs6a4R)NZZ~sAj8|+bj;b?tHL$hh(XMOy+ho2T3sb96h>9lxGY^FZk8cC3h-6|;? zwyzv&$6I+SVAzwbEtH>5h-@Xd>u2ihu6;i8uNYI}s#_9uw}Ij5jCFYb9-i*9zGD); z|MI>=3Wrm4qTf07wU&~g53vqwj(C2x`!xR^rM6WCLyzS$MVeG{hg%D_4tw9%`Wv%8 zlN7Ua8F&#XYdWKhGRi+mYD{=>>|zIpIg7riDLJQpXNs<(o()dij zVw&dI28>+C8Af%o+KceAzm{R2xM)fkN}0P&JZQ)IuwIpJ^=;_mL*v_t@9PhnTXSmM z>*AiVt*0`=J%#5}rhMIMH!BoU8GDnWc_1rVi%oL=`-6Xi%DLouJW-pZ-!9=(y!Y-V z?Zb#yiZ#2bFTk@ho$PZeM(W?~7bWP$l+rMow5EOoWofbSO3dG~)UPyyCXIcEl(d;M z10s;WWsrLHnVXTc>`T@6$3^MJZ}GWeo*qv6x6V)3o%PFm&w$S+OpJvcWu)zWn!Tup zAE?euuj-ZaX)cRTi({Iki>0aoiW}l7I~JKP!3c17FHmH64*M7FI<|yu7E2a{>t&Zk((N zQpKomHxl@Xe*Ksm2iVm7iLHJy z79ouSOZ+s)@7$R<+vlyCH(ySB2rMA#DPPFzY5C{=NoJT*CYV7dA-rAX@*)S-zQ1b zmOWpit$fRH0ztWuugdSR*(BqD#xw&;4>GU!RKBFefYC4m%R<^ROABVX)9eKEA3ooO5qe-ZY{uGQgIXP11SbK3ySp#?q-0UNx4E^NjB;%g?ys~n98uGltb9`ET+u*XW@-{o8c%f?v=eJ1ssD1qEa5tB@ zH2!&r$sUMItsNXQ(!0v8GEi}EU^4h{-JBrA4e&H^49t%^HhC)dOoRP|VZr@jRoHUl43FXG@mYpnvj&$|SPfglrT>^*doX@~^vVnh6MTvo zuv)#YxsGpa6<=m6`#p2=)pBvvj7D@tCa$=>Vy$i-89pVY1jzs!(?`Oznrl%WLo9%3$!=Mbcy}cjf8fNY;qPgZ z|E@_8XxQkv&g-Zxm}!d-?@R1Wm4o6pb?3DW&O?i;hGv)6BfD)rfY4NM8QK2UI?2Pd z%6l`=$z8;b5wxOtSB1-Tuf_kV>v?%YpD0Ltk_v$$q|YiRo(okjy@ZWI0^##}3Q(Hb zFyXIPaT{C&7rbhHcfz-3=lOdk{;t{3%^(UwJSq28PP7^~F)s9cEk8iP0tfhim`U`@ z?O3~XP>aZso_$4`#aVdKkp=g3h6mI^W(#7ac|h8m~a51Vwm ztN{e$2l<>PMj$nPO6GzIw=fJv6-mK6wdc41mj#ZbTD4H#=x$KajeWWm{bNhZiUz!6 zODX}feU?};3E!%k=H58J7RD>PYdIfZw&p@r(~wJ zz`ZL29gOlYbT?=*UO4Xj0~^NhqDw3$-}&U58w&;XoF}~!M7)26dPwSvk<~ccE%zab zR_-04Mh{ei1#humVZ0%&K}K@x)aMexb+jVTLQY-&bu43bXb5*Uc$;Eiyf)Jm-E;;J zo5opi_R|zSyaTZ*Mt_(1-`Es`Nxcvvd-ihbdj#-K8hgpO+01hphazR6PVh9mdPSKe z>cw~33>Oev@r*6o%5^|&Nyp>jxe|sbQK7!Kqt-I~kt#9N-F>>r@pvbh1O|AycAx5X zvoqy)rFm0F`2sO_c@S2^@!?^Z1P2T~+p{ z<7DC5#`0u+<`;tMo|bKoq3mIhE1Cf2CJsb0&(gDi)*A#u1hR9z8Dw(6Yy0^yg;M!c z?4Z>~xLE+TsqBqcw(Z7367=z!kje?dm^yTdw zh+A62@JsdnW9j(w!UpMejp0%MB4Cqq=VFKOF}mo9f-Ozo%g_-q|I!`Ked&2c+0C8k zt|8H{VU+%=F@x>z(J_s-r1M)8K->AYqi8yH5EVH3ynBMKpsl1UX~ozE4|s;M$!(bEv4x!pti+;+Gc7rX?$jB+3{$@ikWR! za5Mug$4vY7oN-W9!)@z(_Ekq6+S;koihXC7-0Bj4d5r3QTq(jsX8+CgG z_Qqx$KeYTO7kf1uIzrm~;-z-w%v3{&xrNrOPd{@yvoED34DonW+ivp7zoS$CH!>)}%e0R( z8c6tobDf}Vkr6}E*Rpj+KQ9ZE27%|s-I=stCuJqvvXR|%_1#ZFVWL0yxv7p*rqb`LafToolgM;X zvGG;knn%QihY}}w-}_BYilB^^T<#Zo65|Sd%&h)2@mfVAo*j1gXqHYCQ|@5K5UefS z{>YaK(?j>5mym_#XN#AK)8=Tg&`=Rn9LAt40=zRq99O<-)7Ua^GgrRFa1@m&A532> z9L?9k2W}^X{f^rO?$@WS^ZOtcncwy=^N;X_-9DV8Q0>W$Q8gqVVC|FS()@cQ(@xTI zzoNIMTVE#+n|}Lq;GfUB>|Ae+oo0x|lB3w;^gt@(tFW@=aWqI>Qaa(AB-lW9N+WyR zERGO8`R{DC)D0U(QB$(a9Sn8OQfX&t&^5aKV=s>#ypYgWgv}#X4vwJ#t!tF z=5)cDO7uA@(Pzs-2KeMtx%w5=7M(iDHRb@?3;a`gsMN*%W1rDynO`LvbM% zO67+i?nh8OhOBPzZqlQa8jt4>$`misbX-7^JBg~rwZA|_B-UqBWJEoX^tAm@`kYs7 z0+(OwF1ULEO+;Mdh=z7+H)5|d-R}456&lOPKZSf3}icO`i6*-gAeGNC40_nqMi(gSjIn60zCt-JSI}dAePBkQisHH4At>!UL0CDR?cP za{hGad`a#KgN>DO3x{bjYbgNj7LSV3C_Ar6`fY$g45D|st|lBghWhQ|K7{t~^kPg= ziv<0y)>XA*V0tks_*nK?vDY80+#ZklY^58t9O5(~ihHNeWBXzRU#FwNHViorp2o+))gs|n#)F!?*Q*RPfVpx`@m6C6`qIG#hl^^|S1uZ~5EASJqh%|)| ze^zMYMqHFoU`T-z9tyAFxrpEfE(${0K_kmx8XSX;^isdlScEVD@N0|OzD77 zEJGs4bB9zB+d<#gqvvg#kJ5+D{Cr)}`*x}-k&jbX|1e;s$oTOonsUA_(?zx4OAEG; z<_n<^k|7i45)=p+*+cO6ci78&Yg>PLebz57(I2U=Oh31JivorZJgy$i=2(!f?sf#_@dS%X2z`q|y8#?R=Yq!xb4(Zc+slEyZV zo!pK@n&dH*28*n)4kwKKPRQAv|;Azxlmm7&H%6A(m+F+uVk>B|PtrEAx4_J5(W?`^fV7?W(1(jCF^I<60w$^#Ya{8=K2Gu^_jkRI()eMy zcvvm5T&Y<7!zVA9kyB)b9tgsg<^{X_H*nZbWiZ39(pTheeE}?-Ayrh1AjX1yPix3T zZhgfY$T4Cl&lg5NbZ%uIC9aX2nc(45NV3rXpm>R_We|{k+orbP#S0PO3Y%dImYZX} ziH%F}h%vT`SD7wn9T{5lJho@KF5tl~yU}(Pyp|_>*?~dWuh)g%MvvVGQR{B&!Vt2k zAE0@+0dds@8I@D-%fGw)Ini;j`1)4s;%_E^??x2k^&m-gd0Keb-tTZfRZU}(mswD_ z-o&?`%yWer3Uw3r$lo_j;ezhDJQeZ4MZGa;7$x<}UR2|9LDbX|?1&%I`(hD6a(jEZ zdbWP%Xo!iIy-$38H{4j&(_Lv+IbemPZmviSOa8S5e@GE_tDyVMZ{EpB4 zVD~$ByG9FsTZvKci3^wP@WqoNcPiUQG# zEk;WUrGkXOV~$XpNeHsSITV051>(mvwJ*@=%S&A0!ZoLu%{G{Z(4I(DTh_a}Zyx4- z@IkiUB^1CCjd%N>pN&qtw;)KTrl{TPAG@Y#V?^6Mv$Hb?`1A*-HgQj=v&7`+oD5Dkv^aY0c6(5$j;kuY2KDjfx8dDRRY<-T zc8)9i9WiDulBy}?dX-R};O=JWl6w{U%GZ=)-bi-tV!b3WNDevPn ze?Q0L1T-O-`k;g&P*W5=PvM_1qZ}y7j}SKIugqcbT)3AWrF_{8wE;pzqNOfI?la0F@!)CCMIbXtv4rBsYG6zfp2|Aha*lmn{BDbsYAN)a?; zG{Y`J#YAIx7ta))PoX1)mIJWQIhX-@iq1$RG{Ir2e^FaTC7;w=wy5zz^k?xjb#E;T zdu#&Ia#5i5co=Y0pAjOI<)DFFFcvB{cVrLgjx>jylflk4h8+A#O+o3nXSc^Tb;jdv z_vGaCjC5VQZ*^#gwtKzPw$&M1PG_*h#_071D~ybDqwtOCGFM#pmDh_4{6;<)ilF=# ze}zHi(ep(QUsL>0C>EpeP%JJ_jno|vwM68EEJ)SFf8)@od7Owz2)kwW%-jS74<7`Sgb^yLf0hMO z9sN(^*!U-?FFe7?Il_-zO#M`a315CxAPyeGM}IZyVKfAGRxInJ`>YO#1q~I>xX<3| zpBEfr+^+M*uAZP~6sk2AQ#%_#X6hD?hE9~&CRU9;RK4uW7Xr|Q3cbs2pM@I2<)c z%U$k4&Qa>qU;5D>tUlr*A17S@4kuid7cagLp;-a(5Dk)O`mUR;_G7zu-s_xq ftQK_1Nw@$1+U@gp``|DC`pf?S-qIK-FWLkEobZ>T literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/publication.json b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/publication.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..852f506 --- /dev/null +++ b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/publication.json @@ -0,0 +1,714 @@ +{ + "mech": "AntibioticMech", + "started_at": "2026-11-20T04:36:47.111384+00:00", + "finished_at": "2026-11-20T04:38:11.711614+00:00", + "deployment_before": { + "id": 7723164727, + "sha": "6ec4c26ca0b650f895b4e3d7d642e5d9eb22dda7", + "created_at": "2026-11-11T22:50:52Z", + "state": "success", + "status_created_at": "2026-11-11T22:51:36Z", + "log_url": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/AntibioticMech/actions/runs/43115053023/job/130841034602", + "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html", + "http_status": 200, + "last_modified": "Wed, 11 Nov 2026 22:51:22 GMT", + "verified": true + }, + "deployment_after": { + "id": 7723164727, + "sha": "6ec4c26ca0b650f895b4e3d7d642e5d9eb22dda7", + "created_at": "2026-11-11T22:50:52Z", + "state": "success", + "status_created_at": "2026-11-11T22:51:36Z", + "log_url": "https://github.com/CultureBotAI/AntibioticMech/actions/runs/43115053023/job/130841034602", + "site": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html", + "http_status": 200, + "last_modified": "Wed, 11 Nov 2026 22:51:22 GMT", + "verified": true + }, + "deployment_stable": true, + "archives": [ + { + "source": "raw.json", + "source_bytes": 2328470, + "source_sha256": "b0d5a60193a7b5440e3af075f7f165370c51760d531c7b88bb51d84fa1fd416c", + "archive": "raw.json.gz", + "archive_bytes": 202544, + "archive_sha256": "68982b13bedeb2ed8307773c7e35a58af0071c8fb02dcc901a6945a15f0faef8" + }, + { + "source": "followup-1.json", + "source_bytes": 317999, + "source_sha256": "6b2b42afe3650aad2d3d19d9e74019e0aa92b49c8e3f22159b62018bd7877334", + "archive": "followup-1.json.gz", + "archive_bytes": 35161, + "archive_sha256": "80c7ef4eaafaf9b5fb377f1b2541b509d9200eece8ad9bfdfe0fed09f8be5677" + } + ], + "pages": { + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/index.html": { + "status": 200, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "", + "cls": "stat", + "text": "3125\nCOMPOUND RECORDS" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "stat", + "text": "2782\nONTOLOGY-GROUNDED" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "stat", + "text": "281\nCHEBI AND ARO" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "stat", + "text": "174\nREVIEWED STATUS" + } + ], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_index_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_index_html-mobile.png" + ] + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html": { + "status": 200, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "" + } + ], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_browse_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_browse_html-mobile.png" + ] + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin.html": { + "status": 200, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + } + ], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_amikacin_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_amikacin_html-mobile.png" + ] + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/avibactam.html": { + "status": 200, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_avibactam_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_avibactam_html-mobile.png" + ] + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/chemical-map.html": { + "status": 200, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "map-status", + "cls": "map-status", + "text": "Showing 3125 of 3125 compounds." + }, + { + "id": "map-search-count", + "cls": "", + "text": "" + } + ], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_chemical_map_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_chemical_map_html-mobile.png" + ] + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antimycobacterial/d-cycloserine.html": { + "status": 200, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + }, + { + "id": "", + "cls": "activity-detail", + "text": "" + } + ], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_antimycobacterial_d_cycloserine_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_antimycobacterial_d_cycloserine_html-mobile.png" + ] + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/map.html": { + "status": 200, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "map-status", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "" + } + ], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_map_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_map_html-mobile.png" + ] + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/sequence-map.html": { + "status": 200, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "seq-status", + "cls": "map-status", + "text": "Showing 132 of 132 proteins." + }, + { + "id": "seq-search-count", + "cls": "", + "text": "132 matching proteins (25 listed)." + } + ], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_sequence_map_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_sequence_map_html-mobile.png" + ] + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/index.html": { + "status": 404, + "error": null, + "fresh_width": 390, + "resized_width": 390, + "theme": "dark", + "saved_theme": "dark", + "background": "rgb(23, 21, 15)", + "counts": [], + "page_errors": [], + "screenshots": [ + "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_index_html-desktop.png", + "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_index_html-mobile.png" + ] + } + }, + "actions": { + "initial": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "" + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "search:CHEBI:2637": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?q=CHEBI%3A2637", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "1 of 3125 compounds match." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "search:rifampicin": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?q=rifampicin", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "1 of 3125 compounds match." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "search:antibiotic": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?q=antibiotic", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "553 of 3125 compounds match (first 500 shown)." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "search:no-such-record-nov19-audit": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?q=no-such-record-nov19-audit", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "0 of 3125 compounds match." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "query_before_reload": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?q=CHEBI%3A2637", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "1 of 3125 compounds match." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "query_after_reload": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?q=CHEBI%3A2637", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "1 of 3125 compounds match." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "query_clear": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "" + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "sort:name-asc": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "" + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "sort:name-desc": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=name-desc", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "3125 of 3125 compounds match (first 500 shown)." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "sort:class": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=class", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "3125 of 3125 compounds match (first 500 shown)." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "sort:structural": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=structural", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "3125 of 3125 compounds match (first 500 shown)." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "sort:status": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=status", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "3125 of 3125 compounds match (first 500 shown)." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "sort:grounding": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=grounding", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "3125 of 3125 compounds match (first 500 shown)." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "facet:#facet-class": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=grounding&class=antibacterial", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "1196 of 3125 compounds match (first 500 shown)." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "facet:#facet-grounding": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=grounding&class=antibacterial&grounding=EXACT", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "881 of 3125 compounds match (first 500 shown)." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "facet:#facet-status": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=grounding&class=antibacterial&grounding=EXACT&status=REVIEWED", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "102 of 3125 compounds match." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "facets_before_reload": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=grounding&class=antibacterial&grounding=EXACT&status=REVIEWED", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "102 of 3125 compounds match." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "facets_after_reload": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html?sort=grounding&class=antibacterial&grounding=EXACT&status=REVIEWED", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "102 of 3125 compounds match." + } + ], + "error": null + }, + "keyboard_reset": { + "url": "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse.html", + "counts": [ + { + "id": "browse-count", + "cls": "meta", + "text": "" + } + ], + "error": null + } + }, + "downloads": { + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/browse-index.json": { + "bytes": 687133, + "sha256": "066ca0225600b0ed63f4a49379ac6104ab7d95cc86a0f71cdcef74430aec7cdc", + "retained_body": ".temp/site-feature-audit-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/0b7dd0a6742a0cd1-browse-index.json" + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/data/chemical-structure-map.json": { + "bytes": 4383206, + "sha256": "556a0e4278e0c013118ff54f3b4068ca8ca9a05fd6ff5cec635359d0a23ffcd9", + "retained_body": ".temp/site-feature-audit-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/be4c112e7dadda6c-chemical-structure-map.json" + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antibacterial/amikacin/record-95343524bd8b9a46c2cf15ba842d7b163a0657af0b8b83af023fe432efc70823.json.gz": { + "bytes": 16292, + "sha256": "95343524bd8b9a46c2cf15ba842d7b163a0657af0b8b83af023fe432efc70823", + "retained_body": ".temp/site-feature-audit-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/7b7dc308730ef3db-record-95343524bd8b9a46c2cf15ba842d7b163a0657af0b8b83af023fe432efc70823.json.gz" + }, + "https://culturebotai.github.io/AntibioticMech/pages/antimycobacterial/d-cycloserine/record-c489fb792a4858d72e998281186020388df8950340ce0a4b24f725bf3a7c85bc.json.gz": { + "bytes": 4158, + "sha256": "c489fb792a4858d72e998281186020388df8950340ce0a4b24f725bf3a7c85bc", + "retained_body": ".temp/site-feature-audit-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/bbf8ed8ff39dc34f-record-c489fb792a4858d72e998281186020388df8950340ce0a4b24f725bf3a7c85bc.json.gz" + } + }, + "screenshots": [ + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_amikacin_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 126648, + "sha256": "a3881fd7a0a480a5695493fb6ff017ed59af612545e5a98a2f80ee0860263139" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_amikacin_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 93685, + "sha256": "e39e841ac6ffde0215d133d4070d437b2e7dd01aced6aefcdbad602455f7e109" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_avibactam_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 131736, + "sha256": "1b100fa20707e25a1126f3d4bafaa20f97c9cd33d7f0550d1f81dea600198d66" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_avibactam_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 97946, + "sha256": "6a00381674f690bfb5bd358470c0ce3e07ae347889c63756f422abd78d752803" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_index_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 146209, + "sha256": "d2b9b28f5017c0a3149ea17b71d7f5830a25199808d0a94bd19717c2bd5053f0" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_antibacterial_index_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 115814, + "sha256": "974f3b50068c9cf5033a5656524998b9c6845992a6fe25b3371ea254e7d37220" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_antimycobacterial_d_cycloserine_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 150920, + "sha256": "0b1139ee435e785edc6c7f497c0d824c17d1035368b1a51d9a121e4bb6a23b5b" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_antimycobacterial_d_cycloserine_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 107575, + "sha256": "93b5c515c87078a23e743ee2b0d5666ad1165de880b86693722f946f15928591" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_browse_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 180012, + "sha256": "192770a84e73163e96250b7fb8fdb7274ab4db26b67d489f52702fab1bd30e80" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_browse_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 82474, + "sha256": "4cbd3853f8f78d4aeca209b42598b3d7df689864e720d4c085d71afedf6b3c52" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_chemical_map_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 204080, + "sha256": "663784b49b2f3b56f67590a3590b93714c870cfe47707c69c33337fbbf1f9a0e" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_chemical_map_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 99030, + "sha256": "c7b37ee5de4367a6516ffa984fcc58a88a4e71e8889cd736c28e65db40c02576" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_index_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 245363, + "sha256": "e8b073402105df7fa47d8dfc449228f5a9981a5bc871ddb2ab454c497d8e713c" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_index_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 153616, + "sha256": "0730d9ef8f7e6994c1d02c000d0333c36b30654ee620ebb2e452ec3c6950a60f" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_map_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 127890, + "sha256": "5b5cde10cd47b9f42e3a38d107374d1217fe8d940ac63d491917993b4dc63993" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_map_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 88258, + "sha256": "24c7840e566531c3a87c7c9dfdc821e6e5a9f51772920a8028e09441fd08be89" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_sequence_map_html-desktop.png", + "bytes": 189146, + "sha256": "ed79de4efd5f79a181a9a15f34c8e58985d8bd3c60a3e4df1456210a279b1407" + }, + { + "path": "AntibioticMech_pages_sequence_map_html-mobile.png", + "bytes": 105272, + "sha256": "57c04d65d4f12ccebe3ce55c378b5edcabba82d9b7d2defbdbbd41abc74daa87" + } + ], + "limits": "Record rendering is sampled. Complete raw observations are losslessly archived; original raw JSON and screenshots remain retained locally and are not required to be committed. External 403/429 responses do not alone establish a broken citation or absent schema." +} diff --git a/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/raw.json.gz b/_fleet/reviews/site-features-20261119/group-a/AntibioticMech/audit-1/raw.json.gz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6087415357904dc98da2fefad74114bd8332bc11 GIT binary patch literal 202544 zcma%ib9Cg-wr}iA>`ZLiw(U%8b7I@JZF^$dnb@}Nmzm$W_nx!XTkqZeqwCYVcWu?K zZ?CG}8#f#R;Li)_^UU+rVTWzu=<-#yrLM8QfW>Ds+EMzPINS$vh?g#a2z_X-Kvi)b$#R5)_V@_<_~^*{g8)L5@k}aOCNN(H-n|KJ zFpDwAM#dB)R36#DIY3`S5Y?!ITwGec9c5lom{&P6iAX%G^g|F?R+#?TIB3`Gs17yL z#n&U3GqM-MTIbdD8QnGBjLL;Sf^e^28$AZDm#x>3BBvW=EBF!I33LGQP=^=diSjqX z53a|)eHids-9Aw`whugbru0|2nF0D654|Xolne+NvCToX6k5woLdB9TP?`^l@q9XL zB;PIeFu90#BTD{xe)^lf5uoT{kpe!job>H+ErG;0+Qr^N z>4ayfVAPzY*cUP%CST5)g;|!+0(nr2a2!vDQ)vP*qDZdR32jA=oUAA7qg6s6Sf}Ut zlM>>}@xJAv(FDSKb$`}u{hD6wa3LSJYY;dgGNa1^y5<9i;$lG3mE-^3|Kio+Ll5#D zcTg%M6h5GKD~C*@iEKnr>dSUy@r4Wji}|gWlZ%@lEyq8rttW#YeJxWMu0C%bPIgXq z4-ba0G}btSffW5-vVEL#fpHzJt1f^?>&CqYO(F+-2i#p-QZ~t^ zaqBh4vBYiav_qIHdXzxq#t*1Z_oBDdlM%l&HWB+v$Wr zFcL;rWXe&o#r~e73lXHLXi%>DT1j^Tgh4*U)39#56cSRl$-^2)-M+Jcd<=LLJguGhja>Pp&FII$lqcDGGx5=B`+iqboAL4%qURgXPW&dg z0($6hK1UGHWX31m~gw*8MuDJ%6s~9<45K_Cz`-x9%BGI$upA4oC*x#w&G#YqtLqm zt>aq~A1aFlM*OQ0H=yH?wj_@p- z4C;)(`%>Wg&dNx;j2bM=m5>DC2pDk@E`17EeRoNWY91n&`kvFHm$2>Q!s3Xx0P_LW zOE@48N#X&|s@GX){9rCNW9>lUcxnB@ttWEsK^Bo(2k*1oLhLbqXwSkj_`6>;XV75b zR0ZiV^vdVZuE!Xh7e9me1>!1_ju{EbYE&xmV}EE3Ui`DlZ6s&$R{&IZj}GU$COkZ| z)6Och4@@@q5;z;oOLDU=#XuMoL+6iO?TsHK6>y*vfJ8g&%dwdNhdPSLHjSS}xp3wo z0o^jjCd4JPdZKp3;m>P2dbSF3_2XH7uBl9f-Rybsh79%F0;(2}%@%aNn#kDW*W393 zw+wff-IUqnF{dONL>bw1h4F~tB??8Ec&8%u@C}gfS^YRtI4&&3!`w35a#46N5=Y3L zCUZQFzJ_wMzTfpuzV!ywkDKWF(CHA>pXMySgY4jZ3&?)y2zSVJzn8o$x%M0R6E7yaCT78~9QU78_0ahX6v64<~YjvZ=%95`lL zdo&W$q@Fn`jCX7&;^!btzBb&M3(4`CK6vmJLZEDid6wB8+Ek)IJ)aA|#d;`lV8 zA&rkJI5!Fy7#(O^1t*gE6g7|>y!Eg#SPX_fO$(jYIG^#cDN3sk?Nby`5$bDe;cNeN zPDhLr;FeiR%Js-7Q2aIZZwVurwo#ZB;PM>E61@dn4L?gY3Y3vF?p3`bj2fJcpWWZwa!e;olcV4@Pjxjcn1|YyslFXxG7fZ8>3Unm z{3x>~L*t6mpx4!#g1=8{Pq_w1$I(NVAV0t`BC9ok_mGaPi%Hx66*x+=UGPf?QE7|k z#yIq2JVm9Od8k1e1!Ajj!Aq#VG(>=KzwK1|XbD-_kUZ{m$>1!jqV~0gIHOqQI87Y- z3`KYq9+8rnSx>X~r+y&o3{XGz%=~v=##>!TZs0V3 zx>O-68Zk*E%InKS_Fj`Q7GoF5i-d}dbl!?pK`$~9k=ZQh$iTj7{vJZO$1cPOL-zy-hwI1+pYcuu(Rx-E+)NO#Z9m?k=|MWcdAWC!VhAL*&8 zc>dC3a4J{b&&*(PM*3X4D3!~H7m8ae)`h?n{F36+q`<(^*l2%oDKuf_d3fkR#fX$k zaN^I&O(@M|ncKR1;h6inb4ke4pH0svr_5Q8_KT<7mkidrjn)a(XgthPi(}3V@=-Um zABtO5Xya(tA<{(Mx@Pr;@u#1PPts^2^buGoVv zanB=`RJ=$Z=Etz_)~qrY^z`+yz(uFz>O7^NOhv8FVINY74_~%<)Mu)`?=^wm<}ZR{ zG?MBhxq@v4k{?Yx*f<#~1SvEnJHQVU#jjxH#Yr8xZ!_@SvI>D1zjoA+(NK2bb1Z9E zJLt3r(WcYS*Nj;fyw@5G&QYQliggpM%TVvv(_P%L%GbS5gI&Awrwhrrd(ISRs+nQg zXi7GKkB(osBPERadFeY|l1fN$m?eXLj8{0pQ*8Yzt^TI`yl4rS|Eq3!EbrBEumV)E zx79qp3QIQbXLwzTb*8CB53^l(x*6Y~_MCi^oISdyz18O)wF$_{X~SZZ;=`bgRa+4% z_9EU{q)DBi611QAoV!7ijpDrDkBt{E)ZM1;K*2icI`}YPy3KE^QW6B%ouL!82ujyg zQjOHtxHdejO!4eztO{QC>xiK@K}WUS2_7K_7Uvak7yi`QQ%@cbR)_UmZ~3TeYGbd| zK}7guHc^S04Q*&Lfn+JHLl(8>?o)+`S036uC)d}tfmYRl84EkUW%R3*=e5RIRn_zW z!qyfCpO&MFyv~A(OJ^TBZnzM^d4(p9N>9gmNK^vL@`ljK@Q8cOpDK^bNG>}0lxYSOgNAMYUpRk-D4E_jg=kckAaYENtYjK&?6p9Ra>w0xkj7J z_Vslj_;G8=5OB1I`c6Nf`%c69xb>tMWNrYeci4dLymfpOsDH1P)GqX&G|;G6&d4h- zGYm!TiIoKoKB)ba8k-$zA}+7v{~Uo4$;zr)BFr)3)+Qfcs8kfrLv)V+Z2Dr$$U|om=z9>=~J|(FiRVGB73e!MzcT8ck~Gp;mT|Hh}0zpN<2{n*Ih_8YqnP$!{c#Hny}U@DVAQYc_Xah(`PEGsR+Q*vbIP#ssa zEpp(DTQa)@l6o|<LMo}z!T$n2mm+wX2mD`ny*{F|KX(s5pPqUD4dS4W z024m{4{75I^JHH?M}WWF@_B!0%_ce^4Sg2Z_lisTFX;PMdiE8*WLt$A?VjNV*&cbS ztL=BVs@<i8ci{ zkxE%{sehLuHjPW+_El_z3+yNB{<5>{gI1PjvdQNE20jAVGuAi2rKxO)d@f}Vj6+*Ks2GH=AWG(4dkxmWa9;iMEVoV_|qp&?tGIfG;Tc=EYEJ;$ao@1+tEiqvXm!Ui=l zwpesLp1u|WtY;}{J+SEasFvvKF_2)~c*EkaV=u(IiMVag8fFXvVQMQSQ#qw5)_Ob^ zqLJC?=7JU!%plhv^aXO!iwx+qP&e021s=%D z$^@GQ4tjA#d%%1_;$3ZR<19KkR*8Nm8|#kNud2xwuvSE8y#+O6(=jmjY*X$FIicN0 zyYuVP&B-2_XBII`vN-Me?2+-)aky%O?Ln3jXX)vhS3<-GWttiVTQVf2M%mp!i%T70NO^9p9)T zt}(dGqjtTFL%bt$_%0n6yvsCXA1C=_7JP0svYC3A8ufW!>OgsC6DX^SR?&BvFflh< z@tQ(Bn;&}Iok&s}b=^CN zU|<*b=-MHjWQH>LW0)yBy}oxxTwi`-HV$kKFzq*&dOjZ1ZKJEkSiV1lg(V|?X+`1r zL`<{_d70-~>@iG%q)z{geH0K!6B5Dqr+s=QB%g%#VTYn^Dj53&4OyhjqGg#y`^-_i zGKVW9KYB+@p?Xkb>8hX+HW;lmlo80D&w{g5L0S;lsFDEkoZ=A$W#E+yLsyRYx6RW? z1}b$Ztu$lg+T0VU@*5_1TxA)Dr1(&hIs0DMIABVw&3ww&wc6dcQN-{U1d)rnB`YuKc!1fdI`~EbS-nvD`e33!nusbU8;XyUCukrl_FRlc zC`h+li8Nlvj>W=b5Y>UeZ{h)>w#{=)C-PY-?1Ib%Px>;8 z(g$sgK!faZRLJ+mtMsJlKkEfSsD2-tR^EA!nPhRkoT9s+vBvYiW^kd;J3Za2hl*8) z>`fWlg362wG_YdrT?WIRI^QN3_`kf@03K9zEbHPhU}=vuKXb(oLVA07(?D(?l=W7H zdz-aEu4W$uP}3Ch{Cs%;s^k7;NuOh6;HpPUb_}%0h{v+<{lUM6d4V+953sPv5J=8y8PS?#3Ls$ZLQ?Gij1tD&PZSxT8Vy>1KgIGvS?4 zZmm`RY1~P_j_%Dw_kN9J`?f7~m>0#?bdBcmrh(`#Ox=$I zH7-~xox`Dr9oEd}K9?5?tgzRm&8A15dqoF{Bc2~f2#2yqeN#RwFt{77BRb7|7}j?p zO^Cz$c3?jVnOu}gE*tpZL z>{&67Kge~(sX}~zXI`(#y#}75NvssE#2zmc$aAqxhAJGFdO&T~@n-C!cZ-^OE5pjt z+=qqV{-x|u8 zVJoKlo#n$T>A?M7mv^giyXc3zIE#*$PnY^AO>wX6-g7i^tFb z=UVOdX@y5-Vs-t^PnFKe(M9!V4oV%9eGDVl7)UsVZGMtZZVV%oG|2~{mxX>sp^WY9!d1=ph-U(z-n|g_;bx%(VfC*&B;N#_{CU*%~uGCQ+s&;k-4R3RJPh>-%QTt}9wuPRaiX zbJ4i&{Qi?<=KN>^EZa6VchR{)_jkN$XyZD+&?fsk()=Y^_l5k&to0z!e`CFX_{&<= z{UxKRa{|upR&ebNo|U)%4{T_A6GG-i7?2f$swmQahHSB%&MUzV)VNd z%)`OyaJm$Ew(^*1YFx!RMJ9+>vx78}u7@CuHSayg;U?n81S|1}CJ=8M$LE{Q*t5N- z_3B74Z{mw(@IzNR^kvvfmnDv;Mxi#Y{|x88c#~_KRhD5o>GHvU!V(m?#ueg`Ccpps zej^@W`a=Fg+QwJ3|9jTMSG51IHpx-wg?-6BUyPc$ zDuCrO>zh>jI|9qDT&aZld`Te1dxjMA0*d>B$2uGS^4)V?33{lqpS^QkS9i2r?~@e+_-J7#>KoXLIpxBOP&gW}++V^w#aSjMJ#k@T81I4BGWPgE z9a%jP3^_-Qn&%<45`B8qmvlZkmpl7pMv7Lq^@yYp5JFfXO=Z@uQwC{k-kOh%pAbop zt=p84{I`#Dh~in0MB%H{nlx?Bu5=8hDGdg2hP2Ll>KPK~9KE8T`1B zl7z8s?TZG*dex)LU3SI*Lt|3Lwgva(&ytvO zr5F_DF~*_Mb5)C7XI>|tYp))-I&W+5i_6c&^{YBw?~YzG?HC!Kj*l4dr%be|XKILw zFQ;{@@6L~(9xt-HCoQW_*C$ViSzGcFo7y;}Q<0PpRHWXR>+`R>XSWT#FZGVfZ*xc5 zR$k7j^ZCOy1!d3CxP^Lc-Stg`lyo44Mawaj2I`h%FSV9Tkwvq=vFeg6qUB^bF<_4THBo7++k?gD#b-mabxaQd_(82dDx>Su{HRRiGeg8;u+5)bkW36`6N)@E*N+_7R=X&?DV>)mI4k>S^E0C{do6fP{U zj<%K;jwL)HAZTPbSbGBTGaFzEex`tq>gtg2`KSI|rsaiK?Sis{C=N3gVx&ex4kb&q zld^!ccn(F|aR798 zHiBOCB1slO#005_QhtC+67|_@gE3>Q7U0y@ciO7%q2aa*Y?B~9K? z4j)@*0t{Od*cq~6jvtNs=&i1}8H(=2y-0BAhunz>2Fzndeu#5L!?X=MPLeI7?7&6U zz=hwmg#9@j`a$9Wc>s$PVqcF35YHfCT(I3hB057dAfgrFs7~_EaOkp-Fk8jwn81sS zP>n|~Sg&@@c0d52QQICtpU2I?Jyg&YX2~E~pm1bLsZzcRZ?dIact01%85iW`+Q?1` zt1I$nECSGWfe```j>tYa;&6nkE9lQ*Q7Qx=G31T`?b``Fqm4==kT8o|&kbv6B>GYA zv+IuNN82rp74R)QNdc0cXJtKhD=DFfk8Q5Oq5%I;qgWKZ>`9-4T|oUN!}+UtX5=PU zL{CB(uA7$CdM76k*?eag&&fYTs&h`H0WOZ2KY=;Y%!{9O7(RM7z zzBJYMF>ho~ukb^O-|j+l@YIg5I43ndh@67J2?lF@sC?<-Hza62$D^>0X|Qyj^iZwk zYHwOzRWsAlu+TV2pGyWBQ54?KRG)dJdYe0Hcn;;uV^7lKb=q%XB}p3hwe8>}0s^in z%=boW01l{YXBF%ou9uSQIDWt<&whQ>$Ab8+zs?|%o!7&)yEsoAUk`g-aRVGUIZo>> z7xFbv`qvn$v0ADC=3u1_tc_4vWY-n2VlD3ghT$*}^qBN~w@5?%v51-n`M4VlJwtce zR#4UPg^nrLvISq&X9=#zc17#t9H3~_y{CUYbDg};@?P?LV`^iyfIwi|W32qDmb zxrnCA1UY(A>yWnQpo}4BvL|4ih{^F?kL|#=x+g}-jlD0}h0}D2hcv@+WdzAzyxtL# z8UjshY#o5&Ko>FOpMsp044Gwn;#zcYnj|sG1Ag)pR>Jp(HTE~x(xL}(IAL;xt`{{e zUPKRk?nNDDGB~KH`zY1Txxp`G~x%}d^kBEY?Fgw643BHiM;Ui*uedO z`Tks-eUY*d(o=oGhfz`}gNqZK*>f*k{a)+r$_%g{caObwZ=R27xpdYoCpJ5CvRi$Z zSEJ|cvihsNBO0lx^25m{X|Z{0C>zd(7h)Y6T}<#uYX`jNQMb&AAB;}Y6CMorwRz-| zTI+`=HI_aLoUbPzS_NP7baH(Gcnu_a3xeW6HVn`LuT!_H3u{4Gi?`E^yG4bv{9<a{JFa&1aRQKY^VLJT-2(=8Vlf-VW=OaXAIS?4+&s0EQWpkV^Ddc%W=ufxd~E^h z$V86w#^u^YL{Z%?U0fCcwI}qR~#vy z)i!S;Brc$0R$hh)2(K}e&L-PP?J5p?>+2*&P-~%Rdx3gq<&~r6?h>Cuky=s*?C0pL>)s46uoFl{lTU+^r75|6vsxK@Gr~^?>=>_3 zTqp8c=mH9gd`Y%E#{ZQZSyjiY=!Bc`Sn>#PS;7`qE^@g$4>dTnVI=!h%6OzRz2(=N zCR99UMK(0ixn9(D*EN?NraPDNGl>}xBqqyJ990BGKH(?AxVE{LF|_T3rEiIDCRpH# zrb;VcnE`g}OjuVwo5w42bpW44l4ULmXj*AP4uCl>7^qV$P$M$v3BDYkjj&E`K_USk zCj`(Q0iYW>(48P&&Zg2t28goi__}ybBb*$J?E+4sqZbDu+8w6BXs}ePH zjPf}h1et>F*Zm+}L0?WcwE|vp9v=@3lx?h^0%Kh+HW=tG0cfGIp&&O5RQneask6f) zd~VJF5@wYkQ`C5+BXd!c$5U5AMSQ|r-fiQzH-xV0e&O6bGGs^fy(CQO?$w(hEEQ$K??Eph1gKA;nL~} z40lw=d`GrjJ@C1xp>mQ4xi~Ng8nFcf=DbxJ~BcuW6cBsf-yP4xIca`1)^Re!46%7t)_-1IwkXbDmcTuxCLc@Ar0^!(Iqzc;1!lIQu~ea0cSt zxqIJquFc;&50rH}S&q zEfM1*f7IcHdCW$JB-?*G4c>l>*H;SF9>tr7>%)uuGJ`?vzK>2Ue3jdc++T?|B6LeK z)<*%X)C(Q#*x(Bd#(1F*PA?Jw7DnK|(?#SOebE$az0eh}aR=tBzu>i1@y^(4kOU+d znAnLu1~*hAoIg;Tn6FA0&^aEN8j`O<7{ERrgqk>CZ9gJnPGc82;B(pT3!B{NxUt+T zo#~TNBuG9oC;?C>kc;`ZuzYXq!#=Eoq1x+ajEvp#3wb;iPo%+(B2=Mc$IK8}wOni-v>fpB| zV+TUSI>H18r-b4P2^yd-TJeY}`S)`O?j}&$CqH1*bdppHfMrtgLCL|FbZt;u))sLn zcr=IP!iiO==V>2tZ%n#!@(yaFbcwgHg9%D$d9(dw>9E|U{{fIav05)y&oBX|^LZ->1JZh2g)wV;-PtYts%p@klJ7@{|o?;u=u+L8RStd3Z0hTh-!y%o z`w~H|oxoM~lyIoGMVSulylDqBt5BrH*59-lWz|vM7TAx+!wS1ax z6G1bz1BIs)g=(h`+*ot)boH&S2a&YZ0vm@@sXmfPo@njK`C}K0mn>YP#^CCKSmvTB zv;cjCEph))a$@&cIDL2zi%C9zg#&6_BU$2J_p{D-zfCoQQq(Y)UN8;G|uCMD0vHO+ZiQbYb}>%P5o2%ypYd^ zH)W{c9b|FABQ@oSNvi{C(pX!nqcAW26qNF?l=w~HayLJ*KI15x(?6UD()03k4emJ7 z?yQwQ7Gn6L$(UVu<*EC62vCPJM+iA9Mvz8>pKMM z@M>$qy@8QN-^ZSzx1hH9dB^8KcuPItR#*CZFSqE>Q)#+TPS@%jj2dIWCjA!xL{~NdTH=2As0s~{iPd1iuDrQa*G9;DKk7#`37;9 z)VNV5gASz&m+xo%w)~dN^jq!(;?OyKG7TF9Z+~SMG=8e0b5Fa+%vpefu=a}=d5k+2 ziWc=I$kYqi_vtLZzBgT2pDT2^XoxwIKAA$^x}_!Xc8TgIXw%sNRsZ0E8Y0{yD(CwK zAO1E&BydYU(wQF$Fn0>n-YtG}hL1Z8`m8Th4WMTH-6n`2O`H}Z|E?F*4HmkikvIk7 zb{cxeGS{r#2Q1($u5WK46!oq-WZnHX<$4+tjXz`ZhwST4lT3Rnv2GKDPq}8B!G=+M zKEfF{IckNDTPkaqC$H+fdb3vwQ~avh%@`$k$Et;s@cKeHjc;iyne|2k`;8r4Xz^W> zoM7U#~U>o&))NH|uv9k=5_E3wnS)eFEC zpH`=~Nw?)eY39>F*$YW^+A25s5k@uR_+_{21*&)~sWmmw^({pnQEaP@-gW4MaF_ld zU`G(M`ha$iQ;r@-9%w?hY|5|d9&^|?7w@~*_Ze@N%ZI`d^5yxlv(fnpg_KKFmsP7C z2V8a+%oiGC-8g8?Won#ft!$<2;g^G8vYTlK9j;$-E@5V6G9^4BJU!_xuKo4P(ye&8 z69Q#8kVR{+*`MoPT6VsrJRMMXBPfrMSlR7CvXzjhEE!VWB0u>z>&5p>P5PT|IA?BY9j*o>%NQA}j(5 zcqlqzGpnEQyvE$wM6+B*$Arhc4ezo3R-std?4+C+DK6h+9qKe>rmrk(c zZQ%FNo+gQ%)9%V|%&b7PZnvVI!6B<32xsO0MRi09E&Cc87bmlF={j6L-5~SWqxho0@4A5yM=nMYb1aMm8YvN%{KaSGkXH7XXuPYZ$`5BurY#5}!B-&XwWp zs7j7(Tb}jk4kcHvTFsPKdh_wS@|e?$y7=^#3tNG(@$lo^1c%2z7bY{>2f(j!8;qcs zi@q$zICn*;PH5-&R@Cd1fP-(1(w_cK8|LCL`Js}7=G=sZ*h=gN%4 zGhZDBD@$RlVR}agl*5L&px<AsI=9=KrylxL0)0GcY!393*8gcG! zB=C4EWHdO?_FUZhgPsP)wu($zI*HfHx0+R^UF8JSNCk8054I}YTM+%ZS-w8gI`g(7 zD|}^VLlY`976#>IW=nC^m=X&x%YVyoPKxh(= z3l`n61IF*EH`@2Vi%Qwb%+lh*Q3eu-N9+&~VHKUfLt8*tR2lhaQt4~XQAskOjKxsx zwH_=bFrldrb~306Yk4;d42kuovEfjbRkkJ39|&yP<#cI=j|x(W+&`5Wxb*{7{`(%JO=n+ z$7&_oTKPz6AEA6TDlI-U*lIoM!Ls?2TEwI4)TYQ{CG6Wc{P&qz%ZsA(vQ^^U_b7+& zY<@m=V7*P2r#}ujqa1G6!`AB7uho9mS|y;Pl_HKguOqRNyQXSZzBfw%xdE#4Ed%wdg4kCNWDuSxQmZuEr}UuG4hm zTYa&VAz4p+rOm;rRFtjD{>)*t6)Y2L!Jq#tr%Iyb#~(RYWl8C|zyFZh%l3^+?*C}3 zE?a}C#91m(*$T5(N}p8wW5YdAGF3U|c7v~mZoHfC7|Ofd-_20j4Xa*JwDy;!5eR&> zxXiietx(xVm02A&|I0t?EoD|%*!sUnMY*@qO*cNxH(g(O zpX5)hVSZFn*v*%Lvy@`AC@cR`7x|Jn(cM@kDVwJ7N8?pldQjS51OKAGtMVtBMT>tX zuT_-IOP7C%Hr`U1cU?m~{ks&(nUhTa(roo}qT)+7N=q4~#(a#-pLiQ@)hWl?F8@)9 z!seJ%rlD01`A569a`~zLKmO3LocznPFJ%7@&CR6sUj}WY{*xu`U#np8Pq2} zSGZSBTIK(-`|E<|Z!&$Yc#-B88#6F#nTB_(%DdF<31M ziMEAb27V<3u}VCfMGop8Tvw&Uq-*+5g8uh{w3n%<{{9N&jpRFq$v({>G}M3`^Nr684{z4N{p=`6q**e#ldToz(v$(VAR> zx$)qCjik8v3_ohsByIBjb?N+L? z^3IwVC|m_AW%1+Z!rG5Re~Y;t2i?MY?VeJ)pDFNn*N-*%qcof6Vk3TW{Gb_wIkiTf;ZpeBey`Zzwfh&*#pzD1MeceyXwH_%du3&hc%6lf5l-o9*=d4}xvng4)wXi(gOa;F{UPDg-m?nQ>al z9)LES6YzM5j~%?Cm_U(*oh;RCOSAgOgWElg(FT*#`?Dhp&;+!=fCHz?SG5Le&uE|q~(76EP0s{QOPVwrWb z%Zg7Zp6KXkYD;(Oy#`b`D-)=$)xvE@>&eni*GNa?UzMqhf*?UIWBi5N8Nt!MxCE-Y zYvNT5Ze#8daX2edF0wY*6yaO{oP>ZZGjf|3l8Nl0PV7aXk@&D|9u-p7|J9+OY2Z0? z`9Krgao~E`q=;JjuU>@)ycU}FR@K9f8w$=aT`+i@z9YS};AlT28owuM8zfEGPaBTR z_MV1UCkHDtnSlCbf~y@UhXDlO_!b-(GlHv%^ zv|TR!^`2ZS8f*^)h$h0HG~GOyKeX;zozXI}wu{Tt0pD7p+v?uLm1!C&%{(2RN?uDH zZfl)!t1S}pCuuvc?S zY8a(3&hw78OO`19tMGX*fFC>Xg9MJnP`V~MlPw}grRM5A{+xT;tM(kVg?3nn4n#Zo zGXHQ;k%DZQN}d-`9+(0N+^i1=v4*g8k4V?+jc(CL0QgY-oE{SD>~>4^Y{ z6LpZ(0ta12jIq}MhS3K&vOB`R`TF8g2;c?-12=_MxY!uk#gOF5G?Z}5pGu;P4muZ@ z+5Asbay~^*)Y&kMxza~hj%>^LJhuaw-hE5oZ-{fUr*pebr5%L`biveD`X!&eVPpp2cS@=oCRvbI#=nbHLS5BmM zI1`I1&@i=(Rvv1g^0d^fqrieFM^yPaUq>zcGsb+ToX)E6x8dp!$p$45dID1x*}Lto za46tbfvEK^XEkdzgL8g#22~wfA5^Vssti zZ~kgO&;Hrk+>!2exI-{vmKN)ox=b$>L?$+zZ)UL=Z1|<_;j*+r{zb+eNeeNa>~Ms( zMw;Im=x=ja8*AE3;mj=j8<=N5EYe@V&fDkX&=qhvC5yYWPj8C~B&rXrCwU6Ah+m(w zueN^i`UNjP1AbJcQLK9BGOm1(!@Tw^2i}=i?8IkcJ+++sYN7|hg}b`XONlcbK&P`b z?L_LMa|*>1|3A-N!1wdIo#IQQow`kAo_ObHtK7Prj_7!wN^aD^7P@X`ou<+~#vrqodykuAYxw;f!6CUGK|?p_~x?T>UZ1jDd1xU&X56n19FNNa{pTiS6w$wFlvkHbA1k)iUm9EKmyz9cimra$=`+{h zT57Ga;tN219l%UNqUGsh+5i6D;cSKalXo|e1hDkXpa~_rZ`z~Tx${YwS0tG{8X{*v)hKfgByaV<*o=6E-A#-9mL8p70%$ ziDnmND+g?rng0m|%S{x_&34woFPxFC3aUkh^tC0tt{2qpzm4n9^M-;zwlR_wGW z{Ra~E07lj_8-b#Y3}QTG&(_ez#Np|x*JCiP90bj2v;;KCFfNIFOUma_oC{N52vuAR z(aqP1aGic&Fsuw80lQ{4>L&XbfmM1yUV1L!M+I3Cm3UNmjA=^ishXOgngg|Ff)c_i zChQdbe;x%p3n@-s+7jtR5EuHd)#R<#8zbnGubS}RtOqDhchG}s=$)7?TTyYlS3{IG zDqW;4N6M@shU(5G!k%>4+?r(;e1?Gc)wk;4lS9{I62FSnWI)6z-4;c4<75e#@_Vvw zO$g>h`(Jm>VvHex^1Kk;Ka*jDaD|zcBKl9k1mr<%rjGjSHNqEVfr`xDTF9zUxLhC& z)~3~`vl{eGbEn!-T8Xr0BXI;I{<|S16Ww%hJHT4>T?JE|^yc86AO$YRket*FnCP>P zUO$Sg03j-mPUG^3i37&1i!-lQuoyHhN}u+@j^2<6+S;21`_~7Jw_)(bjhWb;XUqU0 z^l|3|z(k-ve8m;hjgnX|cOX%Kg3FHOwC!C(BUOI~`iw|;FuE|ZTM!L&t1M8Nu7C`$ zWZ&g%aU;vDbBE5hup5vMXb(6LvcG6UCFLI}~8RhEv@Dtz~Y2 z$?o>PIwxgt6S)2OOE`H_2LtQTy-8PP4dm*MXF}-^i$Wm!(?I}uu%nOFlU<++ieEV; zu}O=uO}TPd!Ne8aj?+yDU!icn6$c?gqfi4yn^6dG+A>_NPq0YL~4y|S+d+(=8^Ou zr*Bw|2l4+WxORYy4Y z9&T;uUOav*9KXHX7%*r?ih)=`!NH{=KvER^LGT$DDDYYSw5jlYr4(e{iDld^}xG;G2l+nhGqbZ>&@D6i%&yy<0vk}A~{70oypcK zbMAkNoPFQTQLjqOor65Rrijg`qKM(cF(8#j+&K}pOuI?750~7rK?J(o-4gU)?U}9q zP&Ea^hV20|!xOO`F}Dm)RZ)12dzXvM0i&v44o5sB6~AFJE4R^d&2@z@(EozZSPf+3 z*aAZ)l$Zm>M*nPZh6+kW5sT`QK0;@WDbiz0oY){6Ls5JeNJ5VV>I*==37}(wjWhBq z%U3qV9pizdQ9ofsa8E%S_>}c|W3*`OSsMSdD}hC%Cm4DxXQTjHfzl1obF8}0pcNv! zLRpM}vN89f(Y{O@;g-LBTP0l6O@2{HlY#RcN;mpxh+V41kJ*^V2J7iC^)KpWPxlM#v zgmxj~0hZ#ChlDFPj)`j} zP5?7GYAD*&cC2&rv?^b?%!fJlhcJD4QvL0!&HK^TK{6v*bI-A|M><6_C0{MusyI@N z)eUGTI3k20wJHzz9hs$*Qu!i%AT!Cmg&co^7NaPn{Ad;tyyLtia$1n+FJ7ePyoDRF zw~!fW<39nb$6VvzG)|IfQkdi)V-%L{M^Wbf7D7TUhy%hSC~fR7hyM~NBJ;ff8-=-w zt0w7Zc}Jc?h}d&gAX`ez-VZiG1~)uTbD0#aV6YwV(LWN=5zb*k+MOyLdf5jDcz(T*vxq59H?zo;+|;#FIpWxVAJ zJBZp4ygJ2N8Ac!mhb@e8m<}jW{6*?!l*wmSTtv99v|h0ikajIW2*qM{L_$PPm4au(204 zoQX5U&Db|%e=?RcCY79UMWz(<@~w%Uv@ew#;oV-A9Rjs&S?g(G5<8w%)cAfvm>t2I zvxm`QA;;bQwpSxZOp7o?h&X-}_bcHLKJ&M^zuvG{{X^)Zid0MHuoo=H7dIQLu?0bz zywYgGd3VQ^JGCV6^Hy8FC`6N7`ROXs)C1;G_M|knI={4M_&h}9_X@GdwR^5yL&E~t z-11oERpUv%CMjjgIklz*XgjzJUoPe{;w_hnvpmQL+PRY zbn-}>UOMfAk&>2Vqp6z%Gt6+guK@v3NoCaORrN?MawMdBwhqA8Kg#WelKb|j!Hc4q zmq3^5k{*Wz_J&^VwSlyknzU04Uyefe$Y;+g;2(-%h%BCp5+}FM zw2WYEq%MNUcXPtS)Hjwn_$u|Y6aPf_7PWo2GuMIkji*@@poU>q{LBwL12AAG#NcM1 zVP*ugzy1gVGs%aVK=1=<7W2^w1A0M%I$%>~qTruJw|7P{IrS&xM-CTYkc8g+N+}nH zhLumrfZ*qsOQ$Re|6Lg%lK`6(uwmd187OVS(FXDv3Yu7=vL8s1Cl*>+8>ledHr~V%U_b7{u9)8_ zBq?*e0L?b$t1-l^jM&Ru|E7aG;8yJGL5Rl8m!o^t&#VQQZb?W@rG5NLiT$dTmou|t z@i|zaS6>k$AC5CRn0Q7(s0dOpK!sF* zS~$RoLFho3_(nnK0I*4(w1-mo*Cw1rtyqA17}T|HNL84ST7C#S9LY-J97dmnwBw$y zl;hMAjP2*)LGBoi+@=QO_?lkC-(kuC@$`ii;a5&WB!JYZghYbMiy8d@DMbT^%#AGD z62p*;-04+Au?b^!{)}7{Oa!uWqUCKi;B9=2Q+aY|rc&%{h1d6$p03j@-$Ut?!DB`o zptFwqm-JjvrvYLsF&d!GNW+fTHHr^4xFQahsLw!C@^9i@vD}8Jorp_kl=SfWlrA-^ zQ4p6f&n|hk)JZak#}OvW+#N1vBU8&QzH>-8bZY&8la7bYZt|TnnLjRS%(EX z$gcy?Fbzs76uF_7dBonAciqPE_N2%DmWQRBoAlR}ZNImu@WKE$wdEB3q0S759~4Nl z3|z=u>(YwY>$zXyLJ3{BYHfqW}^H z9NVHL5-o5F0E%=9*$KG->IgF@lpRm}l>-Vy1x1dgIsnY%)LP z08m->MiR^CBDWOn&l-Q^Osc}|CL{;>`QSc<8SqnY9|!`1$Tq=CSaO}}JRL(7kRd9u zL1)m%GCZ-+_+wKP6Q(4VU-VFLtYgA^DyG3tgq@F3(YgB=-ovp&8n|9$Z@b(ojzBg2 zt2hv*9q{hm^hbH(%)fOwi@x#|938Mm8ZplV4>)tLi7Npq^n)nhsusM6_*S1DW1&v! zVWjR!l*!zpeCiZyGZauOyR^u#6;#xOf#!uDJ-bhXX>2n@jA!ikw(n(~hsr?C{%LtY zwv5i|OKs&bi15ibg}}9`Q_Bi-?f$ReRab4G6SrQcW!Zz+%oKTS?FERKnEvF_YU28- zNO+tDl0;KCy$swI1Z?M4bOC3sjW5%#kPyKWvawK5#*{8dHJ6hkL5eibCkAOQ3-@}u zU@nZXpoqK0kOBOino@ELoVac7H*52N>!0yKzIHT*nh^&?Ajr$#vWc#(px$=(M7Qq| zj>j{I0^hM+%1#|QS*6D2eWo}>r2Ug)%olMIobpmNMbHwzgD8z3pHVcwrsFUl!H&hL ziDfH&(F30|OhinGOG~bUgmR-4`PjfgOILAK2P75TC0Dk<59ecfBTJ=$n(D|X zg!X=78O1p$R*exkB$qY&fRNl`51?L%X_PJ^X+nEUZm>-fEM8+Bb|L1`NQM(Qx^CN8 zB}o<80KGPwB!M@rgWLg;q-;{J_972tyvE?h8sd5~Z6zGlZ@^{l zQr8FjkBQxNJv&^R`Fd8HySIK8`#-;1ZvHeYyOd8XXORh$U?CsUx0F(%xuu0jB(^?| zMi$HMDu3Ph6j2gae;lGhGj{H%W{{tY%|YF%x%avCi!4NMvC+tE@a5g;f0ykE&nO8NAx|Sq~nk8cDvNo1d z=}`ffxtBWkERKX1H!3;Uwd?M3*9Uw%@bsv&OGJGEOw{}!%{lkX_(Rmr7^RI#@jPU4 ztf=>Oy5`m&+JOV{li~bjc_P%6*70DyUm3HfW9SC_Rb^Z$ei+$2WhQT~;ia;dFwgHD z1FzoIBeRxg0jP#5;MKNdb-wogU$^ARzy8-#^}}aOz&Yu?N@u|#S0M;YiKx7VTOVuJ zf#@Y6H3S^*%ypA%{F-KvXrEBbSwyr7hl=HYEJGJyi9f5yfSa4Vm;)ko~9GDV`OCsC+Q)Vx`F^5UiG(&$wDjhmLV z1=XW2z?DaOC~KXBQG!01-B*@WkGDP^*M1a1IV$qoyS=UY52a{bqlV=CC znebc00Xood+4iWM5Yr)f&=2NmPSQ&k6XoFt>g$FsEOgdd(sit5p$s@|dxn(7CD>3k5RaNwHjsL}0b+I`q$! zdG7v)DN9_vgtM2q=_3E}GXr^f=v-*LbA*3_;5pFM`+YRRir8i)p#rd84fN zzs*Cuzf~C;n0z%Ep@-*wh-)?hnttadROK!5FBEWn&j z+@C-R5368FFI_Ac5m}MA-E6oUz^1zLvtK63h;d`WmUcH0{N!X){Yi?TKwn-S=bmBs z8-*G=l%GRF{6CL{I4_mudFNz<{99Enj=3rS{}HXq5s+ zl|NL7MqEUJ1#A8M4L^HYATSe~7~I9CL6D%n0|0M{%3m1dG{+7|8CQ5dnc8?k#1~aM zb@uo7W4wS&_#9G+{MUI6acWIp-uJ8S!YeNV^t*ZgSgsY^1C}*9G$!Ns-`$I+3Qapj{VSSMN{>hIKv9dJDhgT1v*4$L*9T z-j9}a^|}vy@=LJsR7^Y$m`=& zB(}Ch!b2ndf)zR8bTYptV}EL>p--ljAQ0pFQZ&MpwZ%%xQ!at;oV~cw}Eg&`^^yZ;h%yr=xgn?YQ=a~M{gj4?jHbAnt zQVsH2+-Mg;UL&cH(_<$!P90s8r;S&=R?`ux@*2z%#Vn88OhRIk!kbiR$!aZEEQN%U8t(`sVRTwc7mIXPnfeNg#+5Ii68EZ3+Fm6 zbVZ*KO>TNk(Y-MEG;!aHNg3dEO#*xJ$5&^U<86}cvdAUvU_BmTH&ow1cs2$~i*i-7 z5?B-??bdk6eO588V5_LWRDwASnuqNg> z)j)Ad>pS+JAuV*rmsJ=%5@_=+m$IUUGmXAvSkHdnS1U3)z+3`E%fGpVJ+7(pHqFqq z1;3ODtZ2jK1hgN~m)iYJPgcTKMSWNXmKH-TrO6Eg!W};c3{O{wwAfZJ7f^&nW3?t@ z;pwhd4-(hPe<=&c!>g-0ZU96a4FFov-rbv5N`4XuIyw6E<@9o4gLwUim7;rR6o*1g zpmrXKxPp|H*JdpBopU3aLFgB|7_+c2%GB5)vW}m>&>wkPO%1Rmm((z5As6~r>+lX6 z)+z@WRl2F!$b@l@TRvYedd$~jUA|Owrc{_xb211z2uap9r!|yXB}LqGjX7>Wf%IWR zE!ULWr<}8ojXG1?4LkK4%ytJErAARLY3*=Tbg7@uv#}YXN1{)&S_ud6RA*LJSU z(}fzSCRS6GWH0pB^t>m$ey&Bg*pjPm5Kt8m$(S|ltmEt6Ieb#GDOTbCqa;#TIj;Ga zbNbNwd2FeL7*(tgbc$LXUO1QOZVy=_nbK$UlEDumhS_99H49bv{~}fZed74LOz1zT zPZv{d$uDz10LHOWB3mi?Fi{%H&BgC5YqSf#n0PbjopQ0+G*fNbANWCMr+7e&`iND7%D@}V( zbF?e6#L5&LaiD~0$}OIcZybD@=N)j z3{&1U!UnX+0y#aVqa`x{^>p!65Mm1U`{6TcX1D4%Obq*BbdKqDZ0N zI=lmO>8<9Y>c3k1a&g`=?$mISZBF439E zSEPqzrNwSipcex?07Z0msl;3bZF=bUt@27GIPVQCc7@}!ezN<|lEmMVhH;Pvf`ta_ zMebZmPQu^T9gPlly9x|J>CG~*MgCShIto(%Tdk!a#)o|5jb0 z0Z_rett)8Hz9$BuqvXpNHBS`L10#jJA-viUxea*qSS|O1&gc1EZkPEh=uX@D;(%-O ztG&0k3z7sw-mm-79E=v@jbCtNP(}RTY=+$0*n;F2(05!m3e+cP4F82k2VjR|m6}_^Gag=JK=q7kF)c0>hD`B zG_5r)rAzh?t!@nIec6FmdmK~c6U8(qfx>#Bsust(?ByG4_aMW_Sk7AtB9-d>l$kmD zBkpDF4wQbX72fmhD3n#UdhHEuc{v%VNw6N+pi8c9@m&_If#KtRDnE2^j!R`~S8*DC zs~F6%qZNniNhBGs!)#Nf$a z_Bt@F0242UlLkEn(o6~u01&u;8TMeU}~I58bo=`jAIVEjS(a5k7}_g~k*O#heI;1$OA7 zA(zsDqI3Yfji2p)E@K7%LWVxu>-tMb&zYXWJhfbRQ3qK6fMW%|44qI&G-TdUB!* z{vY3^)xa1$RWi||NT}0)gk*M;1V{KEVwF-r06xcoRwuG$2F}^ZOgqu}==>(xe{#~I zn7Z=O(gVW{1&VewYopb5>NW0lYMr%$#<+l9L=vgsLrwHO7B!AQPh<#uY?V<1g0~pA z!$jZw(H?cl(x{vV+B$wAp<@X>eWORdGX=?jPQ3MW!ZF&putrfU6S@yS&Det(GQTRN z)x@BJ8k;kVuYG^1+JjY)Jwn#s_qj%RW|0Ro_urKZ^%Ca z>$zoy!J1E(5+SE{SthIFtbQ9@enL^pB1}Q1-~8@6>nVL5L!Lnpy&7$diJ;!RrON-f zK{7!hbPFsPnm2tE-L`|%F2A2UiCYhu(Kl;e!8)GHRahaqiHY*b<=cR*@y@8^L|UKd z@6&eM1~u4uM5DDOgrei@*W@0~*Dw4%Z+Mx5S(gu5@-qgg2W0-gIN4DeoXRl8U^KZ_ zkV%5dQ-gBReDR!Z&@4uo!zTfSU%T?0${n{_!(%0|AiN9mD-D!z^>k^u3aDB3`hn$U z$PZGhK(N-@zI||z!9G40ufTl$Id4SstG)vxm}5K7HOnnP5_QIf1ex6iu-vHMfFK5v zph)FA{6UeMNNTaI1|+NW)2|D@&!8QGvjLYa@+B!VtoAsvm^u-f08U_P8 z5kJ$BkN?xVK+*70zzr-!$#N)O)fY|oEayn~t^49E8)@>%~{6;54fXYj~^8Qn!*(7v*RNC#21(q|M?|Vcw{Y;!R2f z3K~Aoq9v@JfcC9Whq(*eR#Kj!|8CE1QboHD+tQI=p+17V3v(O9Z$4JH!37y^N(*tU zWjBLz^2CV34O+EA5c$4MacReKRZFnq{woFflEf`9B&k%KWqv$I67=OuCNP3NAqQ$e zCkP)*n{HyV?j<6okl@N>TC?8D@vj7qRb&`Eyshk<mY?!=qHgrWtoAFGCB$< zNjH)*bRn?DcjgPz%qeM>&YA(%)vhlXs5wQX&JOzDY+dc{<-V9TQ0dl z6fcjg&j@wQaGq8*s|c!@D=Qm^PHV%nRfh&Gznry_ioiU*`6`kGris z`@4-P1cH4URdXcqfAc3%x0EG~g51nMhTk7n%||31Q$TpJ2`W zxJiTv+j$YVyp2&K5|EuV%%QHoABdR6v9%`LWNqDC1?&wwf0t+Sko z1D;uBdl#{%62Q;tjPX@_yNDTVSjU}4A5v$NMPD{Pkj!JuFM-^=8-@9YBPG?A$7w+K z{Ox!2@?I8)h#^ffJas2uUn~b&_p>LVbVEHYEbqFjX{<~^&=g91v+kP_Vdj^}vuIO+ z8b+YcP=U?D;74N~Km<~SSd18>zBfCG4$`^oDp2iatDhs7r^03NZ=*+>>1#H_1?HpL z>KULxhlz4xIMIQ5b9^$tfY>jBQ(X;k7T+WYh+yH)fUqfpI((2dN$3$XqA3IlCi<~Ah;KEy_{!HW7Y{I{(T=thQCKy0eCmJ|IhR%h0*5xwijvZRv1p zf1MOQxBL5Gx-zMp+IGV7#o-zo$vlLI)oFDMUElTiK6P|G_093|kN8`i>s5~TlK;00 zMVZVyneBB7&pXY~Hx5&)%&daZIK&3;;g@GViqTiAR-Gq2;%Q(R=NdlVfnKvHV`WWw zJ!rpb+uRvh^g|&Q8FWQvVP$3+v=^m{j3P&QU-}4CWv+x8?P zHr|9$RP>IDtmMK}QmPtCa|$Z%L|L?LB^4Q^L#0F+2l?WR5*C+l892FGeEx{&yHdrW zC0?%N;ZNB523l0c6iLQmt`GxCB!b*bZ(b^><44|nabypjG?{}i&!s(YEDxOso$wFy z0p8{p*4hDHZ(aqI-j#HDR0)hoQ9URP+|lefgC@`v89L|8KbTII?5|_FZ|&+A?(YCn zEv#7SIJ7fkz@N#`r2t{Pt~&+c{6=akqi8UzzcCY+Iw;6$!FWVeZ zM=yy&nBN9SE`@>;zbxDq>c9Oi8`8ioEYz1pm!0x$b*m!E z=!t8pq((NdNkaB|gnRq6nnm!~1q0d#`Ue_6Z$0n&<}unvg7jAh%+c~3(2vv~ec)>XNaV8<-5(B5zN+0tX7NdZaz zK^&N0jlarGkf2lc9RaR;4Rxxj=ow#{laeY_bxgPyAXPwi55{uo3 z*M!&~QvFFC=!j6!^6I&Ub)^F8C4wpYY3X9F50vb|$h6v595@SD(RQGnQe}66UT#Bt zLqYCIz>R!mTzjJE+Q3)<3_mlIIW}EEt5Q zoOqhHDL6WhzMI&+jy1kIo{Zu^-UMfpx-w>I__k~OvL^4Ql0c3c4ERj_%c_f!gkdbB zIM9~OYiWAV5{*V1hgp5=3qtE5=UktKd2ycU%9(9SEI2Bwsvd5 zF{C(kRmW}t_fuoK*uqY>M}!EZ6PZK++W0brTqhC7NLsm-lCGwVz`$jVt`vYg9Evn{ z(Um?~8^N9Cv)-54NaJ%cHdl##<=!uH31PNemeMI=MkGG`j3y}@>}qb0KCf|1#D4UY2y|7KsW z5HXBaENhvP-Y<8gA);Y5YK;F&xRJC1nSL7TG3(OzX|V`7xe_MLn^3O>a;haK&o9NO z+OrMrM+L5=0i@Ajc0QNv?#MWPCSQO{ zYifRBm<(6NBb#zUyAN*+8-3HiliT{a3k%U`0T*a9VGh-vwx`@WjmwsrkvMVGwGq*W znW0lU{f8Yt2boD<<-X4}EhWJ;7lm1p0z+CA(Z?eT1v!8z(QTWC)#jyEja1I8d{Ill z<1lui=|RuT2#UzFjET8yTm92L6t~19vN0M5WL(*_B^+<`au#Pf>qw(*bOx$YtbMpW zt9^fn32%mk7~ozyx7Dt08jD1V?1LdvWP%Y8wtaE8E|s*!d(Up`=bO@;V#5>KYE^EQ zY+=EN%oH^-6jgZ`Cq+aZ%yu@fc`2e(?$|LTUCOD9lMv4x8k8~okZC?9!Yn}GtYa7t z!-J>z9P9TER>XxC0Nh)v!JQTTSIdcT(9TfUJEz2fl zCZwy%wt*LtF9PX>fU|mB>U3++I)CnGBW{dv;bsXL3I~D5ssRkE2Mx)rUXK6hh6BIU zJ7zO;5NY)@*)q*L&7WoM4Z3{upnamvFOWH4k*pn)8?(U-vJc3q_+H@Nz!>eV(Ml|B z&Rt8|XZ3=?+Y)LeMDC(L+-EczbA!7LJD2cGORN4H&avk!Y9p_^2JX3mOFNmO-O6h3 z@_FB)sErcAR*@G49SF$b#J)?>sb22gYEu(|sPMW!DK||NnHj0SRqL#2gib`kQ;#7j zpOD5YzTlgJN4;nG+5@lRW&pki9gLQW$Kl^q);jyxjXnh9iLSW-KXcfi^x^HgdQw6 zLXGkvdb$UlCy2`a$t<^q}(JhL}7mwH?+kEjrz{MH7)@l&xN13`Is zq4tPicP?|)>Vwv1L`L8Se*+{E>m<(7uW0Xjd zYat$Vt~jb!!)N$6rNB@w?ME6}TDY$$Sm*>1H8A=pMeRk}1&}uSZeQc4WnNb1-DO&I zl?qAow&A_|6Mj->3tdm{ld3ZWyu*=J{z9DQ7oy0)be-ok{4xmH5U#WMUn# zBw8laHX(5Yn_xf+MGtpKNMmi4xht_5B(gl9+RU}k3?lKCCFLfn>#^=hc6r5}NCT(q zalixNXz`uMUC8rdrfUrTt4f_3Eg;>YJ{-m(3ZqOvf0>X`HsTmFSC}J6`3sRed7jSL ze1DazWppaP$JV{6$@|dkfE6IUaT0}IpEdbRTIbgLoKE-7ea#>TiYkexuqOUi{ z+2sq*9h$b*4!K0Yu8`t_970h&^Va@;;+Y^XgfKU3{M~a%MSxM-0S&@Rl0BCXDgxB` zS^@UGFlzbuE6;Z}|H^d;_^bvo21Md+4;<1MZg5Cw5@mNBw4E{WNPj2hZLV{Zuf9(< zWVky$1}1xHgq!p5;HeH`Gaz0s7?clnEHJ6I1LbI5FDfRbTtod*051csXO2Sz#a9pOO61E-#SIXq16R@!4`)0O%KBrCkjbW3IZhQomzwBHo)w z@jV%zlUnv|GJ}_FZJ-sO5N1f*dIzgjVrAx|UrUM0H-wP9;PkE+x@DV73<3m*Iu2Md55 z?nIrsB`O&HjN)}S5YY1LT37Gkdp(rL{Ez}7)T#_qR(92u(}k76?aoB~eg(J>w=?Ff z3z7mSsWOue-s94bB4<^dov>9J#h$6F(8h4@bd^R%Btv!8@mRi_8$^2}|_t_6xP2Cec%xpbXlc&C$q~?yoT&O{lL+Y@A4=r^)p|h7{YWf-Hq60Nb7s0H3g+nCMWU0mC9|2$I8-(ScxH9izk z-qOlQm@$%5DVRzr9WR;F&?qmm5eQ<1;x=-wn#+}pH4GtJs-@35F6if%q+wIP)r}~A z8{&Rs*!x^S#n<0n=Amewz88w`zl&<@8zh>IY>;{osZrJ@)n`n$k>P1l6NXo%nb+LX zZ>n(49V~NT8XI7SW8HlvpbxBBMHomDQ;AX98)%ROT*O_uZVlzC(dkW}y~j#2_K5Ew z8(Y%=LT&7>fowJ92P%%@NTcd=ZDc^diAB!C8=OxQ8tcWKn5NKXFpAGRnZqys9EhZhl~CK@~G+JUJ1s_krhDy15EFX`%xr1 z<0ZKbbT&8SKDO77@qG$R#QALqYW)(e9@r{v+EPXc#UP*~<1lP|w%x5^nf#uZc&_AqpoyzTCj^D4D(4RHYaCT9gFrADa_0Q=wcKnq{(SShK#&BX zFa!sqAha#;==q*6x!;4^s7_RI;cVjB$b%Z%;A9@BhuF>0(NxD0JBo+||f@*v* zK(wvP*>LiJHUObdYt0Q?zMEcf%7Cn^K-YD9%08aC3*5}m@v8>~=-6S4whW2s@V7Y{ zES)YkM%mKVc!1%?lf2smvo=4ZfW{6(1*g34BSuXN+x=(6Q{7$B!LeH#y0f%jX;i@B z35Z&&TzIvgae_sv_L<-GTMrE9K3}#;DHTpXS&{e6s?}^Itlk}@CKN4e9-t(f6@71< z+FKxbrAh7N!bDS4j9*#i=pIsJYEjhZEJbfoPQO`o3hm2qMx;Wu>KspqTQ+TCLTy|> zQxaVAYOX|>K$s~%;#@v=qMEhn^pK-B{Np$&Ko+f=Vr8^kd2f`mqPI2n`2ZoShG%Pa zO<}L1Q%l&O0aurJpw;?d8hqe$_X`bFbtd(nSGE}l-j$9&^QW!r&ZW!xb`sAqHL<0w z)_R?qKRktPlQIqCTsJrZd_!RyYN+tl%Vpy!!m5`iV6=~`F%V&{#-Iz10>%pyMF;7u z=o~4^V(B6#&Lq*I;|cFy*WY+FIo5g=vJp$#`z<^!uo`@zlmamkeGzM{llFJa>o&Vd zaF?d7(zY-$_`R^H5O-$gbR+#1;T)78cX*bC*4nYE+n=L$pQmv>YJ}`d`a%&xzixZq zL&=}(3=kuP_ik0O(|r7T{Z(~m?p@)1AMqvDslk%+%ug#2--|gqmyD-U<#Zt+1I$Oq za8KlVHg5}J_LR3o(pbICJ7Z?`ZOqx;g0%7`U0nJCrr%?>F&9 zN((=U4`L)XLiN-O;sXc53u5ybf{;;%4f%f3>KwRSE)Uns`^@YDfU%uY)x^*Pw6F&x zB(aUCQLTgRXWOFGXq2_`Fu$V@Qf$XJ6NbZtn5EvNGT&9q0_9;`^X)JmA4s*3Y$lkKcypAOPWdE%@z8)R;^mULAu zytUFav)MRd9P5>3*TDS-qO(p4__r_Q%G){!zkWlj)`sq`XKa6QaRb#eGm#V5WY9+Q zo-kXwgIch~W;@rK8!e=;I@?x@*s!K{C|S5lP6)?KZ)9M~a=R#zPQ~LqJBhk(n+?*| zQ8au3*EI$%VhgC|w1OWQOC^AOH7ZJFxdG)xcrJMK-8f(6at_73MBmC{)2RzY?yNBl z^pEN+QD5FxLRT&x3{*m&>$a_eS0fM9two5EQ&w6ym)7RfF%aW=7Y&du7P>XzTOM*< z)Ju$-7*Z^=!zGKrKRs3k5laiOE!*lQB#XcN*{<^#F$mGuhJ^k}z4WVC`Y6$8A&e*C zHdJ{Utv`Jr$V@!QN<-09A#FzKK~=s`ND=)@y>xLwQG)kW7i0utz7`_^+8IsOUZfy_ zVef4;mOo;s;QF`DF3Dszf@FjBZ`JYpSN?)OZ97sAyi4GBLOF>_3N%q{Ha8aC;Mu>d zmsxYHrKM2)UuGJ7GHHHteF?_1{T)+KH8EQJGcHwefA~4jp_K0=WL^xbE4v;Vm2RSuT$ zvP7izIA14a{ubjqd(<2)mR15yCR$X`&az=T&9BjB^vqYL~6waviGLS z>o$HfRY9404XGvzvGfTi+Z2L*k`kOa)lSLa2d2Sn(oqaYj`}BWr~wP5y?Yj$cFN6n zcC*+OnHzuu5J&kS^KkVlAvSaTpWnHVuW@}Yi4MTEu-ep8ZW;k<4tCY&_DD~^qZtUR zA#iB6U4UJw@ue1qRt2b`VSpO4XPW)kggLt+_0D4~HiQGyir<+Mj26p?{xbH5d(qmk zYuAaeIe7;?S{oAl?&*$lFz*`ps`m)*nvC9=7K~QXuDn~qY`?C8fv!0kda9qRvf z6g|A-zb*rm-klMk^H|tcDc^CKOL>t}(IAE&*%T!yOC*?=C20R)~@j^%~g2X$+s=zYi2Z#7qRXyJ3U+eiTCGUyBwH1LF;8qG^ z1)?VtcZIiD;`Fy#;smZXL_=1HgKzi$om~cDgK6=rdT(zSoDN+os{0=%(?0-5#DUlT z{I{VVWDicE-QqsZ4!P zH2$|m7j5NmamRl{RauxenTlWjeO&E=%)^R&s`;A{-7E~}+eb72WQJimsW`WNej3q} z6x0t2nK>ICijr;2 zLm#_Uf^(Uq$uRmiRJ1uq|I#_Vgqg64%l9!}+@;*CL!CNTM*2b3h$w{{ncj!3(uT%l zw#Mm0lS;XboF(#xLU)(zeJ7xM&UhGQ94S0Wb<%1;E`7O5p19hsAex`l@Ch*^O zV%>>SQHe;MkT`n=_eJiHn*E5x0Vns=l+tWZW5Nl|9Gs|wq}p^9wACuU{k9{uJw&>@ ztNucqP+xz6ke@AyJAd?0i}Xt76%Z2`SJzJ>nRRklYet)7tDfZTDdx_HHXES6uxjhF z%UOic_0yQ29`Kz9Vr(cXN_1b3Pdp)69BV~UAzpi4g}JkFu75k}n2>+u7VoN_5^yhL zJ6Ic9^Vd{%mi^Q4F{X!=^>x*OU*&2}hK{QB`xnl)y6lnsu)Cx7d73$j>I<;pJt&n6 zbKN!?-R2CM9S-Oe~a#7G>K74_w zyS}0HU9^C~%mObbZfBiS%`j?Zvj{KmE3&0j!0b&d3X>k!kXOLa8TBglY#KliTmTOE zL)ez)*4?fPNzLarYNnsI`=;F(r@G+u&AO5&8MRx#`f9bPOQ(8P__oy&TGOYt(|i5q zX$-WRDJmQEL@nWFg*x8!LQW-rrI#M?Ngf~j+>^sm@Kb)J*KoJj{OPy)G&a>p-wQ?W zi9kN9p9Q&EW@fVI!^=s%=c!4N-GDpy)zQkYvGCSIMn+raEMp;9le8D8!WEO(l{vc~ z=6*Bs5yaYf7`x&Y zG8aq_WV^+v-*SR}5#q0T%wbKU2j}tV)AnN_d)zsz4Q-=vS*MwqaC7 z4yhu~1bk`rsIT(qdWB8qLC@Lt>GCD>hM*Og(A6`nIrCkQ{~xTqV~}LgwzgX~yKK9v z%eK4JW!qMlZQIpl+qP}nW|pm6d!KW@ea^Z2{<-mGWUMvf%^5Q@)}NeXj%U0xoapb5 z*bg>G5D)m(;r4EM;1N@!4pS9Wo3Z4pxu6|&%O4;Fs1i$oqCoSehw8f=b$wW2Cs;gx zMmSQVYyTMRWJ9wdS-S13o6#M!SRaF&DD(WOvK?k6rb8S-6YGhCx>hR=Uhjjs+NsxX z-?V53gMALPf+AVYh92*E$Y&mckxK1**QTKLg=jKujR?OU;TwKVTPL6M+cb3~t8M}_ ze`P?iI|WUJLALjL%sA4ux{6aT9=HoW#oUD*IJY7HsfAe%Jvw6%Q}y;-w(ACB*&SJ| z<=yX%;XtdyY$$dd%>sP?)d&*y_s!-wqVng-hJqs~2DUs!e5JW$CtIVj=F-`cBh%uA zMyHK5g_EeFbc7kxELQ>k^K+E@UlqGfF)*{-ddJ+LBCKcE={ zm&K~~QKp39gPwFC?3p~aRgbN=90%*aC3403{u|ELufDk=bLJ1?I=4|{W z(@keHQI_+sVWHtW=nq=%ZjQ)KWcKq79=A9&D}v4;nQg5h7o6mLr1kN9;s|%Y5T^I0 zT|KM54`3U;ix)J&!-dx5UIHZzs>A~XBKNDv2+N1}ME@g4Gf5jf`40B>C^MgN%sw`;+(Lg;}&52V22DYtw5pf=)G;n)wz)EKAS6qzi-@BKA_mM*f# zsZ(us+tOILkytSC*(ztiF^R(5q^7EawdJe%Q)XftwIGO6>(Fps)mj+RsRz`RLsm4| zPoq@6^23`1S=H6kD z?+52Gh zcbuetO=hUT3OE$d%CKWiSNq)L{0Vxg&fcZ|KQc15pP=L1DcR$lX>T0pB+u(GnPr}? zTZ&C!wE=hNNBpXYI^VpF@bG4M&Wl?)e0xU`pQaIX?-YofEtH|t#&9E!Q^=dPd6{d~`(V^k-gkN?>q`+mJ46pP{XkRC|9gCxCzx`{DVCuv zPbOonz{Whdaz#-+Ta8u5ej?1OB-!Ysh&744Q9>rj2hB;6MVUx(J<%e3%;o{u5P&?$ zo7WX}HpyfdDGv1IHXj8{!1#9Pn6-Vf|VTUBC zyGd|u#eG>t1n}-nggztlDh!M-7NngY&lLK3V@(4=GR9^=_v!i(fa@?wN!L7wz~&JF zP9`@P08V>jxB#f2XaxHiIcbTU3vv}Z^Br~M7l`0Je_C?V0tXif!z7xa9bt#-7xxA8 z&j;8Ju!M&I4ZrVx*?I;wI(`loZ2C}9)mo_^AF_>pN2&jjEn@0H;*4$25u;m{RW4ev zt`e1LC>pIgf174o1{*Gi*&uJ0%95%ljEIOoWu$4aAGRHGG@8pS;g#FqTWVUw>%Z5K zNYnm3nR6_&Ky8UlmBXrq6Xy1V`9%^XIH|=BXTS_Qdg zFujS|IZTL}@A@D5GFl$i9)5?L>U_D^YvBxSr{5^jX@KG^YCyFgWi}QurTXe}cPUyS z@fSW&8Xq#+Y*U}aHCj;-C`=3eH`8tMBS+m7pM<;}a+b%*+g(!y6-zs4As?rjSsE3quMWt`A zhq~XGo$tx z^+AEGBt9Mkp@q_V=Y7FFwbic$)OvCM1Dgx;u+?6i7}hOkm6*+TuUyD>t^CW1$2F}Y zfF2Jy{knOcF5gZDCmxV~bYe1tUIqDa{;0QLj%fSgm0NaHNc*(V#W*mUDN@`Aw;BFR z8Ll(WtZ1gLCPt^5`6A|ZInxBddZfg-0@?pLnFHNPdU181mXevho^6}2Q|>n3@_8kz z+Wqe6=0>!o^~m>e+gX(RbgrK#ULUyaOW9w4&U0nFD0Fcf7W*Bx4=cb9)EanR8LAR{a#jq_?2snwB_1?TiT}Noqyq8JGW8ovczV)^r)x~ zdt|lEHT4tVNXSqyZTH|SM^|3J-to+SZIqXrzpjBf!wsyE<&g0BBt*{q>0}-Kk`LSR zq~c5ZPPShOjk~H&Tk}q^Q>(9Yf-HGSnH@cx3I6yY2M7pYGu6fpkF3ooBEMo;ttj>k zf%oaH``ad?lkg@nnAY}yNnnYe)all+#`hHVg6L%#@45G9atkG+8Y)xy0V*ceq4cdNNJH6Z+J5v&6dyb=V|dTGQbsRh|sR zNQE76XiGSIA~L28-UW;92OKDlRiXC&8@iR>lAwBnE4=^*$$^#dL)JH(!Jv0x7fyB! zlXrZj@QCLVZW*mH__j;fQu>p`>ZQ(duzY;4W(Yo!g&3&`$$ ztb2GOXlD%@G)gRcba*XX+=a?P;qap9xjI#fpX_=1tla{me9(j~GgIyHtNp3Fs8H#?3mMG{7 zQ>mr``2-uTL*Ek9zjwpo)aRJTgGNQ0Qp;$pZk3(^8kA{cc*ehUm96=_X zF>Hr)`1x_qX7MBzFrD*dyPwH$HRN(*@O~U|_r>UK&0Z+t^}WF5T?08xq7^9;@HpqU zTatMwj1EAaa@xwAtqA^ee+(^&w9N+KAn(ozBJg%rsU0sveV7`d_})`WS-Ga z6aXu%;xw{!HCd6fpfUd>)IS6%NV^&s7GzHBxh!L%pA<(+w&Q)eG#&U=3SWgi)G`a! zeu8=;6MMJ8uT~Y@F{93D*_7o;o{-Q0n~wy_4t6v~V4FIsa?CM8q2;~Wd_V*HRo$b< zytFO$*1Bb><0!VY+{3>t^X-$6YO=n;(~7VOzJ`yrJP3_~;$~opm2OYqn?f~g;Qm|V zW2%)_*+?R;{1J==Sy3USI7u;9RUHPdO@k0usY=s2_bUO&0tY4LW7gP%(CYE82yr3A z6g+L>=Z>f840rGRT&mIP!uG}_)!Bnr&1r$e>yFjq*B zMB6_p1KSy}HLXJ(((FH0di3iJGRXs+(XaX^mZHRw>#H&tRSG9ZQ7bh!(vz1WN6l9* zdmp<(a@RtYP4fI3c}#!Q#Nn)a)dj-HUUJO%%-x``qr3!Loi_E-g0*s+|=6w-SXjRzX@?r)GM184R;U0b1O^*)CgHAu@(AF69k92ea6NFBwmyF`@v+_=cLua!j3EVEUPdiN_3;z92y^K=f)12tl1-vH@)$CcNt(pv({?uc` zgBK1R(`NZ5a+lzf8>%)|$I&AP9C-04`8Q+{=j0yOdW&ogm{#K~8?5G8(PE#)uN8B) zs@P`}oawU1KC5OvbQJLZ^oTErs1LR_{02=Rq|$SW7=`ac8Aus+p}{%>&k+~m#f#ap z2yG9T*Fyz*_>sQh3awd@LgM~5;*4Astq9 zaoI>uKRo9@PT1Tn#Q1Z{CY{+B6Ih+8y<(A89_qK^(P-l=E#Ac;;hFDOk5j7*ur|ahCcFlx&0Thindm z?53+Qurh4Zd1z&eRoH;Iq)j{_(!C9gB0-mt*&!fUu6n!>ktbsMW-1<~|6P3*btx}f ztEWSjt(jwjLHSkj!!|#(elf1>{cl_o_k+P;`z`L>IVFcq!pnpls2Y1G0-*1^to(bL z+MuP5l-eBzLmgxZyxt2RD-B{_x@rH)!nJSIo0ldT%v9(%jg;22Vj&TqA!*;dxH4k2 zB|7)9Eg|%+KM`Mzg!-)22Asa`Cx@AqE_z<}1*R#d2blyKmZo_+6}Pvi1GcTDCk6J2 zD#Db4vH*sUJN3X%yBkicG<&9f&#@8vzF)C)?fE}w(#AzZ3^WpE44$apQo-r;@zteA zOyc2`ba`sE#ZrB(P5-DQpSwzu51sTy83=aAIahW6Ek@J#fujfAf{^0x;mN+)x-Abq zMmz5NOkGWERu`J*EoC4G_B7%A$=;icc&kTD%|k~cJN{~$m5fGUuw*2$_K=Ddpu%VP z5^d?OJ=K|k0*k1DPg*gBe*W9$tg=1)8-ehIcmAPfTh;4=4VW0XZ01g>UZ;QBlm-ZF zw*A=fZg%Kw`nc_tnSDIZuQqeexyZT#)R6m3vbI-3sbg1@j3wnriZeulA4X